Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mutiny Beach BBQ

    3.9 (11 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 1 month ago

    Mutiny Beach BBQ Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Mutiny Beach BBQ

    Recommended Reviews - Mutiny Beach BBQ

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Elise M.
    195
    62
    83

    8 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of H.D. C.
    22
    10
    5

    10 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Chaz P.
    265
    4
    0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    I was so excited to try this BBQ! Went a few months ago. But must say I was not impressed. Just ok brisket.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M G.
    0
    8
    0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    8 months ago

    Great food, great space - hard working staff! So happy they opened a second spot! Can't wait to visit again!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Great burnt ends, Beast of the East sandwich and cob salad. Delicious and great portions. Will return!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    $18 sandwich with $1.80 worth of meat. Location location location. Decent food just very bare. Great location.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mutiny Beach BBQ

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Local Smoke BBQ - Neptune City - BBQ Chicken Platter Macaroni & Cheese French Fries Cornbread

    Local Smoke BBQ - Neptune City

    4.1(372 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    We have picked up food here several times. I have thought of writing a review with a picture, but…read morewhen we bring the food home and plate it up, we just start eating. It is so f---ing good! Tonight, as usual, we had 1/2 rack St. Louis Ribs with side salad and sweet potato fries and BBQ Pulled Chicken with side Cesar salad and Onion Rings. We share everything. DELICIOUS! This place is the real deal. Ribs and chicken cooked to perfection and that sauce! Go once and you will certainly return.

    Still just not good. I tried this place one year ago and figured I would give it some time and give…read moreit one more go, but I was even more disappointed than the first time. We grabbed our takeout and took it home. Upon opening each item, I grew more and more concerned with how it looked. Everything we was either overcooked or dried out. The pulled pork was stringy and dried out and lacked taste. Thank goodness they gave us some sort of vinegar sauce to put on it to resurrect it a tiny bit. The ribs were also dry. There was no helping that. The mac & cheese seemed like they made a roux, let it sit there and dry out, then added mushy pasta to it. It also didn't even have a cheesy flavor. Got the green beans, definitely skip those. It's basically steamed green beans with paprika sprinkled on it. The cornbread was decent. I'll give them that. The one thing I will say that was good were the sweet potato fries. Somehow, those made it through OK. The food just lacks heart and soul, and doesn't really excite barbecue enthusiast. It's not even good for just regular food. I really wish whoever the management or owner is would take a moment to sample all of the food and see how it can be approved, we really could use you in the area. So sorry to be so harsh, but it is what it is and twice in a row it was like this for me.

    Photos
    Local Smoke BBQ - Neptune City - Outside

    Outside

    Local Smoke BBQ - Neptune City - Ribs and jalapenos poppers (not good too salty)

    Ribs and jalapenos poppers (not good too salty)

    Local Smoke BBQ - Neptune City - Chicken Bri

    See all

    Chicken Bri

    Joe’s Rotisseria - What's with the wings $15 for breaded wings?They were ok but not what I ordered the last time. the delivery guy definitely dropped my pizza

    Joe’s Rotisseria

    4.1(72 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    So I saw an image online that made me want to desperately stop in and try this item out at Joe's…read moreRotisseria in Asbury Park. I met up with my buddy Tyler from Foodula and we got the item I wanted...and then some! So the item I wanted was a meatball pizza that had meatball garlic knots as the crust. This would have been sufficient enough for anyone but ya know ... not us . We also ordered a pizza with cup and char pepperoni and chopped up mozz sticks on it where the crust was chicken vodka parm sliders. WHAT?!?! crazy. And maybe we added some wings. And uhh..maybe some thunder sticks. The thunder sticks were insane. Fried perfectly with great flavor and the cheese was perfectly melted. We had chil fil a flavored wings and also Thai chili wings. The wings themselves were cooked really well and had great juiciness and flavor. If I got these 2 apps I would have left perfectly happy. The pizzas were wild. I will admit in hindsight the mozz sticks on the vodka parm pizza were maybe a bit overkill on the cheesiness. Without them it may have been even better, but the cutlets were thin and cooked perfectly and the flavor was great. Both pizzas were a little doughier than I typically prefer but they had nice char and crispiness underneath. The meatball garlic knots were awesome. Meatballs had great flavor and texture. This place .. is not cheap. I do think what we had was worth the cost, but plan to spend more than you'd normally plan to spend on pizza here. With the bells and whistles comes dollar signs, I was okay with the tradeoff. Joe's Rotisseria - Didn't Suck!

    As soon as we got in we were greeted and offer specials. We decided to pick a couple of plates from…read moretheir famous mozzarella stick, chicken, and pin wheel. The half of chicken was so good, crispy skin but juicy inside. I thought the Mac and cheese with penne pasta was fun and delicious as well the mashed potatoes. The pinwheel and mozzarella stick were good but the chicken was my favorite. The ambiance is chill and easy going. Love all the Asbury park artwork.

    Photos
    Joe’s Rotisseria - Upstairs dining area

    Upstairs dining area

    Joe’s Rotisseria - Pepperoni and Buffalo Chicken Slices

    Pepperoni and Buffalo Chicken Slices

    Joe’s Rotisseria - View from upstairs down

    See all

    View from upstairs down

    Talula's - Some People Call Me Maurice 12" White Pizza $20

    Talula's

    4.2(1k reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    I fall more in love with this place each time I go!…read more Grabbed a Vegan Cesar and vegan hot honey pizza. Unreal! The Cesar salad was amazing - I'll be dreaming of it the next visit. The pizza, as always, a FAVORITE. Truly the best place ever!!!

    I heard a lot about this place and drove two hours to come here. I love the area and was looking…read morefor a good food spot. I know they have great pizza, but I wanted to find brunch in the area. We sat at the bar because there were plenty of seats. It looked like there were two bartenders working. The restaurant was only half full, but we thought we'd have good service at the bar. Our server seemed new; she didn't write down our order. She repeated it back incorrectly, still didn't write it down, and then entered it into the POS system. She kept asking if it was correct as she shouted it back to us. We thought this was weird because she could've just written it down. We ordered ricotta toast and a breakfast sandwich with bacon. It took 40 minutes for the food to come out and when it did they forgot the bacon. And my toast was cold. We asked the other bartender about the bacon and the long wait time, and he was very rude. We said, we ordered 40 minutes ago and no one came back to check on us. The girl who waited on us was standing behind the bar, staring at us, writing in a notebook and never acknowledged us after that. The other male bartender was rude when we asked how much longer our order would take he said "You did not order 40 minutes ago!!" I said, we did. Upon walking into the restaurant, we took several pictures and they were time stamped. The male bartender went over to the POS system to check our order. We stated that we did order bacon 40 minutes prior. It had never been put in so he added it to our order. We waited for the bacon; it didn't come out for several minutes. While we were waiting, I asked for the manager and the male bartender snapped back at me and said "Why?" He didn't want to get her, and I insisted I speak to her because I wanted to let someone about this experience. He walked away from the bar, threw his hands up and was yelling. After that he didn't speak to us either. I find it shocking that there are people like this who don't care about food, service or helping customers at all. I wouldn't go back here because it was very strange, and I've never had an experience with two servers who were so rude and aloof.

    Photos
    Talula's - Interior

    Interior

    Talula's - Esquites pizza

    Esquites pizza

    Talula's - Food

    See all

    Food

    REYLA - STEAK (GF DF)

    REYLA

    4.3(300 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    Delicious food! Warm and friendly staff. Our waitress was very on her game and took such great care…read moreof us! We would very much like to return! Love the Speakeasy in the basement!!

    Valentine day surprise here. I didnt know in advance so couldnt scope out reviews and menu in…read moreadvance. Location: parked at paid parking nearby which was cheap $1 or $2 per hour. Didnt partake in $25 valet parking but was sorely tempted. The indoors are beautiful, white walls and pretty decorations, large bar. Service: Terrific. 5 stars. Julia was awesome, helpful and honest. I did tell her I cant eat spicy stuff although I enjoy lightly spicy stuff. Drinks: I tried the Lebanese red wine. Very nice medium body. My husband tried the old fashioned which he said were good. Starters: we had the salatim which is 6 different dips and two piping hot large pita breads. I liked 4 out of 6 dips while hubby liked 5 out of 6. We both loved the hummus, salad, lima bean, and eggplant ones. This kind of eating is always fun. The discovery! STAR: The star is the halloumi. Fried cheese with lightly sweet crispy crust honeyed and topped with a light refreshing salad and pomenegrate seeds. Our server charmingly apologized she forgot to warn me about the codfish chili being potentially hot but I ended up trying and enjoying it, although I felt the fish was slightly overcooked. Not rubbery but a little too crusty and not flaky enough. I did not complain though because her dessert recommendation for malabi, a custard with oat crisps, was lovely. Nice to share with hubby and cap off the night. Temperature control: we sat somewhat near the front so were hit with cold air anytime someone entered. My husband is recovering from back surgery so walking was difficult for him. I appreciate he planned such a nice outing for us despite his walking challenges. All in all, we would return and explore cocktails and other menu items.

    Photos
    REYLA - Seating in front

    Seating in front

    REYLA - TURKISH HUMMUS GF

    TURKISH HUMMUS GF

    REYLA - Kachapuri

    See all

    Kachapuri

    MOGO Korean Fusion Tacos - Fish taco + beef taco

    MOGO Korean Fusion Tacos

    4.2(648 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    I keep coming back to MOGO on Cookmam, one of my go-to spots in Asbury right now!…read more Food-wise, the pork burrito is my staple, especially with the veggie fried rice mixed in, it adds this perfect texture and makes the whole thing feel extra satisfying. The flavors are bold, well-seasoned, and consistent every time. The buldok cheesesteak is also a standout sandwich, spicy and cheesy. Don't skip the pickle bar either! The pickled cucumbers and spicy pear sauce are my favorites and honestly elevate everything. Bonus points for the strawberry lychee drink, which is super refreshing. Service is always friendly and easygoing, and even after 20+ visits over the past six months, it still feels welcoming. They also do a great job keeping things interesting, there's always something new or a collab popping up, which keeps me curious enough to try different items. This spot is perfect if you're into bold, Korean-inspired street food and like having some room to customize your order. If you're new, try a couple things before locking in your favorite, but trust me, you'll find one.

    Literally the best tacos I have ever had. Top 5 foodie spots for me. Seriously, you guys have to…read moretry this place. Gourmet well thought out flavor profiles, incredible. 10/10. The staff is incredibly kind and welcoming as well. Place is very clean and well maintained. Will most definitely be returning here anytime I'm in the area.

    Photos
    MOGO Korean Fusion Tacos
    MOGO Korean Fusion Tacos - Chicken bowl, bulgogi bowl

    Chicken bowl, bulgogi bowl

    MOGO Korean Fusion Tacos - Shrimp taco, purple rice and korean donut

    See all

    Shrimp taco, purple rice and korean donut

    Mutiny Beach BBQ - smokehouse - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...