After having a bad day, I decided I needed a quality treat!…read more graeter's was the treat my soul needed. The ice cream is so delicious! Staff is kind and friendly. Can't wait to go back!

Delicious ice cream store with indoor and outdoor seating. Staff is friendly and helpful.read more

The best life cream shop! I prefer Handels over all of the places I've tried. The ice cream is very…read moregood and they have lots of flavors. This is always where we go for a sweet treat.

4 stars. My favorite…read moreflavors: Cinnamon Roll Birthday Cake Cake Batter Lemon Bar Butter Pecan Vanilla Pros: Amazing flavors! Great value! Huge scoops! Coupons in monthly junk mail Sugar free and dairy free options Online ordering available Cons: Line can be atrociously long. Walk Up Service only No indoor seating

Always stop in for this treat when in Carmel! Very cool experience for the kids. Expect a little…read morewait while the make your treat!

Such a fun experience! When you go here you not only receive ice cream, but you also are…read moreentertained as you watch them create a magical masterpiece before your eyes. Service was helpful and quick.Pretty busy inside and a little loud so if you plan on having an intimate conversation maybe take it to go... Many tables to choose from. Something I didn't realize until after I'd ordered is that there is a coffee cafe that sells from within their shop... I will return to try the coffee and report back. It is called 1832 Brew Expresso Bar. Ice cream choices are many and so tasty! I tried the pistachio this time and enjoyed it!

Although this tasted good, be prepared that the prices are higher than normal. Friendly quick…read moreservice. Outdoor tables. I believe that on Wednesday they have some discounts m, so I may return then, but not on another day because the prices seemed too much.I do like the drip catchers and that you can choose your two scoops for the single scoop.

Well, one of my friends suggested getting the caramel macchiato. I was going to try that. Then I…read moresaw southern banana pudding and had to try it. I like Handel's banana pudding but, this to me is 10x's better!!! The texture of this ice cream is so creamy and perfect! They make the ice cream daily in store and use a copper kettle! They have over 150 flavors that are on rotation! I saw they had cherry vanilla ice cream and yep going to have to try that also. This is brand new recently built store. They have a rewards system for coupons and points. They had little dino cups for kids also. They have sundaes too. Strawberry shortcake and the peanut butter cup sounds good! My portion for a medium was huge! The staff was nice and fast. Many years ago I saw Bruster's out east and realized it's a Pennsylvania company. So, that would make sense seeing so many out east. Can't wait to try the other flavors and that coffee one! Will be back!

5 stars. I would…read morenever think to combine Italian ice and custard, but I'm glad someone did! I enjoy the sour Italian ices, but they didn't have any on my last visit He told me to call the day before and he would make sure someone made it the next morning! How sweet is that?!? Definitely a lil pricey, but isn't everything nowadays? They have a couple of tables where you can sit or walk down to the Nickel Plate and grab a seat or swing. Solid weekend afternoon outing for the fam.

Rita's is a pretty good deal for the price. I got my nieces some treats -- a small strawberry…read morecustard with gummy bears for one; a cherry Italian ice for the other. (About $5 each) The custard portion was more than my 4 yo could finish in one sitting but she loved it and it looked great! The cherry Italian ice cup was packed full and made for a good treat for my older charge on a hot day. The staff were super friendly and made sure to offer helpful suggestions-- like making the cone into a cup/cone hybrid to help her eat without big spills. They're a walk up shop, so they have order windows where you ring the little doorbell for service, they take your order, then you get it at the pick up window. They were pretty quick to fulfill orders too! Outdoor seating lines the sidewalks. When we were there, we snagged the last shaded table! I imagine when it's busy over the summer, you'd have to truly take it to go. Was definitely worth a stop for us today!

Good ice cream. You can tell it is a quality product with a low water content and a rich flavor. I…read moream not a fan of Ben & Jerry's values as a company but they serve a good product. We like to walk to this Carmel location from the Monon Trail. That also means they compete with Graters Ice Cream (also off the Monon) with our family. I think I enjoy both establishments, but Graters is our favorite. Plan to grab n' go because the seating is limited.

Sunny weather in February means ice cream. You gotta celebrate the wins (the sun) amidst the…read moreabysmal dreariness that is February in Indiana. No ice cream for me, however, because I'm not a fan. But my children like that cold, sweet mucus, so off we went by foot to enjoy the sun and the new Ben & Jerry's in Carmel. The only Ben & Jerry's in Indiana is located on the corner of Rangeline Road and 116th Street. It's also just right off of the Monon Trail, which is how we got to it. If you visit Central Park, just follow the walking paths to the Interurban Trail, which goes around the park, and take it to the end. Voila! The ice cream shop. They got all the hits here: Cherry Garcia, Chunky Monkey, Half Baked. My children wanted simpler flavors, though: plain chocolate and chocolate chip cookie dough in a cup. But you'll find all of your favorite B&J flavors here, scooped out fresh. They also have pints in a little freezer off to the side, as well as pup cups. We brought our dog, and because he has serious FOMO, we got him one of the pup cups: peanut butter and pretzel. Another one of my dog's issues is that he has no sense of his own mortality, so he tried to eat the whole frozen block of ice cream in one gulp, and then almost choked on the ice cream. So be aware: The pup cups are very frozen! You might want to let them melt a bit before feeding them to your dog. You'll also find brownies and chocolate chip cookies, ice cream cakes that you can order (no cakes to grab-and-go that I saw), cookie dough bites, ice cream bars, sundaes and shakes. There are a few seats inside, but since the Monon Trail is just steps away, if you ask me, your best bet is to get your ice cream to go and enjoy it while walking.

Customer Service was amazing and the ambience is very relaxing with nice music. Overall, enjoyed…read morethe cookie and cinnamon roll I bought totally worth the experience.

Service definitely isn't why I give this place 3 stars. Service was spot on…read more I personally base this off if cost is worth it. I personally think that you aren't given a big enough cinnamon roll to justify. I may be spoiled by the size of Cinnabon thought. I will give them that the taste was good and the toppings were generous. Atmosphere-wise...it's cute...but, I will there were a couple safe style tables and chairs to sit in...either outside or inside...I say this, as I am a person that if I'm going out to enjoy a food item, I want yo be immersed into the place while I eat my food...not be forced to face to either eat it in my car or go home or someplace else enjoy. Overall, it's a good place, just didn't meet a good bulk of what I look for when I'm going yo enjoy something.

Great prices, large menu with different treats and hot food, decently-paced service…read more Went here for the first time today and I definitely will be back; I'd love sit in their outdoor area! I got a gelati with rootbeer italian ice and it was great. Portion sizes are generous as well; I got a small and it was plenty.

Everytime that I come on these hot summer days, I can count on 2 things, amazing customer service…read moreand some of the best frozen custard. The service is ALWAYS fast and efficient. I had a taste for a turtle sundae and this gem was calling my name. Theee absolute best in the city . The custard super creamy and flavorful, the pecans are buttery and crisp (some of the freshest) more caramel and fudge then you could possibly imagine topped with whipped cream and a cherry. I see one in my future. If you have an opportunity, stop by a Ritters Frozen Custard and grab one.