Good thin crust pizza with excellent sausage but a little short on the sauce. Cheese is excellent…read morebut hey Gus' is in Wisconsin! Potato slabs are very good. Staffing is a problem if you want to eat in as a waitress is harder to find than a Minnesota Vikings Super bowl trophy.

Toppings on the pizza were very scarce. Not worth 2.60$ each topping. The wine was of very low…read morequality. Greek salad was a joke, come on!! Probably would not return. Sorry.

Grew up in Chicago so I wasn't expecting a lot as I'm used to some high quality pizza, but holy…read moreheck their mushroom thin crust hit the spot! Such great tasting sauce with the perfect amount, I like my slices a bit saucey. Additionally, their cheese curds were delicious - not overly breaded. Highly recommend this pizza spot.

we have been going here regularly since moving to whitewater 7 years ago. My family loves this…read morebusiness and we have never had a bad experience or visit.

Clean establishment. Great service. And excellent food!!! My…read morego to pizza is thin crust veggie. They really know how to do a thin crust. I have also tried their sandwiches. My favorite it Italian beef. It's a nice place to dine at or even get delivery. Prompt and hot when delivered.

Been here several times since moving here, 3 years ago, and consistent and good pie each timeread more

Wow! What a great pizza! Our 1st time here. The pizza has a fantastic thin crisp crust. We…read moreordered a chicken, breakfast bacon pizza with 1/2 red sauce and 1/2 white garlic sauce. Both were equally delicious. We will be regulars from now on. 5 stars!

Best pizza in Jefferson bar none the calzones are great too…read more Ordered one line went great ready in about 20 minutes

We have ordered pizzas and various other items from Mike's Mr. Pizza often in the past but we are…read morenot done being a customer. The pizzas have a great crust and cheese but it ends there. They have cut back on the toppings to the point that we basically getting a cheese pizza regardless of what we order. This week we ordered a 14" pizza with half sausage and half pepperoni. The half with sausage had 6 small pieces spread out on that half with one slice no sausage and the other with two small pieces per slice. On the pepperoni side it was a bit better, with at least 2-3 small slices per piece. We called the establishment and talked with the assistant manager and her comment was they do not count out how many pieces they put on the pizza. Not at all concerned that we were disappointed. We called them about 2 months ago and got a similar response. We will not be going there again. We do not live in Milton and make a special point of trying to frequent small businesses but we will not be back.

For a small town, Mike has his pizza on point…read more This is my go to pizza on Thursday nights! It's their pizza deal night. Once they made a mistake, and the owner was fast and took care of the mistake. Which has made me come back again, and again.

Medically, I cannot recommend this pizza. It's a cardiac bomb! But if you are adventurous and like…read moregood pizza, and your doctor isn't worried about your heart, this is very good pizza!

Delicious "stuffed" pizza! Easy and efficient ordering. Ready on time and piping hot. We loved it…read moreand will be back!

ALWAYS a Pleasure and a Janesville Treasure !!!! Virgil and his crew are doing a Great Job at…read moreCarrying on the traditional Pizza that Tony and his family brought here !!!!! GREAT Price and Super Value . . . . . .. Exceeds My expectations every time. Great Wine and Beer Too !!!!!!

Been getting pizza here since I was a kid! I now have grandkids who love it as much as I do!…read moreConsistent, generous toppings & cheese baked to perfection. The crust is amazing!!

This is my new favorite pizza place. It is attached to a family video which I believe all or most…read moreof them are. It's a nice added touch that you get a free movie rental when you order a large pizza. While you wait for your pizza you can go into the movie store and pick out a movie. I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and pineapple on one half and pepperoni, pineapple, and jalapeños on other half. Classic crust with parmesan cheese on crust (I didn't look at what the extra cost of the specialty crust was, but I wouldn't waste your time, after the pizzas cooked they just sprinkle a little Parmesan cheese onto the crust , and most of it falls off into the box) The pizza was outstanding! I've never had such a fresh tasting ingredients on a pizza and I'm not exaggerating. I have had pizza at mom and pop shops, national chains, nicer restaurants etc. The jalapeños tasted fresh and we're spicy. I decided to stop here since we had a work function a while ago in which they ordered pizza from Marco's. I had already eaten lunch that day but everyone said they were pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza was, because it was a new place and no one had tried it before. The staff was nice, they had The pizza done right about the time they said they would. I highly recommend you to try this place out, don't be fooled because it is attached to a Family Video

It was so-so. I really won't go out of my way for it, but I wouldn't refuse it if it was the only…read morechoice. I tried Marcos because another parent from my kids school really pushed to do a fundraiser for the PTO. So I figured; give it a try. I was in the area yesterday and figured it was a good pizza night. I live about 20 miles away; not really a convenient location for me, but since I was in the area I thought I'd try. I ordered a Hawaiian pizza; great quantities of meat, and a pizza with bacon, tomato and cheese. The tomato was a bit soggy; I'd suggest tomato diced vs. slices. I ordered through Yelp- did not know that was an option. Very handy! Yelp worked with GrubHub for the order. I arrived early and watched the pizza maker place the order in the ready area. So I got out of my car went in... ding ding rand the bell. And waited... and waited and waited. The pizza maker saw me and ignored me completely. So I waited more. The delivery person and someone working dough in the back were chit chatting. I tried to step into their view. The lady working the dough finally noticed me. Said, oh... then proceeded to walk to the register; not washing her hands as she had been kneading the dough. Without saying a word, Grabbed a money bag and loaded it up with cash,said here to someone Then.... After all that, busily walked back to the counter area and FINALLY (after about 5-7min) asked me if I was the Grub hub order and my name. Yes; that's me. Handed me my pizza and went back to whatever else. The service was very lacking. I don't plan on returning anytime soon; between the service and really not being anywhere close to my home; it was very inconvenient.