Best eggplant parmigiana we've had in a long time. Everyone liked their meals: pasta with butter,…read morefettuccine Alfredo and huge portions. Italian wedding soup is amazing. I want to go back just for that. Leftovers for 2 nights!

Ordered cheese steak. It was nasty!! You pick it up and the bread disintegrates in your hand…read more Reminds me of a restaurant impossible episode. The sandwich was crap. Portion sizes are large. Pizzas look good, but as for cheesesteaks, I threw mine away. I will never go back. Stick to pizza. Service and ambiance are good.

Very quiet and low traffic place to enjoy a lunch or dinner. Service is very friendly and fast to…read morenotice you. As for food, I loved the garlic bread, never had with tomato sauce and raw minced garlic on top. It was good and more mellow in punch compared to garlic butter. Chicken soup was good, the noodles were very al Dante, but way more celery and carrots than chicken. Jamaican beef patty was good, nothing dissimilar to what you get elsewhere. The zuppa di pecse , the penne I got with was good, very al Dante. Plenty of mussels and clam, all cooked great, but man only like three shrimp which was a letdown. But credit to them they butterflied shrimp and cooked so it was tender but not rubbery. The sauce was flavorful but wish it could thicken since it was watery. Credit to them for having cheap lunch specials if don't want dinner portions on their menu.

Let's begin shall we?…read more April 17th I ordered a cranberry walnut salad and seltzer with delivery off the slice app. Salad arrives with no salad dressing or cranberries. I call and they say they can't do anything and if I can drive in to pick up the dressing and cranberries. So I say to myself ok "small business" it's a mistake don't worry I'll give them another shot. I was wrong. April 19th today I ordered a pasta dish. 2 seltzers, rice ball & a cranberry walnut salad. Again the salad has no dressing, the seltzers are missing and no rice ball. I call again now a-little more angry than last time. Request a refund. They tell me they can't do anything. To call the app and ask for a refund. I call the app to request a refund for the salad that has no dressing for a second time. And they only refund me for the missing dressing? Where they said they will give me a refund for the salad. Who eats salad without dressing? I do not recommend this place. I only recommend if you like eating dry salad without dressing.

Came here on a weekend with a couple friends and definitely stayed longer than I planned. We got a…read moremix of stuff - the pizzas are really good, I was even full and couldn't stop eating. Their tofu triangles were a random thing I tried and they ended up being really tasty (it surprised me). Service was also great and the staff was super nice. They treated us as a group like it was no thing. There was a bit of a wait time but we weren't bothered at all. The area is very chill, and there's a small beach area right next to it, which if you wanted to hang out and not rush or anything it kind of works out. I would come back for sure, it is one of those places that just feels good to be at not just for the food.

Got to Bethel early we were starving saw this place WHAT a great move…read more Service was excellent even though the place was crowded. There's a deck right on the Lake front and a second floor deck also. Drinks were excellent and the Pizza was great NOT a five star of course but if your looking for that in this area move on but if your looking for a fun place on the water with delicious food This is it. Try the corn ribs WOW we had two servings of those never had them that way before. If you're going to Bethel Woods for a concert this is the first stop. Beers were cold and the drinks made perfect.

uncooked dough lazy and completely disgusting it was rushed because they wanted to be done and go…read morehome never ordering here again

My family and I enjoy their pizza. Way better than mountain view's. The staff are also kind people!read more

Wow! Friend recommended this place! It sure came through! Our dinners were just top quality! Huge…read moreportions at a reasonable price! Hidden gem! Must try!

First let me say, Pellegrino's will always be our go to place to eat! Now it BREAKS my heart to…read morewrite this review!! Fried Ravioli (5) they were extremely overcooked to the point that they were close to burnt!! Chicken Broccoli Alfredo the flavor was very good BUT the alfredo sauce was Very Soupy!! The Creamy Garlic Butter Salmon with asparagus over pasta had two huge issues, first there was NO asparagus and second the creamy butter garlic sauce was extremely SALTY!! The only good dish was the Chicken Francaise. The chicken was very tender and delicious, just a wee bit too much lemon but still very tasty. Rate: 2/5

It was a beautiful atmosphere but I haven't been here since 2023 the food was great everything was…read moredelicious and the servers and staff were wonderful

We stopped here as a halfway point between NYC and Cooperstown…read more We ordered both pizzas and sandwiches. The pizzas are about 25 centimeters in size and can easily be shared, or enjoyed individually if you're hungry. The sandwiches are also generous enough to share. The pizza here is incredible, with a perfectly executed crust. The house salad is made with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, served with a balsamic dressing. Everything tasted very fresh and crisp. Cosimo's does not disappoint.

Great small business yet amazing, the pizza is taste amazing and pretty cheap this place out huts…read morethe Pizza Hut also when they say "have a nice day" don't say "your welcome" like I did

The service was amazing! The food was great my family and I had a great dinner, would go again! The…read morevibe was very welcoming.

I love this place. We always come when we're in the Catskills. Great Greek food, very generous…read moreportions, friendly staff, cute decor. Such a gem!

This is a fine restaurant that provides consistency, excellent service and excellent fresh food…read more The only drawbacks are due to the popularly of this restaurant. One has to get there quite early for dinner to have any chance of getting in. I'm also quite disappointed that they won't delinate the orders for a table. For example my order and my wife's order can't be separated from my sister and brother in law's order despite the two orders being quite different in price. This is a new policy that hopefully won't lead to a drop off in popularly. This HAS happened with some other restaurants. Recommended