Initial impression when walking in, "This is going to be a good night!" Stamped copper ceiling…read moretiles, soft leather upholstery, brass inlaid tables, classy nautical hinted artwork. Kinda like a Classic Chicago Steakhouse and your favorite Seafood Shack met during shore leave and had a love baby. The staff were as crisp and classy as my Martini inspired Tommy Bahama shirt (medium starch). Hands down the freshest oysters we've had since moving to FL. The selection was huge including both East and West Coast oysters with an amazing selection of local oysters. We fell head over heels for the Sharkbite oysters which are farmed right in New Smyrna Beach, Florida. As a rule; when we find a good oyster place we go overboard! In addition to the Sharkbites, we had West Coast: Royal Miyagi Kumamoto Kusshi East Coast: Pink Moon Malpeque Raspberry Point Wellfleet Duxubury Soleil Local: Sharkbite Baby Sharks Rattlesnake Cove We stuck to appetizers as our oyster adventure was our main focus. She Crab soup and Spanish Octopus were perfect. The Foie Gras had us doing the happy shimmy in our seats! Executive Dessert Chef, oh yeah I said it, pay that person what ever they ask for! Key Lime pie was to die for! Highly recommended! Cheers!

We came for dinner and left wondering why The Oyster Society wasn't our first stop!…read more Our original plan was Deck 560 at the Hilton across the street, but the menu didn't really excite us and the atmosphere felt a little sterile for our taste. We had a cocktail, crossed the street, and that's when the night got GOOD! The vibes were fantastic, the weather was beautiful for sitting outside, and the service was great. The cocktails? They definitely understood the assignment. Strong, just how I like them! Bonus points for fresh blue cheese stuffed olives instead of jarred ones. My only little critique was that the olive juice tasted very bitter to me. Now, let's talk FOOD because we were very happy people at this table! The octopus appetizer was to die for. They prepare it sous vide, and it was incredibly tender. This is the kind of dish you're still thinking about the next day. The Ceviche Yatai was almost too pretty to eat. Almost. Fresh kampachi presented more like sashimi, smoked aji amarillo leche de tigre, crispy calamari, crunchy corn, and sweet potato. Beautiful presentation and absolutely delicious! The miso Chilean sea bass was tender and delicious, and the firecracker sushi was another hit. Then there was the lobster and crab encrusted tripletail with Boursin mashed potatoes, broccolini, and lobster guajillo butter. Yes, it was every bit as good as it sounds! Great food, strong drinks, wonderful service, and a fun atmosphere. Crossing the street turned out to be our best decision of the night. We'll absolutely be back!

It's was like a treasure hunt just finding this place. And a treasure it is! When you see the…read moretennis courts, you are almost there! It's so chill sitting on the boat dock, watching the boats come and go. I had a salad with a Wasabi Dressing and grilled shrimp Tacos that has the most amazing Aoli. We sat at the bar, chilled by fans and reggae music. My husband had ahi tuna salad. He says it the best he has ever had. If your on vacation and need to relax this THE PLACE!

The place was pretty empty and We paid $24 each for grouper sandwiches that obviously sat in the…read morekitchen waiting to be brought out For a long time. They were cold and the cuts themselves were thin. Not worth what we paid at all.

Great atmosphere! A gathering of friends to enjoy the music and a couple of cocktails. Bartenders…read morewere friendly and quick! Everything was shut down by 9:30pm. Marco Island Midnight

Visited Marco for a week....looking for decent places to eat and listen to some live music. Came…read moreacross the Boardroom and decided to take a visit. First off, it was difficult to find. Tough place to locate because there is very little signage. We were able to find it after driving around a bit. We found a nice parking spot in the rear of the hotel that it sits beside. Upon entering the area where the music stage is set up, we noticed a decent crowd with everyone sitting and enjoying the music. The bar is inside where everyone goes to get a drink. The service was good...a couple of bartenders ready to help, if needed. The crowd was mainly older adults....ages 40-65 would be my guess. The music was good....all the hits from the Eagles to Nirvana to James Taylor. As a first timer, it was kind of confusing where to order food. However, I did not notice food being served. I did notice a small restaurant set up in a small seperate building but there was no one eating in there. I guess the bartenders take the order and then deliver the food. Would I go back? Not sure...not much happening that would attract me Vibe: laid back....easy going Drink Price: very reasonable Parking: for me, it was great but I could see people having issues Dress: key west casual 4 stars

Delicious!! Came here for some apps on the beach and these did not disappoint! Super fun vibes at…read morethe outdoor beach seating with tropical music.

The views and the location are everything. If you want a perfect view of the sunset then this spot…read moreis perfect. They don't take reservations but there really isn't a need for one. We were seated and ordered our drinks and food. The drinks were good. I had the toasted coconut mojito. We waited about an hour and finally asked our waiter for our food; he forgot to put in our food order. Thank God we weren't starving. We ended up leaving and just enjoying the walk on the beach and the sunset!

Zach R was our server and was fantastic! The pork chops were…read moreperfectly done. And the environment for a night out was classy but also relaxed.

Exceptional food, fantastic drinks, and wonderful service & atmosphere. We will be back.read more

We have been here twice. Sat out back both times. Had a…read morewonderful experience!! The girl who bartends our back is WONDERFUL!! I can't remember her name, but she's fantastic! The first time I had blackened shrimp BLT and she recommended I get it as a wrap so the shrimp didn't fall out everywhere and it was the BEST decision! Haha and was delicious! This time we just had meatballs and cheesy garlic bread for an app and it was yummy too! My husband said even better than he expected. Love that it's kinda hidden, and unsuspecting from the parking lot... so perfect name! Haha Love! And will be back! Great waterside view, great kept secret!

Food was decent, staff were friendly, owner was very kind…read more The atmosphere was def not of a Chicago speakeasy. Felt very off putting. The owner was very enthusiastic about the history of Marco island, and honestly I felt that what he should've had the restaurant embody, that would make sense for an outdoor restaurant in Florida, not a speakeasy

Amazing appetizers, drinks, entrees Atmosphere loud but…read moreotherwise great Best restaurant on marco

Mia was a fabulous waitress, five stars absolutely amazing. Food Ambiance , service ! 5 stars ! We…read morewill definitely come back!

Everything!! From…read moremaking reservations to seating, service, food and ambiance. Love this place as my family and I frequent this wonderful establishment!

What a wonderful dinner at La Tavola. Our only regret is that we did not try this place sooner! We…read moredined with friends and all enjoyed our food and drinks, service was great and the indoor dining room was nice and comfortable. They do not post their drink menu online and was delighted to see such an extensive list. Our waitress said it changes quite a bit which is why they don't post it. We thought prices were in line with other restaurants on the island. We started with a caesar salad and arancini, both were good and portions were reasonable and what we expected. I had the shrimp and scallop risotto for an entree and the fish was cooked perfectly. Scallops can be tricky, but these were excellent. Risotto was creamy and delicious. Our friends raved about their salmon, also cooked perfectly. Large portion of fish as well. I wish we had time for dessert, but we will be back!!

Great service and food! We sat by the bar at the high top tables and were greeted by staff and…read moremanagement immediately. To start, the skinny margarita was made perfectly. Everything was delicious and cooked with the appropriate seasonings and temperature. I could eat those whipped mashed potatoes as an entree - they were so good. And for dessert, a show! It's been SO long since I had baked Alaska and it was so so good.

I have one word WOW. My husband and I wanted a nice Valentine dinner so we chose 844. We reserved…read moreour table in advance very easily on open table. Our server was Marco and he was friendly, knowledgeable, and had no vibe of rushing us. We had a visit from the sommelier Henry, who was of great assistance in helping us choose a bottle that would suit our meal. (He also mentioned tastings that they have from all different regions!! Fun!) our food was prepared and served beautifully. We finished off the night with the cheesecake which was very different from your usual cheesecake, very rich and savory, and a tiramisu martini that was top notch! Between the service and food quality it was a great experience. Wonderful evening cannot wait to go back for a tasting! Love this place

We had a wonderful experience at Little Bar Restaurant! Lora was an excellent waitress--so…read morefriendly, helpful, and attentive. She made us feel very comfortable and helped us with our order. I ordered the scallops, and they were absolutely delicious! My family was also very happy with their meals. Everyone enjoyed their food, and we had such a lovely time. Thank you, Lora, for making our experience even more special. We'll definitely be back!

Everything was fabulous as always:) Thank you Heather, we…read moreenjoyed talking with you, interesting conversation but the star is the grouper!!