I ordered take out & it was delivered, so I can say nothing more other than my review of the food, which I thought was very good. I had eggplant parm, a friend ordered another pasta dish & we both had leftovers!! The meals came w/garlic rolls & Italian bread & were just as delicious. I wouldn't mind eating @the restaurant next time I'm in the area! read more

Tried a pretty solid selection of items here. None of which were above average except for 1. Pizza: always undercooked and soggy, not super interesting and you really need to put a lot of stuff on it to make it taste good. Football pizza that would be acceptable in comparison to Dominoes but nothing to travel for. 2/5 Garlic Knots: Look amazing. Completely flavorless 1/5 Nancy's wings: Weird taste. Super odd flavor we all agreed. We needed to completely cover the taste with hot sauces and ranch. Not good. 1/5 Cheesesteak Sandwich: Excellent! Like a completely different restaurant made it. 5/5 Will we be back? Probably not. read more

In a word...Wow. The food was absolutely amazing! Service was just as great, and our server made sure we had everything we needed when we needed it. Nice and quiet inside where the Mrs. and I enjoyed our date night. We'll definitely be back! read more

The food, service, outdoor dining, prices, variety, are all great. My NY relatives always enjoy eating here when they visit - especially the pizza! read more

This is one of the few pizza restaurants we hadn't tried, so we gave it a whirl. It's small inside, but super clean and well laid-out. There's also an outdoor dining space near the road. We ordered garlic knots and a pepperoni pizza, two good indicators of their food quality. The garlic knots were very good and came with a red sauce for dipping that was outstanding. I'm not a big fan of overly sweet marinara, and this was perfect, and not sweet at all. They use the large deli sized pepperoni for their pies, which had just a touch of spice. The crust is thin even around the edges, so it's not real fattening. Great taste to the pie and cheese/sauce mix. Pretty damn close to the classic northeastern pies I've had in NY and NJ. Can't wait to come back and try the other items read more

Recently went here for the first time and enjoyed it! The service was fast and friendly. The servers working the counter and the kitchen all seemed busy and helpful. The food was delicious! The lasagna was different from what I was used to but I would definitely recommend it to anyone who likes lasagna! Great family friendly atmosphere! read more

Great place Super clean Great food fresh Nice staff Open late Will return to Nancy's! read more

This food was so delicious, coming from Buffalo New York we know pizza and this is spot on with variety and taste. The pasta was really good. It was a very cool environment and especially clean. i would highly recommend the veggie and Hawaiian pizza. The staff is super friendly and helpful. read more

$19.95 For chicken marsala which is nothing like the description on the menu no Romano no wild mushrooms... Three Ultra thin chicken cutlets from Publix, marsala sauce from a jar and a few sliced white mushrooms... When I called back and spoke to the manager he said well that's what it is nothing to be done... My reply was well you got me once... Never again. Used to eat in.... Been taught... if I ever return... never use takeout. read more

Nancy's Pizza is a great family owned pizza (and so much more ) restaurant in Stuart. I've been doing virtual lunches , so I've had to find places to deliver food to offices. They have come through twice this week making a few of my VIP offices very happy. The staff is very friendly. read more

The lunch specials were a good value, the pizza slices were tasty and the wings were simply average. The house salad with balsamic was a very nice, fresh side to my slice. The service was prompt and friendly. All-in-all average, not great but a decent work lunch. read more

Authentic Italian fare served in a warm family atmosphere. Top notch quality ingredients and good portions make this one of my favorite go-to spots for pizza and stromboli, and the friendly service is definitely a plus. Try their meatballs on a pizza - pure heaven! read more

Came tonight for our 30th wedding anniversary We love this place. We're from Sebastian and come to Stuart as often as we can. We always order or come to Nancy's. Love supporting small businesses. Had spaghetti and meatballs. Very very good. My husband ordered the Buffalo chicken calzone. Everything was fresh and tasty. We had 3 people ask for our drink order in less than 2 min of sitting down. read more

Came through for my cheat day. A huge crowd, band playing and the place was hoppin. Cool energy, very friendly staff and quickly got seated. Grabbed a beer and ordered and before I was done with my brew, the pizza arrived! Top notch service guys, great pizza. read more

Michele's cuicina - The supreme! - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

I stop here all the time when I'm in Stuart. Of course, I wouldn't keep coming back, if it weren't great, and a great value. read more

See all

We saw the great reviews on this spot and it was close to the beach so we stopped in. It was empty with employees staring you down the whole time. Their pizza was ooey gooey. $2.55/cheese slice. Not bad! I received my slice in less than 5 minutes so I was happy. read more

See all

Definitely recommend stopping in to eat at Nancy's! The garlic knots, spaghetti and meatballs and cannolis were amazing! Everything taste homemade and fresh! read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

We started with the garlic knots and I ordered the Burrata pizza with added grilled chicken, spinach and mushrooms. Hands down this place was amazing, the pizza crust was crispy, flavor was off the chart; the garlic knot was fluffy with generous amounts of garlic and that marinara sauce is incredible! I'd been eyeing this place since it opened last year! It was worth the wait! The staff was friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back to try more items. read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic Knot - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

I'd heard good things about the food at Nancy's and decided to try it out. The Pasta Fagioli was really quite good. Unfortunately, I could only taste the fried part of the eggplant with almost no sauce on the Eggplant Parm and the ziti was pretty tasteless. Stick to the pizza! read more

The food was delicious......the waite staff great........clean......and there was outside seating. Unfortunately this outside seating will go away once things get back to "normal". I'll be back again soon. read more

This is legitimate New York pizza with none of the attitude. The nicest staff. The biggest slices. The freshest topics. The best sauce on the za. You can't go wrong. You will be back. There is no other spot to grab Sicilian pasta, pizza, and knots. Super newbie for Stuart. read more

Michele's cuicina - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

The pizza is delicious!!! The garlic knots, YUM!!service was spectacular! Would recommend to all to go try it!

I sat down for a window slice and a chicken parm sandwich the other night and I was very glad I did. I really enjoyed my food and the service was spectacular. The pizza was perfect. Excellent crisp! Especially for a meat lover slice! A lot of the time Meat lovers is floppy and greasy but this one was beautiful. I loved the bread they use for the chicken parm sandwich. I told myself I was going to take half the sandwich home but I ate the whole thing... it was too good. read more

I come here often. I love the normal way of life (mask optional!). The staff is always quick to help and my wait time is almost no wait for take out. When I dine in I always get quick service and the family friendly staff makes my experience great. The place is spotless. Chicken parm sub, penne ala vodka, and chicken parm Stromboli are my favorites. The huge portion sizes make it true Italian. I love the huge pizza slices and the selection is always changing. Lastly you need to try the stuffed zeppolis. Thanks Jeff for always throwing in the dessert. read more

We tried Nancy's out for dinner on the 4th of July. Our waiter was friendly, helpful, and prompt. We ordered garlic knots, 2 pizzas, a kid sized pizza, and a flatbread. The garlic knots were amazing and the marinara sauce was simply delicious. Everyone enjoyed the pizza selections and the "secret recipe" soda. The space was very clean & comfortable. I enjoyed the family pictures being hung on the wall. I love to know that I am supporting a small business and not a big chain. We will be back! read more

First time visit. I would recommend it to my friends and family. The food was very good, the restaurant clean and the service was excellent.

I found their meatball hero to be the best in town although only slightly better than Vesuvio's which is a couple bucks cheaper. Being an investor in a business which is impacted by Yelp reviews I tend to focus on service and quality rather than masks or cops eating in a place and try and not cancel culture places for reasons irrelevant to me. If you don't like the vibe don't go back simple!!!!! Yelp admin needs to get a handle on politicization of reviews. I will return to Nancy's and hope you do too support locally owned restaurants and the people that choose to work. read more

All three. Food Service great for being new and speak Mexican. Ambiance restaurant beautiful

Ordered delivery, food was awesome! Arrived within the timeframe they said and hot. Everyone was friendly from the person who took the order to the delivery person. We had pene a la vodka with sausage and spaghetti with meatballs. Big portions so be hungry! read more

The food is amazing, and the services is even better. We are visiting family from Cleveland but originally from NJ and looking on yelp saw they had a Taylor Ham pizza!! It turns out it was the special and they did not have it tonight but when they heard how excited we were to try it, they ran out and got Taylor Ham to make it for us. Above and beyond! Would definitely recommend! read more

Michele's cuicina - Taylor Ham Pizza! - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Stopped in to try the pizza and really liked it! Sammy was our waitress and was very attentive. Sammy was our waitress and was very attentive! read more

Michele's cuicina - Margherita pizza - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Excellent burrata, meatballs, and sausage with broccoli rabe appetizers. For a main course I enjoyed Nancy's baked wings. They were excellently seasoned with roasted garlic and herbs. Seating is limited so it's not ideal for large groups. The only thing I can suggest to improve the food is the salad dressings. I would have given a perfect score for homemade ranch to dip those wings. Overall a great experience. I recommend. read more

Great food every visit! New favorite for us. Been consistent over the last couple years- pizza, salad, chicken, meatballs, desserts! Mmmm

This was hands down the best Italian restaurant I have EVER been to. We picked eating here because it was close to our hotel but we are already planing a trip with our family to share the amazing cuisine with them. The fettuccine is incredible. The lemon cello is muah! Thank you Nancy's for the best food in all of Florida! read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic knots with shaved garlic - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Great pizza. Cool staff and good service. I'm so tired of soggy floppy pizza with great globs of cheese. This was nice thin crust, no flop, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, and real pepperoni that was delicious. New York style! (One bite, everybody knows the rules!) Had the limoncello cake for desert. It too was awesome. read more

My husband and I decided to try Nancy's Pizza, and we are so happy we did. The pizza was amazing. The crust was perfect crunchiness on the bottom while still being chewy on top without being under cooked. As for the pizza the sauce was perfectly proportion to the toppings, so no one flavor was more than the other. The garlic knots and sauce were definitely delicious. The staff is very friendly and the atmosphere made you feel like home. We will definitely be back. read more

Michele's cuicina - Garlic knot - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

The food is here is FREAKING FANTASTIC! Supreme pizza, wings, garlic knots, stuff shells, but the Buffalo Chicken Calzone was read more

See all

4th visit, solo this time. Still impressed with the great service and amazing food. Taylor was great and the kitchen is outstanding read more

Michele's cuicina - Interior - Italian Near Me - Stuart, Florida

See all

Thank you Michelle, Jeff and Eduardo!! You made our Friday night wonderful! The pizza was delicious as always and I was beyond impressed with this dessert! read more

See all

We live out of town in Boca and we are surrounded by great restaurants. We came here merely on the reviews. Great staff. Wonderful food. Welcoming environment. Don't listen to any of the silly negative reviews! This place is a gem little hole in the wall and the best kept secret in town. Great all the way around! read more