We were going to The Sanctuary in Maynard for a 5:30 gig featuring the soulful, singular Michelle Willson and her awesome backup guitar player, Mike Debarry, and bass player, Mike Newsom. Although we could have ordered from our table there we ordered pizza ahead to pick up at 5:15: A 10" Veggie Supreme with a couple extras. The ordering process, although on line, was easy providing room for personal needs or requests and the communication was thorough. Arriving in a snow storm we were relieved to find the Maynard Pizza & Bar directly across the street from The Sanctuary. The pizza was ready and still hot on time but the piece-de-resistance was when we raised the lid on the heavy duty pizza box. Our eyes popped at the mountain of ingredients. The sweet smells and rich flavors attested to the freshness of all the ingredients. We were glad we hadn't ordered the 16". Just don't forget the forks and napkins next time. Combined with the free performance at the Sanctuary, the under $20 pizza, and a beer at the Sanctuary, it was a perfect, fulFILLing and gratifyingly inexpensive evening out. Rare these days. Memorable all around. read more

Ordered food on Halloween and everything was good! Steak and Cheeses, fries and cheese pizza! So great to stay in Maynard and get decent bar food! read more

Maynard pizza bar for the win Best place in all of Maynard Best food best drinks And Karaoke !!! read more

Maynard Pizza & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Maynard, Massachusetts

let me just say - AMAZING?!! this place is literally so so good i didn't expect it at all. the pizza looked good but it tasted even better and their pina colada mocktail was great as well. i tried the guava pizza which was so unique and delicious. aside from the great food, i loved the vibe of this place. the staff is so great and the service is quick, they are very close knit and well informed. and the place itself is SO cute and quirky we just loved it. would definitely make the hour + drive again just to try more items on the menu. read more

See all

best place ever food is the best Service is the best Love this place it's great here new owners are the best read more

One of my preferred pizza locations in Maynard. They have much more unique flavors than other places - I highly recommend the Caprociosa read more

See all

This is a hidden gem in Maynard, awesome ambience with friendly staff and prompt service. Karaoke Friday and Saturdays here is always a fun spot to go out to, and open late. They have great variety of food for take out or dine in. Personal favorite takeout is their chicken Caesar wrap. read more

Very very disappointed today. Dough wasn't cooked. The cheese pizza had very little sauce and the amount of cheese was really quite disgusting. I had the pizza with ricotta, mushrooms, mozzarella, and prosciutto. Again, dough wasn't cooked through. It seems as though these pizzas are premade and frozen then put in an oven. For the money I paid - won't be ordering again read more

I love this pizza restaurant! The young owner made a bold move and reinvented this pizza place in a town that already has several pizza places. My favorite pizza that I have ordered at least 20 times (actually, I think I've forgotten how many times I've ordered it because it's such a mainstay for me!) is the Messina. We usually add some mushrooms. Don't hesitate to order here. The menu keeps growing! read more

We love their Romeo and Julietta pizza. Such a great combination for a pizza. Perfectly sweet, just like the owner Cute little spot in downtown maynard read more

I've had an excellent Margherita pizza here before, so I was unpleasantly surprised the other night when I ordered delivery and A) the small cheese and pep was not sliced (!), and more troublesome, B) the small buff chix pizza was barely edible. Doughy, no kick to the sauce, rubbery chicken. Yikes. You'd be excommunicated from New Haven for sending this out into the world. Do better, please! The 2 stars are for speedy service and a decent Greek salad. read more

Used to serve very good pizza. Now they don't. Please avoid. Or flip a coin to try your luck read more

What a great, local place! Intimate inside with only a bit of seating but try to grab one of the places at the bar. Locals crowd around and share conversations over pizza and drinks. The pizza was delicious. Far far better than generic pizza places, the crust and interesting topping combination made my mouth water. Another added bonus is the drinks! If you're willing to venture from beer/wine, I highly suggest the Caipirinha. A Brazilian cocktail, the sharp lime and sugar flavor is a refreshing choice. Come here for the food, stay for the neighbors and good conversation. read more

Where do I start? Friendly, family business with its heart in the right place? Check. Tasty pizza house menu? Check. Willingness to accommodate special requests? Check. Open to brand new menu suggestions? Check. Fun new bar with ice cold beer bottles and craft cocktails? Check. My wife and I recently had the best pizza we have had in eight years for of living here - at this place!! And all because they accommodated a special request. The family is great. Hearts of gold. The new bar is warm and friendly. Check it out. Enthusiastic five stars. read more

My pizza was great. That atmosphere was relaxed. I don't drink but the adult beverages looked good. I ordered a small Greek pizza which was excellent but all the options looked good read more

Maynard Pizza & Bar - Bar and television - Pizza Near Me - Maynard, Massachusetts

Great hidden gem in Maynard! The pizzas are amazing & get a quick cocktail while you wait!

This place is just plain s$&#y. Maynard has very few choices for subs/pizza, all are at best just ok. So we have eaten here probably once every other month out of necessity not need/want. Prices are far from cheap and we have never said wow that was good. Tonight's visit however was our last. $21.00 for a small salad, Italian sub and what would barely be considered a short small fry. Cheap frozen fake fries, salad just OK, sandwich just plain awful. I have never seen so little meat/ contents in a sandwich. I hate Subway and would take it over this junk any day. Words can't describe the lack of toppings in my sub. So look at pictures. Don't go here. They should not be in the food service industry. read more

See all

Excellent as always. Pizza was perfectly done and we enjoyed it immensely Recommend pizza. Been going there for years Not much more to say. Enjoy Great local establishment read more

Wanted to try downtown Maynard I am a local.... Sat at the " bar" poor service ... no bar atmosphere ... poor pizza go elsewhere ..... sadly for pizza and beer/ wine read more

I have only ordered the pizza, so that is all I can rate Maynard Pizza on. We always go here for pizza or when we have company because EVERYONE (including us) loves it. The pizza is so good - really nice crispy crust with excellent tomato sauce and cheese. read more

The best new (revamped) spot in town! We love it for the thin crust, sweet sauce pizza and the creative specialty drinks at their new bar. They also have great prices, friendly staff, and indoor and outdoor seating! read more

Ordered an Italian sub and a BBQ chicken sub recently and results were mixed. The Italian was okay but not amazing, and the chicken was dry in the other sub. They didn't ask if we wanted them toasted and admittedly I forgot to ask, so bread was cold (albeit fresh). Pizza is good, subs leave something to be desired. Stick with the pizza if you aren't sure what to get. read more

Fresh ingredients. That's what you get at this restaurant (take out or delivery only). Hand-tossed pizza crust, real mozzarella, fresh vegetables, just as it should be. We also go the spaghetti and meatballs. Very good sauce. Meatballs excellent. I recommend this place. read more

So I've traveled all over for work and pleasure... I've eaten at a lot of pizza shops all over the US. I've been to Maynard House about 10 times before it was sold. I've only been there once since it was. This is that time... and it will be the last time. I ordered a steak and cheese (lettuce, pickles, mayo)... pretty easy, You would think it would be kinda hard to screw it up... and yet... it was. Not that it didn't have all of the things it should, because it was all there, however if I wanted dry steak, cold cheese laid on the heavy on the mayo untoasted bread I know where to go. Except I didn't want that... Generally speaking, the steak should be seasoned, the cheese should be melted into the steak, the roll should be slightly toasted, with a proper amount of mayo, the lettuce should be shredded (similar to taco shredded lettuce), pickles should be slices (not cubes), they should line the bottom or top of the steak. Then once its all ready slightly toast the sandwich to keep it all heated and warm. This is what I wanted... I didn't get it.. Its get a second star because the employee was pleasant and nice. :) read more

Oh. Wow. Keep in mind, this review has nothing to do with the pizza. I haven't had it yet and I'm not sure I ever will. I ordered online, easy enough. An hour and a half later, after fending off attacks by my wife and two kids about when we will eat, I finally agreed to call. It went straight to voicemail, over and over and over again. Having no idea if they were even open, I was forced to drive there and see for myself. Amazingly, they were, and the phone had been out the whole time. "No wonder it's been slow", not a joke. The pizza is in the oven now and I was comped (the only reason I didn't leave), but this place is absolutely filled with smoke to where I almost can't sit here any longer. How the smoke detectors aren't going off, I have no idea. Avoid like the plague. read more

This discussion really needs to start again. A month ago maybe I saw a new sign above the place. I never cared for the old place. The name is the same but the pizza is now Italian style not Greek although I love both. I just got a quick delivery of Pepperoni and Mushroom and say it is as good as the best pizza I've ever had. Good luck to the new owners. Update early June 2013. They just keep getting better. My favorite is the Ferrara pizza. I get a cheap lunch or dinner there by picking up a small pepperoni pizza and it is about $5.30 usually they have to cram it into the take out box. They have added online ordering and while it has a few bugs it is nice. Kudos to Vanessa the young lady that works there, she is always nice and friendly. No I'm not related to this business at all. Just a happy diner. read more

Well, I will go back. It has a special place in my heart. We ordered pizza delivered, and they dropped off the wrong order. Of course, we didn't know this until the delivery guy was gone. We were hungry and the order was eerily similar to our order, so we dug in. The guy came back ten minutes later, apologized profusely, and dropped off our real order at no charge. I have never denied my gluttony. Anyway, I have standards for pizza that are fairly simple yet not always met. This place meets them - good cheese, good crust, good toppings. read more

**4.5** Part of moving to a new area is finding your go-to place for pizza. I think I've tried just about every pizza joint in Maynard, Concord, and Acton. And this is it. This is the one. Maynard Pizza House doesn't look like much on the outside, but these guys know what they're doing. I've tried a few different pizzas from them. The most recent was a spinach, feta, and garlic creation. But you can't even go wrong with just a plain cheese. Delicious. Ingredients always taste super fresh. Customer service is good and friendly, and definitely earns props for putting up with my attempt at small talk whenever I walk in. So why do I say 4.5 stars? They do thin crusts, and every once and awhile the crust blurs the edge between crispy and burnt. That being said, it's never been to the extent that I haven't enjoyed my pizza. These guys got my vote and I'll keep going back. read more

Ordered chicken parm sub and fries. Did not receive what we ordered. Usually we get amazing sub rolls with sandwiches. This time, sandwich was prepared on toast. No sauce, no Parmesan, flavorless sandwich. Super disappointed in tonight's service. read more

I want to like and support this local restaurant and when they actually get the order right, the pizza is pretty good. The problem is, when we order anything more complicated than a basic cheese or pepperoni pizza, we will not get what we ordered. It's happened enough times now that we are probably going to stop going, or at least only go when we aren't planning on getting anything too complicated. Word of advice, check your pizzas on the way out the door! read more

The pizza at Maynard Pizza House, Maynard House of Pizza, or as we call it, 'May Ho' is adequate, befitting the standard New England *.House of Pizza name (sorry, that would be UNIX command-line humor. run away.). The buffalo chicken pizza is decent. The meat-heavy one seems like a good idea until it doesn't. You'll get a better-tasting meatball sub at Subway (which is not a huge insult-Subway's are quite tasty, if chintzy and limp), and you'll wait a while for it. Call ahead. They have those bizarrely comfortable contoured pressboard booths, but it's not really a place one eats in. Maynard Pizza House is good in that generally i am never paying for food from there, it's always the office (or better still, a vendor!) paying for it. If i were, maybe i'd hold it to a higher standard. read more

Quick delivery and good quality ingredients, tortellini as good as can be expected from a pizza place- but surprisingly not overcooked, with great red sauce. I also had their version of a Caprese salad, but was surprised as it's advertised as "caesar salad with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil," and while the ingredients are fresh, it's literally lettuce with a few balls of mozzarella and tomato wedges, plus caesar dressing, which is a good combo but definitely not a Caprese (however, it's true to the description, if their Caesar is just lettuce with dressing). Side note- the delivery driver seemed a bit confused, as he tried to leave without being paid and seemed surprised that I hadn't paid. Hopefully they're better organized at the store front. read more

Just called to place an order at 9:05 Thursday night ... Started ordering and was interrupted with "our frier and grille are off" oh i thought you didn't close until 10.. " yeah we don't close until 10 but it was slow tonight..." Alright ill call somewhere else... "Ok bye"... Really? Closing an hour early because it was "a little slow" read more

Pretty good pizza. Great prices. It was light on sauce, which I like. The cheese was high quality. Their dough was really delicious - even the crust was yummy. The garlic bread with cheese was also tasty. I went to the store to pick it up. My only complaint is that the store seemed a little dirty - really just dust (which is probably mostly flour and does accumulate very fast) on various surfaces. Since I just moved to Maynard I'm sure I will order from them again :) read more

Very close to the worst pizza I have ever had.Doughy,usually undercooked and what tastes like a canned sauce.Fortunately most kids will eat anything resembling pizza and they are the only game in town for takeout. Voila! read more

This is our go-to pizza place, we order from them quite a bit for delivery. The crust and sauce are pretty great, however they are sometimes a little soggy in the center. If you order one of their specialty pizzas, they really load them up. The only reason I don't get the specialty pizzas to often is the combinations are really weird. So we end up going the route of a cheese pizza and paying for each additional topping, which they can be somewhat stingy on from time to time. We have also gotten a cheese and topped it ourselves and put in the oven for a bit, and the extra baking time is often needed to rectify the soggy center. It sounds strange to recommend the salad at a pizza place but GET A SALAD added to your order. Especially the mediterranean salad! It's not the iceberg lettuce crap you might tend to get at a pizza joint -- spring mix greens with lots of great toppings: feta, olives, tomato, roasted peppers, banana peppers, onions, etc. Very good with their house balsamic. The person at the desk is always very courteous. I think she might be the owner, and she's always there. Eat in atmosphere isn't that great for ambiance, but it's clean. read more

Local pizza joint. Staff or nice, food is regular American subshop fare. The interior is renovated with restraunt style tables and bar by the windows. read more

Saved my day when I needed some good pizza for dinner with my niece & nephew! They loved it and I was very pleasant surprised - very good pizza, decent priced and fast! Love the place! read more

Maynard Pizza & Bar - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Maynard, Massachusetts

See all

It is a very good option for a take out. A simple place with a very affordable prices. Pizza is delicious! read more

Great pizza place. Its not the generic pizza place - mix of brick/coal oven. Pretty quick too. Recommended. read more

Maynard Pizza & Bar - Pizza Near Me - Maynard, Massachusetts