And we did return - 2 days later! We arrived at 5 on Wednesday; plenty of seating was available inside and out. We ordered the Madeline Island Pizza and the Black and Blue Salad (w/blackened fish). Both were delicious! read more

See all

My fiancé and I were pleasantly surprised at this little gem of a restaurant! A cool reprieve on a warm afternoon, the place has a really nice vibe. We ate at Manypenny Bistro twice during our trip to Cornucopia/Bayfield recently. The first time I ordered the Vegetable pizza minus the tomatoes and had ranch instead of tomato sauce. It was absolutely heavenly...one of the best pizza's I've ever eaten. My fiancé had a cheeseburger with cheddar cheese and fries. Be said the burger was the best burger he'd had in ages. The second time we ate there I had the Lemon Garlic pasta minus the lemon and added shrimp. It was pretty good, although there was entirely too much pasta, lol. I think I had a pound of pasta on my plate. My fiancé had the Lake Trout and garlic mash with cauliflower & broccoli. He said it was all really good, but the trout was beyond phenomenal. The service both times was exceptional. We both agree it was well worth the money and would definitely eat there again! read more

Stumbled upon the Manypenny bistro while exploring downtown Bayfield. Friendly, fast staff and a great menu. We had the Bloody Mary which was great. It comes with tasty dilly beans and a beer chaser. We also shared some delicious cheese curds. Right close to the water, great location. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

See all

Delicious as always. Went for lunch yesterday, and breakfast today. Ate on the porch, so you go up to the window to order. Dogs are allowed on the porch. read more

See all

Our breakfast was exceptional! It was so good that we're going back tomorrow. The service was wonderful, and we loved that they allow dogs on the screened patio. This is going to be our breakfast spot every time we visit Bayfield from now on. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Happy dog on the screened patio - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

See all

The fish tacos were great and so were the cheese curds! The fish sandwich was ok. The fish was blackened and was really dry. The service was great. We sat on the porch. It was nice. read more

This place was so good. Went here for both breakfast and dinner, and it was always packed. Chicken fried steak was amazing. Had a little window you could order at to sit outside in a closed in porch which was cool. Overall, definitely a spot to check out in bayfield! read more

The food is a 10/10, the service is 100/10, and the rest is 100/10. I would for sure recommend this place! read more

Manypenny Bistro - Trust me, try the evil eye - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

If your hungry for lunch this is the place to go! The cheeseburger was incredible and so was the fries. Crispy and not to big. Portion sizes are perfect with a nice outsdie or inside sitting area. The parking situation can be tight to expect to have to walk a bit. Service is quick, 3 cheeseburgers with fries took 15 minutes or less. It is self serve, but they are amazing. EDIT: Slightly on the expensive side. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

The onion rings with bistro sauce were practically perfect. The fish sandwich got a 10/10 from my boyfriend which is saying something because he is not one to give out compliments lightly. The pizza sauce, toppings, and crust were very good; however, I wasn't a fan of the cheese they use. It is very gooey/wet with barely any texture. The ambience is warm and comforting with nice town views. The service was quick, friendly, and attentive. Would recommend to visit if you're in Bayfield! read more

See all

Perfect!! Manypenny Bistro popped up so many times when searching for the best breakfast in Bayfield. My husband said it's not a legit breakfast spot if country fried steak wasn't on the menu. Since Manypenny Bistro had this on the menu, we stopped in on our commute home to Minnesota. We both enjoyed ourselves. Things we loved: seat yourself, friendly and engaging staff, large dog friendly patio, crispy hash browns, homemade raspberry jam, cranberry toast, large portions, cabin style lodging, robust menu, hot coffee and clean atmosphere. My husband (of course) had the country fried steak while I had an omelette with breakfast potatoes. We both had coffee and great conversation. Highly recommend!! Cozy environment. read more

Manypenny Bistro - October 2025 - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

See all

I took out break fast from here. Crab benny and seafood omelette were my items. Both were excellent. Seafood omelette had a lot of fresh seafood stuffed. I wanted to try the whitefish liver from here. But that was available only in the evening. May be I should try it the next time I am here. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Seafood omelette - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

See all

Best gyros and pizza ever and the staff treat you like revered guests and honoured beloveds

Food was good and was quick. Staff was friendly and it was reasonably priced. Off the main drag, so it was nice and quite when we went for lunch. read more

Nice breakfast location. We stopped by on our way out of town. The service was great and the food very good. We enjoyed the raspberry fritter French toast and the smoked lake trout eggs Benedict. Definitely a place to go for breakfast or lunch. read more

See all

Cute place, good service. Sadly the omelettes were drenched in grease, almost inedible... we had smoked trout omelette and veggie omelette and both swam in a lake of oil. read more

This is a great family run restaurant in Bayfield. Highlights are the good food and friendly service! My favorite are the Mediterranean salad with chicken; the mozzarella sticks and my latest favorite is the lemon garlic pasta with chicken. My son lover the chicken bacon wrap and my grandson says the burgers and fries are great! What I most appreciate is the way everyone is treated! read more

What a find! I asked a local for a good pizza joint recommendation on my first night in town, and this was very quickly her first answer. I came with my dog and she assured me they had a dog friendly window. We arrived, and they have a full covered porch entrance next to the main entrance where you can enter with your dogs. Inside the porch there's a window where you can order food, beer, etc. The porch is lovely with plenty of tables and a counter across one of the walls of the porch. This would be a great dog option for a rainy day given the coverage on the porch. I ordered a pizza to bring back to my room and had a beer while we waited. My pup was given a whipped cream pup cup (of which he made a total mess but loved every moment of it) and service was super friendly and easy. I ordered the giant 20" pizza so that I'd have something to tide me over during my week stay in the event I didn't feel like going out or cooking anything. It was delicious. I ordered a pepperoni with extra sauce. I'm a believer that the sauce makes the pizza, and their dose of extra sauce was just the perfect amount. And it was a mighty fine tasting sauce at that. It was the perfect start to a relaxing vacation. I even went back on my last night for a small pizza (I love pizza). Had an old fashioned while I waited. I thought it was super strange that it tasted like cinnamon, but the Internet says sometimes that's a thing? If I'd known, I would have declined the cinnamon but oh well. Highly recommend checking them out, especially if you have man's best friend with you. read more

See all

We had dinner here with 2 kids really enjoyed it! We had a rockstar server who enjoyed her job and was super friendly with a bright smile and very helpful. Our meals were delicious and come in good sized portions, it was very satisfying! It was a nice place yet kid friendly and in a great location. read more

Great service, very polite servers. Place was fairly busy but we got our meals quicker than anticipated. Food was great with a very relaxing atmosphere. read more

Manypenny Bistro - White Fish taco's were amazing. The pickled onions on top were - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

We had a breakfast and a dinner at Manypenny Bistro while we were in town. Both were great! The bay omelette was superb at breakfast. For dinner, I had the smoked trout salad, which was very good. And my husband had one of the fish sandwiches, that was also very good. read more

Seemed like a fun bar but the owner was really rude and that killed it for us. We wanted to watch the World Cup so my wife went in ahead to ask if the game was on and if they could unmute the game. After we sat down and ordered our food, we asked again if they could go ahead and unmute the game, but the server said she didn't think the speakers were connected to the TV because they were connected to music. Another server figured out how to have them both on at the same time. But about 10 minutes into it, the owner turned off the sound. We asked her if the sound could be turned back on, and she replied that you can't hear the music if the game is on. We asked if both could be on at the same time, since we and one other party were the only ones at the bar. And she yelled at us that she won't turn the sound on because it ruins the music. It's a bar... people don't come here for the recorded music... all the servers were great and very nice. But the owner was really unprofessional. read more

Quaint bistro away from the main drag. Three distinct eating areas, a varied menu (with daily specials), friendly staff, and decent prices. Highly recommend. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Blackened & blue burger with bacon. - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

The Bennys were awesome, as well as their Raspberry Fritter French Toast! Loved the housemade raspberry jam to go with the French toast! Welcoming vibe in the indoor as well as the patio area. read more

See all

We had the Smoked Trout Omelet. Fantastic!! It was enough that my hubby and I shared. Polite wait staff.

We ate here for breakfast and dinner! The food and drinks are really good! Fresh and fast!

The food was incredible and the Bloody Mary's were spot on. Nice spot to grab a bite to eat and enjoy the area.

Celebrating my 30th birthday and my server was super nice on a busy Saturday morning!The iced latte and Bloody Mary was great! They brought out a free piece of cake for my birthday! I wish I could finish it but I was so hungover and couldn't eat. My friends said their eggs + fish cake Benedict was very good. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Chocolate cake - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

We ate here twice while visiting, on a mini vacation. We went on a Thursday evening around 6:30. The place was packed, there were two people waiting ahead of us for a table. They started a line, as there was a sign to seat yourself, but there were no seats available. No one from the restaurant greeted any of us or said anything as they walked by. When two tables opened up, the people ahead of us went and stood by one table, and we stood by the other. Finally, we were "greeted" by one of the servers. However, it was kind of a rude greeting. Once we were seated, I was happy to see she wasn't our server. After that the service was great! We ordered the seafood pizza and the cheese curds (we were in Wisconsin, after all). Both were hot, fresh, and delicious. We had looked on-line at their breakfast menu and had decided to go back the next morning. There was no line. We were seated and greeted right away. My friend and I both ordered half servings of the Bistro Benny with bacon. The hashbrowns were well cooked and crispy. The benedict was one of the best I've had. The mushrooms and spinach were the right amount and blended well with the other ingredients. Bringing it up another level. read more

See all

Adorable place with great service and food! Everything was hot, the ambience and decor were super cozy, and the service was friendly!

I tried the gyro and blackened whitefish. I was shook by the flavor in both dishes. The chips and sweet potato fries were both great side options. Sometimes I think small town restaurants get high rating because there aren't many options around... but manypenny is a real banger. Great work! read more

Manypenny Bistro - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

We had two excellent meals here. It has a casual and fun vibe. Plenty of seating and. Excellent service. And both of our meals were delicious. We will for sure. Return on our next trip. read more

Very nice gyro. Super service at the bar--attentive but not intrusive. Even though busy, food came out quickly. Spotless rest rooms

Not a whole ton of options in the area, but manypenny is all around solid. Breakfast is really consistently good. I could literally eat here every day and be good with it. Breakfast potatoes always great, biscuits and gravy, badger sandwich, and French toast all very good. (Gravy on biscuits 1 time was broken) Pizza is maybe like a 3/5, for folks saying this is amazing pizza, I dont... get the hype. We had the Madeline island. It's fine. I love good mushrooms, but pretty sure these are canned slimey, kinda nasty imo. Crust has ok flavor, I think it'd be better without double crust, but does have a lot of toppings so i understand that. For any pizza snob: again, it's fine. like most square cut tavern style pizza you find in the Midwest, just ok. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Madeline island pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

Everything there was great I recommend you stop there for breakfast and lunch - the portions were good size If you leave there hungry you have a problem Service was great as well friendly and helpful on what was on the menu's read more

We ate here in the recommendation of a fellow guest at our hotel. We are so glad that we did! We have edge. Here twice, the food is that good! Such. Wide and varied menu, seems to excel at Mediterranean dishes - the Mediterranean grilled fish was superb, just the right spices with spinach, Klamath olives, tomatoes. Served with garlic pita and a side of rice. The turkey burger was tasty, not overcooked and had avocado on it. The onion rings are some of the best we had. Staff hard-working and efficient. We highly recommend read more

Amazing atmosphere, good service. Large selection. Brick oven pizzas were really good! read more

Manypenny Bistro - Brick oven pizza on a stand. Doesn't take up the whole table! - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin

Delicious gyro meat on Mediterranean salad. View nice. Location good. Could be updated to appear fresher read more

First time to Bayfield, WI and spent several days there. The location is near downtown and everything is close by. We seated ourselves upon entry and someone brought menus. Had the blueberry mojito (fresh blueberries!!), the Madeline Island pizza and a philly cheesesteak with cole slaw. I asked for a little bit of extra red sauce and was charged for $2.5 as an extra topping. REALLY? The pizza was Detroit pan style with thicker crust which tasted good but too greasy for me. The sandwich was too salty for my husband. Friendly staffs though. read more

See all

Chicken Alfredo pizza looks so tasty! No waiting, food hot and flavorful. The Black and Blur leafy green salad is full of flavor. Will definitely stop by again. read more

Manypenny Bistro - Black and Blue salad. - Pizza Near Me - Bayfield, Wisconsin