Pizza and sandwiches were soggy each time I ate there (5x). Service is usually ok. Restaurant is cute inside/ outside and decent parking. At the end of the day I'm there for the food so I won't be going here anymore unless I'm invited by a friend who is craving it... but that has yet to happen. I have the money to spend, but I still think the place is overpriced for what it is. read more

Was really pleasantly surprised by this place - pizza is really good (we have tried several over the last few weeks). The most amazing thing might be the spinach artichoke dip - unique and tasty. Beer selection in smaller towns is often coors light or bud light, but this place has so much to choose from - you need to have a DD to try a couple. read more

Food, service, went recently and were rushed to leave, server kept coming back every 5 minutes way before closing time and it wasn't even busy, I can see why, I won't be coming to back to waste my money on awful tasting food with awful service and they also treat a certain race better than others read more

Awesome pizza fire oven ambience for super the food was super appetizers were great The artichoke with the little bread was amazing. read more

See all

Anna was an amazing sweet kind server. The red sauce (marinara) was so delicious. I enjoyed the vibe and was able to work while waiting on someone to take a test. The gentlemen (I forgot his name) was very knowledgeable and helpful. read more

A colleague suggested Nardello's for an early dinner. Kudos to her. I really liked the ambiance of this old building on the square in Mount Pleasant. The brick walls and wide plank floors with some white wall toward the back of the space maximized the light from the storefront windows. Open and clean by day, but I'm guessing pretty romantic with some d lighting in the evening. Super fresh, crisp, and tasty Jimmy's salad! Sal-Fredo pizza was a little bland but had a good gluten free crust. Meaty, cheesy, savory and a little sweet goodness on the charcuterie board. Margherita pizza was good standard fare with a reportedly yummy wood fired crust. The service was spot on but it was early and we were the only patrons for most of the meal. But they seemed to know the menu well and made good recommendations, so I'm guessing busy times are fine too. read more

See all

Now, I love coming here because we have few places in Mount pleasant that offer a decent meal. However, we encounter from time to time a bad entrée experience. This visit being one of them. I ordered the New York Strip which was perfect. My husband ordered the filet special. I watched my husband cut his first bite and soon as he put it in his mouth he immediately ran to the restroom. Even I server noticed and when he returned, I asked if everything was ok. He looked at me and said NO! He said smell this and lifted another slice of the filet to my nose and I bought . The meat was absolutely spoiled! It was so badly smelling that it would make anyone sick. The server came to us and we explained what happened and asked her to smell the meat and take it back to the manager and cooks. She did and they pulled all their filets. I had my husband just share my steak but it really left him with a bad taste. Service is always great so of course they took it off the menu. Only thing I was surprised was that the manager didn't come by the table. Lets hope no one else experienced that on Thursday night! read more

See all

The food was very good. I had the lunch special, pizza with salad. Sat outside and enjoyed the nice weather

Cute little place on the square with even better food. Jack took care of us and he was great! We ordered the Filet Mignon Crostini as a starter from the chef's specials menu. While it was small, the flavor packed quite the punch and the chimichurri sauce was fantastic. The five cheese dip was quite tasty as well. Pizza is my love language and I went with the Big Sam and added Italian sausage. Wood fired pizza is my favorite and I was not disappointed. The Italian chicken with the caper cream sauce was scrumptious. The breaded chicken was cooked to perfection, paired well with the sauce and the sides. The Sangria was lovely too. Wr ended the night with dessert and it also didn't disappoint. You can't go wrong with Nardello's. #supportlocal read more

Nardello's - Five Cheese Dip and Fried Zucchini - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

Large party of 13, but it took from 5:30 to just before 8PM to have our dinner. Almost an hour before our orders were taken. One meal had no Alfredo sauce, one had over cooked brussels sprouts, I had to search for my green beans and had over cooked chicken with not nearly enough sauce. The waiter had to come and ask everyone what they had before he could give us our checks. The food was auctioned off when it arrived from the kitchen. The wrong bills were given to two of the guests. Training for staff must be non existent. You serve from the left and clear from the right. water put on the table with no ice. While you could eat it the food was not top notch. Oh I could go on but what is the point. I for sure will not be going there again. read more

I absolutely loved dining in here, it's honestly like a hidden gem. I got the peach bellini for a drink. It was sweet, refreshing and really good. They filled it to the brim. For an entree, I got the majestic pizza without veggies. It is a huge portion but so good. The service was amazing and the food was excellent. I'll definitely go back again. read more

Nardello's - Peach Bellini - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

See all

Great service. Delicious pizza. I ordered the lunch special. 1/2 pizza and salad greens. Alfredo, chicken, bacon and black pepper. Light and airy. Music volume was low, just right. Smooth and easy listening. Husband ordered the gyro. Said it was good. read more

This place was interesting. They had a large wood fired oven and were cooking pizzas in what seemed to be four or five minutes. The chef was hand tossing the dough and they looked very good. My wife and I each got a meatball po-boy. The bread was very good and th meatballs were pretty good, although only luke-warm. Three meatballs in a 5" to 6" sub, and I think they about $10. read more

We love this restaurant in quaint, historic downtown Sulphur Springs. The wood fired pizza is fabulous. The servers are attentive and friendly. Good beer selection. We make a special trip at least once a month. Highly recommend. read more

Delicious pizza. The five cheese appetizer is even better. It's all so good. 10/10. Definitely recommend. Sweet and friendly staff (: read more

Nardello's - Hog hunter pizza without the Spanish chorizo meat and the peppa dew peppers - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

Loved the ambiance. Out with kids and grandchildren to celebrate our granddaughters 16th birthday. Served was polite and efficient. Food was creative and delicious! Even had tasty gluten free pizza crust. Will return here when back in Texas! Thank you. read more

Food- ordered the grilled Salmon, garlic mashed potatoes and maple roasted Brussel sprouts. Salmon was good, mashed potatoes were excellent. The sprouts were swimming in the maple syrup, and it quite overpowered the flavor of the Brussel sprouts. Service was very good, but the server probably should have offered a different veg since I'd indicated a concern about the sauce but the chef was going to do what he could to minimize it. Ate out of doors and that was lovely. read more

A friend and I stopped here for lunch while in town for the recent wine festival. While we found the festival overpriced and underwhelming, Nardello's was a nice find. We sat outside and enjoyed the beautiful Fall weather. There were vegan options, including vegan cheese for the pizza. The kale salad (minus the cheese) was fabulous. Four stars instead of five mainly because they started setting up for a party while we were dining. The constant dragging tables and loud yacking was disturbing. Also the sangria was not very good. read more

Nardello's - Kale salad minus cheese. Glass of sangria - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

Nardellos is probably the fanciest restaurant in town. Great atmosphere. Food is delicious. Lots of great drink choices. Outdoor patio is available as well. Highly recommend read more

See all

Fantastic! The best service and great atmosphere. We loved the charcuterie board, Figgie Pizza and the chorizo burger special. And the sangria was perfect way to end a day on the lake. read more

Nardello's - Figgie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

It's about time Mount Pleasant got a good, crafty pizza place! It's so cute inside, it has a lofty feel with lots of exposed brick. Their patio is inviting and spacious. They offer salads, sandwiches, and of course pizza! They have craft beer and other adult beverages. Their pizza was pretty darn good. I really enjoyed the crust. The pizzas are fairly thin and the crust is light, airy, and sightly crunchy. I like the little burnt bubbly parts too. We got the "islander" and the "outlaw" pizzas. Both were good, but a little on the greasy side! Islander: I would highly recommend the islander. Everything on this pizza made it taste super fresh-pesto, pineapple, fresh jalapeños, bacon. The cilantro pesto added such vibrant flavor! We will get this again! Outlaw: brisket, pickled jalapeños, veggies, red onion. The brisket was super smokey. I feel like the smokiness overpowered the other flavors. We also had a lot of fatty brisket pieces on our pizza. This led to me picking a lot of the brisket off, bc I definitely don't like to eat meat FAT!! Ew. Other than this, this pizza was not bad, but I wouldn't get it again. Next time we need to try their dessert! They had several tempting options, but we were too full! read more

See all

We ordered a The Majestic pizza and couldn't eat all of it. It was very good. Great service and atmosphere.

The sauce was not great, there was no cream sauce, the salmon was dry. Do not recommend this plate, just go with the salad. :) read more

See all

My boyfriend and I went here for valentine's and there was a waiter who was chewing her nails while bring us our food. Not only was she being unhygienic but she was completely rude. I believe her name was Stephanie; she either needs to have professionalism classes or be fired! read more

Still love this place! We have our favorite server now, Sarah! We tried brunch and it was insanely good! The blueberry lemon ricotta French toast is a must try! Their eggs Benedict pizza is also yummy. Only note is the eggs were a bit undercooked...I like a runny egg but I need the whites to be cooked. Their Bloody Marys are also delicious. Keep up the good work guys! read more

See all

One of my favorite "GO-TO" restaurants! Can't say enough about this place. I usually order their Millennial Pizza. My hubby likes their Pepperoni. My husband is a good 'ol' boy and calls it "his fancy pizza". We bring our friends here whenever they're in town. Like their live music. read more

I am stunned how this place has such high reviews... captive audience with no other choices? It was awful. The Ceaser Salad was iceberg stems. That were wilted and brown. The croutons were so stale and soggy at the same time (how do you manage stale and soggy???). The ceaser dressing was some kind of weird mayonnaise based disaster that stuck on the leaves like some kind of bad hollandaise sauce. It was a giant bowl of iceberg stems with n occasional soggy croutons and salty cheese straws. The pizza... good gravy. It looked beautiful but like a blind date as she gets closer uou realize the nightmare evening is only just beginning. The edges were black but the middle was so soggy you had to use a fork and knife. And the only flavor... salt. So salty by the end of it my tongue was numb. Which is hindsight was a blessing. And all for the bargain price of 25 bucks before tip. Are you freaking kidding me? I am speechless bordering on angry that this is OK? And that this many people lack any sense of taste! God bless you if you're from here and this is your jam but if you have any level of pizza (or salad) standard avoid. read more

Nardello's - The brown, wilting iceburg stems that pass for romaine in my ceaser :( - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

Great service food was good, we got the Cheesey bread, Big Sam and The Fettuccine the pizza was very delicious as well as the cheesy bread. the pasta was good as well it was a little cold when it came out but not horribly, the pasta also lacked a little salt but overall was still very good! read more

Nardello's consistently offers the best food and service in town! The atmosphere is very inviting and the menu has enough variety to satisfy everyone! The pizza is excellent as are the entrees! read more

Another great visit at Nardello's! The wood fired pizza, The Majestic, was excellent! Great service too

Place looked clean and modern. They serve a really good Neapolitan pizza with traditional toppings and some very creative options. My Islander Pizza with pineapple, pesto, and jalapeños was delicious. Service was excellent. My pizza was a little expensive but I noticed they had pizza margherita for a reasonable price. I think it was $14. read more

Stopped in during a softball tournament weekend. Great food and awesome atmosphere downtown. Our waitress was very attentive and we really enjoyed the experience. read more

Nardellos is an excellent restaurant if you are looking for a great dining experience in the Northeast Texas area. This wonderful restaurant, located right on the square in Mt. Pleasant, is an inviting place for everyone to enjoy a meal. This restaurant is in a building that is well over 100 years old, but with the right mixture of history, and modern looks. The restaurant has an open feel, and you do not feel, nor come close, to feeling like you are sitting on top of another dinner party. One of the main features is of course the huge fire brick oven in the rear corner of the establishment. There is also an open bar area, if that is your thing. (It's not mine). The menu is not overwhelming and is very simple to read. The choices are to the point, which is, you are here for pizza, specialty appetizers, and custom made sandwiches. I highly recommend the fried zucchini for an appetizer, which comes with a spicy (not hot) aioli. In terms of pizza, the "Straight Up" is a fantastic choice of cheese and sauce with no meat. If you still like going more the veggie route, the "Millennial" is a fantastic choice, with garlic cream, baby spinach, roasted mushrooms, gruyere, ricotta, roasted garlic oil. If you want meat on your pizza, I can't say enough good things about "The Outlaw." A beef brisket topped pizza is literally to die for! You can checkout more of their menu at https://nardellos.com/dinner Prices are totally reasonable. A family of 4 can eat for under $40. Also, if you are an NTCC student, you get a 10% discount, which is pretty nice. Chef Brandon, who runs the place, has a warm disposition, and clearly shows a passion for food. In short, the best pizza I have ever had was from a pizzeria in Brooklyn, NY. Nardellos is literally as good as that! Try this place and you will not be disappointed. read more

We had a wonderful time. Our server was excellent. The selection of drinks was just what we wanted. Craft beer, various cocktails, and wines. We love the ambience. Sitting there on the old courthouse Square. Reasonable fun and friendly. read more

Great service, quaint ambiance, thin tasty crust both gluten free and wheat with homemade herby ranch dressing. The only downside was an odd eclectic loud music playlist. read more

When I tell you they have the best pizza me and all of my friends have ever had I'm not lying! The gluten free pizza was phenomenal, my friend has an allergy and i shared one with her and oh my god we both ate it so quickly! We ordered it to go because we were trying to get to our vacation spot but they were super super fast took them maybe 10 minutes to make 3 pizzas and a wrap! Each pizza was incredible! The service was also amazing the hostess was super sweet and gave good suggestions! Even though we didn't eat there the place was beautiful! We loved all the cute french country homestyle decorations! Would recommend to anyone especially those with a gluten allergy or diet! read more

The food was excellent. Great Fig pizza (yes figs) and salads (huge/shareable). The brunch menu looked great but we did pizza and salad. No complaints. The only issue was the salad arrived w the pizza. read more

Nardello's - Brunch - Pizza Near Me - Mount Pleasant, Texas

Prices are very affordable!!Food is great!!Service is amazing!I recommend this stop to all!

The pizza was FABULOUS, the iced tea was fresh and perfectly brewed. Server Tyler, was good and friendly. Open and spacious atmosphere was clean and inviting. read more

They use the good pepperoni. We stopped for lunch after visiting Daingerfield State Park and we loved it.