My wife and I were in town from Las Vegas to take care of some family business and found Kitty O'Reillys on Yelp just a few blocks from our hotel. Took a chance and were very pleased that we did. The pub was pretty well full with locals for Cinco de Mayo but had no issues with getting a table. Their pub reminded us of our trip to Britain and Ireland last summer and all of the pubs we visited there. What a fantastic atmosphere and our server Jack couldn't have taken better care of us from start to finish. Thanks Jack! The food was outstanding and the beer was up to British standards. Unfortunately (not really) I had to indulge in a final Guinness at the bar while waiting for our Uber to arrive. Suffice it to say the barkeep was just as personable as Jack. If you're ever on Sturgeon Bay this is an establishment that you should not miss. Cheers lads and lasses. read more

Food is really really mid, but the service is great and the drinks are strong. I got so tipsy off of their gigantic Bloody Mary. A bit early for that at 10am, but it was really good so totally worth it read more

Kitty O'Reillys - It's a little early for a Bloody this large lol - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

We went to this restaurant on a whim as my husbands birthday is on st pattys day. When I asked for recommendations she boasted about the Beef Boxty and how good the "slop" is. I had to go for it and she was right. Almost wanted to order more for the way home it was so good. To keep ordering Irish meals My husband decided to try the Shephards pie, he said it was very good though he tried a bite of mine and liked it a little more. Oh I also got a Bloody Mary and boy was it good! If I order a Bloody Mary that's what I want! The Waitress was fantastic, she did a fantastic job and it was a fun atmosphere. She did warn how busy it is in the summer time so glad we came in march. read more

See all

One of our favorite places. Great food all around but on Friday had the pan fried walleye and it was VERY fishy.

I'd give it an overall 4 for the fact that my sandwich was very good. In a group of 8 for a 4:00 lunch the place had 10 other customers besides us when we got sat. The server was from Turkey and very kind but the language barrier to understand the group of older folks caused a few challenges. Unfortunately there was a missing chicken breast on a chicken Caesar salad, a wait time of 7 minutes for a piece of rye bread, dry corned beef and cabbage (this was clearly not the servers fault). To end the meal we shared the Irish soda bread pudding and i don't usually like bread pudding, yet this one was great!!! Also, a lot is to be said about a restaurant according to their bathrooms and the women's bathroom needed to be cleaned and kept nicer in my opinion. read more

See all

Excellent service. Hannah was so friendly and helpful and efficient!!Great bar. Love the Irish decor!! The lobster tacos were very good. The O'cheezy tots were delicious and the Walleye nuggets were very good! read more

See all

Came out with some friends after hiking in Door County. Good food! Good service, would recommend the bang bang shrimp for sure! read more

See all

Cozy little Irish restaurant / bar. Food was good, but pricey. We had the Shepherd's Pie. Service was o.k. on a slow night. This restaurant charges 3% for the use of a credit card. If they were smart they'd include that in the price of the entrees / drinks. Table tip machine starts at 18% and the server will stand over you while you sign. At the bottom of the bill, it has a convenient "additional tip" suggestion, and they even clearly state that the tip is AFTER tax. Not for me. I won't be back. read more

Finally made it back here! It only took me 7 years. Once again, stopped here on the way home after vacation, but had a significantly better experience. There was a bit of a wait for our table - we had a large party - but the hostess was very up front about the wait time. She quoted 45 minutes, "but it probably won't actually be that long." And it wasn't. Our server was a young man from Turkey who was terrific, and I feel bad that I didn't catch his name because he deserves some kudos. He was very patient, particularly with my elderly mother's numerous questions, and we never had to wait long for him to come by if we needed something like a drink refill or extra napkins. Speaking of extra napkins: my hot honey chicken sandwich was delicious, but very messy. I'd prefer my sandwiches to hold together a little better. That's a minor thing, though. The menu is extensive. There's something for everyone! My only other complaint is the bathroom situation. From what I could tell, there were three single-use bathrooms, which was not adequate for the number of people being served in the restaurant and also there for the outdoor live music. The band was great. RC Cola products? Interesting! We'll be back. read more

I was in town for a convention and had never been to Sturgeon Bay. Stopped here for lunch before checking into my hotel and am glad I did. Dined here on a Monday around 2:30. Had the Lobster roll app and Waygu prime rib sandwich. Both were excellent and being from Chicago, the prices were very fair for the good quality food I received. Both service and food were very good and would def recommend and come back. In fact later that night I stopped in to watch the second half of the NCAA men's b-ball championship game. Bartenders and staff were very friendly. I met owner, Amy while here. Pretty much just small talk. She is a genuinely nice person. I told her of the delicious lunch I had there earlier in the day. She was very appreciative and thanked me. All in all this place is a home run for me. Give it a try doubt you'd think any differently!!! read more

Really nice Irish Pub with outstanding service, delicious drinks and fantastic food. I had the open faced Reuben that has thick sliced corn beef, thousand island dressing and chips. Really was full of flavor. My husband had the beef boxty which looked and tasted amazing! read more

See all

Cool place. I expected a generic Irish-Pub-In-A-Box, but this one had some local character. Nice beer selection and even better Irish whisky selection. Mixed drinks made well. The chili was interesting in that it was very, very thick - like paste. Decent flavor, zero heat. The younger bartender was friendly but was working the other end of the bar. Her older coworker waiting on me was in the weeds a lot and a bit stressed out. The drinks were good, the place wasn't too expensive and the crowd was decent, especially in the off-season. I'll go back next time I am in the neighboirhood. read more

Nice waiter, average food, good service, great patio. Happened 8/16/25 good time. Kitty cat o Reilly auto parts read more

Kitty O'Reillys - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

The back bartender was great. We waited an hour for the table and an hour for our food to come out. I ordered my steak medium and it came out like leather. The mashed potatoes were cold and hard. The shrimp were good. Our service was minimum. read more

My wife had a huge salad with a lot of bacon and corned beef. I had a fish sandwich that was fantastic. If you haven't had a fish sandwich with onions on it , you gotta try it. Can't say enough good things about Carla the bar tender. read more

Good food, good service, space has great aesthetics (pressed tin ceiling, exposed brick, natural wood). The boxty was delicious if a little rich for my tastes, and I might've hoped for a slightly more Irish flavor to the music (jukebox was alternating between country and metal). Worth the visit. read more

We could not drive past this adorable Irish pub and glad we didn't. We were able to get a seat down on the patio and the weather was beautiful. Plus they have heaters they were able to turn on and keep us warm. The menu is fairly large and had all the typical options plus lots of burgers and sides. Our food was delish! read more

See all

Fun pub in Sturgeon Bay! It's a small town so I can only imagine this is a popular place for both locals and travelers. We stopped in on our way out of town on a Monday around opening (11am), and it was already filling up with folks for lunch. They sat us on their patio, which is entirely covered and heated. A great area with plenty of space -something we loved because we had three small kiddos in tow. They gave us highchairs and kids menus right away. Huge menu. I chose from the "Irish Favorites" section, because it seemed like the right thing to do here! The Open-Faced Reuben was pretty darn good. I'm a fan of the kraut, swiss cheese, and 1000 island dressing combo. The hand-cut corned beef was flavorful but just slightly undercooked for my preference. Plus it had some large fatty pieces I needed to eat around. My husband enjoyed the French Dip Sandwich, though couldn't finish it because portions were very generous. The kids shared fish n' chips, mac n cheese, and oranges. The mac seemed like Kraft out of a box, but hey they ate it! From what we could tell, Kitty's does great for live entertainment nights and big parties. They also have an extensive drink list! So I'm sure returning on a weekend would be a delight. read more

See all

We loved Kitty's! We sat outside and had delicious appetizers and drinks while we waited for our dinner. Everything was delicious and there was so much to choose from! I loved the Philly Cheesesteak sandwich and we also enjoyed the bang bang shrimp and loaded tots! read more

See all

First time here and overall it was just an average experience. The door county specialty cocktails I wouldn't recommend. I didn't even drink mine it tasted awful. I ordered the baked cod. I could do without the mushy mango salsa on top and enjoy the fish itself. The sweet potatoes fries are amazing. My bf ordered the ribs- he said they were dry. It needed more sauce. I would come back just to give this place another try. read more

Kitty O'Reillys - Baked cod - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Stopped here yesterday and boy was it a St Patricks day party! Tons of music beers and food. I was pleased they had Harp on tap. Bartenders were engaged and we didn't have to wait too long for drinks despite it being very busy. read more

Kitty O'Reillys - Fish & chips. ( that tartar sauce was delicious) - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Service was good. Ambiance was lacking and the food was nothing I'd ever care to repeat. I had the shrimp tacos which were pretty good/no frills. My husband had the taco bowl (pretty much just a salad) . The chicken was super tough and inedible. Almost like it was overcooked in the microwave. We were disappointed and would NOT recommend Kitty O'Reillys. Sorry read more

Ordered a Bloody Mary and got a huge drink that I didn't want and didn't taste good. The breakfast was huge but that's about it. I wouldn't eat there again for breakfast. Every request we had with the bartended was denied so it is not about service. If you just want slop and an overpriced Bloody Mary this is the place. read more

What a great place to enjoy a pint of Guinness and a rueben sandwich in Sturgeon Bay Wisconsin. Located a short walk from downtown is this Irish favorite! read more

Kitty O'Reillys - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Very late putting this in. When first opened had a party of three we were seated at the bar and we were ready to order quickly. They sat and took a table of 10 after us and took their order first. The staff were very rude. Ignored is when we tried to get their attention. Looked us in the eyes first and then ignored. Have not been back since and have to desire to give my hard earned money to snotty workers read more

One of the best Irish Bars I've been to... and I go to as many as possible. The ambience and decor is perfect. I need to visit in the summer as the back patio looks huge and I hear the live music is fun. Our server was fun and recommended a lot of great food. I had the Shepherd Pie and it was fantastic! Can't wait to come back! read more

The food is your standard Irish pub faire with dishes such as sheppards pie, reuben and boxty. I had a sheppard's pie which was okay, the flavor was a bit bland. However, the pub appears to be more focused on entertainment which it does a great job at. The pub has an Irish theme with a really nice courtyard area and a back bar with a stage for live music. This high energy bar is a great place to drink, listen to live music and/or watch sports. read more

Fun place with a menu that is jam packed with options. Good vibe with great entertainment! Have really appreciated the way they keep improving the venue. read more

Lovely bar and grill with amazing food, friendly staff, and a nice outdoor patio. Definitely would recommend!

Really wanted to love this place. I'm a big fan of Irish Bars/Restaurants and I was excited by the look of this establishment. Has what you would be looking for in an Irish pub/restaurant. Fancy bar with comfortable seats and extensive beers and spirits. Friendly bartenders too. The outdoor dinning area is awesome. Large, clean area where the tables are not too close together so you can talk without others on top of you. Menu had a lot to choose from. Including Irish fare, salads, soups, sandwiches, along with some full dinners. Unfortunately, I thought our food was only average. I read on Yelp where someone said that the Shepherds Pie was "one of the best they ever had".... Well, this was not the best ever, certainty not the worst either. It was just okay. My wife had the BBQ Ribs. It was the Thursday night special (which was $4 cheaper than the regular price). I did find it odd that with the "non-special" ribs, you got to choose 2 sides from a big list. The "special" however, only came with coleslaw. So my wife opted for the ribs that were not on special so she could have a side salad and onion rings. (It also came with, for some really weird reason, tarter sauce... not sure why!) The salad was really good.... Made it worth the extra $4! The other thing that came with the rib meal was a really long piece of hair, which my wife found in the barbecue sauce.... That wasn't too appealing to say the least. Waitress saw my wife pull out the hair and really didn't know what to do, so we just kept the meal and skipped the "hair" area. (Staff is pretty young and seemed a bit nervous) Overall... really cool place. Our meals could have been better (and without hair!) but I would go back for outdoor drinks and maybe something different from the menu. And oh yeah... skip the Iced Tea! It's out of a gun, (not fresh) and is not very good at all. read more

Dianna is the best bartender EVER! if I lived nearby this would be my regular spot. I might even move here just to be a regular.

Amazing outdoor patio, great food and even better service! Kid friendly as well. 10000% would suggest. read more

Kitty O'Reillys - Sheppards Pie - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

We stopped in during the fire and ice festival. Food was good and service was also very good. A friend ordered the lobster rolls and said they were delicious and a fair price read more

A little luck of the Irish finally got me to Kitty O'Reillys Irish Pub in Sturgeon Bay for a goblet of bloody! It's just $12 (or $10 on Sundays) for Kitty's Famous Loaded Bloody Mary that even comes with a chaser of your choice tap beer. This beaut is made with undisclosed vodka, A1, worchestershire and mix and then topped lovingly with Renards Cheese mozzerella whips, beef stick, pickle, olive, pickled mushroom, pickled asparagus, pepperonchini and a healthy shake of celery salt. I ordered mine spicy which was the right choice This spice seemed mild but catches up to you over time. She wasn't too thicc or too thin, and honestly was soooo well rounded with flavor. Even though it's huge, it goes down so easy I could've kept ordering more! Highly recommend this stop in Door County for the great bloody mary and food this cute spot has to offer. Awesome experience! #BobsBloodyMaryBucketList read more

Kitty O'Reillys - A delicious goblet of bloody mary - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Great cozy pub and grill where the locals eat (was steered here by a local during a wedding). Great ambiance, very friendly staff, tasty food and excellent cocktails. The dining area is left around the huge bar (typically crowded with happy patrons) that you encounter upon entering. read more

See all

We love Kitty's and have been going there for 12 years. We went for breakfast there today and when we received our bill we were charged for a loaded Bloody Mary instead of a regular one. We asked the waitress and she said that they are the same price now. My complaint is that I think the waitress should've told us that because I would've got everything on it. I feel like I got less and paid more for it. read more

Its the best ! The gardens are impecable, the menu terrific, and the service gets top marks. I highly recommend it read more

I went here by my lonesome after da sista & wife left for dinner. This was about 1 mile from the place where I was staying. I ordered the fish & chips. They were delicious, 2 nice size pieces of cod w/fries & a couple of rum & cokes (I didn't care for the scotch choices they had). The bartender ended up taking my order & serving me since the barmaid was too busy making the rounds and flirting with the guys @ the bar. The fish & chips were a great choice. The other food items looked good too. read more

See all

We've had great experiences. Great variety on the Menus and good service too! Slainte! read more

Kitty O'Reillys - a drink in a glass - Irish Near Me - Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Friday looking at the menu I realized I had NEVER had the Corned Beef Sandwich, so I ordered it. Filled with plenty of tender corned beef on marble rye bread, horseradish on the side. It was amazing! I will definitely be ordering this AGAIN. And their servings are always so big I got to eat the rest of it today. YUM! Also while you're there you can buy some $30 gift certificates for friends (or even for yourself) because with every one purchased you receive a $5 gift certificate free! Bartender Jason was very attentive, as usual. (Such a nice young man.) And don't forget to look around when you're in there because the decorations for the holiday are always SPECTACULAR! read more