6/16/2022 Small Caesar salad with shrimp included red bell pepper, artichoke, black olives and was really good. 4/4/2022 Chicken Parmesan with angel hair pasta and tomato sauce was really good. Side salad with Caesar dressing pretty good. 3/15/2022 Slice cheese pizza with bell peppers was pretty good. Friend really liked pepperoni pizza. Caesar salad with chicken and caesar dressing was pretty good but too much dressing on salad. 3/3/2022 Cannoli filling is delicious but they put it inside dry stale shell. 3/1/2022 One ground beef meatball comes with small order of spaghetti & meatballs. Meatball is good but not enough for the amount of spaghetti that comes with meal. They give plenty tomato sauce, which is made in house. read more

Not sure who was cooking but this food was not good. Pizza no kind of color, wings dry, chicken tenders the size of my thumb with a container full of fries. I'm so disappointed. read more

See all

I tried this place cause they're the only one on DoorDash near me that sells Sicilian slices, glad I did cause they're phenomenal. Ive gotten a chicken Caesar wrap and Sicilian slice a few times and it's been great every time. read more

Broad St Pizzeria should be rated 5 stars my pizza was cooked to perfection and was delicious. Wings were awesome Plus the delivery person was prompt and friendly Thank you read more

Staff was very friendly even helped me figure out the best way to layer toppings lol The young lady that takes the orders always has gorgeous nails she is so nice!! read more

Broad St Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

My favorite new pizza place since I have moved to downtown Bethlehem! Their pizza makes me salivate

I'm in the area waiting for an appointment for my son to get a haircut. I turned the corner and saw that there was a pizza shop. I parked and saw that there was a sign that said lunch special so I asked for the two slices and a soda. The woman at the counter, put it in the system and ordered it, but then there was a gentleman who I'm guessing is the manager told her no that's only the lunch special then he pointed out the time so I said you know what I'll get it anyways when I went to pay, I realize that I only paid for two pizzas I was a little upset because I wanted a drink but I let it slide while I was waiting for my pizza to come out. I told them who I'm guessing is the manager that he should take down that sign that's outside that says lunch special if the lunch special is over because it's kind of deceiving because you see that sign from afar it's really big and he said no I don't have to take it down. I said well if the lunch special is over what's the point of having it he said no I am gonna leave it up. I said well can I order anything that's on there right now and he said no - I said so what's the point of having it up? He got upset with me and walked away, but another gentleman was working in their folding boxes he looked at me and kind of I could tell that he kind of agreed with what I was saying. The sign is pretty deceiving. The pizza is pretty good. The cheese tastes a little bland. The pepperoni is crispy and I like that very much. I was waiting at the door because I left my car door open, but the inside of the restaurant looked pretty nice. The manager needs to think about what he's doing. It's kind of tricky having that lunch special sign-up just to bring in the customers and then tell them no you can't order what's on that sign. It's pretty messed up. read more

Broad St Pizzeria - Super greasy - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

We ordered pizza through a delivery service, received order in a timely manner, and the food was delicious. Highly recommended.

Disappointed food was delivered via Uber Eats, not even warm. Also, should allow to make choices, raw onions...hate them.

Ordered though Slice app. Have ordered many time from this shop. Tonight my order was 20 minutes late. Pizza was barely warm and when contacted the Slice app. Was told that there was nothing they could do. Really?!? You just lost a customer. read more

The Best Pizza. That's it, that's the review Well, error told me I needed to say more! The pizza was good and hot (we picked up) the crust is excellent. Ours had onions and mushrooms. The mushrooms were fresh, not canned. read more

After rightfully passing on this place for close to a year we recently placed an order since our regular in town pizza joint is closed on Sunday. Now when I say pizza joint that does not mean that I ordered pizza from Broad Street because honestly I've tried it several times and each time it was either horribly greasy/oily or the sauce/cheese ratio was seriously way off with there being entirely too much cheese. I do know a person or two who thinks their pies are fine but for every one of them I know five who are have tried it and seriously dislike it. Now the thing that seems to be the saving grace here is their sandwiches. We tried their mozz sticks, meatball parm sandwich and the veggi-boli with the results being all over map. The mozz sticks tasted freshly microwaved. (Hot outside - cool to almost cold inside) The meatball parm sandwich was fantastic. Good size to it, nice amount of sauce and a very sturdy bread that kept the whole thing together. The veggie-boil was also received very well although when I called to order the the person who answered the phone had to be reminded that yes, they do have such a thing on their menu. They told me 20 minutes and I walked in after a little more than 30 to find the order just being put into a bag so thankfully I wasn't there on time nor was I in a hurry because clearly they weren't. I guess what this boils to down is that while I live close enough that this place should be a #1 go-to option I can't bring myself to it unless I am under the duress of total laziness in terms of not wanting to drive someone/it's Sunday so our regular spot is not open. I mean I'll bump Broad Street to two stars but their food just doesn't do it for me and that hasn't changed since almost day one right up until last week. read more

Ordered delivery and it took over 1.5 hours to get to my home, located 5 minutes away. The pizza was completely underdone, crust included, and missing toppings. Garlic knots were inedible and off putting with a very strange taste that I can't even describe. read more

Some of the best pizza in Bethlehem! Always delicious, great service and lots of options.

What happened New Owners..I thought Broad St. Pizza was the best..last night I got a pie from you..AWFUL! Pizza Hut is way better than your place...Not one thing on it I cared for,..could not eat it!!!!!!!! Pls. hire the person back who worked there previously...sorry, I'm Italian..sooo. read more

I ordered dinner from this place on November 7th, 2016. Price was decent and delivery was right one time, according to the Grub Hub app prediction. This is what I ordered: Chicken alfredo pasta Plain pizza slices (2), which comes with garlic bread and salad. The Chicken alfredo pasta was good. I loved the sauce, it had a creamy, buttery flavor. But there was something about the chunks of chicken, not sure what it was. It was a sightly sour taste? Might have just been an off batch. But otherwise, it was really good. The portion was pretty generous too. Let's just say I was full. The salad was fresh, it had grape tomatoes, sliced black olives (most places do green, so that was different) and red onion over iceberg lettuce. They do have really good ranch dressing! I'm always picky about that. But there are other dressings to choose from too. I got 2 slices of their plain pizza (just cheese) because I like to try a pizza place's pasta AND pizza, if I can. But sometimes it's a budget issue, because not all places offer it by the slice, lol. They use good stretchy, bubbly cheese, the kind I like. Sauce is nice, its more savory but slightly sweet. Crust is good, done well and not soggy, burned or doughy. The garlic bread is actually garlic knots, and they are good. Nice distinct garlic flavor, which is what I expect. Garlic knots should never be bland. Based on what I've tasted, I would say it's a good place to order from. Although I feel like I really need to try more of their pasta dishes and a few other things, to really be able to make a ruling. read more

See all

I love pizza and I've eaten ALOT of pizza and I deliver to alot of pizza places that have given me slices of my choice and let's just say they make a great nonna pie, the sauce was so nice and the amount of fresh basil I picked up in every bite was so good! Every bite was graced with the fragrant herb and the caprese style cheese was also quite plentiful! If you dont know what a nonna pie is it's like a sicilian pie but a thinner crust but still thicker than new York style crust, its covered in sauce with chunks of stewed tomatoes hits with a bountiful amount of fresh basil then fresh mozzarella or caprese mozzarella tossed on like pepperoni, its one of my favorite styles of pizza. Also the chicken bacon ranch really friggin good! The crust held up so it didn't wilt when picked up and the amount of everything just had a great ratio, bravo doing a classic very well. I wish I took a picture it was so good I couldn't stop! read more

This is to me the best pizza place since moving into Bethlehem a year ago.. I'm addicted to their Stromboli's they are Amazing, pizza is also really good and I've bought pizzas from around my neighborhood radius and 1 completely screwed up my order and the food was less than average never again and the other ok but after trying this place well I go no other place, professional courteous service and excellent food especially the Stromboli highly recommend this place and I'm a New Yorker so I know good pizza and service read more

food is always hot and tasty. always a go to spot for me. love the thai sweet chili wings, onion rings, pepperoni rolls, and pizza.

Foods good staff are friendly. Haven't had anything i hated about the place. Close to home and walkable. Haven't tried the pizza yet since i live alone and it would be expensive to buy a whole pizza for one sitting lol Edit: tried the pizza today. Crust is amazing but the rest of it.... the sauce is watery and there is barely any on it. Im a big sauce on pizza guy read more

The lady there isn't the nicest. She was a bit rude when we asked for curbside pick up. We ended up going inside because they did not call (they said they would call us not the other way around). They also didn't have their masks on and social distancing basically didn't exist. They also messed up our order. Spend a little more money and get a good pizza at the brick. read more

This is my go-to place whenever I'm in town! The pizza is amazing (especially the bbq chicken pizza), Stromboli is great too, but the best is their cheesesteaks! All their food is always fresh and delicious. Have never been disappointed. I highly recommend! read more

Broad St Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Just walked in and half the staff were maskless as well as a customer standing there talking to the staff, no mask in sight. I turned right around and left. read more

Recently, on a Tuesday night, my fiancée and I (regular customers-we live five minutes away) ordered a chicken parm dinner, calamari and the eggplant rollatini dinner using the Slice app. After an HOUR AND FORTY MINUTES, I called the restaurant and spoke to (who I knew to be) the older lady who usually works the counter. I asked what the status of the order was, and she explained the order "just went out" the door, which I knew to be untruthful, as the Slice app told us twenty minutes prior the order had been marked "out for delivery." Again, WE LIVE FIVE MINUTES AWAY. When I informed her it was ridiculous to wait as long as we were for the food, that we are loyal customers and it's a TUESDAY night, I then asked her what the business planned on doing about rectifying the situation. She said there was nothing she could do, she was NOT going to offer a future credit or any other incentive (as I suggested) and overall, didn't seem phased by the whole situation. The food finally showed up ten minutes after that, just short of TWO HOURS after ordering. Though we always enjoyed their food, I will NEVER give them my business again. read more

We lovvvve Broad Street pizza! We always get a plain pie and pepperoni bites, yummy! I've had their anti pasta salad too which is always fresh. We always find ourselves comparing other pizza places to broad street...and broad street always wins! read more

I always get delivery from here and it's always so fast and hot. Whenever I get extra sauces they are never forgotten! (Like some other places in the area) portion sizes are great. Always friendly whenever I call and great service whenever I go in person. Thank you!! read more

I've ordered dozens of times and it was always perfect!! Last 2 orders were horrible!! Not sure if it has changed owners but the pizza tasted pre made and then tossed in the oven to heat up. Overcooked dough, cheese is different and dry and the sauce tasted like paste...not the same pizza at all!! Not sure if I'll try again or just go somewhere else read more

I've been ordering from here for years and hand no complaints till tonight, I ordered my food from slice and they got my Stromboli order wrong, even on the receipt it clearly says the ingredients I didn't want. I didn't want to go through the headache of having to get another one and just picked out what I didn't want and saw that there was an actual piece of the dough still RAW. read more

Amato's Pizza is now Broad Street Pizzeria! The new owners are family friends of Amato's. They also run Jake's Brick Oven Pizza in Bethlehem. Broad Street delivers. They take credit cards. And the pizza is fantastic. On the north side, I prefer it over both Marco's and Nick's. The sauce tastes like tomatoes and I even ate the entire crust. Broad Street Pizzeria has the same phone number as Amato's, so they can preserve the local clientele. Yay! I'm a fan. read more

Had delivery and they did a great job and on time. Chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was on the money. Cheese sticks were still hot inside even after a drive in this cold weather - no microwave used here. These were like fresh made. Philly steak will be for lunch tomorrow, but it is going to take some willpower not to snag a bite because it smells so good. (Some people will just complain about everything - I try to keep it real. Real deal this is a good delivery with good food) read more

I've been ordering from here over the last few months. Great prices, great portion sizes, and quality food. I've noticed some pizza shops specialize in certain things like only pizza, they are all around good food. We've ordered all over the menu and haven't been disappointed. Chicken parm entree, steak sandwiches, calzones, salads, and more have all been great. read more

We just started ordering from them recently. The pizza is great and the wings are huge which is hard to find lately. The garlic knots are wonderful. The food always is delivered hot. But tonight this is how we got our pizza! Very disappointing read more

Broad St Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Thank you Broad Street...been ordering there for over 4 years. Food is great and they care that you are happy with your order. Broad Street Pizza will continue to be my "Go To" place. read more

Wanting to patronize a neighborhood eatery during this pandemic we ordered pizza from Broad St. Pizza last night! It actually arrived earlier than we expected, was good and hot, and was contact-free delivery! But best of all was the pizza itself! It was absolutely delicious! Our new favorite! We are glad to have helped keep a local business going, and to have had a delicious dinner to boot! If we had opted for pick-up we could have saved the delivery and tip costs, but we are glad to have supported both business and workers! read more

Can't speak for anything other than the pizza but the Grandma Sicilian Pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Tastes so fresh. Sauce, cheese and crust are perfection! read more

Ordered delivery today. The delivery speed was great. They put holes in the calamari container, I assume to keep the moisture from softening the fried product. Good idea in theory, but the calamari was cold when it arrived. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger and received a cheeseburger with NO BACON and they went so heavily on the condiments, I barely tasted the burger. The buffalo chicken cheese steak could have used more chicken and cheese, but the buffalo sauce was good. Might order again, but I'll stick to the pizza and pastas. read more

I would usually give a 5 star due to myself loving the antipasto salad, but I ordered Sunday and the lunch meat was terrible i had to spit it out. I will no longer be going there. read more

This has become one of our most frequently visited places. The food is always good. Never had a bad experience. Your get a lot of food for the price you pay. Staff is very friendly. They will always have our business read more

I've been disappointed recently with the quality of pizza but gave them the benefit of the doubt but it seems to be a routine thing now. We will never be there again. The pizza we ordered was not cooked properly all the cheese was sliding off, I attempted to pick up a slice with two hands just for it to go limp and all cheese slid off. I brought it back with complaints asking them to make a new one. Lady behind the counter argued with me and said it was just cooked and still hot and that's why the cheese slid off. I demanded a refund or new pizza. New pizza was made I had my husband look at it before we left, the lady behind the counter had the audacity to say there's nothing wrong with it just the first one. I never bring food back or complain but to be disrespected like that for shitty food. No thanks I'll take my business elsewhere! Zero stars should be an option! read more

Apparently some people over there need to get their hearing checked. Had an item missing from my order that was clearly said when the order was put in but no one heard said item and it was never charged out and I obviously never received it. Never will I order from there again. read more