Disappointed in myself that it took me this long to try Nicey Treat! From the very first bite, my husband and I looked at each other and immediately knew the hype was real. The shop itself is so inviting, offering popsicles, coffee, and other sweet treats, plus the cutest merch. At first glance, you might think, "It's just a popsicle." Trust me--it's so much more than that. The flavor selection is incredible, with everything from cucumber lime to banana pudding and just about every flavor you could imagine. I ordered the Strawberry Cheesecake popsicle dipped in milk chocolate and topped with graham cracker crumbles, and it was an easy 10/10. Honestly, I could've eaten five of them! My husband went with the Cookie Butter popsicle dipped in milk chocolate and finished with Biscoff cookie crumbles. He insists his was better than mine... but we'll just have to agree to disagree. Safe to say Nicey Treat has officially earned a spot on our list of favorite dessert spots. I would recommend it to absolutely anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth! read more

See all

Nicely Treat was such a fun stop! We tried the Blackberry Lemon popsicle and the Dark Chocolate Sea Salt popsicle dipped in dark chocolate with sprinkles, and both were incredible. The Blackberry Lemon was so refreshing with the perfect balance of sweet and tart--exactly what you want on a hot day. The Dark Chocolate Sea Salt was rich, creamy, and indulgent, and the chocolate dip with sprinkles made it even better. Everything tasted fresh and high quality, and we'll definitely be back to try more flavors. Highly recommend if you're looking for a delicious frozen treat in Fishers! read more

I had a great experience at Nicey. There is a lot of variety of popsicles and drinks as well. The guy who made my smoothie and prepared my popsicle deserves a raise! The place looked very nice! read more

This is not my first time having Nicey ice cream but my first time at this location. This location is very clean and the atmosphere is great. If you wanted to stay there and eat your ice cream they had seats for you. The employees were very friendly and answered any questions that I had. I love this ice cream so much I had to get 3 flavors for myself. I got the pineapple margarita, strawberry cream, and cookie butter. The cookie butter is my go to flavor because it is very delicious. The pineapple margarita was something new to try. It was good but on the sour side. The prices are reasonable. I will say that you got to hurry and eat the ice cream up because it will melt quickly. If you haven't tried Nicey you are missing out! read more

See all

Love love love this place. It is always my "go-to" for dessert when I am around fishers district. I love the variety of refreshing flavors they have and that it can fit any craving. The service is always okay and they usually get the popsicles done in a timely manner. The inside is clean and well kept, but I usually take my ice cream outside to enjoy it. I've been getting the key like flavor lately but would love to try their fruit pops next time like POG and pineapple. Highly recommend! read more

Nicey Treat - Key lime pie flavor with dark chocolate coating and crumbles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

7.19.25 Oh my gosh, it's been too long since I've been back! Still same great flavor choices, and pelasant staff. Was out with my hubs & mom, who both got the dark chocolate sea salt -- such creamy deliciousness. I opted for the very refreshing pineapple basil, which was a perfect ending after the dinner we had next door at Slapfish. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

Nice and friendly staff. I tried the cookies and cream ice cream bar and the not so hot chocolate ice cream bar. Both were really good! Nice and clean atmosphere. The ice cream was reasonably priced. read more

See all

Avocado popsicles! I came for the avocado popsicles, and have since tried many of Nicey Treat's more conventional popsicles, and I love them all. My last visit, I got a pineapple basil popsicle and it was amazing. It was kind of sweet, kind of savory. The thing with Nicey Treat is that there are flavors here for everyone. Even the unconventional flavors (like avocado) are tasty and I'm sure even the most picky people would like them if they just ventured out of their comfort zone. But even if you're not a person who wants to try new things, there are lots of tried-and-true flavors like banana cream, pink lemonade, watermelon and frozen hot chocolate. They also offer lots of vegan popsicles -- I'd say a good half of their menu is vegan. I always get my popsicles plain, but you can get them dipped in chocolate (milk chocolate or dark chocolate), and then top them with things like sprinkles, nuts, chopped peanut butter cups, toasted coconut or streusel. There are a few places inside the store to sit and eat, but Nicey Treat is located at the Fishers Yard District, where there are lots of things to see and do. So I suggest getting your popsicle to go and walking around The Yard. read more

Just a hot day and fancy popsicles in a very chic location. Just the right combo! I tried the vegan POG passion fruit, orange and guava and the Strawberry Rhubarb. Both the flavors were so different and extremely flavorful. Each lick was a different taste and summery vibes all along. The store is spacious and the lines go pretty quick. I, for one found the price pretty accurate. Service was really good where the server took the time out to share the ingredients, that was helpful since I wanted vegan only. read more

See all

Nice and refreshing treat after walking around The Yard in Fishers. A cute, clean, and cool store. I'm partial to the strawberry cream - flavorful and light. My husband is a key lime fan! My kiddo devoured the banana cream. The multiple times I've visited, the staff were kind with speedy service! The only thing you wait on is the person in front of you deciding on one of the many flavors. Some complain of the price point ($4 per popsicle) but for the fun, interesting flavors, you really are purchasing a craft treat. I'll be back! read more

See all

Sooo good. The ice cream bars are refreshing, have a good flavor, and there's so many to choose from. You can choose from their large variety of ice cream bars and have them as is or dip them in chocolate with toppings. We went with just the bars. For our first visit we got three. The Thai coffee. Wowwwww! Seriously soo good. The creaminess with the coffee flavor which wasn't too strong of a coffee flavor, was just amazing. I'd come back for this one for sure. The pink lemonade, which they say is their most popular, tastes exactly as you'd expect. A little tart and a little sweet. It is thirst quenching. The pineapple basil was good. At first, you have to get used to the basil in it because when they say pineapple basil you can definitely taste both flavors. I like that, you should be able to taste them without knowing what it is and you can easily guess it. That's how you know they nailed the flavor profile. Overall, a great place for a treat of after meal dessert. In the summer, take them with you and find a spot in the central area or a bench nearby. No better way to enjoy a summer day. read more

Nicey Treat - Pineapple basil, Thai coffee, Pink lemonade - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

If you're looking for the perfect summer sweet spot, Nicey Treat is it! I absolutely loved my visit. The atmosphere is vibrant and fun--perfect for a sunny day with friends or family. Their popsicle selection is creative and delicious, but the standout for me was the banana cream popsicle dipped in chocolate. It was rich, creamy, and just the right amount of indulgent. You can tell everything is made with care and quality ingredients. This place captures the joy of summer in every bite. Can't wait to go back! The staff were all very friendly and helpful! read more

If you haven't tried these gourmet popsicles and ice cream bars, you are most definitely missing out! It's a tough decision but the nice young man suggested the strawberry and he did not steer me wrong! I've had the raspberry popsicle, banana cream and strawberry cream latter two dipped in chocolate. The creaminess is absolutely perfect and the flavor is outstanding. The chocolate is a nice flavor that accompanies the creaminess of the ice cream bar that I will have to have another soon!!! The strawberry cream is my fave. Everyone enjoyed after dinner at Sweet Green. It's a great location in Fisher's District and is a nice change of pace for a dessert all can enjoy! There's something for everyone here. They even have some yummy looking cakes. Try one or two, you'll love it! read more

See all

Unique flavors and combinations. You might doubt a few but it's all worth a try. Never felt guilty eating this sweet dessert. It for some reason always amazes on how basil or any herb can taste so good in a "popsicle". Parking spot at store front and if full there's ample parking around. read more

My peanut butter pop was very good - I got it chocolate dipped. But with tip this treat was over $6.00- so "Nicey is pricey" for what you get. Would be tough to bring kids here at the price of a small pop. Maybe I'm missing something- but definitely more of an adult treat place. Cool, unusual flavors also. My peanut butter pop had a weird grainy texture when I got to the bottom. It was really refreshing until that grainy part. read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Gluten free- Yes, item specific Casein free- yes, item specific Pleasantly surprised to see Nicey Treat has another location that is so close by. Highlights: - offerings are listed on a clipboard chalk display on the wall as you enter - vegan options are called out on the signs. While there are many options that are naturally gluten free and casein free, you will need to verify, especially the ones with gluten. -the popsicles are flavorful; however, expect to spend $3+ after tax - parking can be tricky depending upon what time you stop by; however, most spots around the shop are a few minutes walk at most -there is a bench outside to sit at and enjoy your treat(s). read more

Nicey Treat - So many options to chose from - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Kind of costly but Delicious tasty treat!! When was the last time you enjoyed an avocado ice cream? Pineapple Basel ice cream? These popsicles come in sooo many unique and interesting flavors it's hard to choose just one! They also a variety of toppings they "roll" the ice cream in which adds even more deliciousness! I had the dark chocolate sea salt... it was creamy dark chocolatey salty goodness... (HINT have lots of napkins handy and maybe a wet wipe!) $3.50 each You can get a 12 pack delivered? Order by Tuesday for the Wednesday mailing. 12 for $30 Nicey is a local Indiana company. Shop Local Shop Small!! read more

See all

We stopped in here after dinner and could not have enjoyed our time more. We actually got 2 popsicles a piece. They are incredibly delicious. read more

I have heard of Nicey but never gone in. My daughter and I stopped in the Fishers location on our way to get facials. Wow so many selections and so many vegan options. I love the unique flavors they offered as well. Such a simple but unique concept. Hey Nicey Brownsburg would love you to come here read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This ain't yo mommas popsicle shop! There is a WALL full of flavors to choose from! I got a Pineapple Basil which was mmmm, so crisp. The Strawberry Mint was also so refreshing. In addition to choosing flavors, you can get your popsicle dipped if you prefer. The sitting arrangements are so unique. You can choose from popsicle benches outside or swinging stools indoors. The inside is cutely decorated & very clean. There's also frozen pies that you can buy to take home as well (hello Cookie Butter Pie!) You can choose from free street parking or free parking garage. read more

See all

Love these pricey little pops! They're worth the price for the quality ingredients and unusual flavors. Try one on a hot day and I guarantee you'll be back! Favorites; sea salt chocolate, coconut, Thai coffee, key lime, strawberries and cream. Yummy and nicey treats! read more

I don't have pictures but they sell amazing popsicles! I've gotten the cookie butter and Cajeta flavors and they were both awesome! They also have some healthy flavors like avocado and orange sour cream :) Must try read more

Nicey Treat is a fun popcicle shop and a change from the normal ice cream parlors. They have lots of choices and you can have your popcicle dipped in chocolate. I tasted the Strawberries and Cream and the Cherry Limade. Both were good on a hot day. Next time I'd dip the Strawberries and Cream instead of Cherry Limeade in the chocolate. read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Found them in Broadripple and so glad they came to Fishers. A nicey healthy treat, all natural ingredients with amazing flavor. Stop in and welcome this new shop to the Fishers Yard. Try the mango ginger my fav!!! read more

Such a cute place with so many options! Of note: the young lady working let us come in and order after she had locked the place up to go home for the evening. She was so sweet and we appreciated her! If you're looking for a fun and cool place to have some delicious popsicles, stop on in. read more

$4 per pop , pretty expensive for a small thing . But it was okay it wasn't bad !The service was quick but it was slow lol read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The experience was pleasant the young lady was informative. I was disappointed they were out of quite a few of the posted flavors. It is definitely somewhere I would venture to go to again but not regularly because it was kind of costly. read more

Love this place. Stopped in to check it out after coming from lunch. Great vibe, very clean. The lady was very helpful in helping us to pick which treat we wanted. There are unique flavors to choose from. Very very good! Definitely coming back! Perfect summer treat! read more

See all

Fun little shop for a quick treat. No easy place to sit but the ice cream bar was easy to eat quickly. $5 for ice cream is not too bad and the flavor selection is fun. Thai coffee dipped in dark chocolate was really good. Service was quick and friendly and everything looked and smelled really clean. read more

Amazing flavors! Friendly staff. Our Favorite flavors are: Passion Fruit Mango Ginger Strawberry and cream. We bought a whole box to try different flavors. I cannot wait. Remember to bring back your ten sticks. read more

After going to Sangrita down the street, myself and my group found ourselves at Nicey Treat. This place is super cute and nice to go to. All pops are reasonably priced as well as delicious! I had the key lime pop and was not disappointed! There is a very good variety of flavors to choose from for anyone who comes in. The only "minus" I could say would be that they do not have a lot of outdoor seating. Despite this, I think Nice Treat is a great option for a quick dessert! read more

Nicey Treat - Key Lime Pop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Never seen the concept of handmade popsicles before so we weren't very interested. That feeling quickly changed as we walked in and saw the list of flavors. OMG the flavors are amazing... just look them up and you will see. My family literally wanted to buy them ALL!!! Staff was incredibly nice and informative Only potential downside is the cream based options melt quickly, but it is worth the drops of melted popsicle on your shirt read more

I love their popsicles. They have flavors for everyone. I highly recommend going in a hot summer day. I got guava and really liked it. read more

Nicey Treat - Guave - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

If I could give this location less than one they would get a zero. Not because of their product, which we love, but because of their posted hours. We have been to this location twice based on the hours that are posted online and via voicemail. Both times when we have arrived the location is closed. It's not that hard to change your voicemail or to update your hours online so customers are not making needless trips to your location. read more

I was slightly obsessed after experiencing my first cookie butter nicey treat. I was telling everyone I knew that they needed to go to get one FAST, that they are so delicious. This is from a girl that would rather have a cookie or cake, not much of an ice cream fan typically. I love this place. It is slightly expensive so you should lick it to extend the joy. read more

We needed a last minute pie for Fathers Day so I quickly searched "pie" and to my surprise Nicey Treat showed up! We ran in and picked up a Key Lime pie and it was SO good. More of an ice cream texture and the crust was delicious. Happy to have had such a good experience and to be able to support local business! read more

Stopped by the new Nicey Treat in the Fishers District and really enjoyed it. The kids were happy with their dipped Not So Hot Chocolate pop-cycles, while the wife and I enjoyed the Thai coffee and cookie butter flavors. Nicey Treat is a nice change up for dessert and a quick in and out if you get a good parking spot. read more

We have loved this place for years and would make the trek to BRoad ripple or their little window on the cultural trail downtown. And now, it is just down the street from us and we are sooo lucky. Love their rotating options and creative flavor combinations like Strawberry basil or blood orange sour cream. Do yourself a favor and try the cookie butter;Nothing better. Always friendly service too. read more