For a small town, Mike has his pizza on point. This is my go to pizza on Thursday nights! It's their pizza deal night. Once they made a mistake, and the owner was fast and took care of the mistake. Which has made me come back again, and again. read more

We have ordered pizzas and various other items from Mike's Mr. Pizza often in the past but we are not done being a customer. The pizzas have a great crust and cheese but it ends there. They have cut back on the toppings to the point that we basically getting a cheese pizza regardless of what we order. This week we ordered a 14" pizza with half sausage and half pepperoni. The half with sausage had 6 small pieces spread out on that half with one slice no sausage and the other with two small pieces per slice. On the pepperoni side it was a bit better, with at least 2-3 small slices per piece. We called the establishment and talked with the assistant manager and her comment was they do not count out how many pieces they put on the pizza. Not at all concerned that we were disappointed. We called them about 2 months ago and got a similar response. We will not be going there again. We do not live in Milton and make a special point of trying to frequent small businesses but we will not be back. read more

I went in person to order my burger, after I ordered I never got a text that it was ready and when I went in and got it it was not hot and the order was wrong. I waited 40 minutes in my car for cold burgers that didn't even taste right. read more

Ordered pizza to go, sharing with grand kids. Online ordering was easy and the order was ready when promised. The pizza had the hand made local pizza freshness. All the toppings appeared fresh. The crew throughly enjoyed the pizza and it disappeared quickly. read more

See all

Pizza is okay. If you're going to pay on average $25.00 plus for a pizza . Put enough ingredients in it. I mean if you order a pizza with bacon in it. You should be able to taste the bacon no problem. Sausage also. read more

Great service, and the pizza was delicious. It was a busy Friday but they still got our pizza out on time. Will definitely be backs

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. And the staff is friendly and amazing. We also ordered the Italian Beef it was phenomenal!

A few things to say about this place. Both good and bad. A few months ago my family and I ordered some calzones and my wife witnessed the "chef" make the calzones without any gloves, and continue after itching his nose pretty "intensely" let's just say. When she brought this up to the person at the front they just said, "Oh, yeah, we'll tell him to put on gloves." turned back to her and repeated the total. Needless to say we didn't eat those. The pizza is good for the most part, just extremely greasy, but that's to be expected now a days with thick crusted pizza. The delivery drivers are always super friendly and easy to chit chat with. Honestly it's just your average pizza shop, nothing stands out, nothing special. Two stars because of the whole calzone ordeal. read more

We had the cheese and sausage and the Milton Supreme and no complaints on the the two larges pizzas I thought the pizza was very good. The wait was on time and the staff was friendly. read more

This is the first time eating at Mike's Mr. Pizza and I carried it out. My family and I have been looking for a pizza place that was similar to our favorite pizza joint. Mike's come very close to our favorite place and is our new go to place. The reason we decided to try Mike's is that we found some coupons and thought we would give it a try. After calling and ordering, I drove to pick it up. The staff was very friendly and asked where I lived. When I told them, they asked why I didn't do delivery? I didn't really have an answer, so the next time we will have them do free delivery. As for the pizza, it is cooked in a stone pizza oven (not on a conveyer belt). In my opinion this is the best way to cook a pizza. The crust was a little thick for my liking but as for the taste of the dough and overall taste of the pizza it was perfect (the dough thickness is the reason this place didn't get a 5 star rating). Overall, this is a great pizza joint and if you are in the Milton area you should check it out. read more

I ordered a Italian sausage, onion and mushroom pizza, garlic bread and side salad. Very bland pizza, even the marinara. Garlic bread ok, nothing special and rather dry. Best part of the meal was the salad and it was just small amount of tomato chunks, black olives and iceberg lettuce. There's $30 I'll never get back. Don't bother. read more

Thursday night special is where it's at! Ordered from here several times and have never been disappointed. Great option for pizza right here in Milton. read more

Know first that I've only had delivery from Mikes, so I cannot speak to the location itself. That being said, the gyros are fantastic! Pillowy bread, authentic gyro meat from the spit grilled nicely for that oft sought-after crunch, fresh tomatoes and onions, and generous helping of Tzatziki sauce on the side. My review is primarily for gyros. I have become a frequent customer of theirs solely for the gyros. The pizza has a wonderful crust, plenty of flavorful and chewy cheese, and fresh toppings. The dessert pizza is AMAZING. Just. Order. It. I didn't care much for the buffalo wings, but I am picky where those are concerned. For those that care, they do bread them, and the sauce is quite overpowering, almost acidic. read more

Looking for something different, we found this place in Milton. Solid pizza, good garlic bread, nice people.

We ate there 2 nights in a row because it was so good!!! First night, we had sausage and cheese pizza, which was very tasty. However, my favorite though was the cheeseburger, and I had to get it again tonight just to see if it was a fluke. Rest reassured it wasn't. It was just as tasty. It's like that delicious burger you find in a dive bar. My husband loved the gyro too. The kids devoured the pizza. We will go back!!!! read more

The food at this restaurant is ok but nothing amazing. The service is not much better. My brother stopped by yesterday to tell me he ordered the same thing he's been ordering from them since the day this place opened, and once again couldn't manage to get the order right. This wouldn't be so bad if it weren't for the fact that he orders, the usual, at least three times a month! don't waste your time with Mike's Mr. Pizza!!! read more

Fish Fry was like a school lunch but for $9 a plate. Everything was cold except for the cold slaw that was disgustingly piping hot. Was really hoping this would be something new that we could start calling. Person taking order asked the number on my address like 5 different times and it was wrong everytime. Then the store had to call me to ask AGAIN what my address was. Waited 1hour, 20 minutes. read more

On Sunday night about 7:30 p.m., the Hubby and I decided that We were hungry for Mike's Pizza. We drove into Milton not realizing that the Packer Game was on . Mikes was bustling, 4 People were working, the phone was ringing, there were 6-8 deliveries lined up on the counter and the place worked like clock work ! We were greeted, Our order was taken, and brought to the table in the usual amount of time, Each staff Member stopped by Our table at some point to make sure We were satisfied with our meal. The food was Awesome as usual! Kudos to You Mike, and Staff for Keeping Satisfied Customers ! read more

Stopped for some Calazones. Totally forgot sausage in one. Marked them wrong on the container so I ended up dropping the wrong one off for a friend. Got home with the wrong one. Weather too bad to go back and fix the problem. The calazones and sauce were totally tasteless. Will never order again from here. One good thing is the staff was friendly read more