We went in 5 minutes before they closed so only got time to pick out some to-go items. I ended up with half a dozen bagels, I picked almost all of them to be the Spinach Cheese ones, they seem gourmet. But they might as well have been just breads as the signature bagel holes aren't very visible. Muffin wise, I took a four-pack to go. The Cheesecake one truly felt like a dessert. I enjoyed it tremendously. All of their muffins are huge but if you want to finish one by yourself, you can do the Cheesecake one. It is more hollow in the middle to allow for the sweet cream cheese so you're not left with a bunch of dough. The muffin top is streusel like while the bottom is moist. I did not want to share mine!! The banana nut muffin is definitely more dense so I liked it less. The Boston cream one may be as good as the cheesecake one but I didn't get to try it. Neither did I try the raspberry one. So I'll have to come back and try more of these treats! Good to know My Favorite Muffin is a chain with more than just one location. read more

My Favorite Muffin - To go order: spinach cheese bagels and two muffins (cheesecake and banana bread) - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

This place is so cozy and great! The service is quick and everyone was so nice! The sandwich we got was SO GOOD the tomato tasted so fresh! The muffins are warm and moist. Fresh and delicious! I definitely recommend and I'm dying to go back! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Start Fresh with spinach Swiss bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

Ok my gosh!!!! Great experience!! I ordered online, great experience! Then I called with a change... great experience! Got to the shop and the muffin case was Beautiful!! Easy in and out as well!! Ohhh and.... Delicious sandwiches and muffins for Father's Day! read more

First of all, this place is clean, clean, clean. What a great little muffin shop. It's clearly family owned as the woman behind the counter really cared that I got exactly what I wanted. The selection/choices available are exquisite and mouthwatering. I ended up choosing a carrot cake muffin and a raspberry cream cheese muffin. Both were incredible but the raspberry muffin was heavenly. It had raspberry filing and cream cheese all through the muffin and was akin to a fine dessert than a muffin. Service is phenomenal, the muffins are first rate, the prices are reasonable, parking is simple and the place is really clean. I highly recommend this muffin shop. I'm glad I stumbled upon it. read more

See all

I know this is a muffin place but the bagel are amazing! Dense chewy and flavorful I got a half dozen bagels and a variety dozen mini muffins and while everything was delish the bagels are my favorite from this haul! Great dining area and a couple patio tables if you want to dine outside. read more

See all

I work in customer service and I know what the bare minimum for customer service is. This place couldn't even do that. We greeted them and received nothing but a stare back. When ordering, the lady's working behind the counter were very rude and snarky. When I received with mediocre bagel, it was untoasted. When I asked politely for it to be toasted again, I was met with rudeness and being told that I was wrong and the bagel was toasted 'enough'. When I asked nicely again she reluctantly took the bagel and toasted it. Horrible service! Tables were gross and not wiped down, so we had to eat outside. Do not recommend!!! read more

I love MFM, but this location charged me the wrong price for my bagel (more than it was) and my card for more than my total. Keep your receipts and double check your charges!! read more

I bought two muffins a raspberry something and a cinnamon cheese cake. One bite of each and threw them away. Look this place is a franchise and was packed, clearly people love it but for me one was like I was chewing on sugar and the other was not balanced - extreme cinnamon and then odd textured cream cheese. Service was pleasant enough and super quick. read more

This place is amazing, breakfast and lunch is FIRE!! Just got a turkey club sandwich on jalapeño pepper, jacket bagel OMG!!! This sandwich was AMAZING. This is what lunch should be, delicious and affordable. Thank you, MFM!! read more

Absolutely my new favorite Bagel shop. It wasn't too busy when I went around 8AM. Probably because it was snowing. But shortly after I got there it started to get poppin!! I totally can see why! Everything was so so fresh! I've never had muffins and breakfast sandwiches that fresh before. There are muffins for everyone! They have Mini and Jumbo sizes for muffins. I got a taste of the brand new muffin flavor, Coconut Cream Pie. SO DELICIOUS. They have options for catering, which is great for all the surrounding corporate businesses. They had an overwhelming amount of breakfast sandwiches to choose from and I ended up trying the breakfast B.L.T. My new favorite. I loved the ambiance. It felt like I was at grandmas house or a friends house. Everyone was so friendly. The music was a plus! Unfortunately, there are no gluten free options accept for the Iced and brewed coffees. read more

See all

There are a lot of different muffin flavors. I tried the berry cobbler and New York cheesecake. The New York cheesecake was my favorite. It doesn't have that cheesecake texture but the flavor was just like that of a cheesecake. It was very tasty. I said I would only eat 1/4 of the muffin and I ended up eating 3/4 of it. The muffins are not dry and they're quite big so one would keep you full possibly. The berry was good but compared to the cheesecake, it was weak in comparison. I love to try more of the cheesecake flavors. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

The variety of muffins is wonderful . The taste of everyone I have tried is delicious. Service is good and place is clean.

The service was quick! It had cozy vibes that reminded me of small town coffee shops and it smelled delicious when I walked in. I got a Boston crème muffin which was tasty, it was not too sweet! I wish they had been a little friendlier and personable though. read more

Is there anything bad that anyone could say about this place? I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place I've been coming here since 2009! The place is very clean and welcoming. The staff has always felt like they were family treating you like their own. The breakfast and lunch sandwiches are amazing and priced right. The muffins are out of this world I hated muffins before I came here lol chocolate chip is my go to and a start fresh on a French toast bagel is the bomb! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Start Fresh on French toast bagel and berry trio smoothie - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

Great place for a quick breakfast. Service was friendly and efficient. Food is tasty, array of bagels and muffins. The bagels are flatter and longer in shape, different that usually shaped but good. Several types of coffee available. Fast/casual atmosphere. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

My favorite bagel shop/muffin shop since moving to Aurora. They have a large variety of bagels and muffins. The bagels are always fresh as with the muffins. I love getting the sunrise bagel sandwich! This location is very clean and the employees are always friendly and the service is fast!! I am always amazed when I order a bunch of things and the ladies don't write anything down and go off memory. They have yet to mess up any of my order. Even when there is a line it goes by quick. I highly recommend this place for with breakfast or lunch!! You will not be disappointed. Thank you my favorite muffin-your name is how I truly feel;). read more

This place is a great spot if you are looking for breakfast in the centennial area! 10/10 would recommend. We checked out this place because we got some coupons in the mail and man it did not disappoint! 1. The homemade bagels are delicious, not too thick and super soft and moist with a ton of flavor! I got the Parmesan bagel and would go back to get a 6 pack to try more of them 2. They also make homemade cream cheese and have like 7 flavors you can choose from to go on your sandwich. They also have some to take home! 3. A bunch of muffin flavors and you can choose between jumbo ( which is the size of a regular muffin) or mini ( which is a good 1-2 bite size) We got the triple berry, cinnamon chip and chocolate cheesecake and they were all delicious! My only complaint was I wish the breakfast BLT came with an egg but I could of always added it on there. read more

See all

Got ignored when waiting in line and then when I went to get a fountain drink there was black stuff in the ice. Very gross and employees seemed pretty dense. read more

Needed a breakfast pick me up while my car was getting serviced. On the route was a My Favorite Muffin and it was the perfect place to pass the time. The service was exceptional and the staff were friendly and helpful. There's dining inside and outside, which is fairly small, but is comfortable and a great place to work. Southern Tradition with sausage. Tastes exactly like Einstein's, which I freaking love. Chocolate Cheesecake, Apple Pie and Raspberry Amaretto Muffins. Great flavors, but the amaretto muffin stole the show. I do wish that there was more variety, but all the flavors sounded agreeable. My Favorite Muffin is definitely a top contender for some of the best muffins I've ever had. read more

My Favorite Muffin - 03.03.22 - Southern Tradition - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Not happy. Just returned home after ordering two identical base sandwiches, Southern Tradition. Ordered sausage and garden cheese, the other bacon and classic cream cheese. I received the bacon sandwich without any issue; bacon, cream cheese, scrambled eggs, American cheese. The other sandwich just had the sausage and garden style cc, missing the Am.Cheese and the scrambled eggs! Why can't they make the sandwiches consistent? What I found was a language barrier. The person helping me did not speak english, and even though there was someone there that did, they were to busy with paperwork. Not sure if I will be giving any more chances to this place, this has happened before. read more

Yum! Fun little bagel shop with lots of options for breakfast and lunch sandwiches alongside various bagel types and muffin flavors. I had "My Favorite Turkey Club" on a Spinach and Swiss bagel. I made it a meal for $4.00 more by adding three mini muffins (apple pie, vanilla sprinkles, and cinnamon). Overall, great taste and prompt service! read more

My Favorite Muffin - My Favorite Club Sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

This place takes your ordinary muffin and turns the dial up to 11. So many wonderful and fancy flavor combinations that one might think the oh so simple muffin has been turned into a work of art. Fast and friendly staff greets you at the order counter and get ready for a taste explosion! Your mouth will thank you! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Muffins - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Brought a friend from out of town, she said we must come get a muffin everyday that she is here! So many muffins to choose from, next time I need to get the mini muffins to go so I can try more flavors! The people working were nice but not overly gotta get to know you. They have lots of seating and it was very clean inside. read more

Food is delicious I love to come eat here but I came today and was peacefully eating my food when the employee came up to my family and told us they were closed at exactly 2pm when I was not done with my food. Doing this was disrespectful because there have been many times we've stayed 10-15 minutes after without basically being kicked out. I hope they are this punctual about opening the same as they are kicking people out at 2 pm on the dot. read more

The people here are real, and they care. Delicious food, delicious muffins of course, and they're doing everything they need to do to make you feel at home. read more

This place is so gosh darn cute!! The service is friendly, the food is amazing and it's really clean. I highly recommend both the bagels and the muffins. Everything I have tried I have throughly enjoyed. Try the breakfast BLT. So amazing! read more

The muffins were heavy and tasted terrible. The muffins may have been frozen. All I know is that I'd never go here again. The dining area was small but extremely noisy. read more

Wow!! What a find!! You have to check it out in here!! This place takes the cake on homemade muffins and bagels.. I will never go anywhere else! I tried the sprinkle muffin, blue berry and haven't had the cherry cream cheese muffin yet, trying it later. DELICIOUS! Great service Can't wait to come back and try a bagel breakfast sandwhich.. yummy! I just know it's going to be so yummy.. u can tell the lord at the bagels looked inside the case! FRESHLY BAKED!!! Yumm Recommend u check it out! read more

Service was excellent. Food was great. Price was fair will definitely be back. Loved it

Limited savory foods options. But for coffee and other drinks it's comparable to other coffee shops. Good for a quick bite and coffee, limited seating but a good addition to the city read more

Super disappointed they made the food wrong (backwards). It matters because my daughter couldn't eat what I ordered for myself so it wasn't a let's just switch option. First world problems I know. The restaurant is not close to where I am staying so I'm not going back. If you get takeout check your order. read more

So happy I made it there before they closed. Very lovely lady inside explained their best deal was the 3 dozen deal. NOT for this belly though. I only bought a dozen and will share the rest. Bought a variety of muffins and took a box lunch menu for later ordering. They make sandwiches and cater. The muffins were very moist and not over sugary. I'll be back to try their box lunches to take on my next picnic or hike for sure. The chocolate cream cheese muffin was for me and I had a bite of the carrot cake muffin. Both will be repurchased. Was told The cherry cheese cake muffin was so good and that was devoured. The NY cheesecake muffin was given 3 stars because I was told they didn't have anything to judge it off prior and said to them it wasn't amazing. But c'mon , average is good . It wasn't bad and that is good. read more

My Favorite Muffin - The dozen I bought , blueberry , and carrot - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

So many yummy options. I have tried the muffins and bagels. Great flavor and everything is reasonably priced. Good atmosphere and staff is so nice!! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Stomach rumbling, an affordable breakfast in-mind, this was the perfect spot. I was staying at the nearby Holiday Inn and stumbled upon this place in my favorite app. Not too many people around probably because of the Rona, but that did not dissuade me. Upon entering, you could smell the delicious smell of yeast and baked goods. They have a really extensive selection of bagels and muffins. I'll admit, I went a big crazy and ordered a large assortment of bagel sandwiches and muffins. My favorite sandwich was the southern tradition. The carrot cake muffin was also killer. I wish I had a place like this close to home. The staff was great, the food was great, and prices were extremely fair. I liked it so much, I went here a few times during my visit. Each visit just as good as the last. Definitely recommend this place. They are also extremely clean and COVID safe. Try it, you won't regret it. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Wide selection of muffins - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Food itself was good. Picked up a dozen bagels and a coffee box for the office. The bagels were great but they got the cream cheese wrong. And of course it was the worst cream cheese. They gave us garden vegetable. had to stop at the grocery store and get regular. read more

I love this place! Hot breakfast sandwiches, delicious bagels, mouthwatering muffins. And the coffee bar has at least 6 blends off coffee, depending on your mood. My favorite sandwich is The Southern Tradition with sausage on an everything bagel. Yum! They now have a loyalty program so you just download the app and for your trouble, you get a free coffee. Woot! Prices are great, people are wonderful... I really need to come in to have lunch! read more

My Favorite Muffin - Southern Tradition with chocolate cream cheese muffin. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

I have been visiting my favorite muffin for many years. It is the main drive to my workplace. I stopped in this morning and got a bagel and without fail, it was awesome. The service is attentive and willing to help with serving you. Thank you for the awesome service. read more

10000/10!!! Everyone staff wise was so sweet and helpful! It had been my first time here and I wasn't unsure of what to get but they definitely made my choice easier! Muffins/Food were real yummy! Definitely recommend if you're looking for a small sweet treat in town. Price for quite everything were real reasonable (in case you're looking for something easy and "cheap") on the run read more

Fast, friendly service. Had 2 southern tradition bagel sandwiches with bacon. I had mine of a spinach Swiss bagel. Super good. We had two muffins as well - chocolate and a crumb ? Both good, dense muffins. We plan on going back. read more

Had some delicious muffins! they had some cookies at the front that are from a baker and it actually tasted like peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It was pretty wild. Will be back for some breakfast sandwiches. read more

My Favorite Muffin - Berry crumb, Coconut cream pie, lemon pound cake, Boston cream - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Centennial, Colorado