Serving up a menu inspired by late night cravings of a hungry post-service kitchen, dishes are shared family style with a beautiful rustic plating. The kitchen decides how to pace your meal based on your choices and serves things in order of light to heavy.
My table of six arrived for our reservation mostly on time. We were seated as some of our party circled the block looking for parking. Note to all, take an Uber or taxi to Mott St, as the parking is very limited and not worth the stress.
As we were seated, an order of cocktails and emergency "everything" wings was placed. Not only were the drinks great but holy shit the wings were AWESOME. Covered with sesame & poppy seeds and coated in a wonderful spicy soy glaze. A surprising, messy & perfect way to start our meal.
Since dinner is served family style, everyone in our group decided to order a thing or two off the menu to share. As mentioned, they serve light to heavy so our meal started out with some fine vegetable numbers. First up a perfectly cooked order of brussel sprouts wok fried with lamb pancetta, and an order of gai lan. I picked that dish because of it's unique addition of oyster sauce and hazelnuts. It was delicious.
Following our veggie items, we transitioned into the heavier appetizers, all of which we really enjoyed. The featured bread of the day was a little loaf with a soft egg baked into the middle which was accompanied by a delicious roasted leek butter.
The "imperial" rolls were a crispy deep fried egg roll type number, that you wrapped in fresh greens and dipped in fish sauce. A complicated affair for what it was, with lots of satisfying textures.
My favorite of this round was for sure the kimchi & cheese filled empanadas served with a chimichurri crème-fraiche. I am a huge fan of empanadas in general, and these lived up to my hopes and dreams. My wife and I fought over the last few bites and honestly I could have finished the meal with a few more. They had a great chewy and flaky texture with a deeply savory filling.
Post appetizer round, the meats started coming, and boy oh boy were the meats good. First up an order of the beef shank noodles, featuring handmade ramen style egg noodles, scallions, ginger, doubanjiang & beef marrow. The beef shank itself was fall apart in your mouth tender, to the point you really didn't need teeth to enjoy it. The broth was so deep in flavor with this wonderful shimmering oily finish. Had I just ordered a bowl of the broth for dinner I would still be leaving a 5 star review.
After the noodles, we had an order of the lamb sweetbreads. These little tender deep fried nuggets of joy with an asian finish were just great. I probably wouldn't have ordered them myself, but I thoroughly enjoyed the few bites I had.
Next up, for me, the best dish of the evening in my opinion... the lamb belly. Like pork belly, it was super fatty, but unlike pork belly it was much smoother and silkier in texture. I loved that the tiny little lamb rib bones were intact. The bbq sauce was smokey and insanely flavorful. It was served with a gremolata, which I did not try as I was too focused on chopping off as much as I could from the plate before it was destroyed by the group.
At this point you'd think we were done, but nope, we still had a 35 ounce rib eye to deal with. That's right 35 ounces. They actually had a 37 ounce option, but our helpful waiter suggested we probably didn't need those extra two ounces with everything else we ordered... and he was right. :)
The rib eye, to me perfectly summed up Mott St's ethos of the late night post service dinners. The meat itself was dry aged and cooked to a perfect medium rare. Unlike how a rib eye would typically be served, it was sliced up in chunks ready to be shared similar to how a turkey might be presented at thanksgiving.
On it's cutting board was a small bowl of beautiful crunchy sea salt, another small bowl of red chili paste, a bowl of deeply umami'd roasted garlic with pan drippings, a bottle of house made worcestershire sauce and a large serving of Mott's giant rice fries.
The fries were basically long portions of silky on the inside overcooked rice that had been deep fried with a beautiful crispy and slightly chewy texture. The worcestershire was classic and deeply flavored. The salt and peppers added high pops of texture and flavor on the perfectly cooked beef. Grass fed for most of it's life, we were told it was "finished" with corn for extra marbling. What a lovely concept!
After all this gluttony, we ordered up a round of cider doughnuts. Deep fried balls sitting on top of an apple sauce type situation. A perfect way to end our perfect meal.
Over the course of 3 & 1/2 hours we tried over half of the menu and loved every single thing. With flavor packed into every bite, we don't regret a single dollar spent. Bravo. read more