Cancel

Open app

Search

NY Bagel & Coffee

4.1 (17 reviews)
Open • 4:00 am - 1:00 AM (Next day)

Order NY Bagel & Coffee Takeout or Delivery

NY Bagel & Coffee Photos

Business Info

NY BAGEL & COFFEE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - NY Bagel & Coffee

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Victoria C.

You HAVE to visit this bagel shop!! Seriously so adorable! The whole vibe is very cute! I can't believe all the hate for their images, there's nothing wrong with it at all and is so unique and fun!! But that's not all that stood out, the service was top notch - we were immediately greeted by the servers and treated so kindly the entire time. We ordered breakfast sandwiches - the everything bagel with smoked salmon was delicious! Definitely get the one that includes cucumber and red onions. The house fried, pancakes, and French toast was also so good. We loved our experience here and are so happy we stopped in. Please come visit this special place, you won't regret it!

Salmon bagel
Nicole H.

Salmon bagel was real good. Onion rings were ok. Place was clean and staff friendly. I got the rose cardomom coffee which was delicious.

This is their number 11!

Best bagel place I've been to. I love it so much and the employees were so sweet and nice. very satisfied, if I could write an essay on how much I love it I would!! Hahaha. Plus the inside was super cute.

We ordered from NY Bagels and Coffee on DoorDash, and it was honestly one of the worst food experiences I've ever had. The bacon was rubbery, plastic-like, and completely inedible -- clearly microwaved from a pre-packaged box. Everything tasted stale and reheated, not freshly made. Afterward, we looked up reviews and saw people reporting mice on the counters and moldy sandwiches at their other locations, Melting Sun and Manhattan Bagel and Coffee. That explains everything. The photos they use online are totally fake -- AI-generated and misleading. Nothing we received looked like the pictures. It's pure deception across all three restaurants. This place is a total health hazard and should not be operating under multiple names. Save your money and your stomach. Do yourself a favor and avoid NY Bagels and Coffee, Melting Sun, and Manhattan Bagel and Coffee at all costs.

Iced Matcha Latte, 23 oz.

See all

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of David K.
114
526
897

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Moy H.
141
90
18

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Michael P.
171
65
55

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 2

8 months ago

Best bagels in Boston. Super creative menu. Clean restaurant and helpful staff. Highly recommend!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Deb A.
2
31
0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

7 months ago

I love this little cafe! It is so cosy inside and the staff are really friendly. It's such a hidden gem

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

They dont use gloves. Touching everything, sneezing then making your bagel. Food tastes good though. Would recommend as last resort.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

We loved their bagels! Good menu and good pastry. The place is casual, but food is yummy

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

We had a great time here!!!!! Everything bagel was phenomenal and the staff was very friendly!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - NY Bagel & Coffee

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cafes 5,856 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Bagelsaurus - Sea Salt Bagel with Honey Rosemary Cream Cheese

Bagelsaurus

4.2(892 reviews)
2.4 mi•Porter Square
•$$

Probably one of the best bagel sandwiches I ever had…read more I came here at 10AM on a Saturday whilst visiting Boston and quickly ordered. My order only took 8 mins to come out. I ordered the Eggspanola and it was so delicious. I'm really not sure what it was, maybe the spread, maybe the egg, maybe the sauce?? Made it so delicious. I was going to save my sandwich but I quickly devoured half and ate the other half later. Will be back if I'm ever in the area.

I visited Bagelsaurus after it was recommended as one of the best places for bagels in the Boston…read morearea. A few weeks ago, I stopped by and picked up a couple of bagels to try. The blueberry bagel I had that day was absolutely superb, probably the best blueberry bagel I've ever had in Boston. A few days later, I craved that same blueberry bagel and made the trip back, which is a considerable drive for me. Upon arrival, I was told that blueberry bagels are not offered every day and are only available on Thursdays. I returned the following Thursday, but the experience was very different. I got blueberry, poppy, and a few other bagels to take home. Unfortunately, all of them were absolutely disappointing. They tasted extremely off and very different from the blueberry bagel I had previously. At home, my family ate about half of what we purchased, but none of us had any desire to finish the rest. Overall, the experience was unpleasant, and the bagels were not enjoyable at all. The blueberry bagel from my first visit looked and tasted amazing and was completely different in quality from what I received on my second visit. On top of that, the person behind the counter seemed careless with hygiene, touching the screen, bagels, and other surfaces without any apparent attention to cleanliness. It felt like a completely different place compared to my first visit just a couple of weeks earlier. Overall, I'm extremely disappointed.

Photos
Bagelsaurus - Merch, some seating, and high chairs

Merch, some seating, and high chairs

Bagelsaurus
Bagelsaurus

See all

PopUp Bagels - Everything bagel

PopUp Bagels

4.2(117 reviews)
4.4 mi•Waterfront, South Boston

I have been wanting to try PopUp Bagels for years now, and I was so excited to see that they have a…read morelocation in Boston! Went on a Friday around 11:30am (FYI use Yelp to get address or Google Maps - Apple Maps took us somewhere else). Located in Seaport district with plenty of outdoor seating available. You do have to order a minimum of 3 bagels with a Schmear so just keep that in mind. We got the Poppy, Sesame, and Everything bagels with Scallion Schmear. Bagels were perfectly soft and the schmear was delicious! I wasn't sure how I would feel about the concept of ripping the bagels and dipping it into the cream cheese, but I actually ended up preferring it - less messy and more cream cheese per bite. Wish PopUp Bagels was in the Bay Area. I would definitely return!

This is the most insanely inconvenient bagel place I've ever ordered from, and totally over priced…read more Want to buy one bagel with cream cheese? Nope. Minimum order is 3. Want your bagel toasted with cream cheese? Nope. They don't toast there. Single serve cream cheese? Nope, gotta buy a full tub. Having never been there before with a group of out-of-towners, we did not know that. Since the minimum order is 3 we decided the three of us would place an order together and all get one bagel + cream cheese, not understanding that it was a full tub of cream cheese each because no one explained that to us. That order of 3 bagels plus a drink came to $29!!! The bagels may be fresh out of the oven, but there is still a difference in the texture and consistency of a toasted bagel that I strongly prefer. Their bagels are super doughy and soft, almost gummy inside. And you have to eat them right away or they get hard. And the everything bagels are so overloaded they make an insane mess as soon as you pick them up. Expect seeds to go literally everywhere. Wholly underwhelming and overpriced. Not for me.

Photos
PopUp Bagels - Scallion cream cheese

Scallion cream cheese

PopUp Bagels - Salt bagel

Salt bagel

PopUp Bagels - Scallion smear & limited truffle cream cheese smear

See all

Scallion smear & limited truffle cream cheese smear

Calisto's - Layered with rich meats, creamy spreads, and fresh toppings for the perfect bite.

Calisto's

4.4(60 reviews)
2.9 mi•South End

I was just thinking to myself that it has been awhile since I took a bite of a meal and had a…read moregenuine "oh my fkn gooooooooddddd" moment Thank you calsitos for restoring my faith. This place slaps. That Roman sandwhich is worth the hype I lost my fkn mind

Five stars for the food, three stars for everything else. We tried Calisto's for lunch during our…read moretrip to Boston. I didn't realize this would be a true hole in the wall; no bathrooms, only three or four tables, you order at the counter. So if you're looking for a sit-down spot, have a backup plan. We got lucky and grabbed a table but it felt like a miracle. This is really more of a takeout spot. The menu is simple: cold and hot sandwiches, about four or five options per category. The sandwiches were delicious, especially the Calabria, packed with prosciutto, spicy soppressata, hot capicola, sharp provolone, Calabrian chili aioli, and arugula. They couldn't substitute the arugula, so I skipped it but it was still the star of the show. My husband had the roast beef and it was good, but the Calabria won. Fair warning: these sandwiches are HUGE. We were so full from lunch we could barely finish dinner and my one regret was not splitting one. Come hungry or come with a plan! The place is a bit chaotic. It took close to 30 minutes to get our order; they were slammed. The guy at the counter was all over the place and forgot to give us our drinks or tell us to grab them from the fridge. But at $17 for a sandwich this thick and this good, it's a great deal in Boston's South End. The flavors made it all worth it.

Photos
Calisto's - Interior

Interior

Calisto's - A deli favorite made with serious care, big flavor, and beautiful texture in every layer.

A deli favorite made with serious care, big flavor, and beautiful texture in every layer.

Calisto's - Golden, melty, and packed with flavor from the first bite to the last.

See all

Golden, melty, and packed with flavor from the first bite to the last.

Black Sheep Bagel Cafe - Lox Classic on Sesame Bagel

Black Sheep Bagel Cafe

4.2(337 reviews)
1.4 mi•Harvard Square, Riverside
•$

Black sheep is exactly what I was looking for for breakfast in Harvard Square, breakfast…read moresandwiches!! The space is pretty tight and it was really busy when I showed up but absolutely cleared out as I sat down to eat. I ordered a cold brew, which was a bit watery, but I like it super dark so it's probably just my taste preference. They put the milk/cream in for you and you pick the coffee up in a separate spot from the food. They call your name for both pickups. For food I got the devilled egg open face bagel that has bacon on top on a whole wheat everything bagel. Eating it was intense. I couldn't put it down once I picked up each side and had to be very careful not to spill the egg mixture off the top. It took a while to eat but was amazingly delicious and exactly what I wanted. I would eat it everyday if I could. If it came with micro greens on top, it would be even better. The mixture had red onions which gave it a punch and crunchy texture. I considered adding salt to the mixture on top but I'm glad I didn't because the bagel itself had sea salt so each bite was salty enough. When I ordered I asked if I could also get 2 bagels to bring home and I was told the limit is 1 on weekends and 2 during the week. The manager (I assume) stepped in and said I could have 2 so I chose the rosemary sea salt, which the only have on weekends. I made breakfast sandwiches on them the next day and it was heavenly. This is a spot to check out!

I came again, this time for my parents to try…read more Favorite: I arrived a bit late, and the Everything Bagel was sold out, so I chose a similar Whole Wheat Everything Bagel, but it was extremely, extremely, extremely salty. Everything else was still delicious; the tomato, poached egg, and avocado were a perfect match, refreshing, clean, mild, and smooth.

Photos
Black Sheep Bagel Cafe - Interior

Interior

Black Sheep Bagel Cafe - Lox Classic on Sesame Bagel

Lox Classic on Sesame Bagel

Black Sheep Bagel Cafe - Everything bagel with jalapenos cream cheese and topped with red onion and tomato

See all

Everything bagel with jalapenos cream cheese and topped with red onion and tomato

Mike & Patty's - Bay Village - Make it your way! Ask our friendly staff about our available ingredient options. Customize your creation and enjoy a truly unique sandwich.

Mike & Patty's - Bay Village

4.4(2.3k reviews)
3.2 mi
•$$

Classic and well-known breakfast sandwich spot with a few locations throughout the greater Boston…read morearea! Well-executed sandwiches. It's a bit tight inside with not much seating and seems like more of a takeaway spot, which is exactly what I did. Staff are nice. The smell of the bacon inside is very enticing. I've been loyal to their Fancy breakfast sandwich which has fried eggs, bacon, cheddar, avocado, (pickled?) red onions, and mayo on toasted bread. While it is not life-changing, I still think it is a very solid breakfast sandwich that is well-balanced. I like the acidity of the red onions and the freshness of the avocado which balances out the oil and fat from the bacon and cheddar. But I would love to try their other popular items like a Mission breakfast burrito, the Crack sandwich, etc!

This restaurant is tiny (175 square feet) and only has 2 seats - which were both occupied when I…read morestopped by around 11:30am. There's a small park with shaded benches about 2 blocks away (Elliot Norton Park) which is a great place to sit down and devour the food. I ordered the Mission Breakfast Burrito and it was delicious. As of August 2026, the website lists the burrito as $14, but the price on the in-person menu was $16. I would give the burrito 4 out of 5 stars because of the way it was wrapped - about a third of the burrito was just egg and cheese and the toppings (avocado, red onion, hash browns, salsa verde, crema) were crammed on the other side of the burrito. If there was a way for the burrito to be wrapped so all the ingredients were more evenly distributed - this would easily be a 5/5 breakfast burrito. One random detail that stuck out to me was that their drinks in their refrigerator were very cold - no lukewarm sodas here! I would come back here to try their signature "Fancy" sandwich. Overall, this is a very solid breakfast spot in Boston!

Photos
Mike & Patty's - Bay Village
Mike & Patty's - Bay Village - Milk-y way to quench your thirst! Try our flavored milk in banana, strawberry, or chocolate.

Milk-y way to quench your thirst! Try our flavored milk in banana, strawberry, or chocolate.

Mike & Patty's - Bay Village - Fancy Sandwich (~$11) with hash brown

See all

Fancy Sandwich (~$11) with hash brown

NY Bagel & Coffee - cafes - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...