Michele's cuicina

Best pizza I've had since I left Jersey in 2019. I've tried a lot of pizza since we moved here and…read moreI mean a lot of pizza but Brooklyn Joe's is the best hands down! I would highly recommend but definitely you will need a bib as the grease needs about a roll of paper towels lol! Yum!!!

Came up to Stuart for the Air show and was craving pizza after going to the gym read the reviews…read moreand had to try since the pizza place we normally go to was closing at 8pm. Great Chicago style pizza

The front of the restaurant

1/2 Greek and 1/2 White with Pepperoni

See all

Sicilian pizza with sausage, green peppers and black olives

Fantini's Italian Restaurant featuring New Haven Style Apizza

4.2(381 reviews)

2.5 mi

Over $100 for meatballs, a pizza, and a couple of beers each? Yeah, that hurts a little…read more But when they personally transport you to New Haven, Connecticut with every bite, you forgive a lot. The meatballs were absolutely fantastic -- easily 5 out of 5. Then came the tomato pie, with fresh chopped tomatoes on every slice, and it was phenomenal. This is the kind of pizza where you take the first bite and immediately understand what they're trying to do. Yes, it's expensive, but it's worth it. The food was fantastic, and if New Haven pizza is what you're chasing, Fantini's gets you pretty damn close without buying the plane ticket. .

I saw pics on Yelp of their authentic Neapolitan pizza and would have liked to try one of their…read moregreat looking pizzas, but they were all too big for 1 person traveling...perhaps next time. So I ordered their calamari because in the pics it looked lightly breaded and they include the tentacle pieces, which are my favorite part, and pictured was a lemon aioli sauce, as well as marinara sauce. But when I asked about the lemon aioli sauce they said that they normally didn't include it anymore, but would give me some. It was a late to go order, so I ordered the calamari, a meatball sub and the classic tiramisu dessert. The calamari did not disappoint me and was the best I have had in a loooong time! It was lightly breaded, crispy, but not overcooked, and the lemon aioli sauce was a perfect sauce to dip the pieces in and not overpower the flavor of the calamari. I ate almost all of the large portion. But I wish I could order a half order next time, in order to get a smaller portion of several different items, for more variety for us single people that don't have people with us to share bigger portions. The meatball sub was good too; the meatballs are good and the bread is great and sturdy enough to not soak up too much of the marinara sauce and fall apart. My only complaint is that the 'marinara' sauce tasted more like tomato paste than a marinara sauce; I did not like their marinara sauce. And I would pay for extra mozzarella cheese if I ordered this again. But I did eat much of the huge sandwich and wish I could have gotten a smaller 1/2 portion. I highly recommend their excellent classic tiramisu, which is so good you will eat it all and wish you had more!! One of the best you'll ever have.

Dining room.

Tiramisu

See all

Broccoli rabe

Vesuvios Pizzeria

4.5(161 reviews)

3.3 mi

Absolutely delicious! Garlic rolls at 3 or 6 = Amazingness…read morein your Mouth! The two pizza slices and drink special?= delicious and amazing!!!!! Pepperoni and sausage pizza slices AMAZING! I'll definitely be back with my husband!

So disappointed. Not sure if the restaurant changed ownership or what happened but it is not the…read moresame food. We got pizza, which we didn't finish, no more garlic knots....these were like a garlic pizza which was not half as good as the garlic knots. We also ordered chicken franchise which was ok, meatballs and ziti which were not as good as well. So sad, this was one of our favorites.

A slice of pepperoni and sausage.

Vesuvio's Meat Amore (we did ours without bacon)

See all

The dessert case

Uncle Giuseppe's Lil Bit A Brooklyn

4.3(369 reviews)

1.7 mi

FYI- this is my go to Italian restaurant Constantly…read moredelicious food! Good service and a nice atmosphere...you can NEVER go wrong with coming for a delicious meal!! Pictured is the veal chop...We had the other night with chicken franchise! And don't forget their tiramisu for dessert!!

Service perfect food perfect atmosphere perfect. Our preferred place for Italian.appreciated the…read moreslide show on big tv of places in Italy so we can reminisce about all our travels. Our beautiful server is from Sicily that's a plus!!! Eggplant was perfect nice portion.. I had cheesecake which is perfection !!

Uncle Giuseppe's

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

See all

Signage

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

3.7(157 reviews)

1.5 mi

Recently had a milestone birthday party catered by ACFP in Stuart. Manager Kristie went above and…read morebeyond to help make the experience as smooth and easy as possible. She was very professional, extremely helpful and made sure everything was included to make for a wonderful experience! The food was great and enjoyed by nearly 50 people at the party! Great job, Kristie and thank you for everything.

Pizza was soooo burnt-to the point of reeking. Why would you actually serve that one? The Caesar…read moresalad was stupid small, with barely any toppings. $20 for that?? For a small amount of lettuce? Do better, bc you're looking like thieves.

Meatball Ricotta 12"

Gluten White 12" Gluten-Free

See all

Mike's Hot Honey & Burrata Pizza

Tutto Italiano

4.1(112 reviews)

5.2 mi

Best pizza ever! And the chicken franchise is awesome. We have been coming here for years. We love…read moreall the folks there. It's my neighborhood favorite!

Was suggested to go here by a friend. We were not happy years ago. But it's under new owners…read more A small little restaurant on cove plaza. Restaurant is warm ambiance with Italian decor. Our waiter Tony aka Kyle- was very professional, friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. He spoke a little Italian with my husband. The food was very impressive. I forgot to take a photo of the homemade cannoli and the cappuccino, was icing on the cake. The chefs came to talked to us. Chef Tino came from Italy, he spoke to my husband in Italian which was sweet. Overall, we will go again. We love the staff's. Thank you

The calm before the storm...

Arugula Salad!

See all

So cute interior

Big Apple Pizza & Pasta

3.3(60 reviews)

2.2 mi

I ordered a pizza & garlic knots at 4:30 in the afternoon. I requested ASAP for the delivery. We…read moredidn't receive our pizza until 6:25PM. The driver said they gave him a bad address. I gave the restaurant my correct address 4 times and they still got it wrong. The pizza had a good flavor but of course it wasn't hot. Neither were the garlic knots. Never again will I order a Big Apple pizza. Their customer service is the worst.

This pizza is awesome! Having had pizza all over I love to try different places…read more Big Apple is simple, but delicious! We got a pepperoni pizza and meatballs, savory and delicious! Can't wait to try more pizza from here! Check them out if you are in the area!

Inside dining area/open kitchen concept

Garlic Knots - 1/2 Dozen

See all

Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza

3.5(237 reviews)

2.0 mi

Website is Terrible can't change orders They don't answer…read moretheir phones Tried different numbers Gong show They apologized they were closed ‼ website needs work

Lunch today took a friend from church close by st Mary's . Service by Laura was excellent you can…read moretell she is a happy people person and loves her job! Food always consistent fresh and hot . Wish I had room for desert!

Sign inside

Pizza

See all

Piatto Divino

4.6(50 reviews)

2.3 mi

Thank you yelpers. We love to travel for good food. This is place is about 35 minutes from home but…read moreso worth it. I would recommend reservations. We walked in and were greeted and seated right away. I read the reviews about the margarita pizza but after looking at the restaurant we wanted to try the pasta as well. We had the Scoglio linguine which is seafood pasta. The fish is so fresh and with of pasta which was cooked perfect. My husband had the pappardelle braised beef short rib ragu. Everything was absolutely delicious. We highly recommended this place. The owner is present and very friendly. They also have a nice selection of wine and desserts.

Always a great experience and meal at Piatto Divino! The service is always spot-on and food never…read morefails to impress!!

Empty restaurant

See all

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza

4.1(289 reviews)

0.6 mi

Great pizza and very polite and efficient service. This was an order on line for pick up and no…read moreproblems.

I had heard great things about Pusateri's Chicago Pizza and was looking forward to finally trying…read moreit. Unfortunately, that opportunity never happened. Their posted hours indicate they are open until 8:00 p.m. Since my wife and I typically go out to dinner around 7:30-8:00 p.m., this was the first time we were able to arrive before closing. We walked in at approximately 7:25 p.m., expecting to have dinner, only to be told they were no longer accepting dine-in orders and were serving takeout only. If your posted closing time is 8:00 p.m., customers should reasonably expect to be able to dine in until then--or at the very least, there should be a clearly posted notice stating that dine-in service ends earlier. Instead, we made the trip only to be turned away. We eat out five or six nights a week and typically spend $70-$90 for dinner with drinks and tip. We were ready to become regular customers if the pizza lived up to its reputation, but first impressions matter. We left without ordering and, unfortunately, won't be back. Businesses have every right to establish their own policies, but those policies should match the hours they advertise so customers don't waste a trip.

See more unrecommended reviews

Chicago Pizza

Place an order with us!

See all

Place an order with us!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

56 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

James B.

7 years ago

Just had a quick dinner at Nancy's. All I can say is it's the best we've found in Stuart. First, there's quite a bit to choose from on the menu. We had pizza and it was great. The crust was thin and firm. The sauce was amazing. We learned everything they serve is homemade. the dough, sauce...the whole deal. We had the opportunity to chat with one of the owners (Jeff) and after talking to him it's clear their goal is to make the customer happy. Whatever you want...ask and they'll try to make it happen. The last part is the great music. They played a song that is my wife and I's favorite, so we danced and they turned up the music. I explained we have only been married three years. But we're both widowed and in our 70s. We all had fun and will definitely be back. oh, and Taylor is a great server as well. read more

D F.

7 years ago

Stumbled into Nancy's Pizza looking for a new local pizza joint as I moved down here recently. I was greeted by Nancy herself who has the most welcoming personality. She hooked me up with some garlic knots to start and then I had to try a regular plain slice as I am from New York and you can tell a lot about a place by their plain slice. Well to say the least, the slice and garlic knots were both just as good as New York City. So I said ya know what, let me try some rigatoni with meatballs! As you guessed that was just as good as anywhere. The pasta was cooked just right and the Meatball itself was made just like my nonna did back in the day! I hope this place is around for a long time! The staff was great, the food was great and the beer and wine pairings are awesome. Most definitely will be back! read more

Marion H.

7 years ago

My fiancé and I went to Nancy's this past weekend for the first time. We were very pleasantly surprised!! We went in, seated straight away. Service was very good an attentive! We ordered a garlic knot each to try them, they were out of this world!! Then the pizza, the cheese was so flavorful, the crust was thin and crunchy, and some of the best pizza I have had. As we were eating, the owner came by to say hello and asked how we were, nice touch. Then to our surprise, he brought us a sample of an Italian dessert. It starts with a 'z' and it's was cannoli cream filled fried dough. Oh my good gravy! They were good!! We will definitely be back and recommend this place to everyone!! Kudos to the owners!! read more

Jaclyn A.

7 years ago

Great food, excellent service and a friendly attentive staff make Nancy's a true gem! I visited for the first time Tuesday night. Hurricane Dorian had just spared us and we decided to go out for a bite to eat. So glad we did! Because of the storm they only had a limited menu but what we had was AMAZING...I had the Stuffed shells, my daughter had the ravioli. We both chose Nancy's sauce and I have been dreaming of it ever since. Delicious! Speaking of Nancy, she is the owners daughter and we were lucky enough to have her as our server. She is awesome. We had the Cannoli for dessert and it was fantastic. Nancy's is definitely worth visiting and I for one can't wait to go back! read more

Becky W.

7 years ago

We had an awesome experience at Nancy's place while vacationing in the Stuart area . Cute casual atmosphere. We ordered the Family style chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant stack . It was AWESOME included soup or salad , homemade garlic knots and a HUGE plate of ( we ordered fettuccine) pasta. 5 chicken parm cutlets and a foot long eggplant cutlet platter! Also included was a huge side of freshly sautéed garlic broccoli rabbe that was not mentioned on the menu All for 38.95 ! Plenty for us 3 and took home enough for the next nights dinner! All delicious homemade and fresh! Menu included pizza subs and pasta entrees it is so sad we do not live closer.. read more

Nancy H.

234

6 years ago

Could say I'm biased! ;) my favorite menu items are not on the menu! I love the different pizzas everyday that sell by the slice but my favorite it's grandmas. Sometimes I eat multiple bowls of the pasta fagolia with extra noodles. I love the Alfredo but my most recent fav is the chicken Marsala. One time I had a fried ravioli dipped in Alfredo sauce. I mean I'm drooling thinking about it. I love the fact that I can tell the staff what I'm craving and they are quick to offer just that! Service is always tip top and the place looks and smells amazing every time I'm there. My advice is start with dessert! read more

S W.

6 years ago

We dined at Nancy's pizza last night. As always Nancy's Pizza never is disappointing. We had house roasted wings Nancy's way, small antipasto salad and Mezzaluna Mozzarella (so delish). It is a definite go to for Italian food. The staff is amazing and very respectful. Shout out to Eduordo the waiter is outstanding and always there to help. We cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. The pizza is amazing, not greasy and perfectly cooked. We live 30 minutes away and never have issue driving to get quality food done the right way! read more

Nancy F.

5 years ago

This was my first eating inside at Nancy's Pizza and I will definitely be returning! I have had their pizza before and it was AMAZING! But this was the first time I dined inside and I will definitely be returning. It was such a welcoming place, with the staff who had SMILES on their faces and the owner Michele who introduced herself to our table, sat down and told us the family story! I not only loved the story, I loved the food! I will be back again and again! Takeout or dine in! It's a great place with great food and a great staff! read more

Robert G.

7 years ago

We visited Nancy's last evening with family and friends. Most of us are Italian and enjoy good Italian food, Nancy's is right there with some of our favorite restaurants. Nancy and Jeff made the visit an even more enjoyable time by taking time to talk with us and explain their goal to make this place comfortable as well as a place to enjoy fresh well prepared food. We look forward to our next visit. Bob and Cathy read more

Ashley G.

7 years ago

Out of all the other local selections for Italian restaurants Nancy's is my #1!!! Great food, good service & awsome family atmosphere!! I have honestly never had anything I didn't like off the menu, but have to say I'm a sucker for the Chicken Francese! I also might add that this establishment is one of the cleanest! So think about Nancy's next time you're in the mood for Italian, you will not be disappointed! read more

Janet G.

7 years ago

What do you call the perfect blend of bubbly cheese, pasta, and Bolognese sauce? Nancy's lasagna! This little lady is not shy but is ready for her close up (check the photo) The food is full-bodied and delicious . While visiting I drove by multiple times and it was always packed by locals. Sorry for giving up the secret but this is one worth sharing! Make sure you ask for Joe who is a fabulous server! read more

Jennifer S.

7 years ago

The first time we came here we had gotten Nancys pizza with the works, let you tell you that was fantastic. This time around we've gotten the meatballs (which were huge!) with penne pasta enough to share for two. We also ordered a cheese calzone which was amazing as well (not need to get it with extra cheese) and the garlic knots and bread were great too. I would definitely recommend coming! read more

Kayla L.

6 years ago

Best pizza place I've been to in Stuart, and I've been to almost all of them. I am a resident of Stuart, Florida and ordered a Stromboli and my fiancé got an Italian Cheese Steak. Eduardo was the best waiter we could have asked for, our son loved him! The owner was also amazing, it was great to be able to speak with her. What a wonderful woman! We will definitely be coming back for more! read more

Susan B.

7 years ago

We love this place! Great food, excellent service and friendly staff. We usually have pizza here - the pizza is fresh and soooo good! Tonight my husband had the Italian cheese steak and I had the chicken Francese. The sauce on the chicken Francese was to die for, and my husband loved the steak sandwich. If you haven't been here, you're missing out. You have to try Nancy's! read more

Edilia C.

7 years ago

If you are looking for more than good food, you must visit Nancy's Pizza you will have a great time!!! The Pizzas and Desserts tasted delicious plus the prices are good !!! Customer service is 100% excellent Everything is clean and the restaurant has a parking space available! Nancy's Pizza is our favorite place to eat with our family and friends! read more

Dan G.

7 years ago

The meatballs, the buffalo Stromboli, the pasta al la vodka and the deserts are something beyond normal italian restaurants. Way beyond. Super fast friendly service and incredibly fast to get eating. Didn't have long at all to even have a few sips of my drink before food was out. Definitely a go to. And also taking home tomorrow's lunch. read more

Eric S.

7 years ago

First time visiting this place and I'm glad we did. All of the food we tried was amazing! Cheese pizza, Nancy's with the works, garlic knots and dessert. We wanted to try more but we got stuffed! I highly recommend this restaurant for pizza and dessert. I look forward to coming back and trying one of their dinners. read more

Libni R.

6 years ago

Nancy Pizza is my go to spot when I'm feeling pizza & wings . They're really outgoing , sweet , funny amazing people we never had a problem with their food the wings are my favorite . You guys should definitely check out Nancy Pizza whenever you guys are around . Its never a disappointment . read more

Patricia A.

7 years ago

Just got home from eating dinner and I have to say I will go back. The food was amazing. The garlic knots are the best I have ever had. The service was wonderful and the server I had was so polite. If I were her parents I would be so proud. Thank you for the great food and service read more

Courtney B.

6 years ago

I have been to Nancy's on several different occasions and have always had a great experience. The food is always top notch and never disappoints. The staff especially Eduardo are always attentive and friendly. Garlic knots, white pizza and the stuffed zeppole's are my favorite. read more

Michele's cuicina - italian - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Michele's cuicina also viewed

Uncle Giuseppe's Lil Bit A Brooklyn

4.3

(369 reviews)

Roma Of Stuart Pizzeria and Restaurant

4.0

(47 reviews)

We have been going to Roma's on Kanner for years. They do a great job and Chris and his staff are…read morereally nice to work with. Food is always good. The prices are reasonable for the amount you get for your money. I would definitely recommend them. Carol C. 7-22-26

Pizza night= Roma's on Kanner. Love the pizza and garlic knots are amazing!!!! Our go to lunch is…read morethe chicken parm sub and fries. DAHLish!!! Love the varieties of salads I can choose from too. Great place and they have something for everyone.

Pastaio Handmade Pasta|Pizza

4.2

(526 reviews)

This is one of my top 5 Italian restaurants I would make the drive from west Palm beach just to…read morehave their pasta , Very fresh pasta and sauce I haven't tried the pizza but it's probably just as good as the pasta Highly recommend Nice and friendly atmosphere

The service needs help…read more Had a great dinner there! Our server was great. The food and drinks were delicious - however as soon as we paid our bill after only an hour and half of being there - a food runner asked us immediately to get up from the table as soon as we had paid stating they had "a family who had been waiting for a while" We spent $200 dining and left what was a great experience with a sour taste in our mouth after being asked to leave as soon as we paid to open up a table for them.

Roma Pizza and Subs

3.7

(41 reviews)

No decent Italian take out in the area. (The local Italian place doesn't make hot subs after 7pm…read more Really?!) Tried Roma- very good hot subs... will definitely be back to try other dishes.

Been there twice. I like the thin crust pizza and the hot…read morechicken parm sandwiches. The sausage and peppers sandwich was on point. The staff is friendly. Will be back soon.

Anna's Pizza Palm City

3.5

(153 reviews)

Excellent pizza with fast, friendly service! If you are…read morelooking for a place to go in Palm City, this is a great option!

This is my third visit to Anna's. Each time I visit, my experiences have declined. Sad…read more Inconsistent experiences is a killer for restaurant. On my first visit we had the grandmother's pizza which was fantastic. I gave them a five star review. On my second visit we once again had the same pizza. It was good BUT not as good as the first visit. While there we heard a guest mention the eggplant parm hero and so, on our third visit we tried one along with an "attempt" at trying a 1/2 meatball and 1/2 sausage hero. I say "attempt" because even though we ordered the 1/2 and 1/2 hero, we received a meatball hero. Unfortunately, it didn't matter as neither hero was very good. The meatball hero lacked flavor and the eggplant hero, although stuffed with a ton of eggplant, left us wanting. Too bad, we do like to support local individually owned restaurants but I believe Anna's has seen us for the last time.

Times Square Pizza

4.0

(32 reviews)

We ordered eggplant Calzone and a meatball sandwich to try them out. We only live a come blocks…read moreaway. Calzone was very good. Meatballs and sauce were excellent. Can't wait to try the pizza, but they, like most mom and pop shops are a little pricey. But that's not for corporate fast food. Will order from here again.

We gave them a second chance, because when they first opened, we were not happy with their pizza…read more We were pleasantly surprised with their pizza, chicken parmigiana hero and the calzone was amazing. We highly recommend and will definitely be making them our go to pizza place.

A Slice of Heaven

3.9

(101 reviews)

Good pizza and fast friendly service. Right next to Planet Fitness makes this convenient to pick up…read moreon the way home. Gives you a decent amount of sauce and toppings. Tuesday discount day was a nice surprise

Once Again Cold AC, Nice seating in or outside. Today was 90 degrees so My husband and enjoying…read morefood inside! The owner and a nice lady running the front. Both spoke Spanish and English with Smiley faces!! Will be back Again!! Thanks/Gracious

Original Anna's Pizza

4.0

(73 reviews)

Hands down the absolute best pizza, sauce, meatballs and entrees as far as Italian food goes in…read moreJensen beach and Stuart. Cannot recommend enough. Might be hard to get through on the phone to put in your order but keep trying, or just go in to see the iconic Anna manning her station in the kitchen.

First time visitors went on recommendation of friends. We purchased 'theworks' pizza and were…read moremodestly satisfied. Below average amount of toppings and DRY amount of sauce. The dough was great but overall the pizza left us wanting. We may try again but, for now, the search for amazing pizza continues!

Downtown Benny’s Pizza

3.6

(16 reviews)

This address is now called Big Apple Pizza. Found them by accident because you can order from the…read morebar next door and have it delivered to you there. Love the calzones and meatball garlic knots. Found the pizza pretty mid, but the calzone is actually huge, appropriate to the price. We come here often for take out.

We were visitng in Jensen Beach and ordered two large pizzas for take-out. We ordered a large…read moreVEGGIE pizza and a large EVERYTHING (or the works or whatever they call it). As another reviewed commented - it looked great. I think this might be billed as "NY style" and I'll admit that I'm not a big fan of really thin, NY style pizza. The sausage on the "works" pizza looked like thinly sliced roast beef. In my mind the veggie pizza was the better of the two. And, it's hard not to like pizza but this was not the world's greatest pizza - OK in a pinch but not a "pizza lovers" pizza.

La Forchetta

4.4

(565 reviews)