I just had the best roast beef I can remember! Yes, Kevin, the best. The fries were lightly battered and I got the family Texas sauce and cheese on them. Good thing my cardiologist likes me so much. Good draft selection as the rusty chain went down smooth. Tammy loved the sweet potato fries with the butter and honey separated for your own indulgence. All in all, highly recommended for simple and excellent pub food. read more

Being a go-to of several of my friends who are from the area, I've ended up here by default a few times. Each time has been worse than before, as the main late night crowd is always a bunch of locals who forget they aren't in a high school anymore (drama). But it was never as aggravating as last night, when my frustration with the bartender has guaranteed I will not return. I first ordered a Captain and coke on my boyfriend's tab. Noticing how weak it was, but still craving my favorite drink, I ordered the next round and watched it being made. The bartender put the glass of ice on the bar and put MAYBE (closer to less than) a half shot in it. Then she proceeded to take and prepare (with the right amount of alcohol) the orders of two people who had just walked in (presumably her friends) who had more complicated beverages than mine. When she finally put in the coke, she skimped out on that too (possibly trying to hide how weak it was). She brought it to me as I turned to shoot in darts. After my turn, my boyfriend's beer was still not ready. When she did bring it over, she just stared at me, waiting for a credit card even though I had cash in my hand. I had to ask her how much it was, and she had to input it in the register to find out. Perhaps because I was already frustrated this bothered me so much, but she is a veteran bartender and it wasn't an excessive order so I anticipated her to know without punching it in. My total was $7.50 (which would be great for two drinks, if it was made with the standard portions). I gave her $8, and never got my change back. Considering that's over an hour of pay being a server, I was very unhappy. I'm not a confrontational person, so I did not say anything. I also understand people have bad days/aren't always on point at work. But she tended to her regulars well, and I was very annoyed with her lack of hospitality at a bar I didn't really want to be at anyway. read more

I stopped in Mitchell's last month for lunch as I was in the area and I was impressed! This is your typical dive/sports bar with lots of sports memorabilia covering every wall. I ordered the Greek salad and my colleague ordered the Southwestern BBQ burger. We were both impressed by our meals especially because of how affordable and fair the prices are here. The service here was friendly and attentive throughout our meal. Definitely planning on returning for another affordable and tasty meal! read more

I'd like to give it less than 1. smelled dirty and smokey when we went in. It was late tho so we thought we'd try to get some food and a drink. Turns out you can only get served if your buddies with the bar maid. After we placed our drink order, she went down and asked all her buddies who wanted shots. She never got our drinks our even looked our way again. We waited a bit then left. Went to Mooneys over on Military, got great service and delicious food. I won't bother wasting my time at Mitchells again. read more

My kind of dive. Good food cheap. I had the fish fry being Friday and everything, the fry was good...not the best but good. I would definitely go back, but probably try the famous roast beef sandwich instead. The patio was a nice and relaxing way to spend the evening. Heard about an exciting men's room experience, too bad that they don't have a women's room equivalent....hmmm....wonder what that would even be... :) I would go back and spend another lazy evening read more

Love this place. Good food, friendly atmosphere ,excellent service. If you like any kind of sports this is a place to visit...

It's a perfect little dive bar, right in the heart of Tonawanda. It's got a pool table, dart board, cold beverages, good food, and great affordable prices. What more can you ask for?! read more

Pretty average bar... I liked a lot of the sports memorabilia on the walls... Pool table is in a good spot... Dart board a terrible spot... That said there really isn't another place to put the dart board... Bartender was pretty fast getting my drinks... I'd definitely go back read more

Smells dirty. My wife and I went there on a Sat. evening for a drink and some food. Stood at bar for a few minutes and bar tender came over and we asked for food menu and named the 2 beers we wanted . We got the menus and she proceeded to give some people at the bar some shots and then more shots and then more so we left. read more

Just spent a less than enjoyable over cooked meal listening to a delightful song going into graphic detail about a girl being raped and murdered. Not my idea of dinner music, and it was certainly not anyone elses either. Probably won't return. No, definitely won't return read more

Mitchell's was a place that I had seen and heard about for years and yet never tried. Well, one day I decided that I would give it a shot. The inside could use a bit of an update, but the food and friendliness of the staff made up for that. The bartender / server helped suggest options, after we stated that we were newbies. Well...the fish was excellent, as was the roast beef. I will definitely be back. read more

Mitchell's has always been a welcoming spot for a casual meal for me and my family. The bartenders and servers are really nice and they have a great assortment of beers and liquor. Whether you're sitting indoors or outside on the patio, you'll have a good time! The beef on weck is great, the fish fries are a generous portion, and the chicken fingers are exactly what you need if you're craving something spicy! Oh, and speaking of spicy, check out the restroom decor...it's the true definition of eye candy...even my 82 year old grandmother appreciated it! read more

Was here for a party and had a great time. The food was delicious and cooked just right! :) The service was excellent. Had great variety in alcoholic beverages. Lots of cool sports memorabilia too! read more

A very nice local pub. Barmaids are very friendly. Nice crowd and atmosphere. The food is average at best and their roast beef.......one of the worst I have ever had! read more

I do not add reviews as much as I should as I expect good service. I have become a regular at Mitchell's. First of all the prices are so reasonable that I feel I should pay more. Secondly, I love the food. The wraps are amazing. I was in last Saturday for lunch and had the Mitchell's wrap. Their specialty is roast beef and this was the best wrap I ever had. The time before I had the Buffalo wrap. The sports memorabilia on the wall is incredible. I always spend time just walking around looking at the pictures and autographs. Every time I go in new items are on the wall. This time a UB game used autographed jersey was added. If you are looking for a great comfort meal or fun place to hangout at night (pool table, dart board, internet jukebox for any song you can ever think of!) then Mitchell's is the place. I also inquired about catering. They have catering both away from restaurant as well as a separate location for private parties. read more

Bar, table are nice. Restroom is the best I have been. Philly beef Berger is awesome. Should stop by!

I had dinner Thursday night and found the server helpful and friendly, the food great, and the decor fine. I especially enjoyed the roast beef sandwich with coarse salt and caraway seeds on the bun and fresh horseradish. Thanks! read more

Mitchell's has excellent food. My husband and I enjoy the atmosphere and the friendly service. Love it there.

Used to work next door @ Buffalo Bearings in the 1980's...Went there for lunch often. The roast beef with horseradish was awesome and the beer was always served in a cold mug... I miss that place . read more

I wouldn't even give this place 1 star. Food was good, but the service was horrendous!!!! The waitress rushed us to order, we had to go to the bar to get refills on our drinks, and after we got our food we asked for silverware and they were never brought to us, she also did not check on us until we were completely done with our food. The waitress was more focused on socializing with other "patrons" which I think were just other employees that came into eat. We also asked for a sports game on a tv, we had to ask 3 separate people before they finally put the game on! The roast beef was good , as well as the wings. I'm just greatful that we had and Amazon daily deal so our food was free or I would have asked to speak with a manager. However the sour waitress has prevented me from EVER returning, we had planned on coming back to try other items on the menu. If your not hospitable the do not work in the hospitality industry! read more