My wife and I went there tonight for our 3 year anniversary...my wife ordered the sizzling fajitas...I ordered three soft shell tacos with chicken...the chicken was not cooked fresh as an ex cook I know the difference ,this piece of chicken had been laying around for awhile and was overcooked from the beginning.. And here's the worst most shameful,and unforgivable part...the only business they had was our table and another 2 top... The last time we went here the Sizzling fajitas,my wife ordered sat around for about 5 minutes utes and there was no dramatic sizzle effect when he brought it to our table.. So,To the management at El patron..Thanks for taking the $18 off the check but,we wont be coming back..its a shame too but,your cook should have been sent home with no pay,for using leather chicken... Oh,and your welcome for the $54 read more

Great food and friendly staff. Older atmosphere. Never overly busy. Open on Sunday

This is a great spot! The food is yummy and everyone who works there are very friendly. It's a bonus that it is open on Sunday!

stopped in for a bite after a long day, friendly faces, good prices, good food. Definitely recommend nachos are amazing read more

EL Zorrito 2 - a plate of food on a table - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

Had the Enchilada supreme, was delicious! Free chips and good salsa, ordered a side of guacamole. It was probably the best guacamole I have ever had in a restaurant! $38.00 for 2 people. Not a bad deal. They don't serve alcohol. Service was ok. Nothing special. read more

EL Zorrito 2 - Enchilada Supreme. - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

This was a very interesting dining experience to say the least. My wife and I ate here on a Saturday evening and both enjoyed our food although I don't really remember what all we ate. I just remember everything tasted good. I remember getting watermelon tea to drink and it was so good I wished I had gotten more refills than I did. I lived quite a bit of my life in the border states of the southwest with approximately ten years in Texas, four years in Arizona, and four months in California. This place could easily hold its own in any of those states and I told them so. In fact, I told them of a bit of a "missed opportunity" that could have made them even better and more authentic. The Sonoran-style Mexican restaurants of southern Arizona (and the two I ate at in Nogales, Mexico) actually used queso mennonita--Mennonite cheese--in their recipes and so it seemed very fitting that this restaurant in Shipshewanna with so many Amish and Mennonite employees and customers should also use queso mennonita in their recipes, but alas they'd never thought of it. The only negative experience we had was having to stand in line for a long time with some very obnoxious customers who were also waiting to be seated. Since the restaurant doesn't serve alcohol they were all acting like they'd already gotten half drunk before they got there. Their language was inappropriate for public behavior in a family restaurant setting and they were rude and insulting to my wife and me when all we were doing was trying to ignore them. read more

EL Zorrito 2 - a plate of mexican food - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

Great authentic food, the service and speed of service was great. I would recommend stopping by if you are passing by or going to the flea market. I plan on going back soon. read more

EL Zorrito 2 - Enchiladas supreme, very good! Red sauce is spot on - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

I have to start by saying, do NOT let the outside appearance cause you to turn around. The food is amazing! And the staff are very nice, helpful. Our food came out hot and large portions with an abundance of chicken, steak and so many shrimp!! All for a reasonable price! This may be Amish county but I will choose to come back here vs one of the Amish buffets read more

EL Zorrito 2 - Chicken fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

See all

Wow! What a hidden treasure! Muy autentico!! Great atmosphere and the food is amazing! I had veggie fajitas and Dave tried the Steak Mexicano. Both fabulous. And we shared the jalapeño poppers, which were good. Our server Nina, was warm, engaging and very responsive to every need! Highly recommend. read more

EL Zorrito 2 - a table full of mexican food - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

See all

We stopped in here on the Saturday before Valentine's Day so we were concerned we might have to wait, but we got there early and we're seated promptly. All of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful. Despite being extremely busy, our server stayed on top of things and our food came out in a timely manner. This is definitely a spot that the locals frequent. The food was delicious! I had vegetarian fajitas which were excellent. My husband had a quesadilla that he enjoyed. My mom ordered some hot chocolate and it came in a beautiful mug and she said it was wonderful. I would recommend checking this place out. read more

EL Zorrito 2 - Hot chocolate - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

See all

We had supper here this evening and we really enjoyed the food, the atmosphere and the friendly service. Food here in Shipshewana has been really good but we wanted to try a little different flavor and we were glad to find El Zorrito. Service was friendly and efficient, it is a really cute place and the food was delicious. We would return and would recommend. read more

Extremely disappointing. Waited a very long time for our food and when it finally came, it was wrong and not tasty. Disorganized atmosphere and the bathrooms were dirty. read more

I received excellent food and service. Highly recommended when visiting Shipshewana, Indiana!

This is a clean restaurant. The building is run down...a little...but it is evident that management is keeping it clean. Not the issue! This isn't true Mexican food. It is Americanized Mexican! The guacamole was horrible. Not fresh. Mexican food isn't this heavy either!! Too much cheese melted beyond recognition. I live in Shipsy, really wanted a good place for fresh, healthy Mexican food. Not here. read more

We eat dinner at El Zorrito. The food and service was very good. We were skeptical about having Mexican food in Indiana as we are from Arizona where eating Mexican food is popular and eaten nearly everyday. Their salsa was excellent . read more

WORTH THE DRIVE!!! I love El Zorrito 2 So much that I have been willing to travel an hour or two just for some good Cooking! I have personally known the family who runs the Restaurant for 12+ years. I love their family with all my heart and I love the food as well. The customer service is on point as well as the food. Def stole my heart and made this my favorite Restaurant in the world. The Arroz Con Pollo is to die for though. Taaren & Carmelo I miss you guys!! read more

Never in my 65 years on this planet have I been in a restaurant that puts to -go orders a priority over dining room customers. Went here last night , ordered 6 tacos. The restaurant was pretty much empty except for 2 groups who already had their food served. Sat there for 20 minutes before the server came back and told us " Sorry for the wait but we had a lot of to go orders to fill your order is being plated" 10 more minutes still no food. Got up and left. read more

Food was good, it took over an hour to be served. Waiter hid behind the cash register until we confronted him about our food then said he was going to "check" on it. Came to table and told us there was an issue with the printer, no apology, just a statement. This will be the last time we eat here. read more

They have the best burritos ever. Not to mention thier tacos and the queso and chips let's just say they have the best food around. And the service is great the staff is very friendly. It's a great place to eat. read more

Do not bother walking any long distance here on a Monday. The sign says OPEN but they are NOT! I've eaten here several times while in town this week, and although I order the same thing each time - the bill is never the same twice. The last employee to whom I mentioned the disparity between published menu prices and my check said: "I'm not management, I just work here." Wrong answer! Despite that - the food is OK and (sometimes) rather reasonable. ;-) read more

Got into town late after driving all day looked at what my options were for dinner and walked three-quarter miles down to where the restaurant was. Nice little atmosphere inside not really like a Mexican restaurant that you're used to but it was OK. I ordered the Kearny Asada and for something that was a quarter of an inch thick it was the toughest piece of meat I've ever seen and the steak knife could've been sharp it might've been better. Service is OK but I won't be going back there. read more

Tried to like it but I just can't. Metal stacking chairs, food that is lacking, and slow slow service. My 2 tacos were about as tiny as it gets. But what do you do? Just no other Mexican places close by. read more

I spent 2 days in Shipshewana Indiana. I stopped here (EL Zorrito 2) for a late lunch. The restaurant and bathroom were clean. Service was wonderful. My server was Carmelo. I ordered the Shrimp Quesadilla. It was huge. The shrimps were large. I wanted only grilled onions and melted cheese. It was served with a salad . I could not finish it, so I'm bringing it back to my hotel room . The price with a beverage was only $11.00. I'll return! read more

EL Zorrito 2 - Mexican Near Me - Shipshewana, Indiana

A lot of food I only eat 1/2 and took half home...the only thing open later in Shipshewana, but well worth it. Warm chips and salsa all you can eat.Warm kind and attentive staff read more

I apologize for having nothing good to say about our experience. Chips and salsa brought to table without asking, not being told they were not complimentary. Young waiter, without a clue, what he was doing. 3 out of 5 got wrong food, no apologies for having to wait to get correct order. Waiter only returned to point and say pay there when you go. Received no bill. When paying, got quite the surprise. When questioning bill as told "I don't know, I wasn't your server" however she could tell us what we ate, and that chips and salsa are extra, $4.50 for soda.Was not told tip was included. So inadequate server was double tipped. 1 steak fajita 16.99, 1 soda 4.50, came out to over $36, not including double tip server got. 1 nacho Mexicana Mexican pizza, I believe was and one water, one soda (once again not taking into account double tipping) was just under $40. Food had no taste, restaurant no atmosphere and could be cleaned, service was horrible. Not told tip was already added, not told when had not asked for that chips and salsa was extra. Very disappointed. Will never return or recommend!! Only downside to our Shipshewana trip!!! read more

Today was Wednesday flea market day and we were able to get in and out of our favorite place quickly. Staff here is always smiling and since we are regulars a big hello from everyone. Today's specials were great and filling. One of the waitresses who was gone for the summer has returned and I am happy to see her friendly face again. When in town please stop in to see these great staffers and some of the best Mexican food around. Plus they have Real Fried ice cream not the cereal kind!!! read more

Restaurant seemed nice and clean, service was a little on the slow side. Once I ordered the food was served very quickly and it was hot! I ordered tamales and they were disappointing, very dry. Once I ordered the food was served very quickly and it was hot I ordered tamales and they were disappointing very dry. It's highly unlikely I will return. read more

One of our favorite places. Tried the tilapia and it was outstanding, from the way it was prepared to the serving portions. Love this place

How about updating your hours of operation on Facebook or Yelp please. Would have liked to try your restaurant, but I came too early apparently. read more

Good Mexican food! A lot better than others I've been to. Friendly staff & fun atmosphere. Would definitely recommend!

I love coming to this restaurant I highly recommend the steak fajita they are excellent. The restaurant is nice and cozy with very friendly people I highly recommend it read more

First let's say we were raised on Mexican food. There are many varieties of Mexican food. In texas and New Mexico, we are used different kinds of enchiladas with a great variety of sauces. MOLE MEANS SAUCE. IN GENERAL, when you see mole know that is a dark sauce with chocolate and cinnamon. Not my favorite. This restaurant uses mole as its sauce for enchiladas. Pass A stand by for new restaurant is fajitas. Usually the easiest to make. This fajitas had poor quality of meat So Tough it was impossible to chew. Very little meat but lots vegetables. Only had enough good meat for 1 beef fajitas soft taco. They did bring free chips and salsas. Wait staff was friendly. I would just say no. Unless this is what you are used too. read more

The worst food I've ever had. Worst service ever and tried to charge us for salsa when it should come with it. Our server was mumbling the whole time and acted like she wasn't tryna help us. I wish I could give zero stars but I can't. Paid $100 for nasty food!!! Tacos had like three pieces of meat on it smh they childish for that . read more

Good salsa and chips. Chimichanga was light any tasty. Good food, and although they seemed short of staff, service was great and food served fast and hot. read more

I wasn't impressed. We went at lunch. It was very slow. The place is clean and nice atmosphere. The salsa was delicious but very, very cold. Good warm chips. No one in our group "loved" their food. The rice was delicious not so much for the beans. The chimichanga I ordered was beautifully fried golden brown, but the chicken inside it lacked flavor and salt. I expect a little heat or spice in my Mexican food and it just wasn't there. Beware-some of the items listed on the lunch menu are priced higher than the same item on the dinner menu. Overall, I don't think we will come back. There are much better choices for Mexican food in Sturgis, and Angola. read more

We love Mexican. This place does it right . We get the Arroz. Con Pollo, and its fab. Chip are warm salsa is just right. Service is great. They are very nice, friendly. We had this server and she was very nice to our kids. She took very good care of our large party. This place is hoping on the weekends full of ppl and good music. They now serve breakfast on Sunday so my hubby and I can order Mexican and the kids can get pancakes. We will be there on Sundays read more

Finally, some good Mexican food in Shipshewana, in a nice setting! We'll be coming back regularly.

This place is awesome!! We came here for dinner after spending the day exploring the local towns. I had looked on Yelp and El Zorrito 2's Facebook, and decided to give it a try. Boy did we make the right decision! My husband and I shared the Amish Fajita Platter for 2. This meal is huge! We both received our own plates of rice, beans, sour cream, and guac salad and 3 flour tortillas. Then this huge sizzling skillet came out. On the bottom was a layer of grilled tomatoes, green peppers, and onions. On top of this bed of veggies is two pork chops, beef strips, chicken strips, and shrimp too! Everything was cooked perfect and very flavorful. The server was very polite and attentive. Very happy. We will definitely be back. read more

We had a fantastic dinner, great service, generous helpings. We definitely recommend. MaryAnn, Port Charlotte, FL

Excellent food, love the cheese dip. We got the fajitas, can U say OMG they were the best. The Chimi - Acapulco is the best I see why the locals love that place. It's a nice change if you are in town for a few days. Staff was very helpful, and good. We will be back again and again. read more