Great service, generous samples to try, immaculately clean; all phrases fit My Favorite Muffin. For me, everything I tried was just too sweet for my taste. I appreciate the effort they clearly put into this venue in all regards. Good job, just not my favorite. Thank you, Bill read more

Good spot, definitely crowded on a Sunday! The bagels are very fresh, along with the muffins. I had the French toast bagel with cream cheese, it was spectacular! I also got a mini lemon muffin which was incredible. -1 star for the customer service. Younger workers, not very kind / friendly read more

My Favorite Muffin - Vanilla latte - Bagels Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Order $55 in bagels and they were delivered in a trash bag. It was disgusting. In the past they have been actually packaged in a box. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Bagels in a trash bag - Bagels Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

We stopped here for their breakfast sandwich bagels. I'm always skeptical about coffee from a shop that doesn't specialize in it, but I thought their latte was delicious. The bagel sandwich was hearty and tasted great. This place is very popular and the line was long on the morning we went for breakfast, but they made our order quickly and efficiently. A great start to the day! read more

I love stopping by My Favorite Muffin as a little morning treat on my way to work! The staff is friendlier at this location compared to the one on Arapahoe Rd. They are always very quick, my go-to order is an Onion bagel toasted with Veggie spread. I also love their mini muffins, lemon, and blueberry are such a classic. Overall, if you are looking for a quick breakfast, nothing fancy, this is the spot! read more

We stopped in for lunch while our car was being serviced. What a pleasant surprise! The sandwich was fantastic and the muffins are delicious! Fast and courteous service. Definitely recommend! read more

Muffins were good, but the employee must've been new because she seemed confused. I'd ask for a flavor, then she said they didn't have one by that name, even though it was clearly labeled. Then she'd pull the wrong tray to grab the muffins. I didn't bother saying anything though bc I just wanted some food. read more

I'm not sure if it's because I order an hour before they close or what. But my sandwich is very lacking in actual content, really not worth the $8.50. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Kick N Roast Beef Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

I love this place. The chocolate cheesecake muffin is my favorite. Number 2 is the pineapple muffin. They make an apple pie muffin that's ok, they need to ditch the canned red apples and go with Granny Smith . This would be killer. Selection is always good Location isn't great and service is just ok. They serve bagels and sandwiches, never tried them as parking stinks during the lunch hour. This is always a go to when I visit Denver. read more

I've been here a few times, and of course the muffins are pretty tasty. However I have ordered breakfast sandwiches here before also and the contents were a little cold, as if they were slapped together really quickly and they didn't take enough time to heat it properly. read more

My family's loved My Favorite Muffin (Arapahoe location) for years, but tried this location yesterday and took home half baked / completely raw inside bagels. Would have driven them back, but 20 minute trip. read more

See all

Hidden gem in centennial I've been coming here since 2012. First the food is amazing you can find breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches all hand made and fresh. Their smoothies are good but we come here for the muffins. They have many different kinds as you can see from the pics others has posted my favorite muffin is a chocolate chip and I get a start fresh on a French Toast bagel! The service is always amazing the same people have worked there for many years. It's a very great atmosphere in there you can go in there for a meeting with a friend or read a book very inviting place very comfortable and clean. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Chocolate chip muffin - Bagels Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

Reasonably priced, good food, good coffee, quick and friendly service! We will be coming back!!

Had breakfast here recently. Delicious bagels and all sorts of assorted Baked goodies !

It depends. Sometimes the muffins are fresh and yummy. Other times they seem stale and not so great. Won't order again

The bagel sandwiches were amazing and the blended coffee latte was also delicious. We ordered no cheese on our sandwiches (which most restaurants get wrong) but they got our order 100% right. read more

Went to grab breakfast on a Saturday morning for the family. I looked on yelp for pastries or bakery and my favorite muffin came up. After looking at the menu online I saw they are the same as big apple muffins so I had to come grab muffins. They offer indoor dining with max 6 people to a table and the tables are spread out for social distancing. I ordered a few breakfast sandwiches on their fresh made bagels. We also ordered a dozen mini muffins for the kids and a 6 pack of jumbo muffins. Everything is made fresh and tastes amazing. The hubs loved the apple pie muffin (he's a apple lover) and I loved the cinnamon cheese cake muffin. The staff was very friendly and offered quick service. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

First time here. Got to the cashier and ordered a muffin and coffee. She gave me coffee cups and I waited for the muffin. A few minutes later she asked if I had received my muffin and I said no. She asked me if I ordered it at another station. I had no idea about this other station and said no. She started bitching me out for not ordering earlier. A male employee said he would get the muffin. The lady kept complaining I should have ordered earlier. Forget customer service. Husband went next door for burritos, came back with them, and we still waited ten more minutes for a coffee and to get bitched out. One and done. read more

I've always been a fan of My Favorite Muffin. I hadn't been in 10+ years and recently returned because I moved nearby. With one bite into my mini chocolate cheesecake muffin, I felt right at home! The staff was very friendly from the get go. I ordered a dozen mini muffins (the pumpkin spice was also very delicious) and a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich on an everything bagel. I'm no bagel snob, but really enjoyed it. The egg was cooked perfectly and it was all still warm by the time I made it home. They have SO many flavors of both muffins and bagels to enjoy. I prefer the mini muffins to try a little of everything, but there's more variety of the bigger muffins and they're so filling. Growing up, I also enjoyed stopping in for a sandwich at lunchtime, so look forward to doing that again soon. The parking lot is a little cramped but it was easy for me to find a spot. It felt COVID friendly, as I was in and out rather quickly. Overall, I'm excited for many more trips here in the future! read more

I can always get a great breakfast sandwich here - but service gives me pause when I go in person. It feels chaotic inside and the tables are never clean. I do understand rushes and understaffing, so for me it's not a huge deal. Lately, I have been getting it to go thru other apps, though. read more

This is such a delightful place to stop by for breakfast, quick lunch, or just a pick-me-up! Let me start with the muffins, because they're indeed my favorite. There's an ongoing debate among my colleagues: Are these muffins or are they actually cupcakes?! Well, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and labels are overrated. Therefore, let's just call them what they really are: epic. From the crazy chocolate cheesecake to the Boston creme pie flavors, you'll probably spend a hot minute trying to decide which one to get. It might help if you get there later in the day, because they'll be sold out of some options. Just beware the jumbo size. You might just want to bring a friend to help spare half the calories. To be honest, I can see why people like to argue that these are actually cupcakes. These "muffins" don't taste as dry as you'd think an ordinary 7-Eleven muffin would taste (no shade to 7-Eleven). The cherry cheesecake flavor legit tastes like fluffy, moist cheesecake. You probably hate that word, but it really was fluffy. Maybe they should call it a Fluffin. Anyway, you should know that it's not all about the Fluffins here. They've got quite the selection of bagels and bagel sandwiches for those of you who prefer savory breakfasts ... to which I'd argue, why not both? Your response would be double the carbs, but I say have half of both and save the other two halves for later. (FYI, their menu even gives you the calories, so you best believe they're looking out for ya.) One last thing - their coffee selection is the cherry on top. And that's not just because I was obsessed with their cherry-flavored coffee (the aroma was unlike anything I've ever smelled). They have quite the variety of flavors, and I think they're seasonal. Blueberry, breakfast blend, pumpkin pie spice. How can you leave without at least a whiff? read more

See all

Visiting my daughter in Englewood, I was looking for an easy breakfast spot within walking distance. My Favorite Muffin came up on reviews. I phoned ahead as I was walking with my daughter's dog. The staff was awesome. The restaurant is clean and inviting. Better still my breakfast order was ready to go. The muffin and coffee were delicious! I have now returned to My Favorite Muffin two days in a row. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Service was slow and muffins were kinda dry but it's a cute little place and they have a lot of different bagel options which I didn't expect seeing as the name of the place is my favorite muffin. But I would defiantly try them again. They were pricey in my opinion. read more

Our family favorite place to visit. Staff is so nice and all their baked goods are amazing. Coffee is good too. I see a lot of regula customers at this location. Place is little small but we enjoy talking to other families there :) read more

A+++! Just what I needed. Speedy, friendly, accurate and delicious! Thanks to the leadership and staff for a great experience.

Food is delicious, not going to deny that! Everything there tastes good. The low review is because you really can't order delivery here from DoorDash or something else because the order always has something wrong with it. You can't trust that your hummus sandwich won't arrive covered in cream cheese instead, so people with allergies or diet restrictions beware. I've ordered delivery from here 3 times, each time thinking I would give it another chance, but it's a pattern now so I'll only be going in person from now on. 5 stars if you go in person and can check your order before you walk out. 1 star if you have to rely on delivery. read more

I like this small bagel and muffin shop. Used to like it much more when they offered FROSTED muffins (chocolate chip and cinnamon crunch in particular), but now just a few have a tiny bit on them. Good bagels and bagel sandwiches. read more

It is a snowy morning and what goes better than a muffin and coffee.... well that's not what we received. When walking into the restaurant we wiped our feet and were told to be very careful as the floor was wet from foot traffic. After carefully wiping our feet we were told to go back outside and clean our feet again. We did and as we did we were told to wait again as another customer came in and the employee said, "oh, mrs. Xxx, I know you, you can come in." So, we left.... read more

My Favorite Muffin makes pretty solid... well... muffins! We ordered a dozen muffins which gave us a full variety. MFM has chocolate, double chocolate, strawberry cheesecake, almond cheesecake, blueberry, poppy seed. The list goes on. Really enjoyed the muffins, the only reason I do not hive a 5 star review, is because nothing truly blew me out of the water! Overall: 4.4 Venue: 4 Service: 4 Food: 5 Drinks: NA Price: $ read more

See all

We ordered 2 dozen mini muffins for a very important meeting. They came stacked on top of each other in a tin. So let's think about what could go wrong right? Mmm frosting was stuck on the bottoms of those on top; and because they are very fresh ( a good thing), every muffin on the bottom was stuck to the one on top. Why in the world would it not be obvious to separate the layers with either wax paper or something to keep them all from turning into a pile of crumbs is beyond me. We ended up tossing 1/2 of them because they had become a pile of crumbs once we able to pull them off the paper muffin holders of those top muffins. What a pain and certainly wasn't worth what we paid given 1/2 were tossed. If they can't figure out how separate the layers then absolutely don't waste your money. read more

Food is delicious, but prices seem to just go up and up. I understand inflation, but seems a bit ridiculous to pay $14 for a single breakfast sandwich. Plus they take forever, so don't go if you are in a hurry! read more

I had an excellent experience here this morning. I work down the street and was looking to grab a quick bagel before work so I stopped on my way in. Lots of parking, quick service, and after asking for my bagel to be double toasted, the lady working even held up the bagel to make sure it was toasted enough for me! So awesome and the cream cheese ratio was amazing. My visit ended with a very nice gentleman happily dancing at the register to Katy Perry as he ran my card. So happy I stopped in this morning - be back soon! read more

Consistently poor customer service. Our order is wrong about 25% of the time. Most recent issue was a completely missed sandwich, and the store wouldn't fix it because we ordered online. Menu offerings are similar to other places with better service, do not recommend. read more

Nothing to complain about here: easy parking, fast service despite it being decently full (we were in & out in 2 minutes max), & the muffins were a treat so far! Around 9 AM they had a good selection of everything for a Saturday. We got the Chocolate Cheesecake, Blueberry, Double Chocolate, & the Lemon Pound Cake. My husband & I only tried our chocolate muffins since they are large and filling but they were so indulgent & fresh! We would definitely come here again to try more of their flavors! read more

The distinction between muffin and cupcake is blurry in general, and these muffins definitely toe the line. We tried the cherry cheesecake, chocolate cheesecake, and funfetti muffins. All were very good, but definitely made me feel like I was eating dessert for breakfast. I definitely want to go back to try their bagel sandwiches read more

I walked in this morning to pick up some muffins or bagels for the office, and the place was packed which was a good sign. But then I got a look at the muffins on display at the counter, and they were COVERED in mold. The danishes? Moldy. Everything on the counter was significantly moldy. If the store doesn't care about that outward initial impression, then I can't imagine how little they care about the food they sell. I'm never going to eat here. read more

I had a coupon for a free muffin so went in to try. Location - easy to find, convenient. It's more like a breakfast place; when I went around 8.30 a.m. on Friday, some folks were enjoying their breakfast. The staff was nice and asked what muffin I wanted. And that is when I went from OK to OMG - as I looked at the variety of muffins they had to offer! They had 15-16 types of them on display. I let many people behind me go ahead as I stood their contemplating about the one I was going to pick! I finally chose 'Chocolate Cheesecake' and boy was it a great muffin or what! Simply delicious and fresh. Yummy. I would definitely go back here for more muffins. And some. read more

My Favorite Muffin - That variety! - Bagels Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

I've been coming here for years now, I'm in love with the cute little shop & friendly service! Brought in two sets of the 12 count mini muffins to work for my staff on Easter and I've successfully gotten them all to fall in love with their product too! Love love love this place. Toasted sandwiches, great bagel and muffin options, excellent prices! read more

They ALWAYS run out of the basics. Plan better. Very disappointing. How hard is it to have sesame bagels on a Sunday morning?! read more

I love my favorite muffin. I stop by frequently in the morning to get a muffin on my way to work or on the weekends stop by to have a sandwich before I run all my errands. They have the most amazing muffins. I love the cinnamon crumb in the morning but if I am looking for a dessert type muffin the boston creme pie is AMAZING...the is topped with imported chocolate and filled with a vanilla custard. The first time I ever tried it I was in heaven. I also like the chocolate chip muffins for just the right amount of chocolate without being overwhelming. The sandwiches are great too, I stick to the cafe chicken melt on a parmesan bagel...delicious. Soooo glad this place is close by! read more