Ordered from DoorDash and they had a special for large pepperoni pizza and deals on the appetizers. We tried the poppers and potato skins. The food was freshly prepared, made well and tasted really good. I'm usually hesitate to try new pizza but they made it really well. The crust was good and an even amount of sauce and cheese! The pizza was thoroughly cut too! And I like how they put their appetizers in foil to keep them warm for delivery and didn't forget the ranch to with it! I would definitely order from here again! read more

See all

Ordered a medium cheese only pizza. Should be $11.99, it's a deal they offer for medium 1 topping. Charged me $16 because a cheese pizza has "a little more cheese" so doesn't qualify as a 1 topping pizza.. I mean come on?! Never coming back here. read more

I ordered regular crust pizza and they gave me cracker thin crust. Both of my pizzas are cracker thin and they're not doing anything about it. make sure you don't order from this place or you're gonna be very upset when you get your pizza. And they will refused to help. read more

See all

If there was zero rating, I would choose that. This was my first time ordering from them and my last. I ordered off DoorDash and the breadsticks did not say anything about a dipping sauce it came with. So I added into the special instructions that I wanted a ranch and a marinara since I ordered TWO breadsticks. Once the pizza was delivered to my house I got a message that they charged me an extra $2.28 because of my instructions. I called over to the place and the guy that answered said the breadsticks come with a ranch. I explained to him that it does not say that when you order hence the reason I added it into the instructions. If I was ADDING a sauce there was a button for that which I didn't hit. The guy on the phone just sat there and did not speak back with a solution or anything at that. I then told him someone could've called me to confirm what I ordered and that there will be an extra charge if I added sauce. The guy on the phone still sat there in silence. I did not authorize ANYONE to take more money off my card. Yes it's only $2.28 but this is terrible customer service! On top of that, the marinara sauce is extremely bland. THIS IS IN NO WAY NEW YORK PIZZA! read more

Great mom and pop owned pizza shop. Pizza was good quality and delicious for the price. They even do pizza by the slice here. Service was quick and staff were friendly. read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

You know, sometimes reviewing businesses can be very difficult just for the simple fact that you meet an owner of a business that you like because he or she or they are so personable they have great customer service, and everything about them says that the business should be amazing. For this little hole-in-the-wall pizza place, the owner told me he has had the business for about three years and unfortunately, I just don't see the cleanliness in the restaurant that I would like to see the windowsills are all dirty the LED lights are falling, there is dirt buildup around the edges of the counter, dead flies. The floor is dirty. I just truly feel that this little restaurant should be taken so much better care of than what I was able to see when I walked in. I do think that because they are located near a school. It is a great business practice that they sell pizza by the slice and the price seems reasonable for that since most kids do not have a lot of money to spend from the other pictures on Yelp that I see of the pizza that has been made. I don't see too many issues personally, I did not try the food here unfortunately due to the cleanliness issues that I saw I wouldn't try the food but as far as financially I see that this business could be very successful just for the simple fact that it's pretty much takeout only they do have a few foldable chairs and two foldable tables that I saw that are very small And again for me that goes back to the whole cleanliness factor. You don't have a whole lot to clean and everything can be moved relatively easily so I believe that this restaurant should be spotless almost all the time. Again, I can see where this business would lose a lot of money. I do see a lot of unnecessary expenditures, and I also see quite a few things that could be changed easily that would better fit the aesthetic of a pizza place and probably draw more customers in. I do think with some help this business could thrive, especially in the area that it's in even though it's almost directly located across the street from another pizza restaurant. Maybe at a later date, I would go in and revisit this location to see if things have changed, and then possibly try the food as from when I could see it looks like it could be good but until some changes are made, I probably will not be visiting read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - a chalkboard menu on the counter - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

Ordered a pizza, this place is very convenient for me and I picked up pizza. The pizza was ordered with light sauce and was very clear when ordering over the phone. Said very light sauce. When picking up I opened the pizza and the pizza sauce was packed in there all along the edges of crust and thick throughout the pizza. I asked politely if that is considered light sauce and the girl working said yes that is light sauce. You wouldn't believe the amount of sauce on that pizza. She said she couldn't remake it and I was out of luck. I asked her to call the manager or owner. Then she proceeded telling the owner that the pizza had light sauce on it and the customer was wrong and fought hard to not remake a medium 1 topping pizza. In the end they remade the pizza but it took a big event to have them remake. I wouldn't recommend this place due to overall customer service and the fact they want to debate with the customer about what they ordered. read more

I ordered pizza from New York pizza on bruceville road. The Chicago thickness and it was thick, soft and chewy. I dont live close to that location so I ordered from the closer location on elk grove florin. Holy crap it was a monumental mistake. It does not look anything like the one I got from the bruceville location. I used to work at a pizza restaurant and this looks like regular dough thickness. Not only does it look like regular dough -- I highly doubt this was allowed to ferment long enough because it's tough, super chewy. I called about this and the staff was pretty rude citing go to the other location if you want it like that. I'd give it negative stars if possible. Don't waste your time and money with this establishment. Go to the bruceville location. There's a thin layer of toppings. I tried to soldier down the pizza but gave up after a few slices. You guys should be ashamed of the poor quality food and service. Should have read the reviews prior to ordering thinking they all produce the same quality. Some of these positive reviews have to be the owners family or friends! Just saying- read more

See all

One of the best pizza place in town that also gives great service. Will recommend and we'll come back again.

Will never go here again. I asked if they can remake it and NOT burn the cheese. They said no, that's how they make it. No thanks! Never again. read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Never again - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

New York pizza good pizza, friendly staff and weekend coupons I never have a bad experience ordering with them

Stopped by for a mid day snack. Wanted to see if they offered pizza by the slice- they do! We ordered two slice of pepperoni pizza for a total of $5.36. Our slices were made fresh to order, which meant a 5-10 minute wait... NOT BAD. they also have Parmesan cheese, crested red peppers, plates, etc for you as well. Customer service is welcoming, friendly. There are literally two mini tables inside with a few chairs. This is really a call in and pick up place or a grab a slice sit for a bit and go- some might even classify it a a hole in the wall. read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

It's great pizza! And affordable! Been going here for 10 years and no issues!!! I would come here right after school and get me some slices of pizza they were / are perfect!! read more

I ordered a pizza yesterday and I'm very disappointed. The pizza had no flavor. Seems like you changed your cheese and tomatoe sauce with cheaper ingredients. The ingredients tasted bland and had no flavor. read more

My daughter and I used to walk here during the pandemic, get a slice and walk home. We hadn't been there since so we decided to return today. Apparently it is under new ownership. We ordered slices of pizza and drinks and said we would eat there. However, the little table was sticky and dirty. I asked for a wet rag to clean the table. The cashier who took our order said they don't have wet cleaning rags. I asked for whatever they use to clean. She asked the man making pizzas then handed us some wet wipes. I cleaned the table myself while she sat on a chair and did nothing. I showed her the filthy wipes and told her that's how dirty the table was. She didn't seem to care so I told her that's a health code violation. Again, blank stare. When we finished eating (pizza is just so-so), I asked where we should toss our paper plates. There was no trash can. She said there was a garbage can outside. I saw none. She insisted there was one. She finally agreed to take our plates and throw them in their trash but we had to clear the table and bring them to her. As we left, I saw a garbage can down at the end of the walk. Clearly not the restaurant's garbage can. Won't be back. Miss the old owners. read more

We wanted to try a new pizza place near our home and we were recommended this place. We ordered delivery through door dash and it took about 45 mins to get it delivered. Pretty fast since it was a Friday. The pizza was very good, flavor on point, everything was good. Not so oily but very tasty. This is our go to spot from now on. read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Garlic sauce, pepperoni and jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

See all

TL;DR: Pretty okay/good special for Monday and Tuesday (BOGO); wonky pricing system; Pizza is great for Kids, but I prefer other places. Location: Located on Elk Grove-Florin Rd in the same shopping center as a dry cleaner and a Mexican meat market. There's plenty of parking in the parking lot. Pizza: So preface I've been in a little writing funk lately, but my experience here has shaken me out of my writing funk. Any ways, I took advantage of their Monday & Tuesday deal, which is buy one get one pizza. I ordered 1 combo pizza and a half chicken garlic and half all meat. Total is about 32 something. If you look at their gallery on their website. They show pizza that's loaded with toppings and most of their older yelp photos are the same. However, If you look at the recent photos on Yelp there really aren't that many. Any ways, the amount of toppings was adequate. If you like a lot of toppings go to Delish Pizza on Folsom Blvd. As for the quality of toppings, I personally like nice long strips of onions and bell peppers. New York Pizza they cut the toppings much smaller like 1 inch. Although the toppings on this pizza were a little too diced up for me, I did like the crust on the pizza. Other Pizza places: Comparison to other pizzas near by, I think Old Town Pizza and Taphouse has better toppings. New York Pizza must have some sort of dynamic pricing going on because a Medium gourmet pizza is $17 + $5 for upsize to XL =Total $22 + Tax ($2.04) (these numbers have been pulled on NY Pizza's website). A XL gourmet pizza should be about $24.04 with sales tax. However, I paid $32.85, so there's some sort of wonky price system that isn't clear. If I paid the amount posted on the website for two pizzas then this is easily a 4.5 or 5 if you include value in your rating. But the pricing isn't straight forward or maybe it hasn't been updated. Comparing it to other pizza places that have a BOGO deals on Monday/Tuesday like Pizza guys (Costs about the same). I would have to pick Pizza Guys over New York Pizza, due to my last experience at pizza guys they were a little more heavy handed with the toppings. Overall: While I did enjoy the crunchy crust of the pizza, I don't think I would order again any time soon. You can see the pictures for toppings references. read more

See all

I just ordered and ate part of a Hawaiian pizza. Something wasn't right with it. Lack of flavor, it just wasn't good. I'm sorry but it wasn't. I threw away the other half. Maybe the sauce? It had no flavor to it. read more

My go to white sauce pizza with chicken and garlic is one of the best I've had, definitely recommend

Great service, great price and great taste. We had ton of youth come over to our house for New Year's Eve. Kids wanted pizza so it would be easy. All the kids love the taste of it and we loved the price and service. read more

A regular here, been around since the previous owner, one of our favorite pizza places! Not greasy, not too saucy, and great crust! Plus a good price as well! I'm glad that the quality has stayed the same and maybe almost gotten better! read more

I've been coming here for years. I've been let down enough to where I'm never coming back.. They made my pizza incorrectly, which is not a big deal. They simply forgot to add a topping. But instead of fixing it correctly and remaking the pizza, the lady crumples up some extra salami, and throws it on top after the pizza was already cooked. With everything being so expensive these days it's really not OK to cut corners with your regular customers people that support your business day in and day out. I ordered another pizza be done correctly and paid for both without making an issue. The second pizza I received was rushed through the oven, so it was cold, and the cheese was hardly melted.... Not only that but they were super scampi with the toppings instead of adding whole pepperoni they cut them all I'm half.. Like you've already screwed me once let's just keep it going, right!!!! I could tell that the gentleman behind the counter did not care at all ... No one apologize for the mixup, but they were all too. Happy to charge my card again. All in all I paid $40 for two pizzas that are what I wanted.. this business has wasted my money, and my time enough... I encourage you to shop where they care about their customers and treat them correctly... This place absolutely does not care about you as a customer, even if you've been loyal to them for years, so do yourself a favor and go get your pizza from a business that treats their customers how they would like to be treated -jm read more

Enjoyed the NY Garlic Artichoke Pizza, would rate it a solid 9/10, they were generous with the toppings which was nice. We made a custom pizza composed of pepperoni and sausage and it was also pretty good, would rate it an 8/10. Lastly, the cheesy garlic breadsticks were great, I could taste the garlic and the cheese was well proportioned to the bread. Will be coming back again soon. (: read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Custom: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza, NY New York Garlic Artichoke Pizza, Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

Me and my brother ordered a pizza and when my brother got home realized they gave us the wrong pizza. When he called back he was told to call again 10 minutes later to talk to the owner because he was out delivering pizzas. No big deal to us, we called back and boy.. He was unfortunately, quite rude. He blamed us for the mistake and assumed we just wanted a free pizza. when we told him we hadn't touched the pizza we received and genuinely just wanted the pizza we actually ordered, he told us to bring the pizza back and they'd get us the right one. When my brother got there he overheard the man telling his employee to be careful with people that call because they got the wrong pizza since they usually just want something free. How rude can you get..??? My brother didn't deserve this type of treatment at all. We've been coming to them for years, whoever hurt this guy and his pockets in the past is obviously still haunting him. He lost some very loyal customers tonight :/ read more

Their veggie pizza is really good. I've been in only one location, it's your typical pizza spot, the service is acceptable

I got 2 slices of cheese for my son. I had a small bite and it wasn't bad. He likes it which is what really matters. I would get it again. read more

New owners... we came in and the costomer service was horrible...the asian guy is so rude to everyone that comes in . won't come back here again... read more

I have been going to this place for 20+ years. Never again!! The new owner is rude and employs rude people. Food quality definitely has gone downhill big time! You would think that with all the much better competition and for being such a hole in the wall that they would appreciate their customers instead of being dicks. read more

The pizza is average. The customer service from the manager sucks. I ordered a CYO 5 topping pizza on their website. It allowed me to select up to 3 toppings and I had to add the other 2 toppings as extra. It charged me $2.50 each additional topping. I brought that up to the staff and a manager came out and acted like I was trying to scam them. I was just trying to get clarification that the 5 topping CYO is just that, 5 toppings for the price. The online system only allowed me to select 3 toppings as part of the pizza. He tried to explain to me that I only selected 3 toppings and the 2 extra toppings are extra charge. WTF? Obviously, this guy does not understand their product and marketing. Sure, it was only $5 extra, but $5 extra on overpriced pizza is still a scam. I was trying to explain to him the problem so he could try to get it fixed, not because I was trying to get a free pizza! I guess my 37 years in IT working as a systems analyst/computer programmer did not help me to understand their order system. Eye roll. I am having a difficult time finding decent pizza in Elk Grove. New York Pizza has the benefit of being close to my home. But hey, there are many other pizza places that are not much further. read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

New ownership, I assume. It used to be ok, but now it is just terrible. My kids liked to get the slice deal after school. They must have been sold. My kids saw the price increase and were like, na, I'll get a burrito at Fiesta. So we had not ordered in a while. So, after band camp, I called in a pepperoni pizza for my husband to pick up on the way home. He got there and was like, 2 pizzas? I said no. I ordered 1 pepperoni X large. They told him there were 2 orders for Mike and he just took the one that was 2 pizzas... oy! So, we open it up and we have a cheese and a pizza with white sauce, japs, ham and PINEAPPLES. The whole fam was like, eww, I'm not eating this. My daughter said: It looks like there's cheddar on the cheese pizza! EWW! We might have eaten the cheese pizza. We were hungry. Son was marching all day. The other pizza was a no go. No one wanted that. ( the new owner explained to me they *had* to put cheddar on the cheese pizza. ???? That makes no sense. The whole family said they would not eat the pizzas. I hate to waste food. And I was ticked off we spent over $40 on wasted food that was supposed to cost $16. Not to mention, whoever this other Mike is, he's gonna show up and his pizzas are not there. Plus, now we're deep into the late hour of takeout on a Friday with no dinner. So I called back and explained the situation 3 times to the person who answered the phone. I tried to explain we have the wrong order, and some poor guy named Mike won't have his order. 3 times, this guy said, I don't understand." I explained 3 times. Finally, I get a manager who says : what do you want? And I was like, I'd like a pepperoni pizza delivered. He said: you can bring those pizzas back and we'll exchange it for a Pepperoni pizza. I was like, ok, but I want a refund on the difference. I showed up and got a cold pepperoni (probably our original) I returned the other 2 pizzas and got a $23 refund. They insisted they didn't have our original order, but I think the cold pizza during rush hour begs to differ. read more

I went in New York Pizza to order for the second time since it's been under the new management, and I experience very rude service. I must say the food was pretty good but I don't want to spend my money at a place where I'm being treated rudely. So it's a no, thanks for me. read more

I have eaten Pizza's from New York Pizza for over 10 years and always enjoy the quality of the food. My family and employees are always pleased as well. Great pizza and Ali, the owner, is very friendly. I love a variety of Italian foods from various places and New York Pizza is one of my favorites. Now that's Italian! I recommend you try one tonight. David Woodel, CEO / Broker Woodel Insurance Services Inc. read more

I order here all the time. Tonight I ordered Ave was told 45 to 50 min two hours later, I called beyond polite explained that I have young kids and if they told me two hours when I ordered I would of passed tonight. Manager said $10 off and your pizza will be there in 20 minutes. Me ok .. 40 minutes later I call and speak to manager again she says $10 off next time? I said you already offered $10 off this time ? She said goodbye and hung up. Beyond rude will never order here again. Driver said it should be free read more

This is solely based on taste. I'd rate it a 4.1/10. There's many pizza places around the country that don't look fancy, are old, etc. But the only thing that matters is taste. This was Costco pizza and honestly Costco pizza might be better so my apologies to Costco. The flavor was okay, felt very doughy, it was a thin pizza but had no crunch at all which means it needed to be in the oven longer. I really hope the owner reads this because I wanted this place to be actual New York style pizza. I've had good to great New York style pizza in New York. From Joe's to Lazzara's to Angelo's coal oven pizza. If the owner just watches a video on how to make New York style pizza, he'll have more people coming to his business. But don't call it New York style and serve this. The only thing close to New York style pizza in Sacramento is Uncle Vito's and that place is okay. Hopefully this place will be better in the future. read more

Eh... the pizza was eatable. Lacked flavor. The sauce and dough were bland. Probably won't be going back here again. It's more of a takeaway place. They do have 1 table with some foldable chairs, if your desperate. The service was not bad , I did not experience any rude employees like the other reviewers. I was hoping it was good, because it's so close to my house. read more

I stopped in to order a pizza and some wings to go. I ordered a thin crust 2 toppings (pepperoni and sausage) with white garlic sauce and the BBQ wings. I also asked for a side of classic red sauce to dip- it tasted great! The service was extremely friendly and helpful. You wont trust me until you try yourself, but I think they sell the best pizza in town. Definitely will come back!! read more

Literally had the worst experience of my life on my brothers death anniversary over charged me and false advertised absolutely made the whole night worst. This literally used to be my favorite pizza place for events. read more

Had a work event and called the night before to see if they could have 10 pizzas done at lunch time. The guy who answered the phone was super nice and related no problem. I gave him my order and we agreed on a time. I showed up and everything was hot and done. Super friendly guy! I took the pizzas to the crew and they all loved the pizza. I will definitely be back! read more

This place is dishonest and taking advantage of the students. He is charging more than 1.99 a sluce as he has advertised on his sign. Then when you call him out for over charging he says, "Yeah...your right." I took a refund today....it is the principal. He can jip someone else. Then he gave the box to the customer at the counter...he doesnt know what we did to the food when it left the resturant...I took the box back in....it says they passed their inspection....but that is suspect! We are done there..... read more

New York Pizza - Elk Grove Florin Rd - Don't trust this business .. - Pizza Near Me - Elk Grove, California

LOVE New York Pizza! They have several locations, are friendly, make Pizza quickly, and always have an ample supply of coupons to help save the consumer money. Recommend the pepperoni pizza hands down! I usually always do the afternoon pick up between 11am and 5pm and a large one topping pizza is only $8.99! And the pepperoni is not greasy. Love it here! read more

See all