We got the Fish Bowl Slim Margarita - highly recommended, and Ultimate Nachos for our shared…read moredinner. We added bean dip that was very cheesy, and an additional basket of chips that was $2. Food was good, drink great, and service was OK. Pork Carnitas was ok, but a bit dry, and other nacho toppings were good. Booths, tables, bar seating, and a pool table complete the dining area. Appeared to be a back room and outdoor seating when needed. Overall good-definitely get a margarita!

Great margs, and you can get tajin rims. Food is solid and…read moreconsistent and the staff is delightful!!!

Waited forever in the drive thru to only receive the wrong order. Went back inside to get what I…read moreordered and heard them call what I ordered "stupid". I have dietary restrictions so what I ordered was literally the only thing on the menu I could have. Clearly some customer service training needs to take place here.

Awful service. Period. They're rarely open as late as posted. I complained at the drive-thru the…read moreother night because they closed early because they "ran out of beans". I yelled to the car in front of me Kwik Trip was open, "Tom" decided to yell put my plates and threatened to call the cops. I emailed corporate and was sent 2 Free Combo meals for the previous awful service from Tom. I went in tonight to use my free meals and give them a chance. I even went in extra early to not worry about them being closed. Tom refused service because his feelings were hurt for being called out for not knowing how to run a business and staying open during your posted hours. I'd rate 0 if I could. This place used to be decent...I mean it's Taco Bell... but now it's not even worth your time. Go literally anywhere else.

On a Fish Fry Friday, I ordered the clam chowder and fish fry dinner with perch and sweet potatoes…read more The clam chowder was excellent. Generously prepared, great seasoning and with the right temperature. The fries are sprinkled with cinnamon which was a first for me. The sweet potato fries were a little soggy but not bad. The cherry hard cider was fizzy and refreshing, It looks like the restaurant used to be a fire house. To me, it's like if the Hot House (Menomonee Falls) and Mission BBQ had a baby. Our server was excellent. She took very good care of us. On a quiet afternoon, we were sat by the bar, by a group that was very loud. We would have preferred a different table.

Really mixed review. Food was good but the service was meh at best…read more We were seated immediately but then it took over 10 minutes before someone talked to us again. No drinks, no "we will be with you shortly" or anything. We just sat there. Finally a server came over and said they had a big group come in and it was causing some backup and the host should have told us; he didn't. The drinks and appetizer came quickly and the street corner appetizer was very good; I would order it again. Once the appetizer was finished we sat with empty glasses for a good while. Again, no communication. Once the food arrived, things got much better. Wraps were good, not great. My daughter's pizza was good. With all the restaurants in the area, they will need to up their game on service.

This restaurant is right on the beach and directly connected to our hotel, making it incredibly…read moreconvenient. They have weekly specials. We dropped by for a late lunch /afternoon snack and ordered the cheese curds and tacos. Both were fresh and flavorful! We spent the afternoon by the water and came back for dinner and ordered the grilled salmon with fries and the cherry pie. The salmon was perfectly cooked, and the flavors were excellent. One of the coolest parts about this place (and Door County in general) is that most of the servers are international seasonal workers. They brought such a great, energetic, and friendly vibe to our dining experience! The restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating right by the water. Giving it 4 stars because there is definitely room for improvement regarding service pacing and menu clarity: Time your dessert order: The restaurant was busy, so I placed my dessert order along with my dinner. Unfortunately, the hot cherry pie was brought out before we finished our main course, so the ice cream had melted significantly by the time we were ready for it. Taco Fixings: Just a heads-up that the tacos come with meat only by default. It was tasty, but I really wish it had come with some standard toppings or fixings. The Fish Boil sells out fast: They host a fish boil right by the lake, but you absolutely need to reserve well in advance. We tried to book it on Tuesday afternoon right after checking into our hotel, and it was already completely sold out for the night.

Sorry but this was the worst experience I've had traveling. Food was disgusting and the bugs on the…read morepatio harassed us the whole meal. Had fish n chips (chef special ). I really think it was made the night before. Dry and greasy. Left such a bad taste we went to Kitty O'Reilly's Irish pub and had the best Fish n Chips so I know Sturgeon Bay has good fish. I won't be back to Waterfront Mary's.

Top to bottoms this place is one of a kind. Staff is excellent, food is amazing and the place is…read moreimmaculate. Huge THANK YOU to Amy and Buster for making our group trip amazing. AZ crew appreciates you so much! Until next time!! M & M

This is one of Sturgeon Bay's popular spots and I can see why! The staff is super friendly and…read morehelpful and there's an extensive menu. It was so hard to pick just one item. The server highly recommended the mahi tacos so I went with that. My dining companion opted for the grilled club and I was so impressed with the thick cut slices of all of the ingredients and the quality of the sandwich like years ago. It was a little on the salty side, but I guess that's to be expected for deli meats. Then the mashed potatoes were real potatoes! That seems to be a thing of the past at a lot of establishments. Service was super attentive and friendly and made some great recommendations. I love the decor which was a super fun Irish vibe as well. Outdoor seating and a beer garden on those warmer days. With plenty of parking. I would love to go back and try more items.

This place was wonderful and so worth it! We had our dogs with us and the outside seating was…read moreshaded and comfortable. We ordered them breakfast sliders and the chef was ya concerned about the onions in it. They offered a substitute of burge or bacon - how thoughtful!!! They brought a bowl of water and served their food in dog bowls. On top of all of that, our food was delicious!! Everything was fresh and prepped and presented with love . The coffee was wonderful. The whole vibe was perfect. Our server CHRIS was the absolute best! He was kind and helpful and pleasant - it made everything even bette! He said lunch is just as amazing. Thanks again Chris . So, if you're looking in a fabulous spot to eat, with or without doggos, you have to try this place! It's off the charts!!!

Always a great meal. Solidly, consistent quality and service. Linda served us today. Quick to the…read moretable and very attentive. Inside decorated to please the eye. Place was dang busy for a lunch hour. Pretty much every table taken. We had the Asian Chicken wrap with chips and the hot Turkey and cheese sandwich with chips. Two glasses of Hibiscus tea to quench the thirst. Sandwiches were excellent, Wrap was loaded with perfectly prepared vegetables sliced to perfection and came with a nice Asian dressing - light and tasty. Bread on the Turkey sandwich toasted perfectly and dressed with a cherry jam for butter. Really enjoyed our meal. Asked for Hibiscus tea for the road and off we went. Highly recommend without any reservations ... my go to place in Sturgeon Bay.