The owners are the hardest working couple I know. They have the best margaritas in northern Indiana, and their food is consistently great!

Friday night- seems like everything else in town (and all the surrounding towns) shut down at 9 or earlier. We found Margaritas and they're open to a decent hour for a Friday! Yay! We were the only ones in there- chips and salsa and apps, then all the entrees. Food was good, service was good, beer was cold. Would definitely recommend! read more

Nice little restaurant in a small strip mall. The wait staff was new but very nice and willing to serve. The food was tasty - flavorful and fresh. The guac could have used a bit more salt but it had texture and lots of avocado. The enchiladas and burritos were very good. The only sub par item was our 'gold margarita' - bland with no salt around the rim. Next time go for the cold bottle of beer if you want an adult beverage. read more

See all

Best to avoid. With so many other restaurants around this place should not even be an option. My wife's order was oily and soggy. My order was cold and oily. This was our second visit, our first visit was opening day years ago, and we had a similar (not as bad) experience. We had hoped the kinks were worked out. This recent visit drove the nail for us, this restaurant is a no go for us now. read more

Margaritas - The so call burrito tortilla wasn't heated. Just disappointing for everyone involved. - Mexican Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

We live in Middlebury, and this is our go-to place for Mexican food. Try the churros for dessert !

Great food, and service. The ambience feels like a restaurant in Mexico. The salsa and chips are the best ever. Recommend taking your family or a date there. Prices are reasonable and the waiters are friendly. read more

Great food and service! We need more Mexican food in Middlebury. Try it out for Taco Tuesday!

Not had food. The pork tacos were a bit price for the quantity and quality. Place is clean though. read more

The food is excellent! It is almost the best Mexican restaurant in the area. They are very accurate in filling the food order and the food does arrive fairly quickly and hot. The food portions are a bit small for the price and the service is not so great. It is supposed to open at 11:00 on Sundays but no one is even in the building until around 11:30. It seems to take forever to receive your drinks and when you're ready to leave, you just about have to beg to receive your ticket. My husband and I had to stand at the register to force the issue. The staff is very polite but they seem to be very short-handed. If you want great tasting Mexican food I do recommend but only if you have the time to patiently wait. read more

very disgusting food. very watery and the tamale was dry and disgusting, rice was dry as well.

We eat here like at least 2 x a week!!! The service is awesome !!! And of course the food Rawks!!! Such a friendly fast authentic experience. Recommend to all!!!!! read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

I really can't complain. We were immediately seated and given complimentary chips and salsa while we considered our menu options. After placing our order, we were served a second basket of chips and salsa. Within minutes our food arrived at our table hot and fresh. Everything tasted good. When you are done, you don't even have to wait on your check. Just go up to the register, they will have it there when you are ready to check out. This is (in my opinion) the way restaurants should operate. read more

Great food! Nice restaurant ran by a family. Food was hot and filling. Enjoyed the atmosphere and decor. Quiet, relaxing place to eat. read more

Margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

Haven't been to Margaritas in years before this, so I was excited to try it again. Atmosphere could be a little better. Seems a little dull inside. The staff was very friendly. Food was good and chips and salsa was tasty! Overall still a good restaurant to me. read more

Lots of mixed reviews for this place, but we're locals (after years of vacationing in the area), and we really like it. We've had many positive experiences here and will return in the future. (P.S. - try the churros for dessert!) read more

Always good food, friendly staff family owned. If you're looking for solid mexican cuisine in the middlebury area, this is the place to go.

This was my 1st visit but it won't be my last! I tried the Maggies and was VERY happy. The salad with guacamole was crisp and tasty and the rice was perfectly seasoned. Even the chips and salsa were very tasty. Excellent choices and I will be back. read more

The chicken mole was delicious! The beans and rice were pretty much exactly what I expected, and the tortillas are obviously fresh made. The only thing keeping me from giving that 5th star was the burn on my tongue from the hot chocolate that kept me from fully enjoying my meal. The decor is festive without tipping into gaudy, and the service was prompt and courteous. I'll eat here again, but I'll be avoiding the molten hot chocolate. read more

Traveling east from North Dakota, first Mexican Food we've had and really good! Lunch specials, plenty of food.

I've eaten here several times and have found the food to be good and consistent. The service is prompt and polite with a desire to please. Prices are reasonable and the selection of menu items is also good. The decor is poor and the booths are TERRIBLE. if they would renovate this place would be a top eating destination in Middlebury. read more

Great spot!!! Gentleman working tonight (perhaps) owner was fantastic and worked his butt off, solo, serving, busing tables, and cashier! He could run circles around most servers nowadays. Prompt service, great chips, and entrees. Highly recommend!!!! read more

What a disappointment. Not sure how you can mess up Mexican food but they sure did. Service was really awful from the moment we came in and were NOT greeted. The person we are guessing was the owner asked a very clueless boy to set up a table. The place was small and not busy yet it took forever to get our drink order taken. It's hard to say what was worse the tasteless food, or the margaritas that seemed to be missing alcohol. The chips and salsa were passable. No one brought us our bills until we forced the issue by all seven of us standing at the cash register ready to go. Before eating we asked for a quote to do some catering, it never arrived. Thank goodness for that as we won't be using them or ever returning to this place. read more

This little Mexican restaurant has delicious food, wonderful margaritas, and a super friendly staff. It's a perfect place to start the weekend. Great chips, salsa, and guacamole! read more

My travel companion and I were extremely happy that we stopped into this little "hole in the wall" Mexican Restaurant on our way home from a training event. The service was fast, the food was outstanding. I am especially fond of "hot" salsa, and they hit the mark on that as well. I will stop in again next time I'm in the area and highly recommend you give them a try. It appears the local factory workers know the place is good. read more

We stop here every time we come to shipshewana.....great food and wonderful service. Try them out. You won't be disappointed.

i rated this one star but only bc there's no option to rate it zero stars. the pricing is terrible it was $40 for two ppl to eat. "putrid" is how i would describe the food. taco bell steak is better quality than the steak i ate here at this " authentic" mexican restaurant. do yourself a favor and drive another 15 minutes to El Maguey on Cr. 17 read more

Ordered the carne asada but it was almost too salty to eat, and I like salt! It tasted like it was marinated in soy sauce. No BUENO! The server was very nice however. Very attentive. read more

Horrible experience. We walked in stood at the door for about 8 minutes to wait to be seated as their sign states....with absolutely NO acknowledgement. When we are finally "seated" (the girl who finally decided to wait on us pointed towards a table in back and told us to go sit as she walked by us) the table was still dirty and needed to be wiped down. We sat there roughly 15-20 more minutes without so much as a drink order...while another family that came in after us was seated and waited on. We then put our coats back on and proceeded to walk out so we could find food for our children....again with absolutely no acknowledgement. In hindsight, I feel this is a blessing in disguise. I was honestly preparing myself for some stomach issues after eating there. Save yourself the trouble and find another place to eat. read more

This place just has gone from mediocre to horrible! Waited 20 minutes to get our order taken on a slow night. Asked 3 times if quesadilla for a kid could be chicken and cheese only and were told yes well when food came had veggies in it and not until the watched me pick them all out did the come check on us. Never saw again until it was time to get our bill oh and to top it off they charge a service fee for using a card! They are lucky to be the only Mexican restaurant in middlebury as if the weren't they would be closing down. 1 star is me being nice..... read more

I went on a Saturday afternoon. There wasn't a single customer in the restaurant. I ordered a burrito & beer. The beer was cold and the waitress was nice . My food came out in about 2 minutes. I thought this was odd then realized why, it was cold. I could not understand why since it was the only order in the kitchen. I found a small piece of metal in my burrito, well that's where it started, I found it in my mouth. The waitress was very nice but just blew off my comments about the food being cold and something metal in my food. I would not recommend this place to anyone just for their own safety. read more

My family and I decided to give Margaritas a try one Sunday afternoon. We were greated promptly and were sat in a spacious comfortable booth....and that is where the good experience ended. We had a self declared "new" waiter who admitted to not knowing the menu or what the ingredients came with each menu item. When my wife ordered fajitas without sour cream....they were delivered with sour cream. The server never came back to the table to check on us the entire time. We finished our meals with with empty glasses. I ordered the dinner portion #39 Pollo con Chrizo which turned out to be very small for $9.00. (See pic)Unfortunately not a good first impression! read more

Margaritas - #39 Pollo con Chrizo - Mexican Near Me - Middlebury, Indiana

Margarita's is a family owned and operated authentic Mexican restaurant. The owner had years if experience with another restaurant group before opening this location. They obviously use quality ingredients and they put out some of the best Mexican food I've ever had. A simple place with great food at a tremendous value. read more

Good service and cold beer. My carne asada tacos could have been much better. The small amount of meat in the tacos was died out and definately not fresh. The place was clean and comfortable but the music was too loud. read more

The booths are horrible because I could feel the back of the booth push me forward every time the people behind me moved or adjusted themselves. The service was okay I guess. The food was decent but the guacamole did not taste well. The exterior looks really nice but the interior doesn't look so well. Food prices are decent. read more

Great food, perfect portion sizes. The service experience was incredibly fast and the food was HOT! First time at this restaurant and believe me there aren't very many places to eat in Middlebury but my expectations were exceeded tonight. read more

We came to eat here once and the service was excellent. The staff was extremely nice and polite. We were a little hesitant to come because of the reviews but I am so glad we did. Definitely would recommend to anyone. read more

Very average place. very 1st they gave salsa and chips was very bad taste never ate like this in mexican res. the server who was taking my order looks like in hurry. the food I got was below the average. there was wifi signal under their name but they said its not for the guest. overall bad experience I would say. read more

First time visit last night. Food was wonderful. There were five of us and each one of us thoroughly enjoyed our meals. I loved my nacho supreme and the fajitas looked amazing! read more

Food is lacking and service ran flat. Saw a table walk out due to not being waited on.