We found Mighty Fine Donuts while searching for coffee shops on Yelp. Since Yelpers can be pretty critical, we were impressed to see so many glowing reviews and a solid 4-star rating -- so we hopped in the car to check it out. The case was full of tempting choices, and everything looked amazing. The maple cream donut was absolute heaven -- the glaze had just the right touch of maple to balance the thick, tender dough. The edges were perfectly crispy, and the texture was unlike any donut I've ever had. The glazed twist was equally delicious. The coffee was very good, though a little too hot to enjoy right away. The only real downside was the lack of seating -- no tables or chairs inside, despite the large open lobby, and no benches outside either. We ended up eating in the car. That said, the donuts were so good we went back in for more. Definitely worth the stop! It was so good, we brought friends with us the following morning because donuts this good need to be shared with friends. And best of all...maybe prices were insanely cheap!!! No wonder people were walking out with two and three dozen... read more

Donuts were disgusting!! They definitely are not the same as old owners . They only had about a teaspoon of filling in them and the outside was dry. Will Never go back. Can by much better donuts at Wegmans. read more

These might be the best donuts I've ever had! Tons of options. Taste fresh and delicious. The cream filled maple bacon eclair is out of this world. The cream filled chocolate eclair is rich and decadent. The donut holes are huge, sweet, yeasty and perfectly fried. Went two days in a row, they were that good! Service was friendlier on the second visit, than the first. There's a large area inside but no seating. That seemed odd until I watched the whole area fill up with a line of people. Go. Go back. You won't be disappointed! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

People were lining up to get their morning orders in. Great service and a classic feel that we certainly love. I really like the cream that is not too sweet. It's not overpowering which I love. The peanut butter cream was definitely my favorite and a must try for any of the peanut butter fans out there. I would be here all the time if it was local to us. read more

See all

Delicious donuts. There are various selections to choose from. We tried Glazed twists (local favs), maple bacon, apple fritter and peanut butter cream, and love everything! The staff is super nice. Will be back read more

See all

Great donuts - great variety- best donuts between Cleveland and Erie PA!! Favorite was Peanuts crusted - read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - Peasnut crusted donuts - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

They're the best for a reason! Fresh donuts each time and large selection to pick from.

It's been years since I've had Might Fine Donuts and after trying them last week I'm kicking myself for not going back sooner!! Good variety, not greasy. Icing was delicious on the different donuts. If you haven't been in a while you have to go back! read more

I have to admit. I don't feel good about only giving three stars to Mighty Fine. I am a fan of any neighborhood favorite business that has been around for generations. I am impressed by businesses that stay largely unchanged for decades, still able to bring people in with the same solid business plan. Mighty Fine must be doing something good for its customers and I'm happy for that - but I would not recommend driving out of your way off the highway to make a stop here if you're hunting for amazing donuts. The bad: The inside of the business looked a bit worn out and neglected, the automatic cappuccino machine in the corner looked like something you'd find in a gas station. There was no place to sit and enjoy your donuts in the business, just a big empty space that looked like it had tables and chairs at one point, or perhaps that empty space is needed to host the morning rush indoors when it's frigid outside... The actual donuts we got were just nothing special (I know, it was 3pm - but one test of a good donut is how it tastes when it's more than two hours old). We got a regular glazed, cherry cake (best of the three we got), and chocolate cake. I would rank most donut chains to have better donuts at 3pm. The good: There was a line of about 8 people at 3pm (which was a good sign!) and the employee behind the counter was very patient and helpful for one particular customer who took over 5 minutes to make a selection. read more

Erie classic! Their donuts are amazing, coffee is great, and they recently updated the place. Everyone is super nice and will make recommendations for what is new and popular. It's a really nice place inside, and great location read more

This is my go to place for donuts, whenever I go to ohio I have to take with me because my family asks for them all the time! The service is always good! And plenty of donuts to choose from read more

I love their powdered fry cake. There's a ton of powdery sugar goodness that gets all over your clothes and car if you're not careful (this might've been my situation during our car ride home lol), but it's definitely worth it. The prices can't be beat, the employees are very kind, and I love the old school vibes. The sign itself is so nostalgic as are the cafeteria looking price/item signs. When we're in Erie, this is a must stop. read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - My husband loves the custard eclair but my favorite is the powdered fry cake. So delicious - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Best doughnuts ever! Super fresh doughnuts. Everyone should try them, they'll never buy others.

Good old fashioned donuts. Got two dozen assorted. Brought them to a client and they were gone so fast!!

Ok don't get me wrong I love a great donut. They had 4 different types of fritters. So I get all 4. They all tasted just like the apple. Just added different fruit to the same mix. Cinnamon goes good with apples. But not the rest. Don't know if this is being lazy. Or don't have a clue. What a shame read more

Fantastic old school donuts. Maple glazed w/ cream are a favorite. I always buy several half dozen boxes when I'm in the area for business. I hand them out to my customers and they love them! Locals know that they are the best. read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - 6 packs - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

The place I think of when I think donuts. Moved to Erie in 1983 and Mighty Fine provided donuts to the lunch room at the place I first worked. So sad there is only one location left. read more

The perfect donut shop does exist and this is it. I made a special detour at 6:30 am to get breakfast and I knew I was in the right place when I saw people standing in line to order that early in the morning. The interior is like a 70s time capsule- including a majestic velvet painting of a ship- and I am here for it!! I got a 1/2 dozen including blueberry & apple fritters, maple bacon, a twist, and a cream filled chocolate round and eclair. Holy smokes, they were all perfect: flavor, texture, portion, everything. Excellent customer service. I would come back to Erie just to get more Mighty Fine Donuts! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - the outside of a restaurant - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Mighty Fine Donuts is a staple in Erie, PA. As someone who doesn't really like donuts all that much, I was really confused when I moved to Erie and everyone, and I mean everyone, would rave over Mighty Fine. As you can probably guess by the 5 star review, Mighty Fine Donuts are REALLY good. And again, I don't really like donuts, so that's saying a lot. I've been in multiple times and the service has always been great. The workers are very kind and patient, regardless of how busy they are. They also recently redid the outside of the shop, and it looks great! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

So we were in town for a couple of days and looking for a quick on the go breakfast so we checked this place out. So glad we did! Old school donut shop in every sense of the word, including pricing! We got a 1/2 dozen donuts, two large coffees and 2 bagels and it was under $9! And the donuts, ohhh the donuts. Soooo good. Light, fresh and so flavorful. We tried a Bavarian Creme, Maple Creme, Maple pinwheel, coconut fry cake and our favorite...the Glazed Twist. So good, we stopped in again on our last morning in Erie on the way out of town. read more

See all

Everyone locally hypes this place up. I don't think it lives up to that hype. It's good donuts that are fresh with a nice variety. The pricing isn't terrible. I was warned the area may not be the safest but I felt safe. Easy enough to just go in and out but also small seating area to enjoy the snack. Pricing: 4/5 Food: 4/5 read more

Mighty Fine Donuts are the best donuts. It's not even close. While I rarely eat fried dessert for breakfast ... when I do, these are to die for. I can't understand how one could live in Erie County and not seek out Mighty Fine for all your donut wants, needs, and desires... Tip your server and cashier. This place is a friggin gem. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts has some mighty fine Donuts if I do say so myself. Corny? Sue me. I was in Erie last week for work and needed a quick breakfast so I settled on the unhealthiest thing I could find, donuts! I came here around 9AM and the place was pretty packed (everyone need donuts on Wednesday, I get it). I waited in line a bit which gave me the freedom to stare at all of the different kinds of donuts they had which kind of overwhelmed my stomach. When I finally got to the front I settled on a sprinkle donut and a chocolate pinwheel (basically just a donut with chocolate on top and on the Inside). What blew me away was that these donuts both same to around $3.50 total and that is magnificent. The Donuts themselves were above average and left me full for a few hours but the main reason I'm giving this place 5 stars is for the massive selection and the incredible prices. I will definitely be stopping back in the next time I'm in town! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - Look at these sprinkles. - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

I'm from out of town and grabbed a couple dozen based on the Yelp review. The person behind the counter was SO helpful! Picked out what he knew to be best sellers and they were gone in no time! I didn't know I hit a local hot spot. Thanks for great service and the amazing donuts! read more

I wish we had stopped to take a picture, but I don't even think they made it out of the car! The donuts we had from Mighty Fine definitely lived up to their name. We had a coconut cake donut, one filled with yellow custard , a glazed puffy one (what's that kind called?), a cinnamon one and two others we inhaled before we even knew their names. They were delicious! We got there at just the right time because there was no line, but by the time we finished deciding what to get a small line had begun to form. The folks working there were friendly and patient, and seemed welcoming of our oohing and aahhing. The location was easy to find and free on street parking was ample. The whole shop was inviting and understated - nothing fancy except for the delicious goodies. This is definitely on our list of must-do things in Erie. 10 stars! The whole galaxy! read more

Yes they have delish donuts! Not the best in Erie but the best glazed twist and fritters. 4/5 stars due to the long crazy lines and the slow service. Had to leave a few times due to the line not moving. Their yeast donuts are much better than their cake/ fry cake donuts. read more

I consider Mighty Fine to be the best donut shop in Erie, Pennsylvania. Before returning to Pittsburgh, my family always stops at Mighty Fine. The selection alone is impressive and the people who work here are always kind and attentive. Overall a wonderful establishment- an absolute gem! read more

Went to buy some donuts today and when I ordered the girl reached for a bag to put them in. I asked to have the donuts put in a box and she said that will be an additional 50 cents for the box. .Seriously you don't already have the cost of the box factored into the price of the donuts? How would chocolate frosted cream filled donuts or any type like that not get ruined in a bag? What a mess it would be. I decided I didn't need them since they would be all squished anyway and just left. I hope the new owners don't continue to charge an additional fee to have your donuts in a box. What's next? Bring your own box? Maybe the pizza shops are going to start making you bring your own box to pick up your pizza. Ridiculous, just ridiculous. read more

Best around . Great selection and price for the product is very reasonable . Doughnuts are fresh as well as pastries. Only game in town now on the east side read more

Best donuts in Erie! The are always fresh and go over great for early morning meetings. Would def recommend might fine over some of the franchises like Tim Hortons, Dunking, Krispy, ect. read more

Their donuts are amazing! I love when they do all their specialties, too! Quick and friendly service!

Best donut place in town! Prices are right and great selection! Local icon here in Erie! Yes for Mighty Fine!!!

Best doughnut you will ever eat, and if anyone disagrees, I'll fight you. I will not be taking comments

The best donuts I ever had! Made fresh and they don't skimp on filling, glaze and most of all flavor. What even makes the donut shop better are the employees! So helpful, patient and kind! read more

Best donuts in Erie. Nothing else needs to be said. But then warm, right out of the oven is best

Best donuts ever! I've been eating these since I was a small child. Always fresh, always delicious!

I was doing business in Erie for Fat Tuesday (donut day) and I googled local donut spots. I decided on Mighty Fine Donuts and was not disappointed. The location is far from fancy but the kind of place that I would expect a great fried pastry and cup of coffee. The workers were super pleasant even though they were busy. The donuts themselves were some of the best I've had. The coffee was basic diner coffee but the name of the place isn't Mighty Fine Coffee. This is one of those hole-in-the-wall spots that everyone needs to visit when in Erie, PA. I highly recommend read more

If you don't like Mighty Fine Donuts, then move to Canada. The best donuts ever. Show your love and support local.

This is the very best Donut Shop in Erie. Never a disappointment. My hubby eats Donuts as one of the 3 main food groups, so we have sampled them all. Maple anything is great. But hey, their pain glazed are amazing. read more

Erie's best donuts! The shop itself is rough around the edges but the donuts never disappoint. The twists are my favorite. The cake donuts are smaller but dense. They've been in business for over 50 years for good reason! read more

Mighty Fine Donuts - Maple ring, maple cream, two chocolate cake donuts, two glazed twists - Bagels Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania