I was on a cross-country road trip and stopped in Old Forge for the night. In my mind, small towns…read morealways have a local bar where people are friendly to strangers even though it's a regular's place. This was that bar. I sat by myself while I had a few drafts but never felt alone. The bartender kept me company, the other patrons talked to me as they came and went, I even got a few good stories of the local "characters" and the history of Old Forge and the locals. I felt totally welcomed and absolutely fell in love with the place. There is no food, but they do have free popcorn. Beer is cheap and cold and there's a pool table and lots of TVs showing sports, news, weather, you name it. This place is like something out of the movies, if (and when) I go back to Old Forge, this will be my first stop.

Great food, fun atmosphere. It was a busy weekend my girlfriend and I sat at the bar for lunch but…read moredidn't feel crowded. Aperol Spritz was delicious! Thank you!

If you are here for an off road adventure on a snowmobile or a side by side this is a friendly…read morerestaurant to hit. Parking and a nearby lot for trailers make it an easy in and out. There is also adjacent camp sites. Sit inside or out weather permitting. No complaints here about the food or service. The star of the show is definitely the generous size of the burger.

We came during the Poker Run. You would think you would be prepared for the influx of people coming…read morefor a long awaited event. There was one waitress and a bartender. Neither communicating with one another. We sat here for 30 min until we finally asked if we could get drinks. We didn't get any silverware and when asked if we could order food and drinks she was nothing but rude saying "I'll get to you when I get to you". Poor service on her part. When walking up to the bar because we couldn't get drinks at our table, the bartender ignored us while serving people that had just walked in. We wanted to pay for drinks with our card but she just slapped the bill down and we had to pay cash. When we first walked in it was not that busy to where we should have been ignored. At least gotten our drinks while she tended to other tables.

To be sure, as good as it gets. The fried cheese curds with marinara sauce dip are exceptional, the…read morehouse specialty. You're going to drive in the country to get there but well worth every mile. Atmosphere brilliant, full bar. loaded with snowmobilers and place is fully dressed us for Christmas, with TV's for sports and decent network signal to attend to your phones.

The atmosphere is really the thing that has kept me returning for a few meals here. Rustic and…read moredivey with a ton of fire fighter memorabilia and toys make each visit interesting since there's always a new detail that you missed before. The food is fairly typical pub fare, but the fried cheese curds in particular have become part of our usual entree order. Great salads, burgers, wraps, and the like too if you have time to stay for a meal. On our last visit, a few locals wandered over to ask some friendly questions about our side-by-side and we ended up staying and talking for nearly an hour, and there appears to be no shortage of decent folks every time we visit.

Driving by on a road trip for work, I smelled something great, even with my windows up. I pulled a…read moreU-Turn and ended up having the perfect lunch. Tender Cube Steak sandwich with cheese, sautéed onions and fries. 5 Stars Thank you

Awesome place!! Stopped in on our sleds. Local little dinner that knows all the locals. All…read morefriendly and tells you about the specials. Cook in the back is amazing. We look forward to stopping in next time we ride by.

From Illinois on vacation and was directed to this hidden bar and grill for my all around favorite,…read moreChicken Wings!!!! DON'T PASS UP the short drive through the country side!!! I rate this place in the top 5 of all my places for wings. Thank you Jackie!! A good attentive bar tender/ cook Brenda !!! Will definitely be returning to Rusty P's when I return to Lewis County!!!! Next time I'll order a double order!!!

GREAT!!! After a long drive, we asked our clerk Amy at the hotel check-in where we should go for…read morecasual, good food and a drink. Without hesitation, she said we should go to the Time Warp Tavern. She told us we had to get the black Betty wings - her favorite. It is a corner bar with character and characters. Friendly good people and great food. Cindy took our order and made some great suggestions. Everything was cooked fresh and delivered piping hot. The wings were outstanding. You could tell they had never been frozen and they were cooked perfectly. The black Betty dry rub seasoning was outstanding. Her other wing flavor suggestions were also very good. The fries tasted just like the cut & cooked to order fries you get at a really good state fair. The house made chips with Cajun sprinkled on them was awesome. Highly recommend going!!!!

If you're looking for the best chicken wings, this is the spot. The BLACK BETTY 10/10 wings came…read moreout hot, crispy, and packed with flavor, with a sauce that hit the perfect balance of savory, spicy, and just a little sweet. Every bite tasted fresh, and the portions were generous. The service was friendly and quick, and the whole experience felt like stepping into a time warp in the best way--classic, old-school, and focused on doing one thing really well. I'd absolutely come back for the wings alone.

this place is so cool the interior is very unique as you can…read moresee from other guests photos the menu really has something for everyone had a special family dinner here and it did not disappoint everyone had seafood or beef dishes the pasta i would love to try next time liz really took great care of my family to answer all questions and provide great service i am looking forward to coming back in the future next time i am in town

Deanna is lovely, very helpful in choosing entrees! Try the broiled fish, steak sandwich, french…read moreonion soup, lavender mule. Ample parking.

This was a fantastic local place with some great food. Our table started out with two orders of the…read morecheese curds, one with the sweet thai chili sauce and the other was a blueberry sauce (I'm like 75% certain but I could be wrong on exactly what it was my memory isn't working today). The cheese curds themselves had a nice light batter and were delicious on their own. I'm pretty sure the thai chili sauce is just from a bottle, Thai kitchen brand. Even with that said the sauce is good and works well with the cheese curds. The blueberry sauce is very sweet but still really good. My husband ordered the sandwich that had both a piece of fried chicken and a burger on one bun. The actual name is escaping me (that memory issue again) at the moment but I do remember it was delicious and if you're debating if you want a burger or chicken sandwich, go with this and have both. It is a very good sandwich. Now the mac and cheese oh soooo good! I had the philly cheese stake mac and cheese. There was so much mac and cheese for about $8. This turned into about 3 meals for me. The noodles were cooked great, an awesome amount of wonderful cheese and a generous amount of philly steak, peppers and onions. It seems like you cannot go wrong here. Great food, generous portions at amazing prices. I'm 100% a fan of the Cottage Inn!

So yummy! We had the cheese curds with hot berry sauce as an appetizer, pulled pork baked Mac and…read morecheese, and a buffalo chicken sandwich. Servings were very generous sized, will prob be eating for a few (happy) days LOL

love the food and the service everyone's so nice! recommend when it opens back up! awesome place!read more

I own my home in Lewis county New York and I have paid land and school taxes in this county for the…read morebetter part of 25 years therefore, I try to keep my business as local as possible as often as I am able. However, it has been some time since I have been out drinking at the bars with friends so we had decided to stop at Bakers bar and Grill as I've had fun there in the past. Upon entering the establishment on 12/31-1/1/24 I went into the smoking room to have a cigarette after getting a drink and while waiting for my friend. I was in the smoking area for approximately five minutes talking to a few people that I had recognized with one of them being Bobbi Jo Turk who I don't know too well other than her being a friend of a few of my friends, yet we talked for a few minutes also. After Bobbi Jo and I were done talking Bobbi Jo stood up and left the smoking room at which time my friend had entered the bar and then the smoking room with me. Moments later Bobbi Jo returned and apparently her and my friend have had issues in the past and began yelling back and forth, I diffused the situation and Bobbi Jo left the smoking area l. My friend and I continued to stay in the smoking room talking with others when out of nowhere this lady, that I now know as Lori Buckingham, slammed the door open, screamed out my name and my friends name yelling that we needed to leave her bar. We were caught totally off guard and I asked why and she told me because she said so. I continued to ask why or what had happened as we were gathering our belongings when eventually this bar tender screamed out that she knew my friend and I sold drugs and when I told her that that was untrue and ludicrous when she got in my face and yelled she knew we were dealing drugs because we knew her son, Josh Youngs. Again I told her that that was also not true that I have never met anyone named Josh Youngs that she must have me mistaken with someone else however, to avoid any more of her threatening onslaught I told my friend that we would just go. As we were walking past Bobbi Jo who was sitting at the bar on our way out she looked at myself and my friend and said "...I told you I would get you out of here." Not only was this experience extremely embarrassing, I also found it erroneously defamatory and unwarranted as clearly the bar tender was kicking people out of a public establishment based on the advice of her drunk friend Bobbi Jo Turck. I was also very concerned with the highly inappropriate, unprofessional and aggressively confrontational behavior of the employee, Lori Buckingham, as when she was screaming in our faces her breath wreaked of alcohol and I never once saw either bar tender ask for identification from the many young patrons present. I will never personally go to this business again however, I think the owner or at the very least the authorities should look into the activities in this bar as the current staff in this establishment are giving Lewis county businesses a bad name.

I'm a 67 year old white male with an affinity for good home cooking. I started going to the whistle…read morestop after my mom told me I ate way too many pancakes. I ate 67 in one sitting at the whistle stop! My favorite thing to eat at the whistle stop is the 67 Oz. Fried fish platter and the 6.7 oz serving of pudding. You have to try the owners special 67 sauce which they slather on everything. It is to die for! I could drink the 67 sauce by the gallon. The ambiance is simply amazing. Most of the waitresses are a perfect 6.7 out of 10. Some of them are so beautiful I would walk 6.7 uphill both ways in the freezing cold just to get a serving of 67 sauce. Don't take my word for it. Go here immediately and make sure you have enough money. I can guarantee you will tip higher than 6.7%!!

Kind of a hole-in-the wall place with decent food and good service…read more Not much to look at from the outside and the inside isn't that spectacular either, but it is clean. Tried their burnt ends and they were tasty. A little heavy on the dry rub. The hubs got a king burger and he enjoyed it. I had the burger with peanut butter, and it was pretty tasty. Fries were the crinkle cut kind and were nice and tasty.