Hoagitos is one of my go-to spots in the area! My favorites are the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich, Chipotle Chicken Sandwich, and the Double Smashburger. I'll occasionally get the Nashville Hot, but that one really packs a kick, so consider the warning, haha. I always order in person and they whip it up in a matter of minutes. I've never eaten in, but they have indoor and outdoor seating and always have some good indie/rock playing on the radio for those who want a sit-down meal. I've probably ordered here close to 100 times and have only have 2 order issues. I brought it to the management's attention the last time and they were super professional and took care of it ASAP. My only other gripe is that they don't have bleu cheese for the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich. Overall, 5 stars all day long, no doubt about it! read more

See all

A lunch break at Hoagitos is a weekly occurrence (sometimes twice within a week!) Our usual picks are the Chipotle Chicken Sandwich and the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich - and yes, the meat is *always* hanging out past the bun. The sauces and the quality of the chicken are always top notch. Today we tried something different with the Spicy Vodka Parm Sandwich - it was lacking a little bit in the sauce and flavor department. But we'll definitely still keep picking up our usual lunch sandwiches from Hoagitos for a long time coming. read more

See all

One of the most juicy chicken sandwiches I ever had, the chipotle burger was spicy but not overwhelming. The fries were hit and crispy. Definitely a lunch/ dinner worth experience guys. read more

Loved that we stumbled upon this place. Everyone was so nice and gave recommendations on what to try. Food was great, seasoned well with a lot of flavors. So many things I'd love to try on their menu. Definitely looking forward to coming back. read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - Forbidden Chicken (Travel Channel Featured) + Griddle Mac & Cheese - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

See all

My dinner at Hoagitos was so good! I have visited the Point Pleasant location and loved it, and this location is just as good (plus it has a parking lot). Upon entry, I was warmly greeted by Justin. He was very courteous and helpful with suggestions and menu options. I opted for the Forbidden Chicken sandwich, which had a sweet and spicy glaze, daikon slaw and roasted garlic mayo. It was a fantastic sandwich that was cooked to order. I had a side of shoestring fries which were tasty as well, but the true star was the sriracha mayo that it came with. It was almost more addictive than the fries. The spicy chicken vodka parm sandwich is an excellent fusion of flavor. I look forward go returning soon to get my Hoagitos fix and try more of their menu items! read more

See all

This place is insane! Went partying hard and had to replenish a lot of missing calories with my buddy Dan. Dan suggested we go to Hoagitos since he knows I love to eat. I got the Southern Comfort chicken sandwich, which is crispy chicken, Mac and cheese, and a chili jam on top. Well let me tell you I almost shot into space with the first bite, what an insanely delicious chicken sandwich, likely one of the best I've ever had in my LIFE. The flavors of that southern comfort were outrageous. I also had a bite of my buddy's chipotle burger, and wow! Amazing burst of flavor in that burger! The fries and BBQ sauces were also amazing. Can't recommend this place enough! They have special sandwiches each month which just makes me want to visit them monthly!! Food was served to us at the table very quickly. The inside decor is cool, kind of feels like you're eating in a much nicer 5 Guys type of food place. Most of their locations are by the beach, so summertime is looking even tastier this year! I can't wait to try their other sandwiches, so many tasty options! read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - Southern Comfort chicken Sandwich and a smash burger with fries. I was clearly famished! - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

See all

Great options, great service, clean and welcoming. My daughter and I wandered in as we've heard so much about Hoagitos, she wasn't super hungry and opted for a basic turkey and cheese. I was overwhelmed by the menu and wanted everything. The plan was to order the chopped cheesesteak until I got up to the register and noticed the Asian chicken special which I quickly ordered. This was a bad choice on my part bc this isn't my taste. I don't like sweet. It was almost like a general tso chicken sandwich. My daughter opted to swap with me and now I was stuck with a plain ol' turkey sandwich. It was good but I was looking for something gooooood. Both sandwiches were on nice, fresh bread and stuffed with ingredients. I need to try Hoagitos again and take my time when ordering. read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - Asian chicken special - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

See all

Why have I not known this place existed 10 minutes away??! All the burgers I could've eaten. Got the double patty smash burger with fries and am just in bliss. Perfection. Couldn't stop eating the fries way after I was done. read more

See all

I love this place!!!! Amazing sandwich options, friendly staff, and reasonable prices. I will definitely be back soon

Absolutely a must if you are ever in Oakhurst. I LOVE the Smash burgers . This place is Super Clean and the food is amazing . They are constantly coming up with incredible specials . Only problem is I have with this place is they are closed on Mondays lol 10 out of 10 every time !!!! read more

Food was tasty, well presented and served with courtesy. We dined in and the place was clean. Service was great.

I often visit the Belmar location, but recently gave this location a try. Honestly, Hoagitos can do no wrong. They make the best food I've ever tried. If you haven't had an opportunity to visit one of their locations out, I highly recommend you do. During this trip we got two specialty sandwiches. The Tinga and the Caesar chicken sandwich. The Tinga was phenomenal and loaded with flavor. This sandwich deserves a spot on the permanent menu. Absolutely fantastic - as always. read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - two burgers and fries on a tray - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

This is definitely a hidden gem. It's a small sandwich joint in a very busy plaza, but it is so modern. They have beautiful indoor and outdoor seating so it's great for big groups. The sandwiches to take time to come out but when they do, they are outstanding! Honestly, some of the best me to order fried chicken sandwiches I've ever had. They have a ton of unique different combinations as well as extremely crispy juicy chicken. We only tried two of their sandwiches but we loved them so much we're going to work out way through the menu. They have a ton of great options and it is reasonably priced in my opinion. read more

See all

Convenient, inexpensive, good quality. Terrific breakfast sandwiches. Generally quick service. But dear God, if I never hear or read a sandwich called a sammy I'll be happy! read more

This place is one of those staples in the community that hopefully continues to expand to other towns. Sandwiches are spot on. I like the fried chicken sandwiches the best. Nice crunch on the chicken and fried just right for perfect tenderness. Potato bun ties it all together. It is flirting with a 5 star review... might as well give it! read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

See all

I never do reviews but after this interaction i definitely had to. This place had terrible service, waited over 30 minutes and my order was not even being made yet. After wasting my time waiting, I decided to just get refunded for the food, and they told me they do not do refunds. I ended up just leaving in complete frustration would not recommend. read more

The food was very good, I got the fried chicken caesar sandwich which had huge pieces of chicken on it! Overall was very good and had a lot of flavor for this type of sandwich. I would definitely go back again. read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - chicken vodka parm - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

See all

This was my first time trying Hoagitos - we ordered to go and got the meatball sandwich, the brisket hoagito, and the macaroni salad. Their sandwiches are a good size in my opinion. I didnt feel too full and the sandwich plus the side was enough to leave me satisfied. I liked my sandwich - the marinara was tasty and there wasnt too much cheese like other places do so it was not too heavy. My partner liked his brisket - the flavors complimented each other although he said it was a bit dry. The sandwiches were packed neatly and not too messy to eat. The macaroni salad was also good. Prices were very fair as well. read more

We absolutely love it here! It's a must check out if you're at the Jersey Shore! There's so many options from fried chicken sandwiches, burgers, sliders, sides! And the griddle mac & cheese is an absolute MUST! You seriously can't go wrong with anything you get here Today we had the Nashville Fried Chicken Sandwich and let me tell you the chicken was so crispy and that sauce gave the sandwich some spice balanced perfectly with fresh cabbage! And on special right now is the Chipotle Double Smash Burger, so good! Double burger, American cheese, chipotle mayo, bacon AND fresh chilis! With a side of griddle mac & cheese an absolute must for your next Hoagitos trip! It's seriously THE BEST and guarantees a flavor-packed experience that will keep you coming back for more! read more

Get the smash burger, you won't regret it. Always a generous portion when you order from them.

Ricky Ricotta! Enough said! Best sandwich!! I just wish the sandwich came with French fries because I sometimes I forget to order. read more

Food was nice and service was good! Had lunch with mom on a rainy Saturday afternoon. The ambiance is quite cute. Would be nice to try the sides as well. read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - Interior (fun space, colorful and bright) - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

I was in NJ for a visit and swung by to grab lunch. I was very impressed by the customer service - they staff were personable, funny, and provide us with great recommendations. We sat inside but notice there is ample outdoor seating for a smaller location. Notably, the outdoor space was created using reclaimed wood from the Asbury Boardwalk, a nice touch for locals to appreciate. Highly recommend the hand-cut fries, very crunchy and thinly sliced. We ordered the Southern Comfort and Colonel Mustard sandwiches, and they were excellent. The spicy chili jam balanced the savory chicken and the griddled mac and cheese. If you're looking for a great sandwich spot, skip Wawa and fast food, and come here! read more

This sandwich shop gives you more than the average burger or fried chicken sandwich. Tasty seasonings spice up the entrees and make it a step above typical sandwich fare. Set up almost like a fast food restaurant with a limited number of tables, sitting space is quite limited. However, that should not dissuade you as the food is that good. read more

-small but yummy a local fav for fried chicken sandwich's. -small but flavorful. -quick fast food on the go for solo or group diners . the go to : is general tso forbidden chicken or classic chicken. - fubar fries with pork delish as unique sauce and griddle mac and cheese are my fav tip :they feature specials on the site. read more

Food is good quality and not your average fare. I like the pulled pork and the turkey sandwich as well as the shoestring fries. All are seasoned well. A bit pricey for the size of the "little" hero but who doesn't over charge today? Only probelm is they seem to have has a gnat problem over the summer. Not great to try to eat while shooing away bugs. read more

Service - Excellent. Very friendly staff. Quick to order. Quality of Tasted Food - very good. Cleanliness - tables and chairs were clean. The turkey sandwich was made fresh to order. The flavor of cilantro-lime mayo paired well with the house made turkey and pepper jack cheese. The fresh arugula and onion added good crunch to the sandwich. It was the perfect size for lunch. Both indoor and outdoor seating were offered. The entrance from the sidewalk to the outdoor seating is not flush so a little more strength to maneuver a stroller or wheelchair over it may be required. Overall, Hoagitos is a hip spot to enjoy a tasty sandwich while sitting outside (or inside) or for take-out. read more

See all

If I could give this place a 10 stars, I definitely would do it in a heartbeat. My family and I stumbled upon this place while visiting the area and after reading all of the wonderful reviews. We decided to give it a try. The food was indeed DELICIOUS! We ordered the Forbidden chicken sandwich and the Chicken Vodka Parm along with an order of their fresh cut fries. Everything was tasty, fresh and so yummy. After eating our food, we decided to buy two additional sandwiches to bring home and these sandwiches were also very tasty. The two to go sandwiches we got were the Asian BBQ Sando and the Nashville Hot. We also tasted their salted chocolate chip cookies and these cookies were indeed the best chocolate chip cookies that we have ever tasted. The staff were very friendly and attentive. The prices were very reasonable. We will definitely visit again. read more

I got the risotto balls and dude ranch chicken sandwich. Both were fried perfectly and delicious read more

Hoagitos: Towne Center Plaza - Risotto balls and dude ranch chicken sandwich - American Near Me - Oakhurst, New Jersey

Love this place. Not only is the staff friendly and attentive but also the food is incredible. I often get the southern comfort chicken sandwich with griddled Mac and cheese as a side with a side of B sauce and it hits the spot. Definitely 10/10 read more

I LOVED this place and ordered regularly, until now. Everything I ordered and loved was removed from the menu! See ya never again Hoagitos!

I first visited them when they were on the boardwalk in Asbury Park, NJ. The food is awesome! And service is great! I finally returned after over 8 years and their menu has expanded. And the food does not let you down. The breakfast options are some of the best, and the specials too. Still have many sandwiches to try. The seating area is nice. Both indoors and outdoors. read more

service was super fast and personable, the interior is cool and cute and the outdoor seating area was clean and would be super enjoyable if it was warmer out. but honestly what stole the show was the food, we had the Chopped Cheese sandwich, the Soppressata hoagie, and the mac and cheese and all three were absolutely delicious. will be back for sure read more

Great Sandwiches here. Lots of varieties both cold and hot, sliders too. Try the Mac and cheese for sure. Some cool merch too.

Been meaning to try this place since they opened. Had my first opportunity to get takeout and it was awesome. I had an amazing cheesesteak and my girlfriend had the Nashville Hot chicken sandwich. Portion sizes were also reasonable. Fortunately I live close by and will return soon. Everything on the menu looks good and definitely recommend read more

Needed quick bite for late lunch and received recommendation for Hoagitos. Perfect steer! Nashville chicken sandwich right on point, fried to perfection, pickles, cheese and spice on delicious potato bun. Portobello mushroom sandwich devoured as well. Go with an appetite and try a few of these tasty bites at once. Bring a crew and share them all. Must try. read more