I only tried the cheese stix, so take that into account when you're reading…read more A little disappointing. I expected a local place that's been around for 31 years would be a bit better. But the cheese stix were not very flavorful. I was expecting more of a garlicky taste. The marinara tasted sweet and I prefer a tart flavor. And the price was supposed to be $15.15+$1.25 for bacon, but for some reason they charged $18.20. Then another 3% on top. So I don't know what was happening with the prices. Paying almost $20 is too much for what I got.

Great local pizza! Cool clean pizza shop. Pick up or eat in. Friendly service. Crust is…read moredelicious & sauce is spot on!

I have heard great things about Salvatore's for years, but had never tried it before. We stopped in…read moreon Friday evening with a large group, and we had an incredible time! Our friends from Chicago were staying at an Airbnb in Sun Prairie, so we made the trek from the west side of Madison to meet up with them. They had called ahead of time, and even though they don't take reservations for groups that large, the staff said that they would make a note of it and have a spot ready to go for us. Between our 3 families, we had many young kids in tow, so I was apprehensive about a long wait. The minute we walked in, however, we told them our name, and they immediately led us to a large table in the back room where we were quickly set up! The vibe of the place is really fun, with exposed brick walls and fun art. One of the coolest things was for the kids - instead of crayons, the menu comes with Wikki Sticks. These kept the kids occupied the entire time! Absolutely genius. Despite our large table, our waitress had no trouble efficiently taking orders and getting us our drinks. I was shocked by how quickly our food came out - everyone was digging into their meals 25-30 minutes after we had arrived at the restaurant! The service was absolutely top notch, and the pizza was phenomenal. I ordered the tomato pie, and it was everything I was hoping for - gobs of delicious homemade red sauce, plenty of cheese, and fresh basil. I ordered a 10", and I'm not ashamed to say I only had one piece left to take home with me!

We've been here several times, and always enjoyed the food. We were disappointed tonight as they…read morehad changed the menu, which is cool, but the online menu from thier own website still showed the other menu, and our guest, the birthday boy, was looking forward to something specific so we chose to leave and go elsewhere. We'll be back though I'm sure.

Tasty sauce, excellent cheese, fresh toppings, tomatoes weren't ripened, crust was undercooked &…read morenot crispy. Pizza wasn't hot, picked up right on time and only live 5 minutes away. Pizza shop cool, clean & fun vibe. Picked up right as scheduled & the front desk was friendly & polite.

I find it amazing, that with the quality of food I have had here, that it isn't busy all of the…read moretime. The wings are awesome, the pizzas are great, and the salads are spectacular. Even the desserts are wonderful. The cannolis are my favorite. There are 3 or 4 TVs to watch and it has booths and tables. Every time I go, I want to wave people down as they drive into the restaurant next door and say, "Turn this way and try Rosati's. You'll like it!"

We went at 5 pm on a Friday and were able to get right in. This place is very large, but gets very…read morebusy. Parking extended into the adjacent businesses, but overall plenty of space Food 4/5: we got cheese curds and spinach dip for apps. The cheese curds were disappointing for being in Wisconsin. They were clearly the frozen kind and not freshly battered like many other places serve in the area. They were ok. The spinach dip is the star of the show. I love that they put tomatoes in it to give it extra veggies and the overall flavor is salty yet balanced. We got the Mau wowi, maple bacon, and Mac and cheese pizzas. Overall the Maui wowi and maple bacon had a salty sweet match up that brought the best umami. The Mac and cheese is just ok. Service 4/5: our waiter lacked personality but was overall great. Very attentive, continued to ask about drinks, and was prompt with the check when we asked. Ambiance 5/5: this place is huge. Overall adequate room between tables. Great space and wasn't too loud like some places can get. If you like a lot of options with your pizza between toppings and crust, this is a great place to try. They also have a large beer/wine/drink menu.

We were coming from Waunakee on way home thought stop this place. We u seats right away…read moreWe waited more 25 min for someone to come. Our drinks. Or food. Nothing No body was at bar either We decided wall out No one. Was around

Love the new location, indoor & outdoor seating. Nice are for big groups, we reserved a room for a…read moreluncheon and were not charged a room fee. Great staff, friendly & attentive. Pizza is always good, lots of great specialty pizzas to choose from. We had the BOARIS KARLOFF, Yummy!

Great pizza delivered so speedy and fresh. The build your own salad was equally amazing. So…read moreimpressed with the prompt service and quality of food. Will definitely order from here again when we're in town

Ok, pretty limited meat market, a bit of the path but simply awesome pizza. Stopped for lunch on a…read moredrive from Minneapolis to Chicago and this hit the spot.

Food meets butcher shop meets artisanal cooking goods…read more We ordered the New Haven clam pizza. Seemed to be a lot of pick up orders while we dined in. Small corner, maybe fits about 6 adults at counter seating (no tables). They had some games - connect four, hook on the ring and cribbage. Cute little kids area too. Pizza: well this was big for us as a party of two so we have the other half left over. The crust was so crunchy. Toppings were delicious! Real clams, creamy. I thought this pizza got better with each bite. Super cheesy, pulls apart. Would definitely come back to order their other ones!

Went on a busy Friday with the family. Service started strong but fizzled due to the amount of…read morecustomers which is not the server's fault. The fish fry was delicious! The cheese curds were also great. Spinach Dip recipe needs a tweak. All in all, pleasurable experience and I'll be back.

It started out great and I was really looking forward to Madisons #1 fish fry…read more The salad was fresh and my husband beef, onions and peppers was delicious. The menu said Lake Perch it was diffenitly OCEAN Perch. It had a sad PC of bread with no butter. The apples were okay and the corn looked kind of old. Our waitress was Okay, when she asked if we needed anything I asked for more tater sauce , it was lucky it never came because I barely ate 1/2 of the fish.

This is my favorite pizza place in Madison! I usually order takeout and always enjoy it. Appreciate…read morethat the box has guidance on time + temp to reheat once you get home

Typically have a great experience here, but tonight changed that for me. I ordered the beet salad…read moreand noticed a piece of flowering grass within the spring green mix. It was no big deal, until a couple bites later my friend noticed something odd in the greens... A LIVE CATERPILLAR was in the salad. We brought it to an employee immediately, who showed it to the manager. It was brought to the kitchen, and nobody returned to our table after that. I had to approach an employee a second time and ask to speak to a manager myself. When sharing that there was a live insect in my salad, he brushed it off and merely stated "this happens every now and then, because our produce is organic." Then, he ASKED if we would like the charge to be voided. That should have been obvious right from the start, I would have preferred my entire meal to be refunded after this event. There was no concern and no apology from the manager. This was incredibly disappointing and thoughtless service, I will not be returning.

Tables not wiped down, messy floor, bad service and sold out of almost everything. Miss when Sarah…read moreowned it. So sad.

If I could give lower than 1 star I would. Ordered for a pizza delivery at 4:20 (visiting from out…read moreof town). By 6:00 there was still no pizza and no follow up so I began calling. After about 10 calls going to an answer machine with no option to leave a message, I saw that the charge on my card was removed. No courtesy call or follow up at all. Very disappointing

Very cute family owned business! Ordered three pizza for takeout! Margarita, mushroom, and…read morepepperoni! All very flavorful and healthy! Definitely will be visiting them frequently! Very quick and friendly service!

Yummy oven fired pizza! It's a cozy spot kinda east side. A simple menu but everything is…read moredelicious. They have primarily outdoor seating, but also a couple tables inside. Plenty of parking (there's a little shared lot and street parking too). Pizza was made fresh and quickly and brought out to me -- sweet staff. They didn't have any tiramisu when I was done with my pizza so I guess I'll have to go back to try that!