NYC Village Pizza

F&A Grog House is a trendy American pub located on E 3rd St. in Bethlehem. It's open Monday through…read moreWednesday, 4 PM - 12 AM, Thursday and Friday, 12 PM - 1 AM, Saturday, 11 AM - 1 AM, and Sunday, 11 AM - 12 AM. My friends and I stopped by Thursday night for some drinks and bites to share. We ordered a mix of appetizers, including the cheesesteak egg rolls, breaded mozzarella half moons, housemade G's sauce wings, and the grilled cheese with fries. Everything came out hot and fresh. The wings were the standout, great flavor with G's sauce, which is like a peppery hot sauce. It's not super spicy, but it does have a slight kick. The grilled cheese could've used more cheese, but overall, everything hit the spot. Fun place for a casual night out! Cheesesteak Egg Rolls - 7.8 Breaded Mozzarella Half Moons - 8.1 Housemade G's Sauce Wings - 8.1 Grilled Cheese - 7.5 French Fries - 7.7 Food - 7.8 Service - 8.1 Value - 7.8 Restaurant score - 79

We visited on a Saturday afternoon around 1:30pm. Place wasn't busy which was great. We were able…read moreto get seats at the bar. I've been here before after my kids hockey games at steel ice. It is definitely a college town bar (I'm in my early 50's). The bartender was prompt and took our drink orders right away. The cook is right in front of you at the bar which is kind of cool. You could tell by speaking with him that he took pride in their menu. He let us sample some of the sauces which was great. I had the special of the day which was a grilled tomato/bacon cheese on Texas toast and a tomato soup with rice, ground beef, onions and peppers. It was fantastic! I also had the Cowboy bites which were jalapeños with cream cheese, bacon and corn - my goodness they were so good! My bro had the "what came first". Fried chicken sandwich with a fried egg and bacon. It came with fries and he said it was really good. My husband had Tri-tip cheese steak with no mushrooms. He said it was delicious. We were there on our own time without a schedule, so we didn't mind having to wait for our bartender. It started getting busy while we were there so the vibe was pretty cool. We will definitely be going back!

See all

Machs Gute Pub and Grille

4.4(100 reviews)

1.1 mi

Nice neighborhood bar to drink and eat…read more French onion soup with toasted portuguese roll was good as a mid-afternoon brunch. Service kind of slow, servers were nice.

Awesome sports pub vibes. Got fried pickles to start, on the money! Ordered the cheese steak for…read moreentree and not only was it delish, 10/10 quantity. Had to dig deep to finish that big boy. Loved every second of it. Highly recommend.

Shrimp and fries

See all

Food menu

Apollo Grill

4.5(688 reviews)

0.8 mi

I stopped by Team Apollo during Musikfest for a quick bite, and it ended up being a great choice…read more We decided to try the Musikfest specials of the day the lemon pepper wings and the shrimp udon noodles and both were delicious. The wings were perfectly seasoned with just the right amount of lemon pepper, and the shrimp udon noodles were flavorful, comforting, and generously portioned. Even though it was a busy festival day, everything came out quickly. A special shoutout to our server, Daniel, who was friendly, attentive, and incredibly efficient. He made sure we had everything we needed without missing a beat, even with the restaurant being busy. If you're looking for a casual spot with good food and fast service, especially during Musikfest, Team Apollo is definitely worth checking out.

First time here. First- the vibe is super cool, very…read morefriendly staff and cool interior. Our meal was PEI oysters (drool), clams casino( yummy), quinoa salad, tuna tartare (excellent) and black and blue steak appy(super yummy). Alison was our server, very cool! What more can I say? Really nice experience!

Fall Menu 2018...begins Wednesday September 12th!

Weekly Sandwich Features! Pictured is the Chimichurri Chicken Melt!

See all

We feature a daily fresh catch!

Flying Pig Tavern & Tap

4.1(78 reviews)

1.5 mi

OMG !!!! Was in the Lehigh Valley and searched for good food…read moreand brews. Saw this place and didn't think it would be this good Nice small selection of brews ... after sampling we settled on the Riot In The ADK My friend had the Italian Chicken sandwich/ fries... he said it was delicious and just barely finished it I had the Grilled Cheese sandwich with tots... it was freakin huge and delicious [I hate showing half eaten food, but I couldn't finish it ] Our server was Ariyani was awesome! I highly recommend this place and definitely going back when in the area

First time coming here & We will never go back. It was half-price appetizer happy hour so We…read moreordered wings with our draft ciders. Wings were tough & Covered in way too much buffalo sauce which didn't taste like buffalo sauce. The Pulled pork sandwich was dry & overcooked & the bun was scorched. The side of coleslaw tasted & smelled so disgusting I spit it out in my napkin! I ordered a medium burger and when I cut it in half it was raw inside! I showed it to the server, he apologized & brought me out another one, I cut it in half & it was well done this time, so I didn't eat it!! Waste of $65 AND we left hungry!

Happy and enjoying the food

Blue cheese burger, fries, non-alcoholic beer.

See all

Cheesecake with caramel and whipped cream

The Burger Shack

4.4(176 reviews)

5.6 mi

Wow such a hidden gem in a small town. Stopped by for some burgers mid road trip and was totally…read moreimpressed. The burger was delicious and beefy. lol. I tried a mushroom burger and a hot honey burger. Very friendly small cafe and the lady was super helpful. Mushroom burger 5/5 Hot honey 4/5

We were in the area for a high school cross country meet and stopped in for lunch on the weekend…read more Super friendly staff who are also the owners. You can tell they are passionate about their food and talked us through their favorites on the menu. We had their homemade pierogies, cheesesteak eggrolls, and everyone had one of their signature burgers. Everything was very tasty and the burgers tasted very fresh. We would absolutely go back if we were in the area again.

Boneless chicken wings after I put the hot sauce and ranch on.so meaty and big I had to break them in half!

See all

The Wooden Match

3.4(223 reviews)

0.4 mi

Great outdoor space. Cornhole, beers, cigars, what more could one want?? Here for Musikfest 2026…read more Definitely will be back.

The patio atmosphere was very nice, and I really enjoyed the live jazz music. The pretzels were…read morealso one of the highlights of the meal. However, the overall experience was disappointing due to slow service, lack of communication, and issues with the food. We visited after the Lehigh Graduate Commencement Ceremony and were seated from 1:30-3:00 PM. Our server, Younise, only checked on us roughly every 15 minutes. It then took 45 minutes for pretzels and another 30 minutes for our 2 entrees. While we overheard that the kitchen was behind, this was never communicated to us directly, which made the long wait more frustrating. There was also an issue with my order. I ordered the Caesar salad wrap (Julius' Chicken Dance $14), but I was brought a Caesar salad with chicken ($3 up-charge) instead. The server did not offer to have the kitchen correct it or provide an alternative. After discussing it, I eventually asked if she could bring me a tortilla so I could make the wrap myself. A 15% discount was applied, which I appreciated, but the bill still listed the incorrect meal and reflected the higher-priced salad instead of the wrap I originally ordered. The burger was also underwhelming, as the cheese was not melted. For a meal that came to over $60 for pretzels, a burger, a salad item, and one drink, I expected better communication, food quality, and customer service. The ambiance was great, but the entrees and service unfortunately did not match the setting

Legal Limit Nachos and Reality Bites..

The wrap I made myself

See all

Haazs

3.8(54 reviews)

3.8 mi

This place is exceptional. I have ordered here early afternoon,evening and late night and it is…read moreconsistently exceptional. While it's not a restaurant I would typically go eat at for dining style ambience it's food is consistently amazing and tastes better than most places I would go out to eat

If I could give the customer service and overall experience zero stars, I would. Unfortunately, the…read moreapp doesn't even allow that. I ordered three chicken tenders meals with fries and specifically asked for two of them to have no seasoning and one to have medium seasoning. Somehow, my order was still made incorrectly, with two unseasoned chicken tenders and only one medium seasoned tender in the same meal. My order was not prepared the way I specifically requested, and the experience was frustrating and disappointing. I expected my order to be made correctly.

See all

Ample parking

Pints & Pies Neighborhood Pub

4.3(31 reviews)

1.4 mi

We took newbies to Pints & Pies to experience there amazing cheesesteaks…read more They were very impressed with the flavor of the cheesesteak! He was even talking about 24 hours later. Now that's making a good impression on a newbie. We had a great time on Sunday night having a later dinner around 7pm. To start I had the peorgie and my wife had 10 traditional style wings. Honey bbq and mild. I got the old barrel cheesesteak. My buddy got a traditional cheesesteak. A grilled cheese sandwich. Everything was super tasty and flavorful. We had a great meal.

I hadn't been here since the new owners took over, but I mostly liked it when the place was…read moreRoosevelt's and then whatever it was after that, I can't quite recall. Love what the new folks have done with it. The outdoor bar, that's half indoors, is really cool, and those hi-tech, rotating fans that spin around on the ceiling help with the temperature and are also fun to watch. My friend and I had great service at the bar and I thought the food was excellent: grilled cheese with two types of cheese, plus tomato; perogies, and a Caesar salad. There are lots of beers to choose from, both on tap and in bottles. I'll definitely be back here this summer!

Perogies. Tasty

See all

Cheesesteak. Yummy.

Retro Burger

3.3(26 reviews)

1.3 mi

We reluctantly decided to return after not having the best experiences in the past, but after…read morehearing the establishment was under new management and seeing many recent positive reviews, we hoped things would be different. Initial thought-It was 5PM and we were the only table. Pros- -Waitress was extremely kind, attentive, and sweet. -Had regular ketchup vs. house-made that was offered previously. Cons- -Sprite was flat and tasted like dirty club soda. -Fries were extremely salty. The bowl that was brought out as an appetizer were a little better than those served with the burger(s). -Fried Chicken Sandwich (see picture) looked as though it was on the floor, or picked out of the garbage, and tasted just the same. -Four of us had a burger, which was just okay. The seasoning on them was overwhelming and couldn't finish the burger as a result. ------ After the two people at the bar left, we were the only table in the restaurant (6 people). We're not sure if the manager was present, but given that we were the only table on a Saturday night, we would have expected there to be some interest in hearing directly from customers for feedback and learning how to improve. While we had hoped that giving it another chance would lead to a more enjoyable experience, there's still a lot that needs improvement for us to consider it worthwhile--let alone edible.

We went on a Sunday afternoon and, as expected, it was very quiet- in fact, we thought they were…read moreclosed at first. I imagine this place is more for the evenings and weekends- so I'll return for a second shot soon. Our party of 5 enjoyed the retro ambiance and throw-back decor. The place was clean, if not, unused. I hope they are getting the business they need to survive. The menu looked interesting with a few out-of-the-box options. The prices seemed on par if not a little high as they upcharged for additions things like fries. I can't think of a more normal complimentary pairing like burger and fries. While my buddy got the normal retro burger I went to their chalkboard special of brisket on a housemade potato bun, of sorts. The flavor was good but it came out lukewarm and cold in spots. It clearly was reheated food. I had to send it back and upon its return, it was warm (not even hot) on the 2nd try. I had hoped for better from Retro, to be honest. The fries seemed hand-cut and tasted decent but nothing special. The service was friendly but unattentive as we had to ask for refills and my water was never filled (since I never asked). Since my dish had to be reheated my party had eaten most of their food by the time I got mine and while the server said "sorry about that" - that's all. Good establishments recognize the major failure of reheat/late dishes and typically offer a dessert, some money off, or something- they did nothing. Remember- the place was empty so it's not as if they couldn't focus on quality. I hate offering their first Yelp review with only 3 stars, but I will return and give them another shot during primetime and will update this review. I can't say I have high hopes for their survival as better restaurants (like Mint) have occupied this space and didn't make it. Here's hoping Jason (Exec chef) and company can make it here, if not just for their sake.

Welcome to REtro Burger

Beer & Cheese Dip

See all

Hipster Burger

Union and Finch

4.5(810 reviews)

5.7 mi

Wow!!! Found Union and Finch in an online review article. Absolutely the best food!!! Started w…read morethe Pepperoni and Brussels sprouts. Crispy pepperoni with Brussels, pecorino cheese, and spicy honey. The most unique combination of delicious flavors!! Followed with the Burrata. Excellent and the bread that came with it was some of the tastiest bread I have ever had. Yes, I know it is just bread..but no seriously, so good! Next a burger and fries! My husband declared it the best burger he has had in at least 10 years! Fries were equally noteworthy!! Best best best meal! Beer selection varied and outstanding and the Aperol Spritz was one of the best I've had. Get yourself to Union and Finch..your taste buds will thank you!!

Ppl of color stay away Severely overrated and don't spend…read moremoney or time here Acting like they don't want to serve you

Bar area

Hawaij seasoned mushrooms on seasoned yogurt

See all

Moroccan Eggs ($13)

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Carmen V.

2 months ago

NYC Village Pizza is hands down one of the best pizza places in the Lehigh Valley! The pizza has an authentic New York-style crust that's perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with fresh ingredients and incredible flavor in every bite. The menu offers a great variety of pizzas, sandwiches, pasta, and appetizers, and everything we've tried has been delicious. The staff is always friendly, welcoming, and provides fast, excellent service. The restaurant is clean, and the atmosphere is perfect for a quick lunch or a casual family dinner. If you're looking for authentic New York-style pizza in Bethlehem, Easton, Allentown, or anywhere in the Lehigh Valley, I highly recommend NYC Village Pizza. Great food, generous portions, fair prices, and outstanding customer service. We'll definitely be coming back! read more

Pádraig S.

7 years ago

Best pizza around, im from new haven ct, the capitol of pizza, everything else in the area is rubber garbage, but this place has the best texture and flavor read more

Monica M.

7 years ago

Delivery was early the food was great and the driver was very polite ty the order was right no problems at all

Jose A.

9 years ago

Never eat their again cheese steak really bad n gyro really bad worst food in Bethlehem pa

Christopher C.

6 years ago

Pizza was good but the beef patties were great. Very nice staff. Will come back again.

Ashley M.

3 years ago

One of the few decent pizzas to eat around here. Place is nice and ordering is easy.

Lyn G.

8 years ago

Great food, great folks, great time!

NYC Village Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Restaurants near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Coffee near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Breakfast near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Things to Do near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Desserts near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Dinner near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Parking near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Burgers near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Shopping near NYC Village Pizza

BEST of Bethlehem, Pennsylvania Movie Theatre near NYC Village Pizza

Best of Bethlehem

Things to do in Bethlehem

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed NYC Village Pizza also viewed

My New Place Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

3.8

(30 reviews)

This is an addition to my previous review! I absolutely…read morelove the food at My New Place. Always very friendly, prompt and eager to give great service, to match the great food! Don't be mislead by the star rate from Yelp! If you haven't tried this restaurant , I highly recommend that you do! Great food, prices and service.

My New Place has redeemed their shameful service with much improved quality of service. The buffalo…read morechicken wrap is now fantastic and doesn't come in soup form. My son gets their California cheese burger and says it's delicious

Antonio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.3

(112 reviews)

The service was superb! The atmosphere was authentic old school New York style with the traditional…read moreItalian music, delicious scratch made food! Portions were well worth the price! Local residents/clients were very friendly and inviting! Hope to get back in town to visit again soon! Ciao!

The "pepperoni roll" is just a stromboli. Nothing rolled about it. Tho good quality i wouldnt have…read moregotten it, too much cheeese. The rice balls were microwaved right in front of me. Overall kindof eh.

Casa di Franco Pizzeria

4.0

(22 reviews)

So I'll start out by saying the food is great. Being from New Jersey, we pride ourselves on two…read morethings: Pizza and Bagels. I'll be the first to say that this is our go-to pizza spot in the Easton area when it comes to your typical takeout "pizza night". It's affordable, staff is friendly, and the Margherita Pizza never disappoints. On the other hand, they seem slightly understaffed. We live a walk away from the restaurant, so when we call ahead for takeout they always say 20 minutes or so. I leave right at the 20 minute mark and get there in about 2 minutes, but still have to wait roughly 10-20 minutes sitting there for the pizza to be done. Probably not your ideal sit-down restaurant for a night out, but solid for takeout. I just wish it wasn't a 40 minute wait for 1 pizza.

Great service and pizza was delicious! Kid friendly and very welcoming. Good place to go to after…read morethe crayola experience.

Pat's Pizza & Bistro

4.2

(176 reviews)

Worth the ride The pizza was real good…read moreThe service was good The place is small but clean. Nothing more I can really say.

I've wanted go here to try a cheesesteak.I got Pat's SPECIAL.NOT a very good! Roll could have. Been…read moregood if not burnt to a crisp. Very little cheese. The fries were exceptional.crusty outside,never had any like them.My wife &I each had a steak & fries with a coke. With tax & 20%tip, total$42.00, not value for the price. Haven't been near the west end In awhile (VERY TRASHY) would NOT RETURN for FOOD or Neighborhood!

Pizza Joe

4.1

(94 reviews)

Stopped by for a few slices; Definitely worth the stop. The Sicilian reminds me ALOT of L&B Spumoni…read moreGardens of Brooklyn. The slice has a good crust, but that light sponge like dough your teeth just sink into. Many sicilians are too dough-y chewey for my liking. This was spot on perfect. This was my FIRST Pennsy Tomato Pie slice It's definitely different, in a good way. The sauce has a sweetness to it, like it should be served with seafood. This would be the perfect slice for a light lunch or even as appetizer. Very impressed. Will definitely be back to Pizza Jo soon.

Slice was not very good. Cheese was tasteless and the sauce was mediocre at best. Pizzas looked…read morelike they were sitting there awhile. Service was slow. No smiles on staff.

La Bella Pizza

4.1

(44 reviews)

Great German Pies. In Florida they do don't know what they are. Always been very good.read more

We just had another birthday party at LaBella's for two of our grandchildren. The staff are very…read moreaccommodating and friendly. The food is always great, making it our favorite place to celebrate! Thank you LaBella's for being such a great family restaurant!

Tonys Pizza

4.4

(57 reviews)

Great food, Friendly staff. Always get take out here it's a weekly go to restaurant! Pizza is…read morealways great.

Excellent Food Excellent service!!!…read moreWe are very proud to refer visitors to our farm to that establishment for their meals

Bruno Scipioni's Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria

3.8

(127 reviews)

Back again, this Wednesday, because our power was out and that large Sicilian pizza left a great…read moreimpression from a previous visit. The highlight of our experience was our server, MASON, whose service was on pointe with a gauged continuum that was refreshing and easy. He mentioned he spends a shift or two in the kitchen helping the cooks with preparing orders. This young man has the right qualities to be something special one day and kudos to his parents. The open dining room is narrow but the table setup worked well in that space, allowing several 4/6 top tables for small groups. Anyhow, the sauce on this pie is the draw because it's very similar to what I ate growing up courtesy of my Nonna and my mom's homemade cooking. The crust is baked just right, topped with quality cheeses and the red pizza sauce was abundant and delicious. As we were waiting for our pizza, we took the opportunity to view all the other entrees served to get an idea what the menu items look like and that frutti de mare is next on my bucket list!! Thank you to the kitchen staff for laboring to serve great food! See you soon.

Been going her for 20 years. Best Italian meals! Meals and Pizza are great. Nice people, clean…read more Never a bad meal. Seafood dinners, Parm dinners, Fettuccine fabulous, even cheese steaks. Calzones are massive. Eatten in and taken out. Family run and the pride shows.

Armando's Express Pizza

3.4

(68 reviews)

Ordered delivery from here just now because it's Friday and I don't feel like cooking…read more Anyway, I ordered a small white pizza w/ pepperoni and a Mediterranean chicken sandwich. Bangin'. Pizza was hot, crust was crunchy, cheese was delicious. And the sandwich? Mm. Fresh mozzarella as stated, chicken seasoned well, warm toasty and fresh bread, and the balsamic vinegarette gave it just the right zest of flavor. Delivery took an hour for a small pizza and chicken sandwich but it did come earlier than the ETA and I had nothing to do anyway while waiting, all good with me. Will order from here again.

I ordered a calzone and a meatball parm sub. The calzone was pretty good, but the marinara sauce…read morewas horrible, I don't think marinara sauce should be orange. The meatball parm had decent meatballs, and a generous amount of cheese, but almost no sauce. Which, considering how bad the sauce was, might have been an unintentional mercy. Three stars is because the calzone was good, if they had good marinara sauce, it would probably be four. The service was decent ( I got mine to go so I really didn't interact that much) and the ambience is pretty much the same as in any small pizza shop.

Sal's Pizza

4.3

(115 reviews)