This review is for the location on Washington Ave. at Carpenter St. We ordered two small pizzas: A thin crust with sausage, and a "rustic" style with black olives. I really enjoyed the thin crust, it had a nice crunch with more flavor than some "cracker crust" pizzas. The sausage had just the right amount of fennel, and the sauce was good. The rustic style was equally good; the crust has more volume but is still not thick, and any toppings plus sprinkled Parmesan are baked on top. As a starter, we split the Caesar salad. It was very good but note to vegetarians -- ask for it without the bacon bits. We haven't been to any of the Nancy's locations. We would come back to this one just because we know how good it was! Service was friendly and fast. We found parking on Carpenter right in front of the entrance, and paid with Park Chicago app. read more

See all

Very good pizza. I'm torn about how to rate Nancy's - the thin crust, Chicago square style pizza was great! It was also darn expensive at ~$49. My heart says the quality and taste make this restaurant a clear five. To boot, the restaurant is fun, clean and service is high end. A wonderful dining experience in the West Loop. My brain, though, also tells me "how can you spend $50 on a pizza?" I would recommend and come back. Ideally on a work trip / credit card. read more

I've had Nancy's Pizza a million times and they have literally never disappointed me. So here I am, totally baked, full-on munchies mode, trying to decide if I should wait for delivery like a responsible adult or just pick up my pizza and call it a night. Obviously I chose pick-up because patience is not a virtue when your cravings have taken over. I live like four blocks away so I ordered online and decided to share with my dog Winston a super thin 12" pizza with Italian sausage and mushrooms. When I went to pick it up everyone was insanely friendly and engaging. The restaurant is always clean, the staff is always ready to help, and somehow every single time I pick up an order it is always ready right on time. Never late, never rushed, just perfect every single time. I don't know how they do it but I respect it. And the pizza? Oh man, the pizza. I took it home and every bite hit me like I had never tasted pizza in my life. The crust, the toppings, the flavor balance, everything was perfect. Sitting at home baked and devouring that pizza felt like a spiritual experience. Honestly Nancy's has to be one of the top pizza places in Chicago. Nancy's I don't care what day it is I will be back. You've got a loyal fan here and probably Winston too because he is clearly a pizza connoisseur. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Came for dinner and we enjoyed our time overall here. Unfortunately, we made a reservation and came early but had to wait until 10 minutes after our scheduled reservation time for the table to be ready. Despite this, our service was good and our food was great and we enjoyed it. The salad was good and both pizzas were enjoyed by our group. We also enjoyed the garlic bread but didn't get a picture before we finished it. read more

See all

Free pizza at work. Believe it was cheese. I always appreciate free food especially if its pizza!

Finally tried this restaurant that I've walked past many times. What surprised me is that they have a take out option that is open later than the sit down restaurant! We got a deep dish and a thin crust. The thin crust was similar to most thin crust pizzas I've had. I enjoyed the deep dish more and loved how flaky the crust was. The pizza was ready within 25 minutes of ordering, which pleasantly surprised me since deep dish usually takes longer. We asked for red pepper flakes and they gave us multiple bags of both red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese in Nancy branded baggies- a really nice touch! read more

See all

On my ladyr night in Chicago I wanted to try my first stuff crust pizza. I sat at the bar. Nice customer service and it was clean. The drink was a bit small but maybe it's because my bartender measured as she should have. Pizza was pretty good, light on the initial cheese pull. Nice place to visit for pizza if you want to try deep dish pizza. read more

See all

Best pizza in Chicago hands down! If you like it cheesy like giordanos, you're gonna love Nancy's. It's pretty much the same style of deep dish Chicago pizza pie, but believe it or not even cheesier, and I felt like the flavors were even better. The cheese pull we got was insane and even though we ate it in the car, to go, it was the highlight of our visit to Chicago. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Decent pizza, could be way cheesier (cmon!) It's part of the large dining group in Chicago so the rewards accumulate. Service can be slow as it gets realllllllly busy Ambiance fast casual read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I now understand why people say this Nancy's Pizza is some of the best in Chicago. Not only is their pizza good but so were the wings, the drinks, the service, and the vibe. I only had enough time to visit here once but had such a wonderful time that I had to make sure they got their 5 star review. P.S. Thank you to Adam who made sure I didn't leave Chicago without trying Nancy's iconic deep dish pizza. As a New Yorker, I've never wanted or considered trying deep dish Pizza but when in Chicago ... :). read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Ember & Ash (Spritz) - Custom made by Adam - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got here at 1030. Says they are open till 1am. They' were doing carry out only. We are from out of town and took and uber to get here. We need a place to sit and eat. I'm just guess most uber drivers don't like food in their car. read more

We were looking for a great deep dish pizza in Chicago. And we happen to come around Nancy. We want a pizza that looks cheesy and flavorful and the reviews did not scare us wrong! The customer service was great. They made sure that we had everything that we needed and answer any questions. We may have out about the menu. The wings are really flavorful too and a nice addition to our deep dish pizza. I love that the restaurant is on the corner of the building and has large windows so you can see outside and have a great view. And it was nicely decorated and clean. I definitely recommend this pizza area if you are in Chicago. read more

See all

LOVEEEE this place! Visited Chicago from Las Vegas, NV and I loved this place so much. I don't remember loving deep dish pizza this much the first time I visited Chicago. My mom and I ordered the bone-in buffalo wings, fried mozzarella, mixed green salad and the original stuffed pizza with cheese only. The bone-in wings had a touch of lime, which made them so much better. The fried mozzarella came with marinara and a pesto sauce for dipping, and I was obsessed with the pesto sauce! The mixed green salad? Delicious! Perfect amount of dressing, flavorful, we finished the whole thing! The cheese stuffed pizza, DELICIOUS! Extremely filling, but sooooo good. Definitely my favorite restaurant we visited in Chicago during our visit. Service was quick, no complaints. We got there before the rush and got seated right away. Noise level was moderate and the restaurant was clean and welcoming. I can't wait to revisit Chicago and return to this restaurant. read more

See all

Nancy's for the win! Tonight we had a large Italian sausage and it was delicious. I love everything about this pizza; another fabulous order. read more

See all

I was extremely excited to try this place after a review on social media & the fact that the takeout section was busier than chick-fil-a on a Saturday night. Pizza was dry. Garlic was muted. To my liking the entire family ate here for just under $60 & we were stuffed. Buttered kids pasta needs some help. Fries with the balsamic were the star of the show. Sort of interested in their wings but I'm in no rush. I'm not certain but there has to be better pizza in west loop read more

See all

Came here for a work xmas party! We were assigned tables right by the door and entering the restaurant space. This made it challenging for not only other patrons to get around us, but to ensure service to all. Our server was amazing! She made sure everyone had a drink - which im sure had to be a challenge with all of us switching seats to socialize. Good was great! I'll definitely be coming back for pizza, as there is a designated take out window. read more

Place an order online for a medium stuffed pizza. I ordered a medium Stuffed Pizza with Sausage. Their medium is a measly 10 inch and rather pricey for the size. Their competitors if I'm not mistaken are 12 inches for medium and 14 inches for large at a better price. The pickup process was great and my pizza was ready by the time promised. But this ten inch seemed tiny. The pizza itself was ok. The crust tasted plain, it had a decent amount of cheese but could have used more sausage. The sauce was chunky but felt they could have balanced the sauce and cheese a little bit better. Overall despite the smaller size, it was still a very filling pizza. There's definitely better in Chicago. Not sure if I'll be returning anytime soon though. read more

See all

We got it delivered and it was still fantastic. To be honest we ate most of it the next day and it's a no doubt 5/5. Highly recommend read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Medium Thin crust pepperoni and feta - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Solid pepperoni, mushroom and mozzarella cheese pizza pie, ordered and received extra crispy. Began with a mixed green and Caesar salad - both as fresh as could be and plentiful. Super clean restaurant, cool décor, great location and decent beers on tap and wine available. Really struggled with this not being a '5', and I can only point to crust texture (Like a cracker / bread crust) being one deviation outside our preferred norm, some likely love it, just unconventional for us. Shout out to Linsey who took great care of us. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Fantastic Salads. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Bar seating was nice, service was pretty good and quick. This was my first time ever having deep dish and it wasn't bad! Might just be a basic thick crust girl at heart though. The wings were awesome--I'd honestly come back just for them next time. read more

See all

We went to Nancy's for post-marathon deep dish and salad. It was a bit of a hobble-waddle from our hotel, but worth it and also nice to get away from the busier part of town. We were seated quickly and had the nicest server. It seemed like the kind of spot that's great for a group (there were several there). I ordered a prickly pear margarita and not only was it balanced and tasty, but so pretty! We had the chopped salad - huge! - and Nana's Special pizza add pepperoni. DELICIOUS! As hungry as I was, we could only eat half the pie so the other half came on the flight with us home. It was my mid-air meal and made me smile all over again. read more

Cool space good cocktails cheap wine big salads and great pizza. Wall of floor to ceiling windows for premium people watches. Friendly service. Wheelchair accessible. read more

Fabulous Chicago style pizza! The sauce is plentiful and fresh. The cheese is gooey and delicious, and the crust is great. We got it stuffed with mushrooms. Service was attentive and quick. The ambiance is casual and fun. Prices are reasonable. So good! read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

(G)o - huge space! Got takeout but definitely want to dine in later and see the interior design. Spotted some cute rubber ducks hiding around the bar. (W)ow - Their onion rings are actually phenomenal. Not too much breading, crispy, not greasy, and huge! (A)ge - didn't get to see other customers bc we did takeout, which was fast and easy (M)enu - Pizza, garlic bread, and onion rings are the trifecta of late night eats. The pizza is round and they slice it into easy to eat rectangles for sharing. Solid flavor and generous toppings, although the crust wasn't as crispy as I would have liked. I enjoyed how the pepperoni was hidden underneath the sauce and chicken. Garlic bread was huge and not too buttery to make the container oily. As mentioned, onion rings really outshined all the other dishes. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 14" Large Classic Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Soooo good....honestly soooo good! The food was amazing and the service was awesome. The restaurant itself is clean and comfortable and a great place to connect with others. We were a party of seven and everyone in the party had a great time! read more

See all

The location is great, right around some busy bars and restaurants. Sat at the bar and there was several TVs that had different sports games on. Great midday place to grab a pizza, the ground beef was not seasoned well. If they would add Italian seasoning to the ground beef this would be a solid hamburger beef pizza for sure. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Rustic Pizza with hamburger beef and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Food is good. However, don't offer a birthday desert that's only good if ordered within 7 days. Best to offer nothing at all.

We stayed downtown on New Years the past few years. I have tried most pizza places in the city. Nancy's was our choice this year. It will be our new tradition when visiting the city. Pizza was on point in every aspect! We had it delivered to our hotel. We can't wait to dine in next time... read more

I've been wanting to try Nancy's Pizza for nearly two years, and I finally decided to order takeout. I got a pizza and an appetizer, and both were worth the wait! For the appetizer, I went with the Bacon Caesar Waffle Fries. They looked so unique, I couldn't resist. All their loaded waffle fry options seemed tempting, but I'm a Caesar lover, so this one called to me. The flavors were fantastic! My only minor complaint was that the fries were a bit thick and dry--I would've loved a little more sauce or dressing to balance them out. For the pizza, I ordered a small thin crust, which was the perfect size for one person. It was just the right amount to enjoy with a side or appetizer. I chose the Uncle Tony, topped with sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, and onions. It was absolutely delicious! I'm a big fan of thin crust, tavern-style pizza over deep dish, and Nancy's nailed it. Couldn't have been any better in my opinion! Overall, I was super impressed and would definitely recommend Nancy's thin crust pizza and their loaded waffle fries. I can't wait to try more from their menu the next time I go! read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Bacon Caesar Waffle Fries - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Was definitely craving a deep dish pizza and Nancy's fulfilled my craving. I shared the blueberry pecan salad and the Rocco's party with Italian sausage, mushroom, onion and green peppers. This was enough to feed 2-3 people as 2 of us did not finish our meal and had leftovers! The salad was actually really delicious and fresh with a ton of feta, candied pecan and a really good poppy dressing. It really helped cut through the heaviness of the pizza. The pizza itself was just okay. I loved all the cheese (of course I got deep dish) but I felt like the crust was really bland and the overall pizza needed pepper and some flavor. The makeup of the pizza was good but needed some seriously help with flavor in the crust and sausage. read more

Such a good thin crust pizza. Don't need to be fancy with the toppings. Get the basics and you won't be disappointed. Delivery and carry out service is just as good as eating there. Love what they are doing with the tavern style pizzas. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

The atmosphere was very cute. We found the prices to be extremely high - why do toppings cost almost $3 each??? I ordered a rustic crust with spinach and mushrooms, there was hardly any tomato sauce and it was very dry and plain. The chopped salad was pretty good, can't comment on any of their other food. read more

My favorite go-to for thin crust pizza, this one with sausage; always fast delivery, arrives HOT, securely packaged & always convenient. Rock on Nancy! read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 10" Small Classic Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Blueberry Pecan Salad with Poppyseed Dressing: 4 of 5 Pretty delicious salad but is very sweet, almost too sweet. I would recommend sharing this dish along with a pizza instead of eating by yourself. The arugula was an excellent choice to cut back the sweetness though. 10 Inch Stuffed Pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, and giardinara: 5 of 5 Excellently prepared and served pizza. You get to pick your ingredients and the price is very fair for what you are getting. I highly recommend the ingredients we picked combined with the salad above. It is a very good contrast in flavors. Salty and savory pizza with sweet leafy greens. Service was fast at first but a bit a bit sparce after we got our drinks. Interior is nice for a pizza restaurant like this I'd say. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 10" Medium Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I had it delivered but the pizza was fantastic! True deep dish!! Lots of cheese and the sauce has that homemade appeal. Tasty, flavorful, and chunky! I was definitely pleased read more

Joined the rewards program and already excited to go back. The stuffed pizza may not "technically" be deep dish for having the extra layer of crust but it hits just as good and is so filling. TikTok worthy cheese pull btw. Got the Chicago beef stuffed and would personally rate this above Lou's or Giordano's. Also got a thin crust with various toppings and it was also a standout. Really generous with the toppings and the cheese was incredible. The chopped salad also might be my new favorite salad read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - 12" Medium Classic Thin Crust Pizza and Chicago Beef small 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We have multiple pizza options in Chicago. I've tried over a dozen and that's an understatement. Nancy's is close to home so of course we tried it but decided to try a few more times and they consistently delicious. The service on a Friday night and Saturday is slow but that's to be expected. I sat in a few times and it was a cool vibe. I have had both thin and deep dish and it's been fantastic. I recommend the thin crust pineapple, Canadian bacon and green peppers. read more

Tuesday night the family placed an order with Nancy's pizza upon my recommendation. I don't know all was ordered, but for sure there was a deep cheese pizza and one with spinach. Pick-up was with ease and service was fine. Back at the house I thought the cheese pizza and the one with spinach were really good. They had plenty of cheese on them, the sauce was pleasant, and the crust had good flavor and texture to it. I would recommend Nancy's over some of the other pizza chains. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Large spinach and cheese pizza deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ordered from Nancy's for the first time and definitely hands down the best thin crust in Chicago as far as proper cooking and proportions, plus their sauce is nice, not too tangy or sweet but just right. They brown the pizza just right, usually for my taste I have to cook pizzas for 10 minutes at 450 so they are actually "finished," but Nancy knows how to do it. The pepperoni is excellent, not that greasy and full smoky flavor, and it seems the cheese is of good quality so it is not rubbery or oily. read more

Nancy's is a great pizza spot. My coworkers were wanting to get some tavern style and deep dish pizza while in town so I brought them here and we had a great meal! I enjoyed a veggie thin crust pizza as well as the pesto fries. Everything tasted great and the portions were large. The service here was great and we were able to walk in without a reservation for three people. I'd recommend making a reservation for larger parties. read more

Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop - Parmesan Pesto Waffle Fries - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all