I love Mellow Mushroom and am happy to say that this location is just as awesome as the other locations I've been to. It was easy to find (west ponce just before you get to commerce if heading into Decatur), easy to park, and I'm pretty sure because we got there right as they opened on a Saturday it was easy to get in, get seated, and enjoy some delicious pizza. When we arrived, I absolutely loved the decor and the vibe. There are plenty of tvs, a nice sized bar area, the bathrooms are clean, and seating area allows for small and large groups to just enjoy good pizza and have some fun. It was just fun and each staff member that we came in contact with was super kind and our server, Micah and Erin was absolutely amazing. They took wonderful care of our party of 7 (which include 4 kiddos) and made sure that we had everything that we needed. I ordered a medium pizza (8 slices) which was more than enough for myself and my two kiddos to enjoy a few slices while there and we had several slices to take home for later (which was a win). The pizza was hot, fresh, and while I added roasted tomatoes and applewood bacon on my half, the kiddos decided to not be adventurous and stuck with just cheese. The dough is a true game changer and the sauce is robust and flavorful. You absolutely cannot go wrong with anything at Mellow Mushroom! read more

See all

We are so back. Checked out the "New" Mellow in Downtown Decatur. They recently reopened and I am glad they did. Hard for them to compete when there is a few pizza shops surrounding them but they held on and reopened! Not going to lie, I don't remember the interior of the old one but what they have now is bright and fun! It seems more upbeat and less quiet. We ordered a simple pepperoni pie on a Friday night and received it in about 20 mins. The employees were kind and helpful. The za was banging. They had the right amount of sauce, cheese, and love to the pizza. read more

My husband and I ordered carryout and got a meat lovers pizza as well as the pretzel bites with cheese dipping sauce. Couldn't help but get two cookies when I was checking out because they look so tasty! Everything was awesome and we look forward to being back. read more

This spot is the best kept secret. The mushroom pizza is DELICIOUS. Thank you Summer for making me feel welcome! read more

I went here last night for the first time and really enjoyed myself. The parking lot is tiny, can maybe hold 20 cars or so but there's a parking garage directly across the street. We told the waiter it was our first time and he gave some suggestions. I ended up ordering the Southwestern chicken salad and the mighty meaty pizza. The salad was so DELICIOUS and the chicken was very flavorful and tender. The pizza was also very delicious and the crust had amazing flavor! The manager ended up coming to our table to introduce himself and thank us for coming in. Everyone was very nice, the place was very clean, and even the bathroom smelled amazing lol. Definitely going back! read more

See all

More than. 50% chance that you will leave before ever getting service. The other 50% of the time you will leave before your food arrives because you don't have 3 hours to wait on them. read more

I'm really disappointed with our experience at Mellow Mushroom. We came in for a sit-down dinner and waited an hour and 20 minutes before finding out that our pizza had not even been put in the oven yet. At no point were we warned up front that the kitchen was that backed up. After waiting all that time, we were told they prioritize online orders, which was incredibly frustrating as dine-in customers. If we had known the wait would be anywhere near that long, we never would have stayed. We ended up walking out because there was no reasonable expectation of getting our food anytime soon. I understand restaurants get busy, but not communicating that kind of delay to guests is unacceptable. This was a very poor dining experience and a complete waste of our evening. We went down the street to brainwave at inner voice brewery and got our pizza in 15 minutes later tasted great, give them a try!!! read more

Will definitely miss their presence in the downtown Decatur neighborhood. Pizza was good, service was decent, and drinks were strong. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - Closed effective 06/16 - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

First time ever eating Mellow Mushroom Pizza was years ago on my job. They ordered several for safety achievements and I remember the pizzas being on the table not hot kind of warm when we arrived to taste and eat the pizza. After a different time I ordered a pizza from the same location in Tucker GA the area my job is located in the pizza was okay. I grew up on Pizza Hut so the pizza I received didn't blow my socks off I felt it was nothing to write home about. After that experience I didn't go back to the location for pizza. I really wanted to see what was the hype about this place and was I missing something. I drove past the Decatur GA location and I remember it being packed all of the time. I saw that they recently closed for renovations and opened back up. I looked at the menu on Uber Eats and I saw The Holy Shitake pizza.. I like mushrooms on pizza they taste good to me delicious and they are good for your mood. The presentation of the pizza is spectacular and I got blue cheese with some garlic parmesan wings oven baked I think I saw that. This is night and day my experience from the previous location. I know that this is a Atlanta GA staple since 1974. I was skeptic about the restaurant pizza before this time. The flavor and the taste of this pizza is delicious. They truly made a believer out of me! Instead of getting a hand tossed crust pizza I got a thin crust pizza which I enjoy because to me you taste the toppings more and the crust is not just a lot of dough. I got my pizza on 12-18-2025 it's worth it no disappointment! Pull up and check them out if you are unable use Uber Eats. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - The Holy Shitake Pizza with Garlic Parmesan Wings and Blue Cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

The pizza was good. It was baked perfectly with a nice crunch. The Sausage Mellow Rollz were NOT Good. There was hardly any Sausage or other fillings in these rolls. Do not order this. It is just toasted bread. Horrible read more

My husband and I went here for a date night as mellow is one of my favorite spots. We were warned by our server that the kitchen was backed up and food would take a bit. We were okay with it at the time as I know it requires some patience to eat at mellow. Took about 30 min for appetizers to come out. After waiting for over an hour without our pizza coming out our server comes to tell us that our pizza hadn't even been put in the oven yet due to the back up of orders. We asked for the check and left hungry and frustrated. On the way out another employee advised us that it's because corporate prioritizes to go orders over dine in orders. This is super disappointing as I've been a Decatur resident for a decade and I've been here many times and was one of my favorite restaurants. I understand a business has to make money, but I've never heard of any restaurant de-prioritizing dine in customers. We left and went to brainwave pizza at innervoice brewing where we had a fresh pizza made in 15 minutes as walk ins. Unless you are coming for lunch or don't mind waiting hours for a pizza, pick another spot to go. It was easy to see that the other customers were in the restaurant were unhappy too and many were asking for their food or the checks. I felt bad for the families with kids who were waiting on pizza for the little ones. read more

Too long to wait for Pizza. They said it would be ready at 6:17 pm and was told at 6:30pm it would be 25 more minutes. Please don't set the expectation if you can't deliver on it. read more

Spent an hour trying to order through the website. Could not get past entering my email to initiate the order. Tried 5x to reload, including closing browser and clearing cache. Tried calling and went to voicemail twice in a row. Tried ordering via my phone and had the same issue as the website. Ended up ordering from my local go-to spot instead. MM is a great pizza shop we used to order all the time. I hope they fix the website issues. read more

Lively, mellow mushroom atmosphere which I enjoy. Was in the house! I was greeted warmly and was served nicely at the bar. Unfortunately, what I ordered was not hot. I had the meatballs which comes with cheese sauce and basil flakes. It looks great but it's wasn't hot. I complained about it, but I was hungry and I was really supposed to have dinner at some Iberian pig place but couldn't find parking. Per you "make another plate" so I just ate that. I probably won't order it again unless I know it's hot. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - Couldn't find parking to go to the imperial pig restaurant so I came here - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

Over and over - this place does not honor it's orders. I paid for extra sauce for my calzone and they charged me a SECOND time when we picked up. We will go to Glide Pizza going forward. read more

First time eating at this location. I won't be back. They allow animals, so if you plan to eat outside keep that in mind. We did not enjoy our outside experience because of that. The pizza was OK. too greasy for my taste. The inside is like a bar type vibe, but with just pizza. Customer service was OK. They didn't greet us when we waked inside, but we didn't get seated right away and it wasn't busy at all. Well for take out they were, not for in restaurant service though. Anywho, I've had better pizza. 3.5/5 overall. read more

Since the relaunch I tried again and received a much better reception. I was reminded of the mushroom trio option which makes a difference. Unfortunately, this location didn't do the traditional magic mushroom soup at all. I liked the sausage as it was chucked and seemed to include fennel while other local spots like APC (Avondale Pizza Cafe) merely provide lesser ingredients, and as crumbs, while the staff there picks winners and losers of their own design. read more

Worst experience in a Pizza Restaurant in years! Getting a waitress took forever , then 1 hour later the only food we had was the appetizer, and a drink. No real apparent reason, lots of empty tables, plenty of staff seemed to be in both dining room and kitchen. Finally they brought one person in our party of five people his sandwich!! And, the other four of us nothing!! Last straw was when they brought one more person their 10" pizza and it was burned!! Meanwhile, the other three of us still sitting ther with no food for another ten minutes. Finally the person with the burned pizza went and asked for a Manager. when she finally showed up, with three of us still with no food, her excuse was, "Well we have been slammed with To Go orders". Like, WHAT? Clearly this place has no idea whatsoever how to manage a restaurant, and knowingly would bring out burned food and try to serve it??? Clueless and Crap.... never going back!! read more

The food was delicious. Now it did take too long for our apps to arrive....literally 20-30 wait. Not happy about that, we actually thought they forgot about us. But we order pretzel bites & spinach dip. And they were good. Then our pizzas arrived 15 mins later. The math wasn't matching on the time it took for our overall orders. Service: Jacob was AWESOME. He apologized for the wait and was on it for all our needs. Overall surroundings were amazing. We sat outside on this bright, sunny, Georgia humid day and we loved it. read more

See all

This was our 2nd attempt to come here at this particular location. The 1st time was busy and they advised they aren't seating ppl. Okay cool. This time its a 30 minute wait. I looked around and saw empty booths but okay. Im hungry so we decide to wait. Our server was a nice young lady & very helpful. I mentioned it was my 1st time here so I wasn't sure what to try. I decided on a hoagie because when I saw it I immediately thought of some good hoagies from Philly. He ordered a house special meaty pizza (gluten free) and wings. I tried a slice and it was good. It was so much on it I barely noticed the mushrooms i don't like. My hoagie wasn't what I expected. It was good but not what I was looking for. I had a strawberry drink which i don't recall the name of it. The strawberries they topped it off with were good n fresh. I wish i had more of them. The drink i cant really comment on because it came with a paper straw. Paper straws ruins everything. Overall I didn't get the hype of this franchise and more than likely wont return. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - I dont remember the names of these drinks - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

I ordered a pizza via Uber Eats and it arrive burnt, and charred. There's obviously no one checking on the quality of the food before it leaves the restaurant. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - Burnt -charred pizza delivered to my home on Tuesday, Dec 31st. I will alert the local inspectors about this incident. - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

New owners, same disappointing product/service. Ordered delivery through Uber Eats. Missing items caused me to have to go to the restaurant after paying over $20 in delivery fees to get missing items and then got home to cold calzone that was burnt on top. Was really hoping things would be different this time read more

No thin crust options for pizza. No meatballs available as stated on the menu. Pizza was Sub-par. Very dissatisfied & disappointed. Will Not Patronize Again. read more

See all

Much like my mom regards my brothers and I, I love all Mellow Mushrooms equally. However, not all of them can be star children. The Decatur Mellow is one such "average child." They don't seem to get much dine-in traffic, the Decatur High School service staff is pleasant but not super efficient, decor is only a tad eccentric, and the pizza came out in about 35 minutes despite us being the only ones in the restaurant. Regardless, Mellow Mushroom is still my favorite chain pizza place in Atlanta, and our BBQ Chicken pizza was fluffy and tasty as always. The location is also neat, and we love it for it's walkability from our home. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - Dining Room of Mellow Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

See all

What's better than pizza on a Friday night? A business a partner and I dined at this location one Friday night and I must say it was a great experience. It was pretty jumping with families, teenagers and couples. Our waitress was awesome! She was very attentive, kind and made wonderful recommendations. Because of her, I tried the lavender mocktail which I LOVED and the mushroom soup which was pretty darn tasty as well. I also had a pepperoni pizza and brownie for dessert. The service was a tad slow, but our waitress was great at keeping us updated. And once we were done, the manager came and checked on us to see how our dining experience was. They had some vegan options on the menu that I must go back to try! I haven't been to Mellow Mushroom in a while and I sure am glad I dined there on that Friday night! read more

Loved the ambiance, my pizza was burnt but overall, we enjoyed the experience. Better than usual chain pizza places for sure.

The cheesy bread here is not as good as the other MM's. Low on cheese. They should've called it "kinda cheesy bread".

Generally speaking I do my best to rate a restaurant holistically, hence the four stars. Here's my breakdown. Ambiance: 5/5 - The Decatur Mellow Mushroom (and most Mellows, for that matter) has always offered a really great environment. The patio is fun and closed in, the interior is colorful and cutely decorated (with a tasteful view of the kitchen). Pizza: 5/5 - We got the BBQ chicken pizza and it was high quality. Mellow's crust is consistently the best, and this time didn't disappoint. You can tell the chicken and ingredients are high quality as well, so big 5 stars on that. Wait time: 3/5 - I get it, Mellow Mushroom is infamous for their long waits. We know. But when there are literally only three other tables in the restaurant a pizza should not take over 35 minutes to come out. I'm not sure what happened there, but it is a bit irritating. Service: 3/5 - Our server was just... a server. We were his only table, but he treated us like he had four other tables and somewhere to be in an hour. Everything was on time and he did the physical parts of his job well, but like... c'mon. A smile or at least some sort of engagement would have been nice. I'm a former server, and if I was that blah with a table I would have been fired. Anyways, that's that on that. Overall it's a decent establishment, but could improve in the managerial category I think. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - The Funky Q with the interior art in the background - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

See all

Great location for this fantastic pizza house chain. The ambience is great and service is quick. They have a parking lot for easy parking. Holy shiitake is my fav mellow mushroom pizza hands down! read more

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Mellow Mushroom, and I must say it was quite the delightful experience. As soon as I walked in, the ambiance struck me as genuinely mellow, just as the name suggests. The cozy, laid-back atmosphere made it an excellent choice for a relaxing meal. One of the perks was the ample parking space located conveniently behind the building, which eliminated the hassle of finding a parking spot. The restaurant was spacious, making it perfect for various occasions - group outings, romantic dates, or even solo dining adventures. The seating arrangement was comfortable and accommodating to different party sizes. To kick off our meal, we decided to try the Spinach Artichoke Dip, priced at $9.49. It turned out to be a fantastic choice. The dip was creamy, flavorful, and paired beautifully with the small pieces of garlic bread served alongside. It was a generous portion, making it perfect for sharing and setting the tone for a satisfying meal. For our main course, we couldn't resist ordering a Large Mighty Meaty pizza for $29.99. This carnivorous masterpiece was a meat lover's dream. It featured a tantalizing mix of pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, honey ham, and applewood-smoked bacon, all generously layered on top of Mellow red sauce and mozzarella cheese. I opted to not get honey ham but everything else came on the pizza. As the pizza arrived at our table, it was piping hot and looked incredibly appetizing. Each bite of the Mighty Meaty pizza was a symphony of flavors. The combination of the savory meats and the gooey cheese atop a perfectly cooked crust was simply divine. It was a carnivore's paradise, and the balance of flavors was impeccable. To quench our thirst, we opted for lemonade at $2.29, which was refreshingly tangy and complemented the richness of the pizza perfectly. We also ordered a few small containers of their signature red sauce for $1.50, which added an extra layer of flavor to our meal. In conclusion, my dining experience at Mellow Mushroom was exceptional, and I would gladly return. The ambiance, accommodating space, delectable Spinach Artichoke Dip, and the heavenly Mighty Meaty pizza were all highlights of the visit. Moreover, the friendly and attentive service added to the overall enjoyment. Mellow Mushroom truly lives up to its name, offering a mellow and memorable dining experience read more

See all

Just went here again today, and the fire alarm went off causing multiple fire trucks ETC to come over and check it out, turns out nothing was wrong but it was really loud and scary and they made us go onto the porch. They were very apologetic about it even though it wasn't our servers fault, and they even gave us discounts! I just can't give it 5 stars because the incident was technically their fault. (Nobody was even remotely hurt), (Food was good too!) read more

Sadly the quality of the food and service has gone down fast here. The wait staff rotate out too quickly now. I've probably eaten here over a hundred times over the years. I don't even enjoy myself because of the lack of professionalism. I'm guessing because It's under new ownership / management. Hopefully they get their act together. read more

Just had the best ever Pizza Place experience with my son at The Mellow Mushroom in Decatur. The service was AMAZING and the Holy Shiitake pizza and meatball sub were FANTASTIC. One of the best lunch experiences that I have ever had anywhere!! Love it, too, when Art Linton plays on the patio!! Great job!!! read more

Worst mellow experience ever tonight at this location. Pretzels were burnt. Took forever to get salads. Some pizzas came out right after salads. One pizza literally didn't come, taking so long that we requested it to just be boxed up to go. Nobody ever got a refill. We were there for 1h 15min and we arrived early enough that none of this should have been a concern. Our server had lots of things to say, lots of excuses, but actionable recovery was absent. read more

They knocked it out of the park with their gluten free pizzas! We get takeout from here often and have dined on the patio a couple of times. The gluten free crust is very crispy and delicious! The Enlightened Spinach Salad has a tasty mix of flavor as well with dried cherries, apples, house-made candied pecans and feta cheese. I love finding food that's healthy AND satisfying! My bf is not gluten free, and he loves the pretzel bites. The atmosphere inside the restaurant and on the patio is welcoming, relaxed, and laid back, with artsy decor, fun music playing from the speakers, and sports on TV. The service is stellar. There's truly something for everyone here! read more

See all

The food was delicious. The Holly Shitake Pizza was so flavorful. With layers of mushrooms, cheese, garlic, onions and topped with aioli. read more

See all

never a bad meal!! service was very good, family friendly . There are so many menu items to choose from. it's been awhile since i've been there, so i must make a return visit!! i visited the Mellow Mushroom in downtown Decatur, and they do have outdoor seating, so i will go and do some people watching on my next visit!! read more

Food was so good that we forgot to take pictures!!!! Cobb Salad is everything! And a build a pizza was fun. It was Delicious!!! Decatur location is everything! read more

Mellow Mushroom has been around since I was a kid and I've had it many times over the years, but it had been a couple since the last time. A few days ago, hubs and I had a taste for wings but didn't want anything fried. I don't think I'd ever tried their wings before but hubs had, so he suggested picking some up from here. I'm glad we did! All of Mellow's wings are baked, which is a major plus when you don't have time to bake some yourself. Plus, they're double-baked, which makes them a little more crisp. I ordered the Cloud 9, which is 9 wings in garlic Parmesan sauce with "just a hint of heat" and garnished with grated aged Parmesan and chives. I'm not sure, but I think these may be a seasonal option. Husband ordered a 10-piece of jerk wings. We also had a small/10" cheese pizza. We had to place our order over the phone because we also had an ad for a discount that couldn't be used online, and that process was pretty rough. We actually tried calling three times the day before and no one ever answered the phone. We thought maybe they were just understaffed so that's why we tried a few times. We were even going to go ahead and order online and not worry about the ad, but even at 5 p.m. we were only given the option to place an order for the next day. When we called again the next day, the woman who answered the phone was going back and forth between taking my order and checking out a customer who was picking up. So, I literally had to repeat my order four times. She asked for it twice then finally put the phone down to finish up with the guy who was in the restaurant, then I had to repeat it two more times after that. She seemed new and like she was trying to juggle quite a bit at once on her own, so it was fine. But that whole process is the only reason I'm not giving 5 stars. Our order was correct when we received it and we both really enjoyed our food. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - Didn't get a great picture of our wings but this is the small 10" Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

During these Covid times, we were hesitant to dine out but they had outside patio dining so we ate here for a late lunch on Friday afternoon. Sweet tea and Sprite to drink, they use paper straws. We order the 10ct sweet thai chili wings which were very good. They good have been a lil bit more crispy but overall very good. We got a medium half and half. Pepperoni for my son and like Supreme for me...6 slices total which are nice size slices. The pizza comes out piping hot and was very, very good Fresh ingredients and a pizza made with love. It felt good to get out with all going on right now Fin dining experience and our server was 10/10. Around enough to get what we needed but not hovering around all the time. read more

Mellow Mushroom Decatur - 10ct sweet chili thai wings - Pizza Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

See all