Another delicious lunch at the charming Noble Pies on Warwick Main Street today. It's Spring and their super adorable dining rooms are the perfect place to enjoy a make your day special treat. We split a chicken pot pie and salad between us two. Everything is lovingly homemade here. We can't wait until the porch is open and the new Soringtime menu is available on weekends. Stop in for coffee and breakfast. read more

Visited the new location of Noble Pies which is down the road from the original location we used to visit post apple picking at Pennings. The newer location is now in a home which offers twice the amount of seating compared to the original location. Lots of cozy seating with couches as well as table and bench seating depending what room are you in. There is a small bathroom in the front left room that is very clean. To order your pies you walk straight from the entrance to the back. They have their pies for takeaway in the fridge and shelves. If you want pies to eat in, they have them displayed in the case. They can heat up any slices if needed. For drinks they have bottled harney teas, spindrift, Bruce Cost ginger ale, teas, coffees and milkshakes. They also have pie milkshakes which they can take a slice of pie in the case to make into a milkshake. Some of my favs here are the buffalo chicken pie, Texas pecan pie and pecan cheesecake pie. Looking forward to returning again next time. read more

See all

Delicious homemade pies at a reasonable price. What's not to love? They have an excellent selection of sweet and savory pies. Service and workers are always very friendly and helpful as well, and there's even nice seating inside. While the cherry pie is still my favorite, looking forward to trying some of the others on the menu read more

A gem of a pie shop! My last visit got the buffalo chicken pie and the curry veggie pie as take out. Highly recommend both these. And the ambience is great for eating in. Might have to go back today for their regular chicken pot pie (though the Buffalo is hard to beat) and possibly a sweet pie! They have most available for eat in or take out. If you're in the area- consider taking one home ! You won't be disappointed read more

Place is insanely good. Its a bit expensive but its also made completely from scratch and it is 1 million percent worth it.

I am not a pie lover by any means but had a deal for a pie so I decided to give it a shot. Noble pies you might have convinced me! I got the mixed berry pie and it was incredible. To start off I got the pie at around 12pm and when I got home around 4pm it was still pretty cold. Bless the cold weather (I'm visiting family but I'm from FL) because it stayed intact. After dinner my bf and I threw in the oven for 30-35 min but we left it a little longer so the top got nice and golden brown at 350 degrees. As recommended we had it with vanilla ice cream. We were able to share with a total of 5 of us. The crust was so buttery and savory. The berries tasted fresh and vibrant, with the perfect balance of sweet and tart. It wasn't overly sugary, letting the natural flavors of the berries shine through. It was just so comforting. I might have to come back before I leave to snag another pie because this was just a great treat. Whether you're a pie lover or not, this one will win you over. Noble Pie definitely lives up to its name--this is pie royalty! Can't wait to go back for more! read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

Our annual upstate NY trip brought us here to get some savory and sweet pies. We came on a Saturday around 10-11 am. They were already out of scones so they must be really popular. I've only gotten pies at Petee's Pie in the City so I just assumed that all the pies would be freshly baked, not stored in the fridge, but most of the pies here are in the fridge. We opted for the curry chicken pie. It was good, but we wanted the pie crust to be more flaky and crispy. There were also huge chunks of vegetables that needed to be diced further for a more consistent taste. For the sweet dessert, we were already making our own blueberry and peach crumble so we chose to do the key lime pie. It was good, but my personal preference would have liked it to be less sweet, and definitely a lot more tart. read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

I've been coming here every week since they opened in their new location. I can't speak to the pies, but their coffee is one of only three spots in town worth going back for--along with Eddie's Roadhouse and Ferment. 10/10 for staying consistent, delicious, and affordable. read more

Very dry and not very sweet. Coffee was lukewarm. The woman that rang me up was kind of rude as well.

Whether you want Savor or Sweet, they've got you covered. Amazing pies made with high quality ingredients. Kind and friendly staff. The standard in pies! read more

My husband and I are huge fans of their pies! Hubby went recently to pick up two savory pies, one which was veggie curry and the other was chicken. Service is always with a smile and welcoming. The place is cute and nicer than their previous location in Warwick. The sweet pies are delicious and I intend to try them all. read more

See all

The pies are amazing. The atmosphere is fantastic. The crust is super good! I will def stop by again in the near future !!

This place is a gem. Was up on my annual trip to Warwick and stumbled upon this place. Had a slice of delicious quiche and an amazing slice of Key Lime Pie. Cozy atmosphere and friendly servers. read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

Delicious fresh pies! Their new location in Warwick NY is even more cozy. Shop is in a preserved Victorian house. The staff has always been consistently awesome and give excellent service read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

The pies are delicious and they have so many different kinds. Staff is always kind. Will be going back!

Phenomenal pies. We ate a few different flavors and everything was fresh and delicious. My kids had ice cream and I went nuts for their peach pies with the crumble. Absolutely delicious. read more

This place is so amazing. We have lived the pies for years but the new location is just so cute and charming. We had the new lunch special and they were so good. Took a pie home for dinner and it did not disappoint !! read more

We had the Berry pie - my husband ate a slice with each meal DELICIOUS!!! we are ordering the chicken pot pie next

We often purchase delicious pies from Noble Pies in Warwick, NY. For Christmas Eve we tried something new, baked Brie. OUTSTANDING doesn't scratch the surface. Gooey, rich Brie topped with chunky cranberry sauce and carmelized onions enrobed in their homemade flaky, buttery pie crust. And the service, extraordinary as always! Mia is an absolute Angel! read more

What a cute little shop with the most delicious treats and pies! a gem of a place worthy of a visit.

Stopped by because we were needing a sweet pick me up and coffee after Apple picking up Pennings Farm & Cidery. Although we were disappointed that the farm didn't have pie, we were very happy to have stepped in by chance to itch the craving. Got a slice of pumpkin pie to share and got three small pies to go - loved to hear that all the pie ingredients were sourced locally. read more

Noble Pies - Pumpkin Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

Lattes and slices of pie were quite delicious. Staff was accommodating even arriving 20 minutes before closing time. The new location is nice that it has seating, but it is split up into several different dining rooms due to the layout which was slightly odd read more

Thank you Noble Pies! This is what the town of Warwick needed, a fairly priced coffee lounge with a few eats. We ordered a couple of lattes and a pastry, which was a pleasant experience given the atmosphere. The coffee was quite tasty, which makes it stand out in this area. The positive reflection we have is the price being so reasonable. The service is kind and helpful. Looking forward to returning to create more experiences. read more

This has to be my favorite place to come here and get the most delicious Pies ever. I did not realize that I came here during their happy hour of receiving the 30% off . I decided to get three slices instead of one. The lady who was checking me out let me know that on weekdays after 3 pm - 6 pm, the slices are 30% . I never knew that, and I thought that was very cool, and it actually saved me some money. I would highly recommend coming here and checking them out . I absolutely love coming here and having some delicious pie. read more

Noble Pies - Very delicious - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

What a gem! Driving to apple picking we came across Noble Pies and was blown away by the savory, fruit, and chocolate options. A fork fight actually broke out over the last piece of ham cheese quiche. There are also baked goodies in their glass show case. Lined against the wall are ready to go pies in large and small sizes each displaying a flavor that makes you say "that one, no wait that one" indecisively. But most likely you'll end up like us and try pies slices warmed up while sitting on the wooden bench by the window and chatting with friends over the fresh made lattes. read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

We got a couple of slices to try and some whole pies to take home. Generally, there was a wide selection even at 4pm on a Saturday. Peach pie: somehow they added a lot of flavor to the peach filling, or maybe because it was at peak season? The pastry top could have afforded to be more flaky/crispy but it was very buttery. Mixed berry crumble: a customer recommended it in and so we tried it, which was a great selection. I appreciated it with the crumble on top which was more oat based. Cheesecake pecan: this was better than I expected. The cheesecake filling was NY style and worked well with the roasted pecans. The crust was the best out of the pies - maybe because it was baked the longest? Chocolate cream: it had a chocolate pudding like taste. It wasn't bad per se but after a while, I grew tired of it and it was the only one that we didn't finish. I took the whole tomato pie to go ($32). This was better than I thought - you would think it'd be like a pizza pot pie but it's not as heavy as that and a lot more veggie based. I was dismayed a little by how watery it came out at first but the soggy bottom somehow worked with the cheese and filling. Buffalo chicken pie (small): got this to go but haven't tried yet. read more

Noble Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

Stopped by for some pie and quiche. I thought the quiche was pretty darn tasty! My daughter opted for the key lime and we also got a slice of the chicken curry pie for my granddaughter to nosh on. The gentleman behind the counter was courteous, friendly, and very efficient. Service was great. I didn't know they had different options for breakfast items, will def try it out if we come back this way. The cherry pie we took back to our Airbnb was delicious!! read more

See all

Well the lady at. Punter was very nice the apple pie amazing pinapple very good pulled pork amazing flavor the chicken is ahh ok the shepherd pie one also it's ok Pulled pork is the winner read more

Came in here because we wanted a delicious pie. They had like no pies left on a Friday morning. They didn't really have anything left. I debated just going back up the road to buy a pie from somewhere else but since it was raining and my mom was like we'll just get slices so we did. Didn't realize the slices were way overpriced so basically for a pie by getting slices we spent like $40. My mom was like the guy could have mentioned it was much more money to do that but I mean why would he, they wanna make money lol. Pie we did get was good at least. read more

This store is right off Windermere Ave but it's a little hidden and can easily be missed if you are not paying extra close attention. Parking space in the back of the building is small. You can always park off the street and walk. As I entered the store, I noticed a comforting smell that reminds me of home cooked meals. Smell is very delicious!! There is very limited space - the counter is right there when you walk in and all you see are pies - no place to sit and enjoy the pie though. There might of been a bench outside the store but seems like a order to-go kinda store rather then a sit down store. I ordered the Shepherds Pie and the apple pie. Both pies came in 2 different sizes. The Shepherds Pie was delicious, it was missing something.. maybe cheese?? The meat was tasty and savory and the mashed potato on top was perfectly crispy on the outside and a little dry in the middle. The apple pie was buttery delicious! Not too sweet which I loved - a little dry. I would recommend this place and would love to try more items off the menu! The boy at the counter was helpful and nice as this was my first time ordering from noble pies! read more

Charming place with little parking. Pies r ok not great as listed. Was left waiting alone for several minutes.

Two pies were $65 dollars. There was almost no selection and I was taking them as dessert to a neighbors. I would have been better off going to the grocery. read more

The cherries in the cherry pie are great, but it feels like the company grew too fast and they no longer offer the customer service they used to. read more

First off, I want to state that I am likely a tougher critic because I do cook from scratch daily and I do make my own pies. We were staying with friends from the area and they raved about Noble pies so we picked up a Hudson Valley mixed apple, a cherry for variety, and a chicken pot pie (because we were headed home and it made for an easy dinner). First, the chicken pot pie. It is definitely well stuffed with chicken but the texture and consistency is like chicken salad stuffed into a pie shell. It ate mushy and dry. No gravy, no identifiable pieces of veggies like carrots, celery and onions to add texture. The pastry was dense and not flaky. I think the most off putting thing was a slightly sour taste to the pie. I wanted to give the fruit pies a chance in case it was a fluke that it was not so great. We tried the apple pie and it was underbaked. The bottom crust had no color and was bordering raw on the inside and barely cooked on the outside. Again the crust is dense and not light and flaky, The crimping was way too thick around the edges. The filling did have some apple flavor but was far too sweet. There was no tartness that you look for with apple pie. It was well filled but the underbaking, lack of spice and oversweet filling was really disappointing. We paid over $100 for these three pies and these first two were very disappointing. I had planned to freeze the third and take to a family Thanksgiving gathering but I expect that I will end up baking my own rather than take a chance on it for a family holiday. read more

Noble Pies - You can see how underbaked this bottom crust is on the apple pie. No color and still doughy - Bakeries Near Me - Warwick, New York

See all

Like some other reviewers have said, the price is very expensive, and the crust is very mushy. I have had to crisp it up in the air fryer. Can they try baking the crust longer? read more

To be fair the pies were made very good I changed my review Prices are expensive all over read more

This is such a cute and delicious pie shop - but it is hidden away! First of all, I lovee the decor! You can take some cute pictures of your pies here. The actual pies are delicious and there are soooo many different flavors to choose from! I tried the strawberry rhubarb, pulled pork, apple, and vegetable quiche. You haveee to get the apple pie! That was my favorite! All of the other pies were delicious as well! There are also two different crusts you can choose from (oats or a regular crust). I personally have no preference and liked both! The pies are a littttlee pricey, $6.5 per slice and about $16 for the smaller pie but each slice is pretty big and definitely worth it! read more

See all

I bought a cherry pie this weekend....I love cherry pie, but what I forgot was that though I asked if the crust was a butter crust and that was indeed confirmed, I had already bought one of Noble's pies before and found the crust so salty that even the sweetness of the filling did not overcome it. In addition, the crust is very thick and heavy so the recipe Noble uses is just not for me.....unfortunately. I recommend using unsalted butter, which I assumed was a given. No pie recipe I have ever seen has salted butter as an ingredient. read more

Simply the best pies in the area. I've had the sweet and savory pies flakey crust and yummy fillings. A must try! read more

A quick stop by for us on a road trip down from Maine. I was in the mood for pies and they delivered! We had the Chicken Pot Pie and the Strawberry Rhubarb and they were both sliced and heated up for us to enjoy. It wasn't busy as we arrived right before closing as a sort of pre-dinner snack. However, they did end up selling out of some of their more popular flavors by then. I think it's worthwhile to grab some pie to go if you're ever in the area. read more