Food was great, some of the best garlic knots I've had. Staff and owner were friendly and…read moreattentive. Will definitely be back.

Had a slice of pepperoni and a salad. Pizza was great and the salad was super fresh. Zach offered…read moreup great conversation as well;). I'll be back when I'm in the area again. A+

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

Excellent Lasagna and pizza. I will definitely be back to try more. It's take out only. You can…read morestop in and pick up Lasagna and bake it whenever you're ready. Yummy stuff!!

Great thin crust pizza and friendly service. My family stopped in here months ago while visiting…read morerelatives and we still talk about it. Every time we get a pizza back home now we lament, "Well, it's not Gordy's." This will be our first stop when back in town again.

Fabulous pizza place! The crust, the sauce, the toppings...super tasty pizza in a neat little space…read morewith both indoor & outdoor tables. Excellent service. Can't wait to return.

Place was cute like an ice cream or candy shop with all the pink! Pizza was good, pricey a bit…read more Service was prompt and staff was friendly.

Super Duper Delicious Food! 1000% recommend. Those Pep Sticks are to die for. All the co workers…read moreare super nice as well.

We had a large Cheese, double sausage, onion, and mushrooms on half pizza. The crust was nice and…read morecrispy on the edge but was softer as you got to the middle of the pizza. The flavor of the sausage and sauce was very good and had plenty of cheese. The staff is always pleasant and friendly.

Amazing broasted chicken with the best rye bread ever. Priced super reasonably…read more Grilled chicken sandwich on sourdough bread - seasoned to perfection. This hole in the wall Wisconsin bar has a friendly lively atmosphere - nothing fancy but clean. Service was decent but you need to go get your bill and no offer for refills. Bartender was also the waitress so not a big deal - just fyi. Would go back in a heartbeat.

Stopped by for dinner and was surprised how good our food tasted. We ordered their special, 3…read moretopping pizza, garlic bread and 8 piece broasted chicken for $32.00. There were 4 of us and we had leftovers. Our original order was taken by another group who claimed it first, so we waited another 20 minutes. We were upset but once we tasted the food we all agreed that we would come back. We visited the following Monday and brought more people with us.

I've never had any issues with the speed, delivery, or quality. It's not the most amazing pizza in…read morethe world but it's still pretty good and much better than freezer pizza. Something that always keeps my family coming back are the Tuesday deals, punch cards, and the really good sausage. My mom has always been super picky about her sausage and she loves theirs. All I've ever really had was the pizza, ravioli, and garlic bread, but my family has eaten their salads and had no complaints. The service has always been easy and when they say they'll be 30 minutes (which isn't that long) they show up right on the mark.

Great family ran business with great service and amazing food! The options are tailored to what…read moreyour needs are. They are willing to take the time to get it right and never miss. There's a reason why it's the only pizzeria in the local area, immediate go to establishment.

This was an absolute treat! The pizza was wonderful, probably the best I have ever had. Looking…read moreforward to going back many times and cost was very reasonable. All the ingredients were fresh and no other pizza place in town can compete with these lovely pies!

Ordered our first Pizza last night. My Wife & I both agreed. Last nights Pizza was the Best we…read morehave had in Whitewater . And we have tried them all ! Highly recommend!

I graduated in 2022 and have not been back to this place since '23 but I still think about this…read morepizza so often. The pizza is perfect, garlic knots, are perfect, and if you have a chance to see the owner, he's amazing! Could not recommend this place more. (Also check out his Italian restaurant next door)

I've been so curious about this place and finally got there! The two slice special saves you a few…read morepennies. Slices are heated up perfectly. It was 6 PM and the place was empty, but there was plenty of pizza to go around. It was fresh crust, light and tasty, and the toppings were delicious.