Thank you Noble Pies for bring pies to the election workers at the Florida senior Citizens Center. The Apple pie was great but the Cherry Pie was outstanding. Keep up the great work and thank you again. Elections Inspectors read more

Shop is really cute and most pies are good overall. Very pricy but you get what you pay for. The savory pies are good but not a ton of "stuff" in the shell. I wasn't a fan of the chocolate mousse but the key lime pie was delicious. read more

Noble Pies - Chocolate mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

Adorable pie shop. Amazing selection and the ones we tried were delicious. They have coffee with dairy free milk options too. The staff was very helpful and friendly. A nice chill place to visit read more

See all

We were robbed by Noble Pies last week in Warwick NY... This past July 3rd we stopped at Noble Pies to take something to an event, went into their shop on 94 for a quick purchase, the shop was open, but nothing was left in the freezer or the pie case except one lonely Key Lime Pie, didn't want to stop at the big stores so we bought it. When we got to the car, we realized Noble Pies had charged us $34 dollars for a 10-inch refrigerated pie. We have since come to find out that Noble Pies actually wholesales their pies to some of the bigger local touristy places in Warwick for about $9 dollars who then resell those pies for about $18-$19 dollars, certainly a fair price for a fresh pie. I remember when Noble Pies was a small operation and sold their pies on the side of the road out of a truck with hand-painted signs saying, "Turn back for Pie". Amazing how greedy people have to chase money to sell a pie, especially their last one on a holiday weekend, Noble Pies you should be ashamed of yourselves. read more

Excellent lies and outstanding selection. This place is our go-to place for dessert since moving to the Tarrytown area. They have a good pie selection including mini pies. Mixed berry is a favorite. You can also pick up quiches that are very good . They also deliver! read more

I had mix feelings about this place after reading some of the reviews. Monday i decided to visit and it did not disappoint! I had the oatmeal raisin cookies and a cherry pie to go! Both delicious! I will be going back for a blueberry pie :) read more

See all

This place has really fresh scones and pies! It is a must try for anyone visiting the area. A hidden local gem in Warwick!

excellent pies. Highly recommend. Especially chicken pot pie, cherry pie, apple pie. read more

Cute decor, yummy pies. Not the best but good enough. Service was great and polite. We tried the apple pie and black dirt chocolate cream pie. We like the apple pie better. $7.xx for a slice. read more

See all

N ext level pies are here O nly if you're ready that is B utterly flakey pie crust L usciously scrumptious savory or not E clectic selection, choose wisely P eeps here are as sweet as their pies I ce cream selection is great as well E verlasting happiness could be found here @thedogtrine read more

Coffee was strong. This place was my first time ever trying peach pie and it was incredible, especially with that scoop of vanilla ice cream. We also took a key lime pie home and it blew my mind. read more

Five stars for their refrigerated section alone. Great local eggs, pickled fare and other goodies. Love their pies! Very happy and satisfied with all my purchases. Also, how can you not LOVE a place at which you can purchase fresh pie by the slice! read more

See all

Noble Pies has the most amazing pies and deserts! All the ingredients are sourced from the family farm and home-made. When in Warwick this is always my first stop! read more

Noble Pies - Sheppard's Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

Best savory pies! I love having a selection and a changing menu! The variety is great. Can't wait for more crazy options!

Very disappointing. None of the 4 pies we bought tasted fresh. The crust on the pumpkin pie was raw only the filling was edible. Cream on the chocolate and keylime tasted old and stale. Cherry pie did not have enough filling. More underbaked pie crust than filling. For what they charge you'd think they'd have fresh pies. They also do not provide a receipt upon request. Very expensive lesson learned. read more

I celebrated Pi day with a friend at Noble Pies (in the Rye NY location) Not only was the Marry Me Cherry pie delicious, but the coffee variety was spot on and the pot pies available make it a great place to have a different kind of slice for lunch! I took a full Buffalo Chicken pie home for dinner and my friend grabbed a small mixed berry pie for her family. I'm already looking forward to my next trip back! read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

This small, quaint place has sweet and savory pies that are so immensely delectable and delicious!! I love that you can taste test a few of the pies before making a choice. Everything was clean and the young guys working there were super nice. It was also nice to see a multicultural staff as well! The location is off the main road but easy to miss. It's one of a few shops in a sort of mini mall set off the road. Circle back if you think you've missed it while driving. They have a sign inside which says "Turn Back For Pie," and that's exactly what we did!! On our way to hike and the sweet pies hit the spot. The dough is flaky and not greasy. The fruits used are so fresh. I could go on and on!!! Just go there and eat pie... PLEASE!!! read more

The apple pie is to die for. The apple pie à la mode is to die multiple times for. The owners are such warm people, and their warmth is reflected in the quality of the products they make. Even their coffee is really good. The few times a year that I pass through Orange County, I always treat a visit to this place as an almost sacred pilgrimage. read more

Best cherry pie I've had in a long time! Husband really enjoyed the chocolate pudding pie too! We will definitely make it a stop whenever in that area Staff was sweet & friendly too! read more

It's iffy Some of the pies are good others are not. The ingredient's are fresh. Cute store Has been in business for quite a bit and In fairness, I have not visited in about a year. read more

The peach raspberry was absolutely delicious!!! I visited the new Tarrytown location and Angie is a GEM! Love her so much. Kind, wonderful and a delight. Service was excellent. I came way after the place was closed and without hesitation, allowed me in with a warm welcome. This is the place to go for your pie needs. 5 Stars! read more

OMG the chicken pot pie was great. i may never make one again. I thought it was pricey until I saw the beautiful and generous filling. The pastry was flakey I.m sure to get it again ........and again read more

Bought a Strawberry Rhubarb pie from them at the Pleasantville Farmers Market last Saturday, it's a family favorite. Alas, not this one from Noble Pies - just threw out half of it uneaten - a rarity in our home. It had no strawberries or rhubarb in it, just some sort of flavored cornstarch gel in a bland crust. This was a poorly done supermarket pie - very disappointing! Their posted menu looked very interesting & we were assisted by a very gracious young woman, but I would not trust making another purchase from them based on the very poor food quality . read more

Delicioussssss and wonderful customer service . Will definitely come every time I'm up in the Warwick area. Jackie was the sweetest :) Can't wait to be back! read more

Noble Pies - Trust this sign!!!! It tells no lies!!!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

The service was awesome but the pies, not so much. In an area that has horses, cows and farms, I would expect fresh baked pies. These pies look like they've been in the coolers for a week. I purchased the lime, mixed berries and apple pies. All of which were not fresh. The crust on the lime pie tasted like wax. I guess I'll keep searching for freshly baked pies that actually taste good. Until then, no more of these. read more

Noble Pies quiche is unmatched. The vegetable quiche was smooth, creamy and delicious. I'm a fan of all of their pies. There cherry pie is one of my other favorites! read more

Sometimes bigger is not better! I ordered and prepaid for my pies on November 12th . I was scheduled to pick my pies up at 11 am on November 27th. So when I walked into the Warwick Noble pie bakery I was given my apple pie and was asked if I lived local. When I told them I do live local they told me my pumpkin pie was not available. I was like how can this be since I preordered and prepaid For both pies. The so called owner tells me they are making the pies and they will deliver it to me later today. At 4 pm I decided to call the bakery to see when I would be getting my pumpkin pie the women said she was just finishing up and would be delivering the pie. At 6pm I checked outside my doors to see if a pie was dropped off..nope! At 630pm I finally get a text saying my pie has been delivered at my mail box. Who would ever drop a pie off by my mailbox on the ground where millions of dog have taken a piss! I will never ever buyfrom them again! read more

Cool spot. All towns should have a pie shop think. Stopped in the other day to bring some back home. Price points were pretty high, but everything looked good so I tried not to let that stop me. I got two small pies, which are perfect to split with someone or for one hungry pie lover (I know I'd could've destroyed one in a sitting). Went with the blueberry and the strawberry rhubarb. Then I decided to grab a chocolate chip cookie and a blueberry scone as well. The cookie and scone were pretty disappointing and forgettable, but the pies were fantastic. Crust, filling, crumble topping were all delicious. Strawberry rhubarb was my favorite for sure. For $15 a piece I'm not sure if I'd get too many more, but I was definitely interested in trying some of the savory pie. The curry pie and buffalo chicken pie both sounded interesting. Next time I'm in the area I may swing by and try something different. Good pies, but pricy. If you have that kind of pie budget, go all out. read more

brought a ck pot pie on Tuesday the 15th. pd 35 Bucs. it was for sick family to enjoy. 2 small bones found in pie. my 90 yr old mother n my 1 yr old grandson ate this. lucky no one choked. will never ever go back their. it ruined the whole pie n we threw it away. DeeDee 8455451173 read more

Always excellent sweet or savory pies. Single slices, personal or family size.In season strawberry and rhubarb is the best

Best apple crumb pie. It was so fresh and buttery with just the right amount of sweetness. The chicken pot pie is also amazing. The best I've ever had. I can't wait to go back to get more. read more

Noble Pies - Hudson Valley Apple Crumb - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

Country pies from the country service by people from the Country love every thing country including Donnie and Marie. Go and go often

Brochure lists SO MANY delicious sounding pies. We went out of our way to stop there on our way home from a weekend trip, only to find three pies on their menu and some sad looking scones. Please, please stop misleading patrons. Just wrote on your brochure, "call ahead for daily pies," instead of making people think all pies are always available. Also, we spent 47 dollars on three very, very small pies. Stay away....there are much better local establishments. *edited We were there about an hour after opening. PUT it in writing. My boyfriend owned a deli for over five years, so we both get, "food waste," but put it in writing! Also, the chicken pit pie was super dry, you're better off with a store-bought frozen one. read more

After speaking with Zachary I was able to pick up the pies free of charge. I feel like the mix up that occurred was due to an unfortunate circumstance. read more

Leslie Noble has done an excellent job! Delicious pies, super friendly staff and a great vibe! Love this place, love bringing these pies as hostess gifts and desserts. read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

Too much money for to little return. Chicken pot pie for $18.00, I hope the chicken was from royalty.

I ived in Warwick for 16 years and definitely define Noble Pies as the tastiest pies and several other baking specialties that bring the party as pie love. I've blended with the two owners and give you Wonderful treats, hard to beat but they don't give it away their specialties aren't given away and "yes" you might have to wait in line a few minutes but if you call ahead and specify the date it will be ready.. read more

Love the owners and the pastries. When I'm Warwick we try to stop over and eat a few slices and maybe take a mixed berry pie home.

Really ymmy pies! I will definitely return to try different pies. The apple was great!

I don't like apple pie. There have been many people that have had me try apple pie from different locations served different ways and I just never got around to a slice of apple pie that I liked. I was in New York to visit a friend and I thought "if I'm going to find a good pie, NY is a good place for it" so I looked up what are the best pies in all of New York State and I chose Noble Pies. I went in, asked for a slice of apple pie, and I sat down and ate my first bite. I cannot tell you how happy I was to have the privilege of eating this slice of pie. I remained calm and just sat there, ate my apple pie, and I handed the dishes back and told the sweet lady that worked there that it was the best slice of apple pie I'd ever eaten. Then I walked to my car and I just started screaming because I couldn't believe that I just ate something so delicious. I ordered an entire blueberry pie for myself and I'm not ashamed of my decision. I actually like blueberry pie so I can only imagine how I'll feel when I dig into this. To the store owners: you all should be so proud of yourselves. I hope you know I'm going to be coming back soon! read more