Pirate Pizza is easily in our top 3 favorite pizza spots ‍--and that's saying something. The pizza…read moreis consistently great, with fresh, flavorful ingredients that actually taste like they were chosen with care, not just thrown together. But let's talk about that garlic bread... wow. It's the kind you keep reaching for even when you swear you're full. Perfectly balanced--just the right amount of garlic, butter, and seasoning without being overpowering. If you're craving solid, satisfying pizza with sides that don't feel like an afterthought, Pirate Pizza absolutely delivers. Definitely a spot we'll keep coming back to.

We've lived in the WGV area for 2 years now and we finally ordered a pie from Pirate Pizza. Why…read moredidn't we try it sooner? The best NY style pizza in the area! We ate 3 slices each for dinner and I usually only eat 1! We had a good old cheese pizza and the girl on the phone was right- we didn't need to order extra cheese. My husband's only comment: Great foldable crust, delicious sauce, quality ingredients but needed olive oil to run down his arm to his elbow- essential oils in his mind! Add to the fact that we had just returned from Huntington NY where we ate at Little Vincent's - a 41 year old cornerstone!

I had been craving pizza and kept hearing good things about this spot so I picked it up a pie and…read morebrought it home. It was still piping hot when I got home, which is always good news. I just got a plain cheese pizza. The sauce was quite good but the cheese itself didn't really hit for me. It seemed super salty somehow? The crust was pretty good too tho. So overall a decent pizza. I'd try it again. One bummer tho... it did not reheat well at all! I didn't interact a ton with the employees there but they were pleasant. No complaints at all!

I had two to go orders done incorrectly in a row. I had to try to get the second one corrected and…read moredoing so led to an unpleasant argument with the restaurant. But the owner reached out to me the day after, explained the confusion, took responsibility and sincerely apologized. Trying to be a better Christian and knowing that they are just trying to make a good living also, I am updating my review and make it more positive. Because to be honest, their pizza is very good and my kids love them. We go there at least once a week. The owner also committed to get future orders right this time. And I guess I need to triple check my order before leaving so it gets corrected right then, instead of having to drive back.

Nicolas was very friendly but did need some assistance. This was his first calzone and it wasn't…read morevery good. Not enough ricotta or mozzarella cheese. The calzone was also a bit overcooked.

We Have ordered here multiple times. We are very happy with the food and the customer service…read more Owners are hands on love that. Very nice and clean. Highly recommend. Rae Malee Walsh Watson Realty Corp 813-784-7891

Great cheesesteaks! Found this place by chance and enjoyed our meal completely. Had onion rings and…read moresteak fries too. Great service and food was fresh and tasty. They even brought us some watermelon ice. Nice treat after our meal. Definitely will be back.

What a hidden gem! I've been spoiled by Louie and his wife since we started going in here. I won't…read moreget a cheesesteak anywhere else now. I live in the area so it's convenient, but if you don't is WORTH the drive! Took us a while to finally try the pizza because we didn't want to not get a cheesesteak, but it was worth the wait. The pizza is just as good as the cheesesteaks, and don't get me started on the cookies. Like crumbl but better and not as expensive. The place is decorated with Philly sports decor but they still show love for the jags, if you dine in you can receive water ice as a treat while waiting for the food to be prepared.

I went to Rosatti's and I was pleasantly surprised by the food, the hospitality of the young lady…read morewho greeted me and gave me my order. I did pickup of an XL double dough pepperoni and half sausage green pepper , as well as an Italian cheesy beef sandwich with hot and sweet peppers. They were both excellent, and the beef was very flavorful like the ones you would find in little Italy in Chicago, at Portillo's, or Buona Beef. I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. The pizza was really good too. The place has a couple of booths and a little counter. It is not a traditional sit down restaurant, and I would suggest you get takeout anyway, but it's there if you want to try dining in. I'll certainly be back.

I'm from Chicago and have only been down here a few months. Was surprised to find a Rosati's down…read morethe road and ever more surprised by the pizza I received. You guys nailed it! I ordered a Sausage Supreme thin crust, which is typically what we eat in Chicago. I do like a good Deep Dish every once in a while so I'm anxious to give that a try next. This location is mainly take-out, but they did have a few tables. Very clean inside with excellent customer service. Cheers!

Excellent pizza and garlic knots Friendly service…read more We are on the patio as the inside was packed and very crowded

This was a pretty neat Italian restaurant but there wasn't noting over the top about it. Its…read moreservice was friendly and polite but noting that would make you remember it. I ordered Chicken Marcela and my wife order lasagna. Both were pretty good but definitely not the best we have ever had . The atmosphere was a bit crowded and loud. It definitely wasn't very romantic. I will say that the Wood Stone Pizza really looked like the star of the show and we should have gotten it. We talked to multiple customers and they all said pizza was fantastic. So honestly we probably just ordered the wrong thing. It's like going to a steak house and ordering chicken! Just don't do it. I would give this a solid 3 1/2 to 4 star rating. Nothing was bad just wasn't nothing over the top either!

Great food, friendly service, and a fun atmosphere. I ordered the House Special minus the veggies…read moreand it was loaded with meat, cheese, and flavor. The slice was huge and definitely hit the spot. My daughter had the kids meal, which was basically a cheese pizza on hoagie bread, and she cleaned her plate. The staff was welcoming, our food came out quickly, and the vibe inside made for a great place to sit down and relax.

Just want to tell you about an absolutely horrible experience we had at this restaurant…read more Came in with our family of 5 Ordered Salad 10 piece boneless wings - 2 flavors came out lukewarm warm 10 piece wings - 2 flavors came out cold 10 piece wings - 2 flavors came out cold 10 piece wings - 2 flavors asked for well done came out cold Kids meal came out like warm We told the server she was like no worries I will have them remade. Our 13 year old realized he made a mistake and wanted boneless instead of classic and asked since she was having them remade if he could get them boneless, she said yes. When we got our new wings 1 set of 10 came right warm not hot. The classic she had changed to boneless came in flavors no one asked for. And the other set of boneless came in another set of flavors no one asked for We told her and she said said sorry but In the end we ended up eating and having to settle for the incorrect food. When she asked if we wanted a box she brought it to us. And end up taking the extra wings that were the wrong flavors anyways and trashing them so we couldn't take them home. And to top it off when we walked up to the restaurant 6 staff members were hanging out outside and when we left 6 were still hanging out outside including our server who just left us. Horrible experience would not recommend this place

We stopped here while in st Augustine for a few things. It was a cute little place and my boyfriend…read moreand I got two different pizzas, some cheesy bread and I got a ceaser salad. The service was great our waitress was very friendly and helpful in giving my boyfriend a suggestion on what to get, he always asks the waiter/waitress their opinion since they know best since they work there and he wasn't disappointed. We started with the cheesy bread and it was pretty good. My Cesar salad was absolutely AMAZING. Loved it. He got the Chicago deep dish pizza and he had never had one before. He LOVED it! It was a lot of food. I got the hot honey pizza and it was a flatbread pizza. I wasn't the biggest fan of the pizza and I'm not entirely sure why. The one thing I can pinpoint is that there was a lot of honey on it and sometimes it was way too overpowering. It was also a cute little place. I will say if you are coming here for pizza you definitely want to make sure you have time. The deep dish pizza takes about 45 minutes (it says this on the menu so it isn't a surprise which I love.) and the flatbread pizza was I believe 30-35 minutes. So we were there for quite a bit waiting but it was a pretty nice place!

A number of people told me to visit Hillary's for some great pizza, and I have no doubt that they…read moretruly enjoy the unique flavor and texture of Chicago Pizza - it's not exactly my style, but Hillary's does do a nice job overall of providing a nice dining area, excellent Greek salad, and a quality of pizza that many others enjoy. I found the pizza better on the second day when I reheated it at home. I found the outside of the business not so enticing, being right next to a check cashing store. Once inside however, the Chicago themed artwork, lighting hanging from the rafters, and the bar area we're all quite attractive. Service was also good on the day of our visit, we were told that the standard thick crust Chicago style pizza generally takes between 45 minutes and an hour to prepare, in case you're expecting to enjoy in-restaurant dining. Pricing for a salad and a shared pizza with drinks, tip and tax average about $30 per person, a reasonable value. Overall, the quality of the product is excellent, it's just not necessarily my preferred style of pizza.

I visited the Oakleaf location and thought it was the perfect stop for me and my son to grab a…read morequick and delicious bite! Tons of options, friendly staff, and a great location. We always love our visits here.

We did take away from Jersey Slice and ate in our holiday home…read more The staff was very nice and offered a free drink while we were waiting. We had Margarita and Veggie Pizza in Large size for 4 adults and couldn't finish it up. Both pizzas tasted very well.

Excellent pizza Great ingredients…read more Very good service Try it they're across from the new big Publix

Delicious NY style pizza, they even offer Sicilian style and regular all by the slice. Excellent…read moretaste and good sized slices. Their garlic knots are delicious and not greasy. One of our go to's when in the mood for pizza.