Cancel

Open app

Search

The Collier House

4.0 (21 reviews)
Closed 4:00 pm - 9:30 PM
Updated 3 months ago

The Collier House Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Collier House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Deviled eggs
Michael R.

We enjoyed our dinner at this "newish" restaurant on Marco. There are a few things which can make the experience better, and I expect in time some of the hiccups will be worked out. One of the difficulties is the reservation process. While they seem integrated with OpenTable, you can't book directly with it. You must call and leave a message, then wait a few days and someone calls you back and tells you what time you can come. Not great. They limit reservations to certain hours as well. We had a 7pm reservation on a busy Friday night and it was pure chaos at the door. The place is popular, packed and loud. It was an unusually cold night on Marco and nobody wanted to eat outside. They said our table was reserved for outside. We were not asked or told that was the case when a time was given to us. Again, a problem with not being able to make and review your reservation. The hostess had us wait and found a table for us inside. There is just complete confusion at the hostess stand, but we observed they try hard to accomodate all that come in. We were seated by 7:20 or so. We had a wonderful waitress, and her service was good throughout the meal. Food from the kitchen was very slow however, our first bites came after 8:00PM. That said, everything we ordered was delicious. The hanging bacon, and deviled eggs were great starters. The fried chicken entree was delicious as was the shrimp and grits. Heads up, if you share a dish, they do add a split charge. This was not mentioned when we ordered and said we were sharing an entree, but we later saw it printed on the menu. We thought prices were on the higher side as compared to comparable island dining. All in all we liked the food but as I said there are a number of things that are detracting from an enjoyable, relaxed dining experience. I hope they will be able to improve on those fronts as they are relatively new. Looking forward to coming back here and enjoying more of the dishes in the future and hoping for a better overall experience.

Biscuits
Antoinette S.

We dined at collier house last night. Lovely restaurant. Friendly staff. We had the jalapeno corn bread n biscuits w strawberry haberaro dipping . Hmm was out of this world. And generous portions. Don't stuff ur self too much as the menu has so many yummy items . Hard to decide what to have. But we decided on the small gumbo, corn bisque n charred Cesar. Corn bisque tasted good, gumbo was ok had shrimp n sausage n the charred Cesar was different w romaine lettuce leaves that had the toasted corn, ham, buttermilk dressing n cornbread croutons . Tasted good. For entrees had the southern beef Wellington ( a lil expensive) n was ok, the pan seared grouper was great. The best I've had any place. Everyone commented on how fresh reasonable n generous portions the items were. We ended our dinner w crime lime pie n brownies so good. Tx 4 a great dinner

Collier House
Ivette I.

The Bar and Waitstaff at Collier House are true professionals the service they offer is fabulous! The deviled eggs are one of my favorites! Oh heck... everything is absolutely delicious!

Shelbi G.

10/10 - the BEST restaurant on Marco. Absolutely loved everything about this place and am looking forward to my next visit. The drinks were phenomenal, the staff was amazing and the food was delicious. The place was packed and that's a good sign of a great place!

Steven R.

Very nice ambience with exceptional service. The menu was very southern United States influenced with a sprinkle of comfort food. Prices are high but the food was delicious. Dessert was forgettable.

Snobtini - savory, medium rare and excellent! Compliments to the chef!
Kristi C.

We dined at Marek's Collier House and it was exceptional from beginning to end. We were greeted with warm smiles upon arrival, seated swiftly (we had a reservation - thankfully! It was packed) and had the most incredible service from Brian - who set the stage for an amazing night. The beautifully decorated dining room was light and airy. The bathrooms were pristine. The service by every employee rivaled that of a Michelin-star rated restaurant. We loved the cocktail menu that had catchy sayings to describe each moody mixology that hints to a wink and a laugh. The appetizers of deviled eggs, corn chowder and the jalepeno bread were absolutely to die for! I am craving it as I write this. We could have stopped there but proceeded to order three entrees and each was delicious, fresh, savory, and expertly prepared. We loved the Snobtini and Fried Chicken, Mac and Cheese and fresh-off-the-cobb corn. This southern delight has so many food options from sandwiches, to entrees, soups to salads, mixology to handcrafted artfully tasty desserts. Speaking of desert, the boozy berries were yummy. The wine options were delightful and differentiated on the island. Brian, our waiter, was outstanding. His care for every detail made our night a perfect ending to our week. He knew the menu so well. seeked to understand our every want and made wonderful recommendations that didn't disappoint - but rather, blew us away. We will ask for Brian every time (my parents, Pat and Sandy loved him). The history of this restaurant upholds very high standards, setting new levels of excellence on the island today. That is saying something! We can't wait to return! Highly recommend - of all the choices, this is a must-do! You'll return again and again. Thanks, Brian and thank you, Marek's team! Bravo!

South Carolina Jalapeño Cornbread and biscuits

Amazing scratch made food in a beautiful southern coastal setting. It's our new favorite place.

Shrimp & grits!

See all

24 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mara F.
90
71
31

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Steven R.
134
44
79

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 3
Love this 2
Oh no 2

4 months ago

Good service. Good was good. Enjoyed our breakfast there. Their prices were in line with the other restaurants in town

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Jim H.
0
20
0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of C L.
0
4
12

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ann H.
0
17
1

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - The Collier House

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood 1,763 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Oyster Society - OYSTERS!!

The Oyster Society

4.5(789 reviews)
3.3 mi
$$$

Visited the oyster society while in Marco island. Convenient location right across our hotel…read more Friendly welcoming staff. Ou waiter Mirro was v good n informative. Was bustling, we sat inside n there was live music. Enjoyed it . Had the she crab soup Mediterranean salad n scorpion roll for starters. Soup was really good n flavorful. Our son enjoyed the scorpion roll. The salad was good too. The rolls n corn bread were good w a tasty spread that had an orange flavor. Different but good. For entrees we had the scallops w black pasta, surf n turf slash/ flash burn snapper and the filet mignon. The red snapper was out of this world. One of the best we've had. The scallops were v tasty too. The surf n turf good too n so was the filet mignon v juicy. Generous portions. We topped it off w key lime pie n caramel n sea salt s'more.. Heavenly. The smore was one of a kind. Sorry forgot to take photo of slash/ flash red snapper. Tx u for a delicious meal .

Never a bad experience at The Oyster Society!…read more We were back in the wine room, so the vibe was intimate and quiet, which was perfect for our group. Obviously, got a lot of oysters. Our usuals are the Pink Moons but we also tried some local oysters and they were delicious! I got the seared scallops with the black spaghetti and it was great. Always love their seafood! Overall I think everyone loved the food - a friend got the lamb shank and said it was amazing. The only thing that could have been improved was the surf n turf special. The steak (which I think was a strip) was reported to be lacking in flavor... Pro tip - don't skip on the free bread/cornbread and butter! It's the perfect carb start to any meal!!

Photos
The Oyster Society - Bar area

Bar area

The Oyster Society - Local raw oysters

Local raw oysters

The Oyster Society - The Oyster Society bldg

See all

The Oyster Society bldg

The Boardroom Tavern - Live music Tuesday thru Saturday

The Boardroom Tavern

4.6(30 reviews)
0.2 mi
$$
Locally owned & operated
Veteran-owned & operated

Great atmosphere! A gathering of friends to enjoy the music and a couple of cocktails. Bartenders…read morewere friendly and quick! Everything was shut down by 9:30pm. Marco Island Midnight

Visited Marco for a week....looking for decent places to eat and listen to some live music. Came…read moreacross the Boardroom and decided to take a visit. First off, it was difficult to find. Tough place to locate because there is very little signage. We were able to find it after driving around a bit. We found a nice parking spot in the rear of the hotel that it sits beside. Upon entering the area where the music stage is set up, we noticed a decent crowd with everyone sitting and enjoying the music. The bar is inside where everyone goes to get a drink. The service was good...a couple of bartenders ready to help, if needed. The crowd was mainly older adults....ages 40-65 would be my guess. The music was good....all the hits from the Eagles to Nirvana to James Taylor. As a first timer, it was kind of confusing where to order food. However, I did not notice food being served. I did notice a small restaurant set up in a small seperate building but there was no one eating in there. I guess the bartenders take the order and then deliver the food. Would I go back? Not sure...not much happening that would attract me Vibe: laid back....easy going Drink Price: very reasonable Parking: for me, it was great but I could see people having issues Dress: key west casual 4 stars

Photos
The Boardroom Tavern - Book a place at Smith House's upper deck for a romantic night

Book a place at Smith House's upper deck for a romantic night

The Boardroom Tavern - The Boardroom Tavern by Smith House restaurant

The Boardroom Tavern by Smith House restaurant

The Boardroom Tavern - Olde Marco historical district with that ambient feel , great atmosphere

See all

Olde Marco historical district with that ambient feel , great atmosphere

Kane - Pupu Platter

Kane

3.9(123 reviews)
2.9 mi
$$

Kane is right up my alley ...a Polynesian-inspired tiki bar and grill located at the JW Marriott…read moreMarco Island Beach Resort. We stopped by for lunch and enjoyed our meal right on the beach, which made the whole experience feel like a tropical escape. We started with the poke tuna nachos super fresh with some avocado and eel sauce and jalapeños all around.. packed with flavor. My friend ordered a light salad, and we shared the chicken skewers and pork bao buns, both of which were delicious . Just a heads up if you're dining beachside , the birds can get a little too friendly, so keep an eye on your plate!

Kane was such a wonderful beachfront Polynesian restaurant to eat at for lunch! We sat right in…read morefront of the shoreline. Absolutely spectacular view. A bit hot at certain points though. I asked Josh to put up our umbrella. Every table has one. Josh was our server. He was funny and accommodating. We decided to get a few appetizers and things to share. We got the tuna poke nachos, pork belly bao buns, chicken satay and the crunchy Kane salad. The poke nachos consistency of the wonton chips was extremely crunchy and fresh. There were pieces of tuna, srirchaca lime aioli, avocado, scallions and jalapeños. I am very sensitive to spice, however I did not find this item to be spicy. The pork belly bao buns were also delicious! They came with honey garlic sauce, pickled onions, jalapeño, cucumber, green onions and sesame aioli. The chicken satay was FANTASTIC!!! They came as 5 skewers. The peanut sauce it came with was one of the best I've ever tried. Super creamy and peanutty. Made to perfection. The Kane salad was phenomenal and I loved the addition of the crunchy noodles. It came with mixed greens, red onions, bell peppers, carrots, cucumber, sesame seeds and a citrus vinaigrette. Overall really beautiful dining experience with a breathtaking view of the beach while we ate.

Photos
Kane - Tiki hut restaurant Kanes

Tiki hut restaurant Kanes

Kane - Kane appetizers

Kane appetizers

Kane - Cheers with frozen drinks

See all

Cheers with frozen drinks

DaVinci's - Burrata, Prosciutto E Melone

DaVinci's

4.3(952 reviews)
3.3 mi
$$$

Wow, what a great restaurant! They only take reservations for indoor seating and we wanted to sit…read moreoutdoors, which is first come first serve. We only waited about 10 minutes. The staff was absolutely incredible. The atmosphere was vibrant yet upscale. We started off with complementary bread with an oil (& something paste - I didn't catch the name) which was excellent. I ordered the Cernia Alla Pescatore ($52): grouper, clams, mussels, shrimp, garlic, white wine sauce, grape tomatoes served over spinach linguine. All entrées come with a house salad or you can do an upgrade to a Caesar. I chose the house salad that comes with balsamic vinaigrette. Very well put together, light and refreshing. The Cernia Alla Pescatore was very flavorful and everything was cook to perfection. For desert, I had the Profiteroles ($17): cream puff filled with vanilla ice cream and topped with hot chocolate fudge. What a great way to end a fantastic meal!!! Overall, yes, this was a splurge (expensive) meal but so well worth it!! Highly recommend for a special occasion!

Very convenient location with a cluster of restaurants & shops that are close to hotels and condos…read more Definitely worth a visit if you are in the mood for some delicious Italian cuisine. Freshly baked bread is provided. Our table sampled chicken Parmigiana pappardelle bolognese, lasagna and ravioli Della casa. Plus two kids meals- large meatball & plate full of pasta and chicken parmigiana. Both adult and kids Meals had huge portions! Salads were included & with surcharge soup could be substituted Very attentive edit staff & worth the wait!

Photos
DaVinci's - Main Dining Room

Main Dining Room

DaVinci's - Ravioli D'aragosta

Ravioli D'aragosta

DaVinci's - Cittadinella

See all

Cittadinella

The SpeakEasy of Marco Island - Shrimp Sammie

The SpeakEasy of Marco Island

3.5(299 reviews)
1.1 mi
$$

We have been here twice. Sat out back both times. Had a…read morewonderful experience!! The girl who bartends our back is WONDERFUL!! I can't remember her name, but she's fantastic! The first time I had blackened shrimp BLT and she recommended I get it as a wrap so the shrimp didn't fall out everywhere and it was the BEST decision! Haha and was delicious! This time we just had meatballs and cheesy garlic bread for an app and it was yummy too! My husband said even better than he expected. Love that it's kinda hidden, and unsuspecting from the parking lot... so perfect name! Haha Love! And will be back! Great waterside view, great kept secret!

My husband and I are full time residents of Marco Island. Since moving here almost a year ago,…read morewe've been having fun trying all of the amazing restaurants in the area. Today, we attempted to have lunch at The Speakeasy. We've heard mixed reviews from other residents. However, we like to form our own opinions so we thought we'd give it a try. What a mistake. Walking into the bar/restaurant, a handwritten sign told us to seat ourselves. So, walking towards their outside area, we were hit by a wall of cigarette smoke. No biggie. It's outdoors. Not ideal but whatever. It IS mostly a bar. So, we picked a table. On our way to sit down, a server walking past mumbled a hello and kept walking. So, we said hi and sat at a table. The server then stood several feet away and just stared at us. Literally, did not move. Not even to take care of other tables, which we noticed after a time, were just sitting there not receiving service as well. So, we waited. ...and waited. 10 minutes later, and the server never moved. Ultimately, we decided to leave. As my husband and I stood up and began walking out, the server reached behind her and grabbed two menus, watching us the entire time. She then said, "Sorry folks. Have a great day." Wow. Off season, places like this depend on locals to keep their businesses afloat. With the kind of attitude and service we received, we won't be back.

Photos
The SpeakEasy of Marco Island
The SpeakEasy of Marco Island - Side salad with Italian dressing

Side salad with Italian dressing

The SpeakEasy of Marco Island

See all

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar

4.0(304 reviews)
3.4 mi
$$$

What a wonderful dinner at La Tavola. Our only regret is that we did not try this place sooner! We…read moredined with friends and all enjoyed our food and drinks, service was great and the indoor dining room was nice and comfortable. They do not post their drink menu online and was delighted to see such an extensive list. Our waitress said it changes quite a bit which is why they don't post it. We thought prices were in line with other restaurants on the island. We started with a caesar salad and arancini, both were good and portions were reasonable and what we expected. I had the shrimp and scallop risotto for an entree and the fish was cooked perfectly. Scallops can be tricky, but these were excellent. Risotto was creamy and delicious. Our friends raved about their salmon, also cooked perfectly. Large portion of fish as well. I wish we had time for dessert, but we will be back!!

A gem on Marco Island. We had a wonderful dinner - the salads were fresh, crisp and perfectly…read moredressed. The soups were rich and flavorful as well. My Clam Chowder was packed with clams. The Lamb was exceptional - a nice portion, perfectly cooked and rich. The restaurant is attractive, tables well spaced and comfortable. Although packed on a Saturday night, there was plenty of noise deadening material and we could converse at a comfortable level. Overall we had a great dinner and will return.

Photos
La Tavola Restaurant and Bar - Inside

Inside

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar
La Tavola Restaurant and Bar - Cappuccino- first rate

See all

Cappuccino- first rate

The Collier House - seafood - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...