Mateo's Mexican Cafe not long ago was simply called "The Coffee Shop." I am not sure when the new name occurred.
I wanted to love my first experience at "Mateo's" on March 26, 2026, but it fell short, so I'm going to have a solo working lunch or breakfast here hopefully soon to get a better sense of the dining scene.
The cutoff at 7 pm is a bit early for dinner in my opinion, but that's when they close.
Also, when I just wanted a few items to take home with me to add to add to my homemade taco dinner, a young female employee explained that they had to take the chile con queso off of their menu because "nobody liked it." Lol. I mean, I appreciate the honesty, but maybe just mark it off of the menu and be a little more professional next time.
The salsa tasted homemade. The small bag of chips did not.
My daughters did not like their birthday cake cookies. That was a bummer.
Super small cafe, but colorful Mexican decor all throughout. Located on the south side of Albertsons Market in the plaza. read more