Nice local pizzeria…read more Was in the area and decided upon here for dinner. From the outside, it looks like a converted house - but most businesses in the area look the same. Inside was spacious enough to where they were having a birthday celebration in progress on one side, leaving all the tables for other patrons on the other side. The menu selection was decent, but I already had my mind set on garlic bread and the bacon chicken ranch pie - both since it has been a little while since I last had it and because I knew I'd be having the rest of it the next day for lunch. The pie was tasty - so tasty that I forgot to take the picture BEFORE I removed a slice. The garlic bread was okay - I've had better but I've also had worse. Garlic bread is often made differently at establishments and it's a taste and choice for preference. The rest of the pie I didn't finish taster just as good the next day when heated up. Really, if I ever go back I do plan to grab this one again. Staff was very nice. Waitress was friendly. I got to talking to one of the owners and it turns out they were from Brooklyn NY. So any doubt about the quality here should automatically be put to rest. Had I known about it previously, I'd have taken a regular slice too. Owners were friendly and welcoming. I've been in their old neighborhood, so we had a nice conversation about the general area. There is no lot, so parking is street. All in all a nice place and a good option for the area. Good for locals who want a more authentic choice for Italian food and of course pizza/ I'd easily return here if I'm in the general area again.

We truly enjoyed every thing about this restaurant. The service was exceptional and the food was…read morefresh, homemade and absolutely delicious!! The ambiance was welcoming and relaxing. We would definitely recommended this restaurant. If you haven't been there or got food from there you should!!

Had dinner last night at Tutoni's Restaurant in York. They have a very nice wine list by the…read morebottle and also by the glass. Our waiter Johnny was also the bartender. He was awesome! He helped us narrow down the selections we ultimately decided on and was very knowledgeable on the menu. My wife and I started out with the calamari appetizer, I had the gnocchi with spare ribs and she had the mushroom pappardelle dish. For dessert we split the limoncello cake which was absolutely amazing! The service was outstanding, the food was delicious and the overall experience was 5 star! We will definitely be back! Would highly recommend this for anyone looking for a really good Italian food in York.

This has quickly become my husbands and my favorite restaurant in York! The food is always amazing…read moreand the service is impeccable! I have gotten the short rib gnocchi almost every time and I am not even the biggest fan of short rib. It is just that good! We have done the "Mercy of the Chef" which was the best food I have ever had! For my mom's 70th birthday they all signed a card and a homemade pasta candle! The ambiance is also great with romantic lighting. We can't say enough good things about this restaurant!

This place is SOOOO good! Was a favorite when I used to live in the area. Came back on vacation and…read moredid NOT disappoint! Was immediately seated, staff was attentive and friendly. Atmosphere is casual and welcoming. Relaxed. The food... did NOT disappoint! The same as I remembered. DELICIOUS! This IS a must hit spot!

For all the years I have lived in York, HOW have I never been to Mexitaly before?? I guess I was…read moreworried it would be an incongruous mixture of the two cuisines- but that is far from the case. Great Mexican, great Italian, great beer, great service, and a perfect hipster ambience. We had our Valentine's day dinner here, and the place was packed but service was still attentive and timely. We had nachos to start and pizza to follow, and washed it down with some craft beers- a positively indulgent college-esque combo, but prepared in a high-quality way. Oh, and they play great music. I loved it.

Visited Ferrante's with colleagues during a business trip. It was walking distance to our hotel so…read morean easy choice. Among the 5 of us we ordered several pizzas and Stromboli. I will say, if you're ordering for yourself, get the half Stromboli, they're HUGE! Everyone enjoyed their meal and had some leftovers. Our server was fantastic. She kept drinks flowing and was great. The restaurant is clean and you can smell the wood fired oven when you walk in. I love that! Due to Pennsylvania laws, their drink menu is somewhat limited but we worked around it. Thanks for a great meal! Would definitely return next time we're in the area.

My husband and I stopped her for lunch and we were disappointed. We both ordered woodfired…read morepizza's but never saw anyone go up to the woodfire stove to cook our pizza's. They were very thin crust with no Smoky taste or even a little Char on the pizza crust. We decided to try it out because of other reviews but very unsatisfied. Especially with it costing us over $50 for 2-12"pizza's, a glass of pop and a water. Not worth the money. Save your time and money, go somewhere else.

They never fail! !They have the best pizza . So fresh and hot ! ! The place is clean and the staff…read moreis friendly.

We tried this place with family from out of town and they said it was pretty good pizza. Coming…read morefrom NYC that is a great review! I also enjoyed the pizza. The crusty was crispy and the sauce wasn't candy sweet. The cheese could've been more cheesy flavor such as more Romano and or fontina cheese. I enjoy my slice with herbs, salt garlic and peperoncini, yummy!!! We also ordered spaghetti and meatballs. It was a great portion and sauce again was very good not too sweet! Everything was so fresh. The location is not far from Perrydale Dairy farm. It was easy to find and has amble parking. Very friendly and wonderful service, they brought the food to the table. The best part is the place smells very clean! The only dirt I noticed was bathroom doors need to be wiped clean. Other than that, I intend on trying more items on their menu.

Food is always good when we go. Their service is professional and efficient and friendly.read more

Love the food and the service.Wished I lived close thanks for the hospitality if you want a great…read moretime eating nd talking and you mind at peace eat here

Raw pizza! Old veal ! No heart! Got to veal Parmesan hero's old, dried out veal cutlet about a…read moreteaspoon of sauce and some cheese, a taste list dried out mess when entering the establishment, you see rows of Pizza all hours or perhaps days old beautiful place beautiful parking lot, you are Better to go across the street to Marinos! ! I meant to order from Marinos, but I haven't been to a York in some years and forgot the name my bad I deserve what I got.

Food is ok. Service I terrible. They left my food on the porch 2 hours after I ordered it. No…read morecall no ring nothing. I have a ring door bell to prove it. 50 bucks for this garbage left on the porch. Manager wouldn't even get on the phone. Shame on them. Service is awful, they should be ashamed

I ordered an margarita pizza and a cheesesteak and both were excellent! Finally a pizza restaurant…read morethat knows how to make a pizza!!!!

The food was amazing and the service is fast and kind and the restaurant it's self is clean and a…read moregood vibe