While I am thrilled to have a decent grocery store within short walking distance of home, historically I have been more ambivalent about the Mariano's chain than all of the fanboys and -girls out there. It is clearly superior to Jewel but not the Second Coming of Grocerydom. However, so far I am a fan of this new location. It is roomier than the Roscoe Village store, and there is always a legion of employees on the floor, many of whom will greet you with a friendly "Good morning."
There are a few unexpected elements that set this place apart, such as fresh popcorn at the candy counter, a barbecue stand, and an oyster bar. I am also impressed that 98% of the products are available right at opening time at 6 am. You can't get a fresh pulled pork sandwich or maki roll at that time (wait until 9), but the deli, the bakery, the salad bar, the candy counter, the meat and seafood section--all are staffed and stocked and ready to serve.
One major drawback is the lack of self-checkout terminals. I have to say that this Mariano's keeps their checkout lanes staffed satisfactorily in the afternoons and evenings; but in the mornings (weekends) I usually see only two lanes open and end up waiting several minutes.
The store is predictably zooish at 6 o'clock on weeknights, but weekdays around 1 pm are not as bad as you might think. Weekend mornings at 6:30 are dreamy.
Generally I don't think that it's productive to compare all of these chains on prices, at least for groceries. For example, Mariano's beats Jewel on our brands of peanut butter, veggie burgers, and canned cat food, but Jewel wins on pretzels and milk. Mariano's regular price on whole pineapple is cheaper than Jewel's, but two recent Jewel sale prices soundly trumped two recent Mariano's sale prices. So why bother running hither and thither to save a few cents on regularly purchased items? I choose to shop for convenience and there is nothing more convenient than a one-block walk.
Random positive notes:
+ Pretty good craft and imported beer selection: on the shelves, in the walk-in cooler, and in the make-your-own-six-pack. I wish that it included more local options.
+ The deli items are hit or miss but mostly hit; my favorites so far are southwest roasted corn, edamame quinoa salad, and teriyaki salmon.
+ I have tried all of the soups worth trying, and most range from good to great; my favorites are black bean, potato bacon, turkey chicken chili, and tuscan white bean & kale.
+ The six-dollar meals at the deli
+ Kirk's Castile soap ($3.99 per three-pack)
+ The white paper bakery bags are manufactured in Chicago
+ Choice of salad bar containers includes the brown compostable "cardboard"
+ The bakery makes a really good raisin bran muffin
Disappointments:
- No bulk candy like at Roscoe Village
- No Kerrygold Irish butter. Instead they sell some knockoff called "Shannon Gold."
- The apple fritter is disappointing, just like at Roscoe Village
- The bakery produces a wondrous range of goods, but the only single rolls available are bolillo and telera. While this is grudgingly adequate for most of my random sandwich needs, sometimes I might want a different kind of roll to go with soup or a meal. Multigrain? Sourdough? Pretzel? More variety please.
- The barbecue is not good. The rolls are dry, the brisket is dry and bland, and the sauces are so-so. The pulled pork is greasy but better than the brisket.
- Speaking of not good--the bananas, almost always overripe and beaten up
- The walk-in beer cooler door operates on a motion sensor, so if you are browsing the selections close to the door, it will open and close constantly. Terrible waste of energy. read more