Super cool old building makes for funky seating areas and interesting vibe. I think this was an…read moreold service station in the early 1940's. Food service was friendly and portion sizes were generous. The only chips they had that day was plain. They were "good" but likely not really fresh. We split the Dagwood and still had another whole meal for the two of us.

Great sandwiches & pizza. Takes me back to college everytime we visit. Service & atmosphere are…read moregreat and old school Fayetteville

Prompt friendly service. First time and won't be last. Highly recommended for breakfast. I'll have…read moreto come back and try the burgers!

We got a to go order. The cheeseburger was amazing. It was cooked to perfection with all the…read moreingredients in and on it. I plan on going back but this time I will dine in.

"Your restaurant is so good. The lady waitress was nice. My…read moregrilled cheese was 10/10." Declan 8yrs old. Dad- Italian stallion- 7/10 Only because I tasted the olive and I'm not a fan of olive. But other than that it was good. Mom- caparese melt- 9/10 Only because it had too much pesto for my liking. The vibes were chill the waitress was very nice. Our kid is on the spectrum and is hard to please sometimes but he loved it he even tried his dad Italian stallion and gave it a thumbs up. We will be back next time we are in AR. Thank you!

Driving through Fayetteville, I had to stop at Hammontree's Grilled Cheese. I've seen this place…read moreall over the internet for years, so it finally made the list. First impressions were a bit mixed. The restaurant was quiet, but the floors were noticeably dirty, and the restrooms were just okay. Nothing outrageously bad, but definitely not as clean as I would expect for such a slow night. The service was probably the biggest disappointment. Our server wasn't rude, but she wasn't particularly welcoming either. She took our order, dropped off the food, and brought the check without ever really checking back in. There were only three occupied tables in the restaurant with three servers working, so it wasn't like they were overwhelmed. One thing that really stood out was that every employee in the dining room except the bartender had headphones either in their ears or hanging around their necks. It gave the impression that customer service wasn't much of a priority. I started by ordering a sweet tea, only to be told they don't have it because they brew their tea in-house and "can't add sugar." That explanation seemed a little odd. I switched to a Coke instead, which turned out to be one of the flattest fountain drinks I've had in a long time. After a few sips, I gave up and just drank water. Now for the part that really matters: the food. We ordered the Kids Rookie grilled cheese and the Big Dog from the kids' menu, along with the Cheebacca and the Brie's Company. We also couldn't leave without trying the Blueberry Grilled Cheese for dessert. The only real miss on the food side was the chips. They were stale, cold, and almost rubbery. Honestly, they were some of the worst house chips you could possibly have. The sandwiches deserve a much better side, or they'd honestly be better off taking the chips off the menu altogether. The kids' meals were an incredible value at only $5 each. My 5-year-old couldn't decide between a grilled cheese and a hot dog, so he got both. The Big Dog was excellent--hot, juicy, and grilled just long enough to get those perfect char marks. The Rookie was exactly what you'd want for a picky eater: simple, cheesy, and well made. The Cheebacca ($12) was packed with sharp white cheddar, house cheese, bacon, pulled pork, grilled onions, and a garlic cilantro sauce on sourdough. Every ingredient complemented the next, and nothing overpowered the sandwich. Easily one I'd order again. The Brie's Company ($12) was the surprise of the meal. Grilled apples, Brie, Gouda, caramelized onions, and fig jam on sourdough sounded adventurous, but it absolutely worked. Sweet, savory, rich, and balanced all at once. If you're willing to step outside the traditional grilled cheese, this one is worth trying. Then came dessert. The Blueberry Grilled Cheese ($7.25) combines mascarpone, cream cheese, fresh blueberries, and honey between slices of grilled pound cake. It sounds unusual, but somehow it's fantastic. It's one of those desserts that makes you question why you've never had it before. Awkwardly delicious in the best possible way, and absolutely worth ordering. Overall, Hammontree's is a place where the kitchen is doing almost everything right while the front of house leaves quite a bit to be desired. Cleaner dining areas, better service, and replacing those terrible chips would easily push this into 4 star territory. As it stands, the food absolutely lives up to the hype, but the overall experience holds it back. If you're passing through Fayetteville, it's still worth stopping in. Just skip the chips, order one of the specialty grilled cheeses, and don't leave without trying the dessert.

Top notch Italian Beef (on par with Portillo's). The Tomato Bisque is excellent with just a little…read morezip. It's nice that half sandwiches are an option. I had a half grilled cheese to go with my soup.

Where's the meat???? 8.00 BLT and 1 piece of bacon? (See…read morePic).. And my Asiago sandwich had 3 small, small pieces of chicken breast that would fit in a teaspoon. Spent $30.00 and going to have to stop somewhere else to eat. Total rip off. Should be ashamed to feel good about running a company and doing this to customers. We even watched the two ladies run the 1 piece of bacon through the oven all giddy and laughing. They definitely were taught this. Again.. Should be ashamed.

Obviously a local spot, and I love those. The burger was…read morepretty good, and fresh. I had to take a couple stars off because: A: it took a LONG time. I was one of 4 tables in the place and 2 complained loudly about the slow cook time with one even getting up to leave right at the time their food got there. B: My order was wrong. Not a HUGE deal, but I was by myself and Ordered a burger and onion rings. It came with fries. I was told I could get onion rings, but no indication given that a mistake had been made. I chose not to wait. I would still recommend trying the place. I'll probably try it again someday, but only if I'm in the neighborhood.

Food and service excellent!. Old home town diner atmosphere in an older building. Parking lot…read morefull and you could tell a lot of locals and regular customers came in. I look for these type of places while traveling

Visiting from another State . Eaten at several places nearby. This was our favorite restaurant…read more Everything was delicious. We will return on our next visit. Service was great.

I found this restaurant on Yelp while searching for local favorites and it definitely lived up to…read morethe hype. We were there from about 11:30 to 1 and there was a constant line. It was busy but after about a 20 min wait to order, our food came out quickly. We had the giant spiced chicken sweet potato, which was delicious, especially with the avocado sauce. We also ordered the Big Beef and Chicken Caesar, a kids' pizza, mango tea, and a giant cookie. Everything was tasty and everyone enjoyed their meal. The restaurant is small and inside an apartment complex with outdoor seating. The staff was friendly, efficient and worked together really well to keep things running smoothly despite the lunch rush. I'll definitely be back!

Went here for take out but had I realized there was a sit down area earlier I probably would have…read morestayed. Inside was very nice and cozy. In addition to my pick up, I ordered a milkshake and a couple pies. The burger I ordered was great and hit the spot as well as the shake. Onion rings were a bit overdone but good. Service was excellent and very friendly folks. I appreciate them very much. Certainly worth the stop!

Amazing food. Got the biscuit and gravy with scrambled eggs and omg out of this world. Will be…read moregoing back. The people are always so friendly. The food never let's me down.

mmmmmm good so hungry after work this is so worth it better come get yours im trying…read moreeverything and getting something different everytime i come here

New clean location with fast service! The Gyros are really good here, even though it's a burger…read morejoint.