After months of closures in NYC and quarantining, some friends and I were in East Hampton and decided to come to Moby's for an early dinner. The restaurant is outdoor seating only and per requirements, tables outside are spaced apart and all employees wear masks and gloves. The service was very good, and the food and drinks were brought to the table quickly. For 5 of us, with 6 drinks and 5 dishes, it was $71 per person including tax and tip, which was not that bad, and I would've happily paid more after so long of not having eaten in a restaurant. The Kale Caesar salad, Riggatoni cacio Pepe and the margarita pizza were all outstanding. The menu was pretty diverse and reasonably priced - I think the most expensive thing was in the high $30s. I'm glad restaurants are slowly opening back up in a safe way! read more

Made a res via Resy for two & arrived a few minutes late, which was no problem. Our table wasn't ready yet so the hostess walked us to the outdoor bar stand and we got to admire their adorable outdoor set up. The vibes were awesome and the tables were a nice distance from each other. Food was fantastic, we ordered the ricotta, burrata, pizza, lasagna and cacio e pepe, and everything was delicious!! Would def recommend and hope to be back. read more

This place was a pleasant surprise! I was a bit unsure when I first checked the Yelp rating before visiting but their food is better than what you see here. Their mushroom pizza was absolutely delicious probably best dish from the table I had with my friends that day. I also thought the Rigatoni was pretty good. My husband wasn't too impressed with his chicken dish that he got but the pizza and pastas were all very satisfying from the friends we were with. We were seated outdoor and it was a nice space. Loved their decor in general. The only comment I would leave for better experience would be the bug control for outdoor seating. It was a bit tough to enjoy the entire experience when there were so many bugs constantly attacking us and our food. read more

Moby's - Rigatonj - Italian Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Moby's is the perfect restaurant pre & post covid. The have expansive outdoor space dotted with 30+ white picnic tables, all spread out at least 6ft apart. String lights lit up the evening sky and give the space a warm, charming feel. All staff members starting from the parking lot, hostess to our server / bussers were so kind, polite and all were wearing masks. For our group of 5, we ordered- Vegetables: Sunburst peppers Mushrooms Broccolini Mains: Fusilli cacio e pepe Mezze rigatoni bolognese - LOVEEEE! The pasta was a teeny bit overcooked but the sauce was on point Spaghettini Shrimp Linguine Alle Vongole Atlantic Halibut - the fish was okay but the greens were phenomenal Pizza: Salsiccia with pork sausage, tomato, mozzarella Portion sizes were just right, pizza came out piping hot and flavorful, the bolognese was my favorite! The ambiance was perfect for a summer night and the service was on point. I was extremely happy to enjoy a great meal at an establishment compliant with covid regulations. read more

This place sucks. Food is average, service is non existent. Accommodates large groups.

This place went from Cool to Kids in less than a season. And not just well behaved kids that know they are out at a restaurant, listen to their parents and behave. Kids that literally run around the entire place climbing trees and the sculptures and play tag and scream. It's fascinating how hard a parent can ignore their kid in a place like this. It has to be an Olympic sport at this level. The food is great. Pizza is amazing. And the staff is awesome. It's well worth going if you have a 7-year old and need an hour or two to just let them run and bug the sh*t out of someone else for once. If kids aren't your thing and you want to eat your $38 entree in peace - this ain't your place. read more

So much fun- casual food at fine dining prices but it's about the experience and the food was delicious- service was great as well- fun spot

Came for dinner with a few friends and ended up staying for hours. The staff was friendly and nice all the way from the parking lot to the table. We got the liter of Spicy Margarita and it was absolutely delicious. Every plate was beautiful and full of flavor, Chef Darragh really outdid himself. Will definitely be back again next time I'm in the area. Attached pics of the dishes we got: didn't snap any pics of the Tuscan Kale Caesar salad but it did not disappoint either. read more

See all

Absolutely horrendous. This place has gone downhill exponentially. The octopus was rubbery and awful. The replacement pasta was missing key ingredients. The mushrooms had zero Hen of the Woods. The broccolini was burnt . All of this for nearly $1000. We are done. You should be too! read more

vibe was overall cool. good place if you have kids but so many running around everywhere so if that isn't your thing then you won't be super pleased. food was sub par to say the least and massively overpriced for what it was. dry , bland pizza. additionally, we made the reservation and were there on time. ordered apps and drinks and after a half hour we were told that we only had an hour left. mind you, the waiter hadn't even taken our dinner order yet lol. they should have at least warned us when they initially sat us so we knew to order everything all at once if we were on such a time crunch... overall, skip out on this place and go somewhere else. read more

I'll start by saying we loved going to Moby's multiple times last summer. Great food, great vibe, so much fun for the kids, and outstanding service. Our first visit of summer '24, tonight, started out to be disappointing, but the glitch with our res was quickly resolved with compliments to the Manager, Em. She couldn't have been more accommodating and professional. Every server was outstanding, setting us up quickly and changing our table just as seamlessly. They were all warm, friendly and professional. As for the meal, the kale salad, shishito peppers and pizza were delicious, and the pasta dishes were all great, too. It turned out to be a lovely evening. Our entire group sends a huge thank you to the Manager, Em, for working with us, and accommodating us tonight. She truly took the time to make it right and we appreciate it. She was professional and warm and we all say thank you. read more

Great food and amazing atmosphere. The pizza and pasta is terrific! The service is a little slow but worth the wait.

Food is delicious!! Ordered caccio e Pepe and margherita pizza and it was quality food made with fresh ingredients. One of the best caccio e pepe's I've had and better than a lot in NYC. We also got red wine on tap, and I was amazed at how smooth it was!! The service was also good. One of the most striking aspects of this place is the ambiance. There are many seats and large tables, perfect for date night, grabbing a bite with friends or coming here as a family. I saw many young families and young children, and it is nice to see a restaurant that accommodates children. This place has the vibes of fun summer days. Definitely coming here again! read more

Moby's - Margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I loved the location on the water in the bay from last year, but this location is just as beautiful. They did a great job with the outdoor decor and furniture. Huge lawn space and delicious food. Zero complaints. Definitely make reservations well in advance for dinner here. They are CLOSED on Tuesdays. read more

Came here for a rezzie on a wednesday night. Overall the service and food was wonderful. a few points for them to work on: -why is extra bread with the burrata 3 dollars? likely should be free, or just at least include bread with your app. -the pizzas slide of the metal stand all the time; so much so that the waiter said, "watch out- the pizzas fall off." this happened to me, which was fine given that I was nearly done but moral of the story: if your customer keep on losing their food, you should probably fix your pizza stand. cute little boutique outside lovely garden in good weather or they do tents in the rain if you get rained out. used to be the old EMP house but a great spot. will come back summer 2021! ~T read more

I would definitely go here again - excellent service (we sat at the bar) and a good vibe. Food mixed - funghi pizza was delicious l. The orecchiette was good but a bit on the salty side. Parking lot is stressful during summer evening times so Uber here if parking is not your thing. Or go later. read more

Moby's is a must eat in the Hamptons! Great ambiance, delicious food and fun drinks! Their menu is seasonal and always made to perfection. Definitely recommend getting their soppresata pizza! read more

Ridiculously overpriced. Drinks are over the top expensive. Kids loud and running around unattended on tick infested grass. Pizza is yummy but couldn't afford much else. I'm a working class local and I just can't afford to hang out or eat in places like this. read more

The food was very good however when it came to dessert I was very disappointed. There was not much of a selection. Panacotta, sorbet, chocolate or vanilla ice cream. Also, they do not serve coffee???? read more

Great Ambiance but don't know if the spaghetti I got was worth $33. Still tasty though and service was really good.

Great-looking space with a positive vibe. Big shout-out to Ethan who took VERY good care of me and my family! The pizzas are the BEST in The Hamptons and the mushrooms and kale salad got rave reviews from everyone! read more

The food was absolutely delicious! Great and spacious seating... Wonderful backyard. Staff very friendly.

If I could give this place zero stars, I would. We came here with my family for a birthday dinner and sat for over an hour without receiving our appetizers. They screwed up the drink order and they weren't even apologetic for not bringing out the appetizers --then they brought the wrong entrée out twice. We came with children who were well behaved sitting patiently- and even that did nothing to make the staff pay us any mind. Do not waste your time coming here. The plates are over priced, salty, and definitely not worth it. The service is the worst part by far. I have never been tempted to leave a place without paying- but this place brought me very close. read more

Moby's is one of the most consistent places to go for a delicious meal. Their outdoor seating makes it the perfect place to go where you can feel comfortable and safe. Everyone is following all Covid related protocol to ensure a great dining experience. read more

Moby's is the perfect spot to go with a group for cocktails, food (pizza is great!) and an overall great time. Can't go wrong!

Every time I'm in East Hamptons I NEED to order their amazing pizza or enjoy their outdoors dinning tables!

Mixed experiences each time I have come here. The pizza is not worth it I've tried them all it's lacking flavor, the dough and sauce are both boring. The mushrooms are the best side vegetables to order. The peppers and chickpea sides are overpriced and not good. The chickpea is just a bowl of chickpeas in a sauce and not made for sharing, it was strange. The cod is good, the bolognese also good. Tuna is a good appetizer but small portion, really serves one. The thing that I was floored by is the "lasagna". It is actually the worst thing I've ever had at a restaurant and even worse that it was at a place like this. It is legit noodles in what tastes like canned red sauce. Then a crispy thing piece of cheese on top. The waitress forgot to add the meat to the order as well, but this is literally terrible and a disgrace that this is on the menu. The drinks are good. The only reason it is worth it to come here is because it's cool outside. The service last time was also terrible they forgot multiple things and food was bad. Hit or miss, and not up to my standards. read more

Moby's - Lasagna worst thing I've had - Italian Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Food is average, sparse and underwhelming. Lively with kids running outside in a lovely setting that surpasses the food. read more

Got the margarita pizza, fusilli pasta with black pepper and clam linguini. The food was glorious. So tasty I was licking the pasta bowl. Dishes are about $20-$24 each. On the smaller side for portions. The drinks are $18 and about 6-8oz. They were tasty but not enough for the price. I'd def go back! read more

Pizza was good- nothing to write home about. They use sugar in their sauce (that's cheating!) Overpriced menu, even for east hampton. read more

The food is fine, the service good. But it's way overpriced. I understand it's the Hamptons and everything is overpriced. But seriously, can my drinks at least not come in small plastic cups and with full servings if I am going to pay $18 for "glass" of wine? read more

Service is amazing. Staff is following all COVID protocols and we felt totally safe there. Food is so good Pizzas are beyond delicious. Lincoln, the owner, is attentive and personable. I'd go here again and again! Outdoor area is super and feels safe. read more

No wait at 12PM on a Friday - had a delicious margarita pizza and kale salad with chicken. Sat outside and had great service!

Horrible service, horrible food, horrible waitresses!!!! To start, we waited THREE HOURS SITTING IN THE COLD being judged by elitist Hamptonites (if you would even call these scums that). They were also all very fucking rude to my family and I. They asked me, a 46 year old man, for identification. I came here to drink, why the fuck would I need a DRIVERS ID THAT I LEAVE IN MY CAR. They would not serve me, so I had to take secret sips from my wife's wine, of course they hadn't asked her for an ID! After complaining to a supervisor, my blonde ponytail waitress served me "warmed apple cider" in a plastic cup. She gave me her own, still warmed, piss. If that doesn't qualify for 1 star I seriously do not know what does. Dessert sucks also. The "cheesecake" is a straight up block of fucking cream cheese on top of a "crust" of pistachio. End of story, do not go to Moby's if you're looking for a fun Saturday night out. FUCK MOBYS EAST HAMPTON! read more

Moby's - Brought home for examination - Italian Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Don't go here idk what happened but they can't cook here anymore. The steak was dressed with marinara sauce. So disappointed. Eat literally anywhere else. read more

I went here to celebrate an event with 8 people. They sat us at a bench and sat 6 people at a huge round table. They served us frozen fluke, 3 slices of steak and the worst cacio Pepe of my entire life. Cold and vile. The thing is they told us, "no one else complained." For the amount of money it was disgusting. Don't get anything besides the pizza because this place serves food from 1 year chefs. read more

We came here for dinner with our baby and toddler. Service was excellent. The food was delicious. Really nice ambiance. My daughter was able to run around and make friends. Highly recommend for families! read more

It was our first time here and the restaurant was so inviting. As soon as we sat down we felt good vibes. Our server, Yanet, knew the menu so well and helped us with choosing what we wanted. She was so outgoing and friendly it made our experience so great. She even helped us with our itinerary for the following day in the hamptons which we really appreciated! We will definitely be back! read more

I came here with a big group (10 of us) for dinner and we had a terrible experience. Because we were a bigger party, they had prix fixe menus for us that we weren't expecting and didn't accommodate our entire dietary restrictions and delayed everything else - they wouldn't let us order off of the regular menu. Drinks were tasty but in tiny glasses, I had the Paloma, food was acceptable, outdoor seating area was really cute and the staff is polite but there seemed to be issue after issue with our orders and being able to accommodate a large party and it was a little disappointing. I don't think it was worth the $$ per person if you're expecting a regular dine-in situation. Also, they charged extra for bread, they dropped a tray of drinks which delayed things even more (which I get, we're humans, but after other issues it was a lot) and only got us two rounds within the 2 hours we spent here. read more

After months of dining at home because of covid, was very excited to finally dine out with my family and thought they had a great setup for safe, outdoor dining. When ordering, I informed the waitress I am gluten free and ordered the kale salad without the bread crumbs. When it arrived with what appears to be light beige flakes. I ask the runner, is this gluten free? He says yes. I point to the bread crumb flakes and he says that is Parmesan cheese. I'm skeptical so I ask again if it's gluten free and he very confidently said yes and so them I foolishly trust that he knows. While eating my portion of the salad, I'm feeling doubtful. Because there's a lot of dressing on the salad I can't really taste them. But my stomach is telling me otherwise. I stop eating, and ask the waitress when she passes by, and she says oh yes those are breadcrumbs! Nice job Moby's, serving bread to someone who clearly states they have a gluten allergy and telling them it's not bread. Been sick for hours post eating, and will be for the next few days now. Being glutened when your celiac is like having a full body flu for days. As if this wasn't enough, when everyone at my table received their dinner, either chicken or fish, my husband and son who ordered pizzas, did not. They sat and watched everyone eat their fish or chicken so it didn't get cold, while inquiring multiple times on their order. Theirs finally arrived after we all finished eating, apparently it wasn't made because the kitchen was confused by the gluten free note on the order and since the pizza wasn't gluten free, they didn't make it! Nice. Poor poor service all around. Despite the manager coming over to apologize and comping the bill, I will never eat here again and don't recommend it to anyone with food allergies. read more