We rarely eat at Mill Creek, but we often do take-out. It's by far our favorite pizza! Friday nights are particularly good, because they have "pizza flights" - four small slices of all kinds of pizza. And when we do dine in, it's pleasant, with very nice staff. read more

The food is truly amazing and the people are awesome. The customer service was great and on point. I will return again

Millcreek Pizza is a local spot with some strengths, but there are several areas in need of attention to create a better overall experience. Starting with the food, the kids enjoyed the pizza, which is a definite plus. However, the dough fell flat--literally. It lacked the airiness of a good fermented crust and had no bubbles or holes, making it dense, like a baking soda dough (which I'm sure it wasn't). The salad with chicken was fresh and flavorful, and the chicken Parmesan sandwich featured good-quality chicken, though the portion was disappointingly small for the price. Half of the sub had hardly any chicken in it. I went home hungry. The service is counter-style--you order at the counter, and the staff brings your food to the table. While the employees were polite and offered a kind thank you as we left, there were no smiles or warmth upon entering, and the lack of uniforms (everyone wore random street clothes) made the operation feel less professional. The dining space itself is where things fall short. The booths are in terrible condition--uncomfortable and visibly deteriorating. Our table was wobbly, adding to the frustration. The condiment holders (oregano, peppers, garlic powder, etc.) weren't clean, which isn't a great look for a restaurant. The bathroom was clean, but had a empty paper towel dispenser and a slow, dated worn-looking hand dryer that looked like it was picked up in a flea market. On the bright side, the food came out quickly, which is always a plus. However, the numerous small issues--from unclean condiment holders to worn-out furniture and the other things mentioned--add up to an experience that feels neglected. Millcreek Pizza has potential, especially with its kid-approved pizza and quick service, but it's clear that details are being overlooked. With improvements in cleanliness, professionalism, and overall upkeep, it could become a much more enjoyable place to eat. For now, it's an okay stop, but there's definite room for improvement. read more

For a local pizza joint, the food is very good. Service is excellent and friendly, food is consistently good, and the price is most fair for the quality you get. Overall it was a quite pleasant experience. read more

I called up to order two pies for delivery and the lady entered my address and was fine to continue my order but a gentleman in the back said "I never heard of that address" then they put me on hold and claimed " you're out of the delivery range which is 5 miles" I'm 2.5 miles away from them and called back to let them know I'm in the delivery range. The lady responded back "okay". I've ate here before and never wrote a review about any place ever. My coworkers and I eat there very often and will now definitely start sending my business somewhere else. read more

Never again unless no other place is open. Ordered a cheesesteak tonight with extra meat (if I did get extra I feel bad if you don't order extra). Definitely didn't get extra meat. Soggy bun & drenched in grease to the point the bun was split and falling apart when it arrived.. It's not a 'Philly' cheesesteak so I got the sauce. Not really, just a little, and little cheese. The best thing about this place is the thick balsamic dressing from the previous place. read more

Small, clean pizza shop in Trexlertown Walmart shopping center. Salad with housemade Caesar dressing was delicious. Enjoyed salad with flame grilled cheeseburger and soda. Cheese pizza was really good. Friend did not care for sausage pizza. Housemade cannolis were good. read more

We've gone to Mill Creek a few times and it's always been a great experience. Prices are reasonable and the service is exceptional as well. Needless to say we'll be going back for more read more

Mill Creek Pizza - Large cheese pizza, boneless wings - Italian Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

I ordered a small pizza and received this. Very disappointing and a waste of my money and time. I tried to send it back and management gave me an attitude. I will not come here again. read more

Mill Creek Pizza - Small Pizza - Italian Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Top slice of pizza in the Lehigh valley. Perfect crust and perfectly made. Clean establishment and friendly workers. Go see for yourself.

I enjoy their food. It is always fresh and hot. Everyone is friendly and helpful. I enjoy eating in and relaxing. Owners are nice people who always welcome you to the shop read more

There was time when this was a good place no longer. I guess cooking cheese on a pizza is too much to ask? Ive eaten better pizza on a Boardwalk.....in fucking Bulgaria. This was garbage. read more

Mill Creek Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Just ordered catering from Mill Creek for a party of 20. The food was outstanding. It was super easy to order on line and I called to update the order and it was super easy. They were ready for me when I arrived and helped to load my car. read more

Just had margarita pizza from this establishment.The pizza was among the worst I've ever eaten. It was delivered cold . Reheated it and there was zero flavor, the dough tasted days old, the sauce was tasteless and the cheese was so hard and old it wouldn't completely melt. Considering they charge high prices this is clearly a place to avoid. The place was once much better read more

you have lost me forever today as a loyal customer since the day you opened. No longer a meat lovers pizza was just the starter but now you are charging a convenience fee at 3.5% with no notice except on the door. I am done and so is my hundreds of dollars of business with your establishment. You are destroying your business on the backs of your most loyal customers. You are simply trying to cover you brewery upstart charges now. Smaller portions at the expense of a quality pizza is not a sound business plan. You left me no other choice but to look elsewhere for a good pizza. Charging me $26 for a large three meat only pizza without substitutions plus a 3.5% fee for using my credit card rewards card is simply price gouging. No pizza is worth that price. And who the hell does not put sausage on a meat lovers pizza but places bacon bits as a meat on the pizza? If I wanted a smaller portion pizza, I would buy them at the grocery store. I can get 4-6 pizzas at Giant for the price of one just one of your pizzas. Your website is outdated and misleading as well. Goodbye Like Comment Share read more

I went in for there Wednesday pizza special $8 for a large pizza. It tasted great and was ready in 10 minutes. That day they also had free face painting and balloon animals for my toddler. It was a really nice fun event! read more

Mill Creek Pizza - Free face painting at mill creek family event - Italian Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

We started ordering lunch from Mill Creek Pizza a few weeks ago. They are always spot on with orders for delivery. The food is always good and exactly what we ordered. They have a "special gold" wing sauce which is outstanding. any sauce can be put on any chicken dish which is nice. the woman taking our order is always so courteous and reads our order back to ensure its correct. This is our new go to place for lunch at work. Give it a try. you will get hooked. also delivery is good timing and they try to package things appropriately as to being hot or cold. i mean who does that? common sense thoughtful business practices here! read more

Absolutely Pitiful! Every order screwed up from everyone that has owned this place. We have had it!. RUN FROM THIS PLACE! USE MY EXPERIENCES OF THIS PLACE! Never again. When it was Vinnys, it was burnt Pizza. Forgotten deliveries, very late deliveries (over 2 hrs late!) Screwed up orders. From wrong items to wrong toppings. Hot peppers and someone's steak sand who has bowel problems! Now mill creek can't get any order right. And it's the same exact issues all over again. Some orders were so wrong, the only thing close was that there was four long sandwiches. What they were was not even close to what we ordered! Now for the most shocking of all? Rotten salami in hoagies! Yes ROTTEN! Ordered 2 hoagies with oil and vinegar on the side and a ravioli dinner. This was at 7 pm. For once the order was gotten right. We pick it up. We had to. It was 45min-1hr. delivery, and we all know that with this place. The order was for one to eat the ravioli and one to eat a half of hoagie that night. The other 3 half hoagies were to be kept for lunches the next day.(hence o&v on the side). While eating the hoagie the person stated it didn't taste right and said something in the meats didn't taste right but she also had a cold and attributed it to that. Low and behold, next day we were all at work and blowing up each other's phones asking each other if their hoagies tasted right. Each were saying they tasted bad. I immediately got mine out and smelled it and it smelled so bad of old, rancid, spoiled lunchmeat! I opened mine and looked and there was brown salami. Not red or pink but brown. Weeks old Lunchmeat!. Bad smelling and bad tasting. No one can blame us. I am a stickler about refrigeration. They were immediately wrapped and refrigerated apon arrival and packed for lunches with the usual 6" x 6" x 1.5" ice gel block, as all lunches are in our house. As far as I'm concerned even if we left them out for a day, it would have never gotten to this point. I'm beginning to think this was intentional because any person that has made themselves at sandwich at any time in life would know the smell, the slimy feeling and could visually see it and know it wasn't right. And why is this? Supposedly they are so busy. Or is it the sheep thing, where you all follow everyone just because everyone else says so, like Starbucks because you just want to carry the cup. You just want to be in the in I quess? Find a better quality restaurant. We all wanted to vomit! So would you! read more

The food here is fantastic! Everything is so fresh, especially their salads. It's the only place I ever order salad when I dine out. The staff and owners are very friendly. You have to try it. I know you won't be disappointed. read more

First time ordering. Nice online menu. Placed order and AFTER checked out saw I was charged $1.50 "convenience fee". I just did all the work entering the order. I called and they said if you call and order no fee. How STUPID is this. She said it is there "service provider" that charges the fee. That is bull. Credit card companies charge fees too and there was no CC fee for paying by card. Have no idea how the pizza is yet but Last order from me just on principal read more

My pregnant wife and I were driving home from New York and we both stopped in because I wanted a couple of slices on our way back home to Lancaster county. Because of the pregnancy, pizza is sometimes not desirable for her, so we first grabbed a soup at the local Panera before we came in and she was going to eat it while I ate the pizza I ordered and paid for. The manager had the nerve to come up to her and tell her she can't eat an outside meal there. And he did that while I got up to use the restroom, so I wasn't there to explain the situation. Also, there was no sign outside of the restaurant that stated or explained this rule. Very poor treatment and a complete lack of respect...even if she technically was violating a "rule" or "policy." A classic example of someone taking a policy too far at the expense of the customer and the reputation of the establishment. It gets worse. This may be tough to believe, but on my honor, this next part is true. My wife was diagnosed with a brain tumor less than a month ago. Emotions have been running high and it was a lot for me to hear when I returned from the restroom that the manager treated her so rudely. I calmly went up to the manager after my wife had told me why had happened and I said to him: "My wife is a pregnant woman with a brain tumor." His response: "She's not wearing a sign that says she's pregnant and has a brain tumor." I swear that is what he said back to me. The two girls working behind the counter near the cash register overheard this exchange. Shocked, my wife and I walked out, and I shouted back: "Remember this." I didn't expect to the manager to know that she was pregnant with a recently diagnosed brain tumor. How could anyone know that? But I told him that to make a point that you should never be rude to people, because you never know their backstory. I know this is a lengthy review that may seem unbelievable, but on my honor, this happened. I was shocked. To treat a couple like this deserves consequences. read more

Ok pizza. Meatball parm pizza better then most. Nice place. Staff usually friendly. Cheap napkins. Got the lunch special "with discount " for $7.92 although board read $6.50. With tax not sure that adds up. Best pizza in area? Absolutely not. That designation goes to slice of Italy. Not bad in a pinch read more

Three things that describe Penn Pizza @ Mill Creek. 1. One of the best places to eat. 2. Franky P the man who makes magic with pizza is a show indeed. 3. Staff and family are the salt of the earth people. read more

Only have myself to blame for ordering from here again. I forgot to say "please cook my pizza extra" and, happened again..had to cook it myself, basically raw. Should I have to say that? Other reviews say same thing so take the hint. Never again. Tasteless as well, no seasoning. Pizza shops are dime a dozen. read more

This is by far our new favorite for subs, salads and Stromboli. The Cobb salad was fantastic! The turkey sub was real turkey sliced .. incredible! The Stromboli was out of this world!!! I highly recommend! read more

Really slow on the delivery side. Called 3x, pizza delivered lukewarm 1:45 after order. At least if it's late, reheat the pizza! Disappointed. read more

Great meatball sub, plenty of meat on hot toasted bread at a great price. Fast service friendly staff. Will be back to try other menu items.

Lori T. I dined there a few days ago. I would have to say "Not the best Pizza in Town" it was very chewy and cold. also, had to use many napkins as they were paper thin. Also, my friend got a hoagie and wanted extra onions and extra tomatoes and it looked like they didn't even put any on! We won't be dining at this place again! read more

Have been ordering for company events since they opened. Always on time, always courteous, food is amazing. The stuffed pepper is to die for, they never have them if I wait to call in a late lunch! I highly recommend them! read more

I'm giving this restaurant two stars because of the wait staff. Every single time we order from here we get over charged, and our bill is wrong... nothing is worse then having to stand in front of other customers who are waiting to pay/ order their food and having them hear you working out the charges on your bill... please check the math and double check what the wait staff are charging you... it's not worth the hassle to eat here any more because of this. Our bill was over charged 34.00 this was not the first time as I said... read more

I dined here a few weeks ago for the fourth time...I honestly can't remember if the pizza was good or bad...soooooo take that for what's it worth. The garlic knots though, are DELICIOUS! Another reviewer said they were different than the usual twisted doughy knot. They are plump, fluffy, and covered in a garlic oil. The first time I ordered them, I tool one look and thought I wouldn't be a fan. They come with a lighter red sauce that most definitely is not marina. I took one bite and was hooked! THE SAUCE IS THE KEY!!! I can't figure out what exactly it is, but it's delicious. The garlic knots are more like little rolls and I hope they never change the recipe. I will keep returning as long as they have the garlic knots. read more

I absolutely love this place! I only recently discovered Penn Pizza on Mill Creek Rd and would recommend it to anyone. The staff can't do enough for you. They are friendly and courteous. They are what many places have ceased to be; your friendly neighborhood restaurant. Fresh food with attention to detail. read more

Mill Creek Pizza - Hot and yummy - Italian Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Whomever made my plain pizza tonight with the crispy crust should get a raise!!

Love it, Love it, Love it! Great food, great owners. Only thing that sucks and is out of their control is the door. In the winter you freeze your tailfeather off eating there due to simple physics. When someone opens the door to come in or leave a blast of cold air comes in. So in winter order take out! read more

We ordered a bruschetta pizza last Saturday. Delivered to our home hot and delicious. Generously topped and perfectly seasoned. Helpful hint: always order "well done/extra crispy". Tried to reach the owner,Frank, three different times to give him positive feedback...unfortunately, he was busy/unavailable. His loss. read more

Decent pizza for the area, prices are great and the service is even better. My only complaint is that the garlic knots are a little different than I am used to being from New York, but they are not horrendous. Definitely recommend. read more

We have been ordering takeout on Friday nights pretty regularly. The owners, Frank and Elizabeth have done an outstanding job with their staff!! They are courteous, friendly and most importantly, extremely competent when taking orders!! Their food is not only tasty but their portions are tremendous! I absolutely recommend Millcreek Pizza!! Well done Frank and Elizabeth!! read more

Their Eggplant Parmesan was okay and it was overpriced. I didn't try anything else, so I can't really comment on the other dishes.

Though I think the food here is good, the service leaves a lot to be desired. Twice we have ordered take out and the food was wrong. The second time was a huge inconvenience, because we had ordered sandwiches to take to an event that didn't have any food. We discovered we were given the wrong sandwich after we got there (tuna!!), and my daughter refused to eat it. We ended up leaving the event early so that we could get her dinner. I brought the wrong sandwich back the next day, another inconvenience, and I got a curt, "what would you like me to do?" from the owner Beth. She gave me my money back and that was it. No apology whatsoever. I was so disgusted, I called when I got home pointing out that she didn't even apologize for their error. Only to get an insincere "I'm sorry" to placate me. That's it- no elaboration, no we could have handled this better, no I'm really sorry for the mixup, no I'm sorry for all the inconvenience, nothing. Not okay in any sense of the word. The young teenager at the cash register had more people skills than her. Pizza joints are a dime a dozen. If the service sucks, customers won't return. read more

Great Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteaks, definitely the best in the Valley. Also a super friendly staff and some of the hardest working owners around. read more