Yay! Green Valley AZ does NoT have very many restaurants. I've resisted going here since I moved to town but it's been 6 months since I've had pizza. It was time! Location: good, easy to find Restaurant: clean, organized and staff were friendly, especially the blonde woman who brought my pizza out. (I purchased to go). Reasonable amount of time til my pie was ready. It was still hot when I got home. Crust: nice, crunchy and good flavor Cheese: impressive, I could actually TASTE the cheese! Very nice! Pepperoni was okay but I ordered (and payed for) double....not really a double amount. A perfect amount of sauce. All in all...I will be back! Thank you read more

The newest pizza spot in town. So clean and the staff is amazing. I walked in and ordered to go. We ordered the meatballs appetizer- 2 meatballs bigger than my hand. Tasted like meatloaf and oh so good. Had a 8" chicken bacon ranch was so yummy and a 12" sausage, black olive and mushroom. My dad's favorite. Everything was delicious. We had the cannoli and the peanut butter Reece cup cookie. I'm not a dessert person and I was left wanting more. So glad to find a spot to treat my dad when I'm in town and give him his pizza craving fix. read more

See all

Came on a work trip from Los Angeles. Amazing customer service! Came really hungry and smelled great when walking in! Huge shout out to Megan! She made the experience great as well! Super friendly and welcoming! She deserves a raise!! Next time I'm in town, definitely bringing more of my work people! read more

Everything!! Pizza was like cardboard! Fresh ingredients would wonderful!! But unfortunately won't go back! read more

Pizza is delicious and service is very good. Haven't tried the entrees yet but they look very large. read more

Mario McGee's Pizza - Mushrooms and Olives - Pizza Near Me - Green Valley, Arizona

So...one year ago we had a bad experience at this establishment.....but, we try to always be positive and give them a 2nd chance! We have now been back to Mario McGee's 2-3 times and have enjoyed ourselves each and every time.... I love the #8 Italian sandwich and ask them to toast it before adding all the vegetables.....AMAZING! Best sandwiches in GV..... And they have just an amazing 'marinara' sauce that is a very Old family recipe .....to die for..... I will try to curb my sandwich appetite and only go every few weeks...... read more

Mario McGee's is my favorite place in Green Valley for comfort food! The place is clean and the waitstaff are friendly. For lunch we had a meatball sandwich, the Southwestern Stromboli, and the Carne Calzone. Everything was fresh full of flavor. Their house made marinara is excellent. The standout for me was the chicken parmesan as an appetizer; amazing! I really enjoy this cozy restaurant. read more

Ham/turkey/salami sandwich was delicious!! Also had a pepperoni and mushroom calzone. Perfect size, homemade side of marinara. Delivery by Toast. A bit steep delivery fee, but food arrived hot and well packaged. Salad stayed chilled, flavorful Italian dressing. My new favorite pizza sandwich place in Green Valley. read more

I was really excited about a new pizza place in town and so we tried a few items. Super disappointed. It was just bad. Flavor was just not there. Will never go back. Staff was nice though. read more

The smell as soon as you open the door is magical. I was touring stores for my job and said to everyone where's the best pizza and no one could tell me. I went on an adventure before going back to my hotel and I am happy I did. The smell .. is just unreal I got a pizza split half regular half pepperoni and hot damm Batman it was phenomenal!! Great job family!!! I will be coming there many more times when I get into the area. Also the customer service was on point !!! read more

Food is delicious. Toasted garlic Parmesan bread great. Meatballs are huge. Wedge salad is to die for. Lots of blue cheese dressing. Yum! Service is great. Ice clean rest. read more

5 stars goes to the server. She was wonderful and the nicest server we've had in a long time. Definitely went over and above. The pizza, cheese bread and side salad were really good. Whenever we're in town, we will go back!! Ambiance was cute. read more

Excellent food and service. The staff is always friendly. Everyone liked the pizza. I liked the meatball sandwich.

Just ordered the wedge salad from Mario McGees, and was it good! The presentation is wonderful, and the blue cheese is outstanding! Just perfect! Also love their sandwiches and the BEST meatballs! So glad to have Mario's here in Green Valley! read more

Not the first time the pizza had raw spots. Just let it finish cooking 1 more minute... I wish i tipped AFTER i got home and ate my pizza.... read more

See all

Place is small n sometimes very loud n u can't hear the waitress asking u questions. Parking is tight sometimes cause u have to share with other businesses. Food n service is good n staff is very friendly n helpful. Ambiance is nice when it's not crowded so much. Great food n plenty for ur money. read more

Great place.Food- exceptional: service- out of this world-Beer-none better. I intend to visit at least weekly.

This place is great for lunch, there antipasto salad is to die for its huge and only $7.00. They also have a great lunch special 8 inch pizza with salad and drink for only $11.00. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Give it a try you won't be disappointed. read more

Mario McGee's Pizza - Great salads. - Pizza Near Me - Green Valley, Arizona

great Pizza, small but friendly! Went twice in 2 weeks. Service good. Wine and beer. open Monday when many other eateries closed. read more

Food was good prices very good. Service was great people were very friendly. Would go again if ever back in the area again

Best Pizza We Found in the Green Valley Area By the time I wrote this review, we'd been there 2 more times. It's a little hard to find, in an end unit and faces Trader Ln. I don't think they've been open too long as everything is still like new. Modern without being stark. We were there later in the evening towards the end of dinner hour and were seated immediately. We've seen two older ladies who are servers there and they are terrific. Anytime we ask questions about the food they steer us right every time. They are attentive without constantly being in your face. We go there to get two menu items - the small Antipasto Salad ($6.99) and a Medium Supreme Pizza ($24.79). Along with the abundant amount of veggies and meats in the salad, they also shave in cheese. A spectacular salad with not much lettuce. The Supreme pizza has Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Mushroom, Green Peppers and Red Onions. Nobody loads topping on a pizza like they do in the midwest, but Mario's does it pretty well. We really like how the crust is almost cracker thin. A little thin to hold up when first brought to the table, but firms a little more as it cools. With the salad as a starter, we only eat about a third of the pizza and bring home the rest. Just like Jello, there's always room for a Stuffed Cannoli ($2.99 ea.). These are made to order, not from the fridge case. My wife goes crazy for these. We've seen other dishes come out to tables and one looks as good as the other. They do have a bar as you enter with a couple beers on tap and I know they have a good selection of wines. Stop in someday and I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. read more

See all

We always enjoy ordering food from here. Everything we have gotten has been very good and with good sized portions. Plenty of food for later! read more

GREAT food and Excellent staff. We are never disappointed. This is always my husbands first choice. Great value for the money!!!!

Ordered a full sized chicken parmigiana sandwich. had a half: bread was very good, sauce and cheese were good. But the forgot the chicken. Both sides of the roll were full of sauce and cheese, but no chicken. There was 1 chicken finger in the middle of the roll, no meat in either end or on either side. WHAT A RIP OFF at 11.49 per sandwich. Don't order take out if you're hungry. read more

Fresh pizza, amazing crust just wish they had wings on their menu but they have the best tasting pizza in town and the appetizer meatballs.... Amazing! Great work! read more

The service was very nice, we ordered a small antipasto and a calzone to go. Everything was fresh and the open area allowed for the wonderful cheesy aromas to fill the area. They serve verb in draft and wine. They have brownies and rotating deserts (spumoni, cannoli, tiramisu). The location was consistently busy which is always a good sign. During the waiting time there were also people calling for reservations. Also the staff was cleaning consistently which was something else that will have me coming back. I will say that it is the same price to order a custom calzone verses one of the combinations that are listed, so next time I am just going to entirely customize it. Overall the entire experience was pleasant and I was very imporesses with the attendance and cleanliness of the restaurant and staff. Be willing to wait! It's worth it. read more

See all

First time here today. Husband and I shared a medium supreme pizza and the olives and cheese appetizer. I usually don't like olives, but it paired deliciously with the cheese. The pizza was good. I really liked the crust too. The staff was nice too, but I didn't like that our check and an empty pizza box was brought out without us asking for it. We were not done yet and we planned on finishing the pizza there, plus I wanted dessert. I ordered Spumoni to go. It's really good. Other than the check coming early, it was a good experience and recommended. read more

Mario McGee's Pizza - a pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - Green Valley, Arizona

Great Pizza! Lots of choices in toppings and the small is quite big! We were surprised and how good the pizza was!

I've benn ther 3 times. I've had the pizza and the meatball sandwich. Both were done to perfection and tasty. They've had their typical startup problems, but that doesn't take away from the fact that the food was very good and the staff is awesome. Give it a chance. We need more good restaurants in Green Valley. This is and will be one of them. read more

Delicious pizza, fresh ingredients and the crust was cooked perfectly. Recommend and will go back.

This is one of the first place our neighbors took us when we moved here. Since then it is one of our regular places to revisit. Any time we have guests in town, we take them here. All the dishes we have tried were full of flavor. The prices are very reasonable as well. The size of their seating area is quite small, so expect a wait if you go during peak hours, especially when all the snowbirds are here. read more

Definitely not the same pizza that we ordered in July 2023. Just bought a large pepperoni pizza today and it wasn't much different than little Caesars. Last July, it was comparable to New York pizza department in Tucson. read more

Food is good, and the place has a very nice vibe. There aren't a lot of tables and we've only done takeout. This is an updated review. We were unhappy with the pizzas until we advised to ask for extra-extra well done crust. In fact they credited our account for a pepperoni pizza that they couldn't crisp up because of the pepperoni grease. That said, I am very impressed with their service. read more

Good pizza at standard prices. Their lunch special is 1 topping 6-8" pizza with salad and fountain drink $11 For $12 you can have that special with up to 3 pizza toppings! Highly recommend! read more

I had the personal pizza. It was delicious and just the right amount. Highly recommend McGees Service was excellent and the hostess was efficient and friendly. read more

NOPE. NOT AGAIN !!! Unfortunately we decided to give them another try after bad experiences before. Nope, was even worse than before. Ordered the sandwich and it was like 95% bread and chopped up lettuce. It looked like ONLY one SMALL maybe two extremely, AND I MEAN EXTREMELY thin turkey slice. A photo of a turkey slice would have been as think. And tasteless and very disappointing. How can they even in good conscience prepare someone something like this for their customers. Just wanted to give a heads up to anyone as a warning. BEWARE ! Spooky. read more

I got takeout pizza here when they 1st opened and thought that it was o.k. Today I chose the $12 lunch special and it was good, but not great. The salad was mundane w/only iceberg lettuce and 2 grape tomatoes. some cucumber, onions or parsley would have been appreciated. The 8" pie was alright, but the toppings (mushrooms, meatballs,s, and anchovies) were sparse as was the sauce. The bottom crust was not crispy. Lots of average pizzas in GV/Sahuarita; so I'll still have to venture to Tucson, for the real deal. read more

New pizza/Italian food place in Green Valley Sahuarita area. The pizza was excellent, nice crust and plenty generous on the toppings Also ordered chicken park, with spaghetti. Also very good. Nice addition to our area, also small area for inside dining. We will be back to Mario McGees for a 2nd helping.... read more

Although it was a busy day of the week, the people were very friendly and the service was quick to buy a gift card. We will definitely return to eat. There is plenty of parking and it's in a very convenient location. read more

The pizza is OK, but not good enough to make me want to go back. The facilities and wait staff are adequate.