Mel's became a staple of my undergraduate career after it re-opened a couple of years ago. For a long time in my life, it was missing, mostly because it had tragically burned down in April of 2010, just after my first year of studies at the city's namesake university had wrapped up.
I've had a lot of great memories here. The place feels like an old style diner, the majority of the experience is via the booths that line both side walls of the restaurant.
One of those "great memories" was discovering a thing called "poached eggs", and then discovering further that there are "hardnesses" of poached eggs - "light", "medium", or "hard". Man, did I have a field day for breakfast that day (one of each, I got three poached eggs! Haha!).
I've also particularly enjoyed their burgers, since diners are usually more well-known for those kinds of things. I never tried that massive 3lb burger, but I promised myself I would before I die - so keep an eye out for that challenge later, I'll definitely Tweet about it, or at the very least update this review to reflect that.
The beer selection isn't readily obvious or available, but they have one - you just have to ask (and show ID, of course, if you're my age and look way younger than you actually are).
The environment is definitely nice and casual, and great for smaller groups (2-8) as well as individuals, but if you're trying to host a party of 10+, good luck!
The biggest downside of this place is the sheer size. For the popularity of the restaurant, you'd think they would have bought more space, or at least found ways to clear and rotate tables more efficiently. I get that they're a smaller establishment and are trying their best, but clearly things can be done a little better.
Let's get down to brass tacks, though!
Pros:
-- Great selection & variety of food - one of the best I've seen in a long time, actually, especially when it comes to the breakfast selections! - just be sure you order exactly what you want, since sometimes the menu items feel a little more restricting than they actually are.
-- Great prices - I've never seen a dish over $20 on their menu, pegging this at a great mid-ranged diner within walking distance of UWaterloo.
-- Some of the best breakfast foods I've had in a long time. Pancakes / French Toast here is awesome, and the bacon is always freshly cooked & exactly the way I like it (a little crispy, but not at all greasy).
Cons:
-- Inconsistent quality. Some days I feel amazing when I eat there, others times it's just "meh". At the start I thought it was because it was a honeymoon effect, but as time went on (read: three years), I realized it was more because they're better at breakfast than they are anything else.
-- Burgers are the biggest "hit-and-miss". Some days, they'll be exactly as ordered, others will be like "wait, is this medium? it feels like well-done!"
-- Fries are a little too greasy for my liking - even the sweet potato fries! (I'm a huge sweet potato fry lover, BTW!) This is especially unfortunate because while I like these fries, and the portion sizes are great, I can never bring myself to eat all of them because of how greasy it is - that's how terrible I feel about myself.
-- Beer selection (I don't think they have a lot of other alcoholic beverages?) isn't amazing. I guess it's a diner, so I let that one go without being penalized.
-- Bathrooms are a little cramped - sink isn't intuitively well-designed (have to pull up and hold to keep water flowing - annoying when trying to wash both hands simultaneously). They don't seem to clean them a lot (the men's, anyway), or replace the paper towels that often. (this could be because it's not their focus, which is fine, but it's been the same experience for over a year in my experience)
Overall, I'd recommend this place for newcomers to town, or to new students/residents to the Waterloo area. I wasn't a "regular" here by any means, but it's a solid place to go to, provided it's not busy (wait times can be 1 hour if there's no seating, since the max I've ever seen is two wait staff, and two cooks, at any given point in time). read more