Cancel

Open app

Search

MMEA Photos

Business Info

Recommended Reviews - MMEA

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

People searched for Italian 132 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Magnone's Italian Kitchen

Magnone's Italian Kitchen

2.4(91 reviews)
19.8 km
•$$$

Just like everybody else who comes to this location during the summer, it's for bachelorette. When…read morewe were seated at the table, our waiter (the only reason that there is a two star) came by with a glass of champagne for our bride. We ordered a couple of appetizers and a whole bunch of pasta. Me personally, I ordered the carbonara and was very excited for it. However, once it came, it reflected more of Alfredo than a carbonara. Some would say to lower your expectations however, if I order something, I would expect it to come out that way. So the food for me did not hit at all. However, the staff and the overall vibes of the restaurant is the only reason we gave this a two star rating.

It's always tough to dine-in at the Blue Mountain Village: there are few options, most are full,…read moreand all are expensive. Magnone's is one of the better dining experiences available, in a nice fancy restaurant environment, but food and service can be hit or miss. The pastas are decent, average/average+ with good flavours and use of fresh ingredients and cheeses, but expensive for what you get. Carbonara was rich with a creamy sauce. The kids menu offers some basic classics (Alfredo, buttered parm pasta, or cheese pizza) at a decent price. Service can be spotty. One of our meals (of our party of 8) wasn't served with the others, with waitstaff saying "it would be another few minutes". Fifteen minutes later, it was clear that the order had been initially forgotten, when a barely-cooked, rush-order ravioli was delivered. It's still a popular place as it's hard to get a table here. Either reserve several days in advance, or walk-in very early or late.

Photos
Magnone's Italian Kitchen
Magnone's Italian Kitchen - Great gluten free pasta, my family loved it two much

Great gluten free pasta, my family loved it two much

Magnone's Italian Kitchen - Pizza is great and cheesy

See all

Pizza is great and cheesy

MMEA - italian - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...