I only tried the cheese stix, so take that into account when you're reading…read more A little disappointing. I expected a local place that's been around for 31 years would be a bit better. But the cheese stix were not very flavorful. I was expecting more of a garlicky taste. The marinara tasted sweet and I prefer a tart flavor. And the price was supposed to be $15.15+$1.25 for bacon, but for some reason they charged $18.20. Then another 3% on top. So I don't know what was happening with the prices. Paying almost $20 is too much for what I got.

Great local pizza! Cool clean pizza shop. Pick up or eat in. Friendly service. Crust is…read moredelicious & sauce is spot on!

The pizza always fresh with wonderful flavors & delicious. Crust is crispy, crunchy with a nice…read morechewy texture & great taste. Friendly service & fun atmosphere decorated seasonally.

Staff were very nice. I wasn't overly impressed by my pizza but that may be partially on me. I…read morelike alot of sauce so i should have ordered extra sauce. Having said that i thought the sauce could use a little sugar. The bartender was awesome! She knew all about the special soda they had (can't remember what mind but it was great). I rate it 5 stars for customer service but only 3 for pizza but i am very fussy about my pizza.

I find it amazing, that with the quality of food I have had here, that it isn't busy all of the…read moretime. The wings are awesome, the pizzas are great, and the salads are spectacular. Even the desserts are wonderful. The cannolis are my favorite. There are 3 or 4 TVs to watch and it has booths and tables. Every time I go, I want to wave people down as they drive into the restaurant next door and say, "Turn this way and try Rosati's. You'll like it!"

I wanted to love the Chicago style deep dish but I couldn't get past the thick bread crust. It put…read morethe other ingredients out of place and was dry and hard to eat. You might love it so please try before you take my word for it. It was a heavy, well baked pizza with a good tasting sauce. It was hot when we picked it up and the place was clean (bathroom aside). They have a decent menu and I can see where they are coming from on their pricing. Don't let my review stop you from trying it out because everyone's pizza tastebuds re different and the ingredients seemed fresh and good quality.

We ordered takeout - so I can't comment on ambiance or servers - while in town visiting locals, at…read moretheir recommendation. A good one! I appreciate the variety of crust options (including gluten free, which we did need for one member of our crew), and the high quality toppings. The meat and cheese suppliers were called out on the menu, which told me to expect good things. Everything was reasonably priced for the elevated quality involved. The order was ready when expected, and pickup was easy & trouble-free. The ride back to the Air BNB was excruciating while hotboxing pizza air - it smelled SO GOOD. The flavor delivered, as did the texture of each crust style we tried. The salads we ordered were also fresh and delicious, and the dressings totally topped out at max tastiness - my favorite was the Greek. Overall, I would be so ready to go again at any time! Fatpants are ready, let's do this.

First of all, we got here at 6 pm on a Saturday and were told for a table of 2 it would be a half…read morean hour wait which we had no problem with. About 16 minutes later our table was ready which was great. Our waiter was in the top 5 for worst waiter I have ever had. He would literally point at things and never speak. At one point he pointed at my empty plate but he was asking if I needed water. When he brought our food out he handed me my plate instead of setting it down in front of me. He had the personality of a saltine cracker - I never saw him smile once. Not personable at all. Definitely needs some training in customer service.

My name is Pam last Monday. My husband went to take takeout at glass nickel he ordered a regular…read morepizza for himself and a gluten-free pizza for me. I have celiac and gluten-free means I cannot have any kind of flour or anything like that. They must've got some kind of flower regular flower on my pizza. I got Violet sick and it lasted for a long time I used to like glass nickel. I used to love their meat lovers pizza even the gluten-free one taste like a regular pizza but now I'm too scared to eat glass nickel pizza so anybody that has celiac be careful because they do not watch what they're doing clean their utensils or the oven or whatever when they're making celiac pizza for somebody that loves pizza and loves glass nickel, but I will not order for them anymore

Great pizza delivered so speedy and fresh. The build your own salad was equally amazing. So…read moreimpressed with the prompt service and quality of food. Will definitely order from here again when we're in town

Food meets butcher shop meets artisanal cooking goods…read more We ordered the New Haven clam pizza. Seemed to be a lot of pick up orders while we dined in. Small corner, maybe fits about 6 adults at counter seating (no tables). They had some games - connect four, hook on the ring and cribbage. Cute little kids area too. Pizza: well this was big for us as a party of two so we have the other half left over. The crust was so crunchy. Toppings were delicious! Real clams, creamy. I thought this pizza got better with each bite. Super cheesy, pulls apart. Would definitely come back to order their other ones!

I was there on a Saturday for lunch. Inside there were some seatings. There were some good outdoor…read moreseatings as well. Patrons except me were enjoying food in the outdoor seating. I went for a New Haven clam pizza. It was really cheesy and flavorful. I liked it more than the clam pizza in New Haven. The pizza was big and will probably be good for 3 folks. They also had fresh meat. Display mean looked fresh. I went for roasted garlic herb butter. When added to rice, it made rice very flavorful.

It started out great and I was really looking forward to Madisons #1 fish fry…read more The salad was fresh and my husband beef, onions and peppers was delicious. The menu said Lake Perch it was diffenitly OCEAN Perch. It had a sad PC of bread with no butter. The apples were okay and the corn looked kind of old. Our waitress was Okay, when she asked if we needed anything I asked for more tater sauce , it was lucky it never came because I barely ate 1/2 of the fish.

I go every year after the World Dairy Expo for their pizza. I branched out and got the citrus bbq…read morepork pizza. It was delish!

New favorite. Too…read moretired with the baby on the way to write a long review but veryyyyy good. We've been getting takeout here a lot lately and have had at least like, 8 different pizzas, all YUMMY. Very happy mommy and baby. (And daddy, too ) Crust is chewy, not too thick, sauce is just the right amount of chunky, ingredients are fresh overall. I'm not sure if I'll ever order from another pizza place in Madison ever again. Sorry but like, Ian? I don't think I know that guy?

We got delivery to a downtown hotel around 7pm on a Saturday. We got a beet salad and 3 pizzas. A…read morepepperoni, a bufala, and this margherita. The pepperoni looked fine, and the salad was good. The other 2 pizzas, however each had something wrong. The bufala was missing some toppings and had pepperoni instead but was at least cooked well. My margherita was more or less inedible. It was so burnt the crust was like charcoal on the raise and burnt leather on the inside. The cheese has turned into plastic and the sauce was basically reduced into a tomato paste. Topping it all off was burnt basil that was the most edible part of the pizza. Based on this experience I would recommend thin crust Papa John's or Domino's over Pizza Brutta. Way cheaper and at least some good garlic butter.

If I could give lower than 1 star I would. Ordered for a pizza delivery at 4:20 (visiting from out…read moreof town). By 6:00 there was still no pizza and no follow up so I began calling. After about 10 calls going to an answer machine with no option to leave a message, I saw that the charge on my card was removed. No courtesy call or follow up at all. Very disappointing

Went in for lunch. They run a great deal for pizza by the slice. $2 a slice and $1 a can of soda…read more Great spot for a lunch break while working on the job. They have a small dining room with clean table booths. The lady at the register was very kind and smiled like she cared which is a rare thing in fast food nowadays. Pizza was great. Very satisfied with my visit, looking forward to coming back!

Yummy oven fired pizza! It's a cozy spot kinda east side. A simple menu but everything is…read moredelicious. They have primarily outdoor seating, but also a couple tables inside. Plenty of parking (there's a little shared lot and street parking too). Pizza was made fresh and quickly and brought out to me -- sweet staff. They didn't have any tiramisu when I was done with my pizza so I guess I'll have to go back to try that!

I stopped by on a weekday for dinner. The place had only limited seats. I went almost at the…read moreclosing time. Fortunately there was one seat left. The seats are a bit crammed, there is a good chance you are going to come in physical contact with others. I went with one of their specials - Brassicalina pizza. It was the only vegetarian pizza in the menu. The pizza was flavorful, with some healthy vegetables on top. Never thought eating pizza could be reasonably healthy.