One of the nicest restaurants in the Whitewater area! The food is always delicious and the…read moreatmosphere is so pretty. The servers are also great! On our last visit, we enjoyed their tomato soup, as well as penne Ala vodka with chicken and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. They also have great salads and desserts. We reviewed their lunch menu after the meal, and may try one of their sandwiches on our next visit. This is great place to stop if visiting a student at UW-Whitewater or for a special occasion. A step above other restaurants in the area.

Food is very good! Fanatico feels very nice inside but is inexpensive for the quality and…read moreatmosphere it provides! I went here for a retreat with 8 other guys and once else with my girlfriend for Valentines Day! Service both times was very good too! Would recommend

There are good restaurants and there's Holy Cannoli a great restaurant. What makes the difference…read moreis the proprietor. In this case her name is Melissa who was more than nice to us and made sure our experience was second to none. We felt so at home we closed the placed out. When I say the penne pasta is al dente, there's still fight in them, definitely not wimpy, pair that with their light creamy vodka sauce and is quite possibly the best pasta I've had lately. Special mention also goes to the grilled octopus on a bed of Arugula. The restaurant is called holy cannoli so of course we had it but what takes the cake is the tiramisu- just get it trust me you'll like it. If you don't we can't be friends anymore.

First the good: The gnocchi is made in house and delicious. Also, their dirty martinis and…read moretiramisus are pretty solid. Second the not so great: I ordered a side of spinach for a little over $8 and the portion was very small. Plus, the spinach came out half uncooked and with a piece of broccoli stem in it too. Finally, there was some confusion with the order and the server wasn't very accommodating and essentially told my party that we were misremembering what dishes were ordered. However, it was Labor Day weekend so I can get being overwhelmed by the volume of people. Overall, I would give it another shot but I'm not dying to go back on a busy weekend.

Reserved online for 4 people on a Tuesday. 2 ordered ravioli which was amazing. The other 2 ordered…read morelasagna. They were impressed with the flavor but not the temperature. My husband hit some cold spots but said it was flavorful. We will be back. Hopefully temperatures will be better. There was only 6 people there including us.

I was in the mood for an Italian pasta meal and found Mangiami Italiano online. It said they were…read moreopen until 8pm on Saturday, so since it was only 6:30, I decided to take a ride over. From the outside, the place looked inviting.., even had a big free-standing sign on the sidewalk that said OPEN. When I walked in, though, the setting felt dark and dingy. There were about 20 tables total, and only 5 of them were occupied. I asked for a table for one, and the host asked if I had a reservation. When I said no, I was told they were "reservations only." I even asked if they were expecting a big rush, given the number of empty tables and more than an hour left before closing, but the answer was still no. So instead of serving a paying customer, they turned me away. Honestly, what a poor way to run a business, especially when the place was 75% empty. Extremely disappointing experience. I won't be back

Oh my goodness--I truly felt like I was back in Italy while dining at Mike's! My husband and I…read morefirst met Mike when he was part owner of Mama Mia's on the square in Baraboo, and now he's opened his own restaurant as the sole owner. Mike immigrated here legally from Albania and became a U.S. citizen, and you can taste the pride he puts into every dish--everything is homemade, even the pasta. I had the spicy chicken arrabbiata with Alfredo sauce, and it was absolutely delicious. The homemade garlic knots were mouthwatering, and the salads were fresh and crisp. My friend ordered the shrimp pasta and loved it. I also brought home two pizzas for my family, and they said it was the best pizza they've ever had! The service was excellent, and the restaurant itself is spacious with a great bar area. From now on, Mike's Italian Restaurant will be our go-to spot whenever we're in Baraboo. If you're in the area, give Mike a try--you won't be disappointed!

This was our favorite restaurant we visited during our vacation! The food was amazing and the…read moreservice was above and beyond. We had delicious garlic bread and I got the spaghetti limon special which was great. Everything tasted homemade and fresh and it was a very kid friendly place. Our server Cody was so kind to our daughter.

We read about this restaurant in our local paper. We have visited Elkhorn once a week for the last…read more7 years and had no knowledge of this restaurant. It's in a strip mall and not a location that is really that visible from the road. The restaurant received such a good review we decided to stop in. Small intimate Italian restaurant, 52 seats. We were seated within minutes. We ordered a Chicago style deep dish. Excellent We took 1/2 a 12 inch pizza home. Prices were very reasonable, excellent friendly service. We'll definitely come back to try other menu offerings.

Had a great dinner here last night. True Italian dishes (the special was stuffed shells) like Pasta…read moreItaliano with loads of artichokes. Prices are very reasonable and the staff are incredibly friendly. TIP: Not a lot of tables so come early!

Came here after attending a baseball game in Fort. This place is classic Italian pizzeria vibes…read morewhen you walk in. If i could bottle up the smell that hits you when you first arrive, i would. It's perfection. Our server was excellent. She was very attentive and gave great recommendations. My baked Mostaccioli was 10/10. My husband's Italian beef was absolutely delicious as well. I love that they make all their salad dressings homemade. I got the Italian for my salad and it was great. Great service, great food, great place to be with your family for a dinner. Can't wait to come back and try something else ! Ps: they offer gluten free pizza crust!!!

GREAT stuffed shells. Went on Valentine's Day and the service was great, very quick and efficient…read moreby anyone's standards but especially for a big out to eat holiday like valentines

Relaxing environment, professional staff & fantastic food. Others in my party raved about the…read morelasagna while I had the crusted salmon which was fantastic!

We were excited to finally try Olivia's. We decided to go for an early dinner (5:30ish) on a…read moreFriday evening. First impression, the parking lot was empty. We had heard they were busy, many times with wait times. So we were surprised. The ambiance is really nice, A really nice Italian dinner restaurant. I started with an Old Fashioned and it was one of the better ones I have had. They really nailed it. There are a couple on their menu so I was sure to say "not the one with soda/selter". That a Wisconsin one :) We asked if the Caesar was large enough to split to start. They said yes. Great. There were 3 tables filled so it was finally not empty. Not sure why the bar seating was empty- looked like a great place to sit too. After ten minutes we gave our order, Chicken Piccata for my wife and I had the Pork Chop special. The waiter didn't come by and we didn't get our salad. He was busy making drinks for one larger party (the 4th table). Finally our entree's came. I asked what happened to our salad. He looked confused. I reminded him we asked if it was large enough to split and we would start with it. He was genuinely sorry. It happens. Then we ate the entree's. My wife's Chicken was flavorful and served hot. It was very good. My pork chop was closer to room temp rather than hot. The flavor was really good. Unfortunately I have a thing about eating my food hot, not on the cold side. I told the waiter. He was sorry and asked if he could have them heat it up. I passed .... Didn't want dryer food while my wife ate alone. The manager came over and insisted it didn't sit at the window. Not sure WHY he wanted to argue this point. I offered the plate so he could taste or even feel the dish at that point. He seemed genuinely wanting to help, but he didn't need to make us feel like we were wrong. Again - not the end of the world. So why 3 stars? My wife's food was great. The taste of mine was good. They didn't charge us for my dinner. Their Old Fashioned was out of this world (ask Omar to make it). The truth is we want to try it again and see if this was a glitch. If it wasn't a glitch, it's why they weren't packed on a Friday night.

Their spaghetti and meatballs are phenomenal. Their legacy sub is delicious. And I don't even like…read morecold subs. Still slaps.

How do they not know how to cook pasta? I have tried 4~5 times and every single time the pasta is…read moremushy and gummy. Today we ordered spaghetti and mostaccioli. We ate it right away and couldn't believe how mushy the noodles were in both dishes. I keep trying, thinking that it will be better but it's not. I asked for some Parmesan to put on my pasta and the man said it would be 1.00. Who charges for cheese? On a side note, the garlic bread was delicious.

The food is wonderful. The service is friendly. It was our first time there and the people were…read morevery attentive. My wife and I ordered three different things to eat there and checked out all the deli items while waiting. We ended up getting a lot food to cook up a huge meal and invited our kids and grandkids out to help us eat it all this Sunday. We live about 45 minutes away but decided we would try to get there at least once a month.

This place is amazing. Great deli with so many options. Staff is always very nice and efficient…read more I can't put into words how good the food is here. The cuts of meat are top tier as well.