Cancel

Open app

Search

Matolis Pizza and Subs

4.1 (44 reviews)
InexpensivePizza
Closed • 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM

Matolis Pizza and Subs Photos

MATOLIS PIZZA AND SUBS ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Matolis Pizza and Subs

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Lg pizza sausage, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers & anchovies. $29.11 + $4 del tip. Under done in the center.
Kim L.

Lg pizza sausage, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers & anchovies. $29.11 + $4 del tip. Meh...crust was under done in the center, anchovies are usually salty but these tasted only of salt, would have liked the onions chopped vs rings, canned mushrooms

a pizza in a box
Marion M.

Awesome pizza and Greek salad was great I'd sure eat it again the wife really hates pizza but she ate this one so that says a lot!!!!

Mushroom, pepperoni and Italian sausage.

Honestly surprised the place has 4.5 stars. Not because it's bad; just because it's extremely average. The toppings and cheese were bland. The only season came from a well rounded sauce and well made dough. Honestly with better toppings and premium wood fired oven I could see this being a strong 9/10 but as it currently stand it's at about a 7/10. For comparison most NYC pizza is 8+.

See all

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Tried to call and order a pizza for the kids. The guy who answered the phone was extremely rude. We don't tolerate rude in the south...

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Matolis Pizza and Subs

Review Highlights - Matolis Pizza and Subs

“I tried the White Pizza which was terrific, The garlic cheese bread is a 'must', and their Matoli's sauce had was delightful”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Rocco's Pizza Restaurant - Sicilian cheese pizza

Rocco's Pizza Restaurant

4.0(144 reviews)
3.3 mi
•$$

We have always enjoyed eating here. It's nice that they serve pizza by the slice to take home too…read more Portions are generous.

We have been coming to Rocco's for over 3 years. We are not regulars, but have been here over 25…read moretimes. I have never reviewed because while the pizza is good and the food is good the service has always been mediocre. Just kind of what is expected and honestly that is pretty normal for a pizza place. Today put a bad taste in my mouth. Joe our server sees us walk in with my two kids and you can see the change of demeanor when we say we are eating in. Again nothing we are unused to with two young kids we kind of always get mid or poor service, because they assume we are going to be a mess, loud and don't tip well. While we were sitting his regulars came in and boy what a flip of the coin. Very attentive. While they were sitting he shared a story about how he went to a restaurant and his server gave poor service. Didn't fill his glass for 12 minutes. How he was half way through his meal before she noticed and her excuse was she didn't see the glass. He was critiquing how you have to be more observant and attentive. How he is a server and he gets being busy, but you still need to pay attention to your surroundings. Well I ordered my daughter spaghetti with the sauce and meatball on the side. He brought it with the sauce and meatball on top and his excuse was he didn't hear me. He then didn't offer or refill my drink once. Infact because of his story I made a point to lift my glass when he came over and he still didn't refill it. Well over 20 minutes with an empty glass. He had 3 tables and one was regulars. The icing to my grip I also ordered a Diet Pepsi which is what was on the fountain but it was definitely a Pepsi Zero, all my fellow diet soda drinkers know, there is a difference and we have a preference. If your ok with good food but mediocre service it's fine, but don't expect more.

Photos
Rocco's Pizza Restaurant
Rocco's Pizza Restaurant - Large  salad with vinaigrette

Large salad with vinaigrette

Rocco's Pizza Restaurant

See all

La Bella Napoli Italian Restaurant - Antipasto

La Bella Napoli Italian Restaurant

3.7(191 reviews)
4.5 mi
•$$

We had dinner at La Bella Napoli this evening with a 5:30 reservation. We arrived around 5:20 and…read morestill waited about 15-20 minutes for a table, which probably speaks to both the restaurant's popularity and its biggest drawback: the dining room is simply too small for the amount of business they do. We both ordered the Veal alla Siciliana, with veal, eggplant, and ham. The dish was well prepared, and the kitchen did a nice job getting everything out promptly. The sauce was good, although I've had comparable or better Italian food at Argento's, and I personally prefer a thicker, richer sauce. Overall, though, the entrée was enjoyable and reasonably priced for what you receive. The extra charges were harder to understand. My fiancée had the house salad with blue cheese, while I ordered a Caesar and was charged extra for the Caesar itself and again for anchovies. By the time the upcharges were added, the salad was around $8. We also paid extra to substitute angel hair pasta. Considering angel hair is hardly a premium pasta compared with spaghetti, penne, or fettuccine, that seems unnecessary. These relatively small charges add up and detract from what otherwise feels like a fair-value restaurant. The fresh-baked rolls were very good--light and fluffy and particularly enjoyable with the seasoned olive oil. I had a Pepsi, although unfortunately it was somewhat flat. The highlight of the evening was the service. Anna was outstanding: friendly, attentive, efficient, and helpful, including boxing our leftovers. Our tip reflected how pleased we were with her service. The atmosphere is where La Bella Napoli struggles most. Tables are packed closely together, the chairs aren't especially comfortable, and the restaurant can get extremely noisy. Tonight included a crying baby, and with such a small room there really isn't anywhere for the sound to go. If you enjoy a lively, crowded family restaurant, that may not bother you. If you prefer a quieter, more relaxed Italian dinner, this probably isn't the atmosphere you're looking for. Our total for two, including tip, was roughly $80-$85. I also noticed the suggested tip percentages on the bill now extend as high as 30%. That's certainly becoming a trend, but 30% as a suggested gratuity feels excessive. There are plenty of positives. The restaurant appeared clean, the staff was consistently friendly, the menu offers a tremendous amount of variety, and the kitchen handled a busy dining room efficiently. It's also good to see a local, family-style establishment doing a strong business, including what appeared to be considerable takeout traffic. Overall, La Bella Napoli serves reasonably good Italian food, with a diverse menu at a fair basic price, with excellent service, but the numerous upcharges and especially the cramped, noisy dining room take away from the experience. Perhaps their success has simply outgrown the space. A larger dining room with more comfortable spacing would make a substantial difference and double their business. Overall: Good quality food, excellent service, fair value--but crowded, noisy, and a few too many little upcharges.

Flavor is on point and we did a carry-out however despite calling 40 minutes ahead and they said it…read morewould only takes 20 minutes we got there and still have to wait for another 18 minutes for them to get our food. What's funny is that when they rang us up and just stood there wait for me to sign and when I tipped 10% of my order, the lady rolled her eyes and proceeded to get my food packed up. Probably the reason why my food took about 18 minutes to pack up. But it's carry out, why would you expect to tip when you are not serving? And since it's carry out, I didn't get the complimentary house salad and bread like the dine in.

Photos
La Bella Napoli Italian Restaurant - Quite spot

Quite spot

La Bella Napoli Italian Restaurant - Seafood pasta

Seafood pasta

La Bella Napoli Italian Restaurant - Sauvignon Blanc

See all

Sauvignon Blanc

Ceparano's New York Style Pizza

Ceparano's New York Style Pizza

3.4(80 reviews)
4.0 mi
•$

Visited The area back in November 2017. Ordered a Chicken Marsala pizza, it was soo good, we had it…read moretwo more times that week I visited. Finally came back to visit area from Pennsylvania, my first phone call was for a chicken Marsala pizza. I was told "we don't make pies to sell, only by the slice". Are you kidding me ! Please have someone from Ceparano's get in contact with me. I'm here for 5 more days and I'm hungry!!!! Fast forward 2 days, I was able to order the chicken Marsala Pizza. It was worth the wait.

Here's a firm but factual review that focuses on your actual experience:…read more This was the third and final time we've tried to give Ceparano's a chance, and unfortunately nothing has improved. My wife placed our order at 4:45 PM. It is now 6:45 PM, and our pizza still hasn't arrived. We called three separate times for an update. Each time, the staff was dismissive rather than helpful. On the last call, we were told the pizza had left "about five minutes ago." The restaurant is only four miles from our house. Twenty minutes later, we're still waiting. Delays happen, but poor communication and a lack of concern for your customers are unacceptable. If the order was delayed, just be honest. Instead, we were repeatedly given information that didn't match reality. After three disappointing experiences, we've decided not to order from here again. I genuinely don't understand how a business can continue operating with this level of customer service. I can't recommend this restaurant based on our experience today.

Photos
Ceparano's New York Style Pizza
Ceparano's New York Style Pizza - Garlic Parmesan/buffalo Boneless Wings

Garlic Parmesan/buffalo Boneless Wings

Ceparano's New York Style Pizza - Supreme Pizza

See all

Supreme Pizza

Matolis Pizza and Subs - pizza - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...