3-12-26. Passed by while running an errand. Ordered a regular slice and a slice with extra cheese. Nothing life changing but a very decent slice for a very decent price. It's not a "destination" pizza joint but you'll leave here pretty satisfied. A few tables inside for dining and they have a restaurant portion that I did not venture into during my visit. Wait staff was very friendly and accommodating. 3.5 stars. read more

Mulberry Street - 6-8-25. Chicken Parm slice. Very good. - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Service is always great love eatting here. Ambiance is a cute cozy restaurant feels like home. Food is always amazing, I think this place has the best free bread also but forgot to take a pic of that. Really enjoyed my shrimp parm. Five stars. Also think this mulberry street is better than the east islip one. read more

See all

This place slaps. Just stopped in for a slice & I was blown away. Staff were friendly and welcoming. They made sure we got a hot fresh slice that just came out. You can either take out or dine in. We opted out to eat in the parking lot. One of the best slices in this area. Nice flavorful sauce. Good sauce to cheese ratio. Nice tase on the dough. A little flop but still a little crisp. read more

See all

Came in craving a slice of pizza. I was pleasantly surprised since the last time I was here I got a plain slice, and it was delicious. Staff was very friendly lot of choices to choose from as far as specialty pies will definitely be back. read more

Close to boyfriend's parents house, food was good and waitress was very friendly. Would go back for the sake of convenience read more

Mulberry Street - Annalisa's birthday dinner - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

This is the place to go to get authentic Italian cuisine They are always friendly whether you're calling in over the phone to place an order or coming to dine in I'm always choosing between penne a la vodka with grilled chicken or fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken. They have decor to match the food, they have booths and tables if you're looking for a casual sit down restaurant read more

Mulberry Street - Penne Alla Vodka with Grilled Chicken - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

The place is a bit of a hole in the wall but the food is delicious. Tonight my friend got Fra Diavlo & I got the eggplant parm & we both had mozzarella & tomato app. Everything was perfection read more

Mulberry Street - Caprese salad - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Even pizza gets boring sometimes. My wife and I decided to try a new place for Friday night pizza. Instead of the five minute drive to our usual place, going to mulberry took ten. So delicious. We went for the Chicago pan pizza plus half pepperoni. We like our local place but the pie from Mulberry was just so full of flavor. The dough, the sauce, the cheese, it was just outright good. We will see you mulberry again next Friday. Thank you for adding the spark back to Friday night pizza. read more

Mulberry Street - Chicago pan pizza half pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Vinnies Mulberry Street, Bayshore. This is gross - warning. Went in to pick up our weekly order last Friday. As soon as I walked in, a young girl behind the counter was rubbing and scratching her bare stomach with her hands, coughing into her shirt and then touching everything. She then licks her finger while talking to another employee and then...begins to CUT MY PIZZA with her hands touching the box and my pizza. I asked to speak to a manager, but a different young girl attended to my issue. I said - 'I am not taking that pizza', and explained why. She goes and tells an older bald male manager - who instructs her to tell me that they will remake my pizza. He does not come over, does not aologize, and does not address the insane hygine issue I just saw. She is not asked to go wash her hands, or even spoken to. She literally just keeps it moving.... Then, coughing girl in question looks at me, says 'sorry' and then begins to cough into her shirt, while looking dead at me - lifting it so high that I see the tops of her bra! After coughing and exposing herself, she proceeds to dump a filthy looking plastic tub of ice into the soda machine, using her hands to assist. Then....she continues coughing, and goes to refill the all the napkins and spices - putting her hands on TOP of every spice jar while filling it and putting them on the tables/counter. At this point, I dont want my food, I want my money back but am so grossed out I want OUT of there. When my fresh pizza comes, the cook is mean mugging me and the 'non-coughing non-manager' girl says - we gave you some zepps. Uhhh....thanks? Three days later I began to come down with norovirus. Not saying its connected but I have never been so grossed out by a pizzeria experience in my LIFE. We were weekly patrons but the fact that no manager addressed me, no one made her wash her hands and that they just kept it moving makes me think they need a food inspection visit ASAP. read more

Fantasic food and great pizza Had diner one night there and waitress suggested chic marsala that was great good portions. read more

My wife and I have been loyal customers of Vinnie's Mullberry Street in Bay Shore for easily more than 7 years. We have recommended family & friends. This is basically a pizza place with a restaurant seating area on the side. The food has always been very good. The lunch menus were very reasonably priced. We remained loyal through COVID - and ordered take-out from there........although this location was 25 minutes from our home (no shortage of similar restaurants in our area) . The regular waitresses knew us and knew our usual food orders. The kitschy Italian music playing in the background was a nice touch. We would frequent this establishment at least once every 2 weeks - with an approximate payment of $38.00 per visit - for 2 lunch meals. On top of that - we would always leave a generous tip - and an especially generous tip for Christmas. Our yearly spend there was easily over $1,000 per year. On February 24 - my wife and I felt like taking a trip to Vinnies Mulberry Street. It was always our "Go To" place for a nice lunch and a nice time. On that day - we were told by Mike (the owner) that the restaurant area was closed - no waitress was available. We were told that we could order "'take-out" and sit in the pizza dining area........tables and chairs close to the front door entrance ........with the full force of cold weather and winds whenever someone entered. So.....OK.....we decided we'd do that. We placed our orders. My wife usually orders either Ravioli or Eggplant Parmesan. Ravioli is priced on lunch menu at $11.95 (with a side salad). My wife requested Angel Hair pasta instead of Ravioli. Mike angrily tells us that this is not available on the "lunch menu." Now, we've ordered many times FOR YEARS with minor substitutions from the printed "lunch menu." I check the receipt....and I see that he charged me a total of $16.00 for the Angel Hair & the salad - a difference of $4.05 from the lunch special price. I bring this to his attention. He tells me "that is not on the lunch special." Now, it doesn't take a genius to determine that the cost of ingredients for ravioli (with cheese) is higher than the cost of angel hair pasta (with only marinara). So, instead of making an "exception" for REGULAR CUSTOMERS - he persists in being arrogant & abusive. Mike then went on to proudly tell us that he fired our regular waitress. The lack of foresight here was UNBELIEVABLE! He lost REGULAR CUSTOMERS over a $4.05 difference in price. When I confronted him with this lack of logic - he actually asked me if I'd like to take over his Pizzeria. We ended up walking out, picked up our own ingredients, and prepared our meal at home. I realize employee salaries, rent, cost of ingredients, etc. I'm in the "food business" - so I'm not oblivious. It's a shame, though, that due to the pennywise/pound foolish attitude of Mike - that he has lost regular customers. We will never return to this establishment. A sad state of affairs - considering that many folks are being cautious about the cost of going out to eat.....not to mention the difficulty in hiring a good staff. read more

I'm giving a 2 star rating because I have had tasty entrees here.A week or so ago no,no..no.The bread basket did not have the same delights.The bread with the tomato sauce on it was not bad.We ordered the bruschetta app.It was more like a pile under the toasted bread.Not very appetizing nor appealing to the eye.The cheese was not bad.My chicken caccitore,I love garlic like adore.The flavor of garlic powder not fresh garlic mad my tongue frown.I really did not like it.My friends daughter had chicken parm... she said it was not as good as it usually is and they live around the block so they had patronized regularly.My girl Cakes had a shrimp dish,the shrimp was good. The salad was cold,not chilled cold.That is a peeve of mine.The waitress was nice,vacant and did not know anything about the menu ...but she was nice. I would go back for a pie but skip the entrees for awhile. read more

See all

Review based on their pizza, but haven't ever sat in to eat here. It does have seating if you'd like, suitable for large groups as well. Favorite pizza spot out on Long Island. My usual go to is a pepperoni pie w/ extra pepperoni and the occasional calamari. Always consistent in deliciousness whenever I've ordered. I can't say for the other things, but I love me a fresh pie from here! A solid pizza spot in terms of flavors, cheesiness, and crispy crust consistency!! read more

Mulberry Street - Pepperoni pie w/ extra pepperonis - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Ive had good slices and slices I'd skip, some things I like because they are unique but I wasn't fond of a few others. Granted it was the end of the night last night and I should have know by looking at the pizza it was going to be lackluster to say the least, the grandma was just not what a grandma should be regardless of time. Service is fine and dandy, poor girl dropped my slice on the floor when about to bag it... kinda wish I got a know for the wait while my second slice sat there getting cold but why be greedy when the food wasn't great last night to begin with... cute girl though. I'd stop by in a pinch if passing by but I wouldn't go out of the way to grab anything here. read more

Mulberry Street - Not the greatest grandma slice - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

This place has been a staple for my family for quite sometime...my nanny loved to order and get delivery or pick up very regularly and the food was always delicious...didn't matter what was ordered, everything was very tasty! I hadn't ordered in a few months and decided I wanted a shrimp fra diavolo parmigiana...called and ordered for pick up...the girl was very new, and unfortunately messed up the order which I didn't realize right away because my friend went to pick it up. We called because the order was wrong on a couple of different items and the owner/manager gave us both credits towards our next order. So tonight, 2 days after thanksgiving, instead of leftovers, my family decided to order from Mulberry Street. We got a lovely assortment...baked clams app which was ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC! Omg...chopped and perfectly portioned in the mix were beautiful hints of clam! Then onto seafood bisque which was creamy, flavorful, and hot! We also ordered the baked pasta combo w ravioli, manicotti, and stuffed shells in a delicious tomato sauce and topped with gorgeous mozzarella! The ricotta filling was on the same level of taste. Instead of the traditional chicken dish, we opted for the chicken cordon bleu...wow! Yummy creamy sauce layered over crispy chicken cutlets topped w mushrooms, ham, and mozzarella over linguine (our choice)...this was a very flavorful dish! We then ordered 3 slices...regular, white, and spinach...the slices were your typical good quality Italian pizzeria/restaurant slices...my only small gripe as I was the one who ordered the spinach, was that it was a bit too oily...but that's it! Nice people at the front, delicious and quality food, ready and also corrects issues promptly... All of this adds up to 5 stars to me! read more

See all

I ordered the shrimp scampi over linguine pasta dinner to go. It was tasty but I did find some bunches of pasta stuck together. Wasn't too happy about that. I'm willing to give it another try because it still tasted good. read more

Mulberry Street - Shrimp scampi over linguine pasta - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

This is our favorite Italian restaurant, our go to when we order in. The food is always great, everything we have order is always tasty! Very generous portions, plenty for leftovers. Staff is always so friendly and delivery is always quick. If you're new to the area and looking for a good Italian place, this is it. read more

I ordered here for a quick bite to eat for the family at the recommendations of friends. Portions were huge, which was a plus only problem I had was that I found the food tasteless. I would try them again to see if maybe I called during a bad time. read more

Absolutely the best pizza on Long Island. Perfect crust and the sauce is never too sweet. read more

Mulberry street is a little pizzeria/Italian restaurant right off of sunrise highway in Bay Shore with a warm and cozy atmosphere. I decided to finally give them a try after being told several times that their shrimp scampi was one of the best. I'm sure glad I did because it was delicious! The shrimp were plump and seasoned perfectly with a nice blend of lemon, garlic, oil and breadcrumb served over a nice bed of angel hair pasta. The dish was exceptionally good when paired with the house salad that it came with and some warm crusty bread and butter. I would absolutely come back again. read more

Mulberry Street - Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

We live right down the road so we order here quite often! The food is always good and prepared correctly. We like the pastas (Lasagna, Penne alla Vodka with grilled chicken, and Pesto pasta) the best! Big portions with plenty of leftovers to take for lunch the next day! Pizza is good. Staff is friendly & efficient! I've only ordered takeout, so I cannot attest to the service for dining. read more

I needed to place a gluten free order. The girl who helped me Saturday afternoon was very nice and helpful. My friend said the clam sauce was really good. Chicken in her salad was cooked perfectly. Order was made quickly and ready for pick up right away. read more

This mulberry street location is absolutely awful - staff is super rude every single time (despite me tipping anyway) and gives attitude to you no matter what you order. Their food is incredible but the staff leaves an awful taste in my mouth. The girls at the counter are usually super rude but theres a few redeeming people there. In addition to everyone being rude no matter what to you, the staff is NEVER wearing their masks and constantly wears them on their chins. It's just disgusting and today I watched them give a tired overworked nurse who just got off her shift some serious attitude. Ugh. Usually they're always rude to everyone who walks in but that really made me want to write this review. I wish I could rate it 1 star but tbh the pizza gets the only star I'm allowed to give read more

Smallest buffalo slice I have ever seen! Half the size of a slice anywhere else, but the same price! WTF!!! A the slice had very little chicken on it. It taste good but I just don't understand why they think serving a slice so small is acceptable. It a shame because years ago I used to love this place. Don't think I'll be back. Paid for a full lunch and walked out HUNGRY! read more

Food was great, service was great, I am very satisfied. I will come definitely come back! I got tortellini with pesto and linguini seafood combo, they both tasted great and huge portions! read more

Mulberry Street - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Not bad chain restaurant serving pizza and Italian dishes. Went to the rather small Bay Shore location and we were fortunate enough to be seated promptly. The focaccia bread given to us after we ordered was nice. Started with a salad with the creamy garlic dressing which was too thick and pasty to spread evenly. Chicken marsala was a bit thin and buttery but the pasta on the side was good with a flavorful marinara sauce. Tried the orecchiette di Bari and it was pretty tasty and a large portion. Service was friendly and tabs are reasonable. Not my favorite place to come for Italian but not bad either. read more

See all

Ordered penny alla vodka with chicken and broccoli it was dry didn't taste like alla vodka sauce and it was all cut up and mixed in one bowl together did not like it was fine the first night the rest in the garbage,Big disappointment will only order pizza from now on read more

Mulberry Street - This is Penny IPenne Alla Vodka with Grilled Chicken - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

We get delivery from here all the time. Order is correct staff is patience on the phone. Food is top quality!

I'm Traveling & Sitting here eating my salad with my fingers because no fork was put in my bag but whatever. Besides that i Found a piece of plastic paper in my shrimp salad. It was supposed to be a grilled shrimp Cesar salad but i got a regular large garden salad. I guess that's why the salad was almost $20. the pizza i got was not fresh. Cheese dry and not melted on and the spot is literally across the street from where i am a 3 min drive. oh well never doing that again. read more

My parents brought me here as a treat one night. I had no idea what to excpect. I got the shrimp parmesan. The portion sizes were quite large and the food was tasty. I've since been back two other times and have tried their ravioli and pizza. I highly recommend at least one dine in night. It doesn't look like much from the outside but it is worth it. read more

There's a sign on the door about wearing masks to enter due to the government overreach again, only to walk in and see all 3 people behind the counter and 2 other employees ALL WEARING THEIR MASKS UNDERNEATH THEIR CHINS. Straight up disrespectful. Won't be ordering food from here again as they obviously DO NOT CARE about their own customers safety, never mind the actual population during a pandemic . wearing a mask is to prevent carrying and spreading Covid, and they clearly think it is a joke. Gross as a restaurant, and gross as people in general. read more

The worst Italian I have ever had. Sausage was so dry and pasta didn't even hold the sauce it was watery and the girls at the counter were to busy on there phones and eating behind the counter un professional never ever again. read more

My go to for local pizza and Italian food. Unfortunately today I was a little disappointed not only was the pizza ice cold but it was way undercooked. The crust was to soft and chewy. Usually always on point with pizza light and crispy, today was just off. read more

Excellent neighborhood pizzeria with small cozy restaurant service. The hot fresh Italian bread was fresh served with seasoned olive oil. Salad was fresh and the creamy garlic and blue cheese dressing was homemade deliciousness. I ordered penne alla vodka with grilled chicken and broccoli, it was a plentiful portion, cooked to perfection. So good! My husband ordered Chicken scarpiello, served with shrimp,chicken,sausage and pepper. He can't stop talking about it! Service was great! read more

Just arrived at six past nine and was denied seating because "they stopped seating at 9pm". Lost out on business. No where have I seen that they don't seat past 9pm. Their establishment is open until 10pm, so you would think we could eat until 10pm. Have been here a few times and enjoyed it. Too bad I won't be back again! read more

Expect dirty oven on the bottom of every slice you eat from here. It has that fine black burntness cooked in so consistently, I call that stuff "mulberry"! I used to love the buffalo chicken slice, but something about those ovens, they need to be cleaned multiple times a day. I had stopped going here but I moved back into town and tried them for delivery and I couldn't believe it, I got reheated old and BURNT pizzas that were so hot the cheese was sliding off. Not only were the pizzas dark brown but the bottom had big pieces of black "mulberry" on them. I called and got a 30 dollar credit which we still haven't used. Maybe we can order something that isn't baked? read more

Meh. With so many pizza joints there is really no reason to choose to go here. Years ago, under the original ownership, this was outstanding. Now, not so much. Robotic counter service, which is annoying each and every time I've ventured in. Expensive slices in comparison to what's out there and nothing special as far as the fare. Pass. read more

My husband and I called to order take-out and the girl who answered the phone was extremely rude! We asked for delivery and she hung up on us....so we called back and placed the order and she still had an attitude. We asked her if we they had ginger ale and she said "in a bottle" and hung up the phone....she never gave us a total or said can I get you anything else....my husband called back and canceled the order because of this girls' piss poor attitude. Needless to say we WON'T be getting food from here ever again....management should be mindful of who they pick to answer the phone....clearly customer service is not their forte. read more

Its alright. Not high on my list for pizza. So many places close by its just easy to skip. read more

I ordered the minestrone soup and chicken francese. Both dishes were pretty good. The entree came with a pasta of choice, the marinara sauce wasn't superb. The staff at the pizza counter were extremely friendly when we walked in and the waitress was decent, seemingly overwhelmed though. I would like to come back and check out the pizza selection. read more

Mulberry Street - Minestrone soup - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York