Great Sicilian great meat lovers pie. Fried calamari was very good BYOB which was great. Service was great and business had a good flow of customers with filled tables as we left at 7. Been going for over 20 years but first time dining in. read more

Slice was not very good. Cheese was tasteless and the sauce was mediocre at best. Pizzas looked like they were sitting there awhile. Service was slow. No smiles on staff. read more

Pizza Joe - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

A CATERING MUST!!!! This is the 2nd time we got catering from here. It's delicious! A few years ago we did the chicken Francese and Caesar salad, and it was a hit! This weekend we did the baked ziti, chicken Marsala, and meatballs... SO GOOD! We were happy to have left overs, so we could enjoy it more ! As an Italian that is used to authentic Italian food, I am picky, and THIS was excellent! read more

Pizza Joe - Catering Menu. Amazing Food! - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Absolute gem. Love Pizza Joes. Has the perfect mix of neighborhood Italian feel with affordable pricing and excellent food. I would eat there every week if my waist line wouldn't suffer. read more

Awesome pizza, and pasta Service is second to none.Good people. Come hungry . You will take some home. read more

Went to Pizza Joe's for a family dinner. Nothing fancy about this Italian restaurant but we've been here before so we know the food is good. The wait staff was terrific, very friendly and helpful. Our party of 8 all ordered different dishes and all were very pleased with their meals. We started with some Calamari and Focaccia bread for the table. The calamari was crispy and delicious, the focaccia was cheesy and scrumptious. I ordered Angel hair pasta with sausage. The sausage was all sliced into pieces. I would have preferred whole sausages but the meal was tasty. My wife had the Chicken Francese which was excellent. I recommend this restaurant for good food and service! read more

See all

Small but, very quaint, service was very good, very friendly and accommodating..Food was like I would make-delicious. I had the fettuccine Alfredo which I ate for two days after because it was such a huge portion.. my friend ordered a pizza which I tasted, which was absolutely delicious. And their prices, are more than reasonable. I plan on going back many many times even though it's not right around the corner from me well worth the drive. read more

Pizza Joe - Fettuccine Alfredo, pizza, and side salad.. - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Great food This was a small calzone and 1/2 small tomato pie Got 4 meals out of them Love it read more

Pizza Joe - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Bruschetta pizza was awesome. Salad was pathetic! Do not get the salad. Ordered a large. Got iceberg lettuce two pieces of tomato, three cucumber slices and white onion rings. read more

We were so happy to have found this pizzeria, we had ordered a tomato pie ( the flavors explode in your mouth, with a sweet twist ) and a Sicilian pie, which was full of flavor and had just the right amount of cheese. Looking forward to coming back and trying there dinners. read more

See all

A friend recently summed up "Pizza Joe" to me they said "its similar to New Jersey pizza." That's exactly how I would describe it... its similar. The standard pies are average they are what you would expect to eat at a low budget kids birthday party, or even watching a football game with the family. Their an average pizza joint in a small town. That in itself is probably about a two star rating in my opinion. What lowers Pizza Joe's rating in my opinion is how they make their Sicilian. Its gross. Like they barley cook it enough for the dough to not be raw, and that's after it sits in a warming oven waiting for you to pick it up. I was reading other reviews about Pizza Joe and the thoughts on the Sicilian seem to be similar. If you like just barley cooked dough this is the place for you. But after eating it, personally I felt sick and gross. My recommendation is you go to Sicily pizza right down the street if you are looking for better pizza in Nazareth, PA. Or maybe just skip it and get a frozen. read more

Love this place for their tomato pie and Sicilian pizza! Scrolling through Facebook one day on an EASTON, PA group post, there was a man you wanted to know the best local place to eat great TOMATO PIE and people listed local pizza places plus others mentioned Giant, Wegmans and Aldi?? Seriously, folks settle for cold, boxed, week old, store shelf tomato pie? I'm thinking they never had PIZZA JOE'S over on lower S Main Street in Nazareth, PA and should stop by and try a few slices and you'll never buy pizza in a supermarket again! And it's the sauce, not bitter, raw, crude but wholesome semi sweet style. Their dinners are substantial and could feed a couple or hearty enough to take home. The staff is always pleasant, hustling and if you want to tread lightly, stop by for Lunch Specials for a taste if their menu. Surely special over all! read more

Gave a local pizzeria a try. Sad to say this place was very disappointing give the other positive reviews. We ordered veggie pizza and a Sicilian. Sicilian was OK, very doughy! The veggie pizza was soggiest pizza we had. Veggies were not fresh at all and looked boiled and watery and mushy which explains why the pizza was soggy and no crisp to the crust. It's pricy for a pizza like that... read more

Pizza Joe - Veggie pizza. Soggy. - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

The Sicilian Pizza is One of the best in this area that's for sure. Haven't tried much on their menu. I usually order my Sicilian pies there. Heard good things about their other dishes. read more

They say when you cross the NJ border into PA it becomes devoid of that NJ/NY wow feeling when you eat pizza. Pizza Joe is the exception. Get the Sicilian and thank me later. All the ingredients are top notch; best mushrooms on a pizza I ever had. The cannolis are as good as little Italy. The atmosphere is quintessential PA Italian with the restaurant occupying a free standing house. This is a family run business and you get service with a smile, I put this in the worth a 30+ minute drive category. read more

Pizza Joe - Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

See all

the best Sicillian pizza in the area . Always great excellent quality ! We drive from center Valley to get the Pizza here . Wish they had a second Location . read more

Ever since our fave pizza place closed, it was hard to find a replacement. Pizza Joe's is cozy and clean and full of Italian menu favorites. One night a week is all you can eat pasta and another night the lasagna special dinner. I ordered the cheesesteak, the cold subs are full of meat and fresh and great. The Siciliano pie slices are $2, saucy and tasty with just enough dough. As you walk the place, assorted pizzas are sitting in the window to order by slice. My other fave is the tomato pie topped with the sweet sauce I grew up eating from my mom's homemade pan pizzas. Anchovies and all! LOL. Make sure to stop by to give it a go. If you don't try it, you won't know what this eatery excels in. And besides NJ and NY, we also know our pizza here In PA! read more

I have been here many times for pick up. The staff is friendly except one young lady my last visit but I will excuse that as she must have been just having a bad day. I enjoy their tomato pie, it is delicious! I do wish they had more vegan options... read more

Pizza Joe - Tomato Pie with one slice already eaten because it is too good! - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Great food! Great people! The pizza is the best around! They're always busy, so you know it's good!

Best Sicilian anywhere. Hoagies are great also. Friendly service too. Very clean resurant

Great pizza!! My husband and I are from NY and this pizza tastes like it followed us from Brooklyn. The crust was just the right thickness, the cheese was generous and not too much sause! Can't wait to go back. read more

Pizza Joe - Large cheese pizza, well done - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

The best pizza I have found since moving to PA.. 20 years ago! Great pizza, great service, close to home, no delivery; or I'd die of a pizza overdose! :) read more

I understand the pizza here is awesome. But, I ordered a cheesesteak to go. If the pizza is so good, I figured the house cheesesteak would be, too. It was absolutely awful. I took 2 bites and in the trash it went. The meat tasted very nasty. I don't recommend ordering a cheesesteak. The young woman at pick up was very polite. Kudos for that. read more

1st time there we ordered a Sicilian pizza, I am not a fan of pizza with the tomato sauce on top of the cheese, but one bite and I was sold. I am from NJ and I know good pizza and this was one of the best, flavor was outstanding, yea it was messy because of the sauce over the cheese but worth every bite. My go to Sicilian pizza place from now on. read more

We just had the most amazing dinner tonight and our waitress (The teacher ) was so attentive & service with a smile... Also the family that owns this little jem is awesome and treat you like family... The food was yummy and the servings were a lot ...‍ read more

My hubby found this place while looking for a casual place for us to have an impromptu date night. What a great find! They were fairly busy when we arrived, but you seat yourself so no big deal. It was probably the fastest we've been waited on in awhile. We no sooner sat in our seat and our waitress was right there. She actually had to wait on us to put our order in. Everything sounded so good it was hard to choose! My hubby went with the Chicken Parm and I opted for the Chicken Florentine. They came with bread and seasoned dipping oil and a salad. Let me tell you, you better not eat all day before coming to this place! The bread and salad were yummy, but the main course...wow! I still can't believe how much food were on our plates! I should have taken a picture, but no phones out on date night. I can tell you I had quite a bit of my Florentine and it didn't look like I touched it. The waitress actually asked if it was ok and if I liked it when I asked for a box. It was incredible! I just couldn't eat that much! My hubby, who always finishes, couldn't finish his either! Pizza Joe was a great find by my husband. I definitely see us returning soon. And a big shout out to the staff there! You were all friendly and smiling. The young girl answering the phone and cashing out, we noticed you too. No sooner putting the phone down and had to answer again for another order. Yet no one seemed stressed or rushed at all. Very nice atmosphere. Well done Pizza Joe staff! read more

Called for 2 orders of fried cauliflower told me 15 turns out it took a half hour Wtf you drop these in a deep fryer i think they more employees and these are greasey as Hell read more

I forgot how great the food is here! Great Sicilian pizza. The specials all sounded wonderful. My wife got a Sample 3 special and she loved it. We had the tomato bruschetta appetizer. It was very fresh and did not disappoint. Friendly, family oriented service. The interior of the space is a lot like I remembered. A bit dated, but the food, service and friendliness more than made up for any of that. Check it out, try the Sicilian for sure! read more

Pizza Joe - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the Lehigh Valley. I don't like the rectangle pizza that places around here make so I didn't try it but the regular pizza is so good we keep going back and back. read more

Very very good pizza. The pizza here is some of the best we have found in the area! Great staff and pick up system!

Pizza Saturday #5. Coronavirus may have cancelled school, but not pizza saturday. The board of judges met up again to judge yet another Nazareth pizza place, and let me tell you, this one was a smash hit. Great taste, crunchy crust, and the sauce wasn't too overwhelming, which was an issue we ran into at some other restaurants. In conclusion, damn good pizza. 93/100 read more

Amazing food and staff! Their food and service never disappoint! Always satisfied after eating there!

We found this place on yelp and we were very pleased. The one thing that amazed me was they had tripe on the menu. As a Brooklyn Italian living in NEPA for 25 years, I have never seen tripe on a menu here. They listed it with spaghetti but my husband ordered it without. He said it was very good. We ordered a large Sicilian and it came "upside down" style. The cheese under the sauce. They boys really liked it. I had the large tossed salad and instead of chicken I asked for grilled shrimp on top. It was no problem to sub. The amount of shrimp was ample. Salad could have been drier but it was good. Service was excellent. It's a no frills mom and pop pizzeria, right up our alley. read more

So the first time i went to pizza joe we got the sciallian pizza the crust was good and the pizza was the breaded chicken calazone was goood and and we got the calamari it was good so that's why i did 5 stars read more

This pizza is fan-freaking-tastic!!! I can't believe I lived in Nazareth for 6 months, tried 4 different pizza shops, and it took this long to find this place. Pizza Joe's pizza is THE best pizza in Nazareth. The wife got a cheese sub and mozzy sticks. They were so-so. Now she's eyeing up my pizza. I'm not going to share this deliciousness with the likes of her. read more

Pizza Joe - Pizza Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

See all

The BEST pizza in Nazareth. We tried every pizza joint in Nazareth and don't get me started on Sicily's. The pizza is rock solid but the other food is great too. The large cheese steak is enough for three people to eat and it's only 10 bucks. The garlic knots are like a loaf of bread and are amazing, but they could use more olive oil when served. The pasta dishes for take out are huge too. Try the vodka sauce with chicken, totally on point and amazing. Drive by the other pizza joints and visit Joes. Family run restaurant and it shows. Bravo!!!! read more

This place was overwhelming for me. We did order a lot of food but was not informed by our server that wait staff that the portions are the size of Jupiter. Everyone thing was fantastic though and we he had a lot to take home and have yummy left overs. read more

We have been here several times in the past month. The pizza is amazing. We did get a stuffed pizza one time and it was just too much cheese and grease. But their regular pizzas are outstanding. The service is good too. We pass up a lot of pizza places to drive here. read more

Ordered a take-out "Tomato Pie" on recommendations from several people, and also a standard issue pizza. It was my first time trying a tomato pie, and I found the sauce to be rather sweet -- but it was tasty enough, a rather nice variation. The standard pizza was very average in flavor, crust, texture, toppings -- not something I'd run back for. (But that's not too much of a criticism, since I still haven't found a good pizza in the Lehigh Valley.) Given that "Pizza Joe" bustles on a Saturday evening -- lots of people coming and going, dine-in, take-out, etc., I can see it's a favorite with the locals. I'd be curious to see what other Yelpers think of Joe's Tomato Pie. read more

This is my new pizza place. Awesome pizza and to die for bruschetta. The cheesesteaks are NOT good but everything else is very good. Low prices. Definitely a good spot to go if you're in the Nazareth area. read more