Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mr P's Cafe

    4.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Mr P's Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mr P's Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Lea H.
    0
    14
    4

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mr P's Cafe

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Rezk's Burger Lounge & Pizzeria - Double Combo

    Rezk's Burger Lounge & Pizzeria

    3.3(12 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Recently I have been back in my hometown more times than I can count. When I lived here years ago,…read moreand any time I would visit over the years, options for dining were lacking. They still kind of are, but Rezk's kind of fills a void in this town. Their menu is the simple one that offers what one would consider to be bar food, absent the bar. Think fried, burgers, pizza, etc. The first time I tried this place we got the food and brought it home. The second we ate in house and both times, in my mind, were superb. Each time I have gone with the House Double. Which is a combo meal and you get fries with it. Cooked to your liking and topped how you prefer. I topped mine with lettuce, onion, pickles, and mayo. The fries are fresh cut and amazing. The combo also comes with a drink, and for $11, not a bad price. It is just the right size of meal to hold you over. Made fresh when you order, so comes out hot. The one item I did not like were the fried pickles. The menu didn't have much of a description of them, but they were not the best. I believe they prepare them in the same way they prepare the fries and even might used the press they use for the potatoes on the pickles. They come out like shoestring fries, not spears or chips. Because of that, when they batter them, and the pickles being too wet, they really don't cook in the middle. It is crisp on the outside, but doughy on the inside. If you eat inside it is a nice open area. Kind of an open kitchen concept where you can see them preparing your food. Front entrance and a side entrance. Side entrance is the handicap entrance if you were to come in. The noise level can go between noisy with the sounds from the kitchen going on to quieter than a library. Decent and well needed spot in town. I have yet to try the pizza, maybe that will be the next item I take on from here on my next visit.

    I ordered the dinner special which was on the board as roast beef, potatoes, gravy and a veggie. My…read moreplate came with no veggie. When I asked "doesn't this come with a vegetable?" I got "no, I don't think so" as a response. I said "perhaps the sign shouldn't say it does then?" She walked away, muttering "I'll check". She came back with a small bowl of canned corn, muttered "I just bring the food" and the corn tasted like feet. I kid you not, FEET. No, I have not eaten feet before but I can't compare it to anything else. It was seasoned with feet. I didn't say anything because I don't know how to tell a cook that their vegetables taste like feet. I took one bite of the corn and threw it away. It made the rest of my very mediocre, barely warm food taste like feet. The gravy was brown salt water and I had to gargle with my Pepsi to get the feet taste out. It didn't even completely go away till I came home and brushed my teeth. My mother-in-law ordered 2 cheese slices and got 1, the young lady saying "we're making a fresh pizza for your 2nd slice." Why not just wait and give her 2 fresh slices, instead of unloading the last gross slice on her? It was hard and crusty and barely warm. The fresh slice that came was very good and that's why I'm giving 2 stars and not just 1. I've been here many times and I always order the dinner special because I'm not a huge pizza fan. My mom is though, and she says their pizza is pretty good. The other times we've been here, it's the same thing with the dinner special, it's like they took a Banquet TV dinner, warmed it up and scraped it onto a plate. This is the first time it's been feet flavored though, which is why I was compelled to write this review. Horrible.

    Photos
    Rezk's Burger Lounge & Pizzeria - House Double

    House Double

    Rezk's Burger Lounge & Pizzeria - They have small napkins with different comics on them

    They have small napkins with different comics on them

    Rezk's Burger Lounge & Pizzeria - Decent pizza

    See all

    Decent pizza

    Hastings Beaver Street Cafe - Meatloaf

    Hastings Beaver Street Cafe

    4.2(24 reviews)
    3.5 mi
    $

    Going home just doesn't feel like it used to compared to just a few short years ago for me. There's…read morea number of reasons for that, but this isn't that type of review. One of the things I miss the most is the home cooked meals I would look forward to. Recently, those meals are far and few in between. On a recent trip my brother and I had decided to give this place a try. He had been here before, but this would be my first time. We ventured over and walked in. There wasn't much of a crowd and we were seated with menus in hand in no time. I did a once over of the menu quickly and spotted meatloaf. I don't know what it is about meatloaf on a menu, but I have to give it a try each and every time I see it. Our server was quick to take our order and we were just now going to wait until things started to arrive. I looked around the space as we waited and took it in. This place really does give off a small town vibe with the decor. My brother told me that the space is bigger when they use the other dining room as well. With it being not so busy, they had no need to use that part of the space. Unlike the one reviewer that said they get hit with a smell when they come in here, the only smell I got hit with was the food being prepared. We both started off with a side salad. It was a decent size, but I did have to pick through it a bit as there was some undesirable pieces of lettuce floating in the salad. They give you ample salad dressing so you can go all in or add as you go. Wasn't anything special, lettuce, tomato, onion and your dressing. Nice way to start off the meal. Then the main dish arrived. Like I said, I went with the meatloaf which came with two sides and a roll. For my sides I went with mashed potatoes and my choice of vegetable, corn. The choice of vegetable varies on what they have that day. You could tell that there were some shortcuts taken on some of the plate, but not the meatloaf. With gravy over the meatloaf and mashed potatoes it was the way to go. The meatloaf was seasoned nicely, it was overpowered by peppers or onions, it was just right. I did the Pennsylvania thing in me with the mashed potatoes and corn. I would take a glob of the potatoes and stick it in the corn to eat it. Not sure if anyone else does this, but I find it easier and sometimes the combination is spot on. The addition of the sweet corn to the potatoes gives is a buttery taste. While we were noshing away at our meal we got a bacon cheeseburger with fries to go for my Dad waiting at home. They cooked it at just the right time. As we were finishing up the meal I saw them placing the to go order near the counter. Almost perfect timing. Paying was easy and we headed out for the night.

    Today was the first time we have tried this restaurant. The initial smell of old and moldy hit us…read moreright as we walked into the front door, but people were seated in the main area, so decided to stay and give it a try. The speed of service was amazing. The wait staff was attentive, kind, and very quick. I have absolutely no complaints when it came to service. The food is another matter entirely. I'm surprised they are still in business with the food quality. The Italian hoagie is a joke, and would make a real Italian spit on his grandmother. The turkey hoagie (which we ordered cold) came out toasted with a piece of crunchy American "cheese" in the top, with half burnt bread. The pulled pork looked like it was either eaten before, or sat in the fridge for a week. It was like slop on a plate. Disgusting is an understatement. We more than likely will not be going back. Save your money.

    Photos
    Hastings Beaver Street Cafe - Side Salad

    Side Salad

    Hastings Beaver Street Cafe
    Hastings Beaver Street Cafe

    See all

    Sheetz

    Sheetz

    3.2(6 reviews)
    5.5 mi
    $

    Food is always prepared accurately and quickly. The location is always clean and the shelves are…read morestocked.

    This location has moved, and not very far. Like most Sheetz', when they outgrow the location they…read morehave become accustom to, they move on. That is the case for this one. For months there was site preparation, building, installation and moving from the old location. Finally they opened this new location and it is much better on an aesthetic perspective. This location now is one of the pretty ones, you can read that as modern. With the move there is now an additional pump which makes for a better experience and less of a wait when you need gas. The inside of this store is pleasing and better in a sense that you won't feel claustrophobic. Nicer lay out and oddly there are two sections to this store depending on how quickly you need to get in and out of here. The basic store is set up in the conventional way where you can browse the shelves and coolers, order an MTO and use the restrooms. However what sets this new store apart is the fact that they have a condensed version of what you will find on the shelves and coolers right inside the one entrance to make a quick convenient stop more convenient. Personally what I think sets this location apart from a majority of other Sheetz is that they will have a beer cave! The first Sheetz I have come across in Pennsylvania since they loosened the reins on the laws that dictate where you can buy your alcohol in this state. As of me writing this review however, this section was still in the midst of setting that up. They do have the license and it is displayed in the window. If you are wondering what the address of this store now is (and until Yelp updates it), it is: 139 South Main St. Carrolltown, PA 15722 Enjoy everybody, and remember to "Free My Beer!" Things to note: Inside and outdoor seating now available. Newer machines to use debit/charge cards. Easier entrances/exits. Froyo.

    Photos
    Sheetz - Older store, possible new one coming soon.

    See all

    Older store, possible new one coming soon.

    Mr P's Cafe - burgers - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...