Places like Manny's makes me realize I lead a sheltered ass life. I go to fancy restaurants and write snide reviews about food I pay entirely too much for. Meanwhile, there are people making simple, delicious and cheap food for (probably) far too little in a town that has most certainly seen better days. If anything, Manny's is a testament that the good things in life don't have to be complicated. Maybe their food is nothing special and I'm just sentimental because I can't get pizza, cheesesteaks or cannolis like theirs near DC... but I don't really care. Besides, any hole in the wall with employees willing to shoot the shit while I watch the Flyers' game on their kitchen TV deserves five stars. Oh, and I'm too full to drink beer 2.5 hours later. That good. Oh Oh, the pizza sauce can cause 2nd degree burns to your face (NOT joking). read more

Manny's Pizzeria - a sandwich on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

Customer Service is garbage. I've been a loyal customer for over 15 years. They have a nasty attitude when you call. I've tolerated that for the longest time because I liked their food. This is is the straw that broke the camels back: They Refused to honor their own voucher system. Requiring more than the vouchers state. While giving the nasty attitude. They just lost what was once a loyal customer. Never ordering from them again. Only giving one star because I can't give less. Maybe they'll learn to appreciate their customers. read more

Manny's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

Does anyone know what Manny's hours are? They don't seem to know, or they are keeping it a secret from their customers. Their own website says they are open tonight until 9pm. I called to place an order at 7:34pm and they did not even say hello; they said "Manny's Pizza, we're closed." I know it is not easy to manage a take out place, but this is the kind of thing that does not take an advanced business degree to get right. If this was a one off thing, I would not bother to complain. This is the third time in the past month I have tried to place an order more than a half hour before their own website says they were closed only to be told (in a pretty rude way) that they were closed. They just seem to check out whenever they don't want to put in the full hours they advertise. The food's pretty good, but not good enough to be worth the hassle. I will try again at random times to see if they get their act together, but not going to plan on it for dinner with friends as we were planning tonight. Get it together, Manny's. read more

right to the point, bad service and bad attitude, always seem to forget somthing on an order, just bad management for sure.

As a loyal customer to Manny's Pizzeria, I've always bought from here and chose this pizza place first. Tonight, I found a hair in my food. A small black hair. This is really upsetting to me and unfortunately, I will not be returning. I am completely unsatisfied and enraged by this. read more

Manny's Pizzeria - Hair - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

See all

Unfortunately after many years we will no longer be getting food from Manny's Pizza in Millville on High St. This became a ritual every weekend; we would order takeout from them. Tonight they missed the mark, sending a cheeseburger sub and a gyro that were unappetizing,to put it mildly (The onions on both sandwiches smelled like wet dogs!) and sides that looked like field rations; I called to let them know and try to find out what happened since they're always on point, NOT looking for compensation at all. Whomever I spoke with was rude and patronizing and the end result was he hung up on me! I've worked in food service for 22 years and this is NOT the way to treat loyal patrons. Very sad. Shame on them read more

The pizza is so good here! They have this large slice due to this is one of My favorite pizza places! I recommend everyone on Millville NJ to go here! read more

I ordered food from here three times and the food is the same straight trash there cheesesteaks chicken tender platters n the Stromboli plus it's a lil pricey too read more

I went there other night was not impressed at all got stuffed shells.. Shells was undercooked and a sloppy mess thrown into a big container!! read more

The place I usually order party trays from was closed today, and it was 45 minutes before my daughter's birthday party and I was like "oh crap, oh crap, oh crap, what am I gonna do?!?" You have to understand that pizza in my family is a sacred thing. If I had made the wrong choice, I would have been in BIG trouble. I've tried almost all the pizza joints in Millville and knew that of those I'd had previously, none made an acceptible party tray (round pizza yes, party tray NO!) I hate party trays to begin with, but for a children's party, ya gotta compromise. So I'm sitting with the phone in one hand, trembling staring at the phone book... "WHAT TO DO?!?!?" And then I remembered a convo with a co-worker about this place down the street from where the party was gonna be. But could I remember the name? tick tock tick tock tick tock. ok OK.... I'm gonna Yelp it. Oh crap! No one's Yelped it yet. Damnation!!! Hmmm mmm mmm... scanning the phone book... "why the hell does there have to be so many freaking pizza places... damnit, what's the name of that place?!?" "A HA! Manny's!!!" *inner happy dance* I call, and order my party trays and have a lengthy discussion with the girl about the strange location of where we're at and make sure the driver will be able to find us. Promptness was important, I stressed because the party is on a strict time table because the place we rented throws us out promptly at 3pm. No prob she says. She explains that I can pay by phone, but I have to have my credit card and ID with me so the driver can verify my identity. I didn't believe for a second he'd actually check. I asked if I could pay the tip by credit card and once again, she said it would be no problem. Gee... am I still in NJ or have I slipped into the Twilight Zone... these people are awfully friendly. Go figure. So the party ensued at the pool and I got totally wrapped up in taking pictures of the kids that I lost track of time and wasn't waiting for the pizza guy like I should have been. It was so noisy, I also didn't hear his first phone call. But bless his heart, he waited a couple minutes, and called me a second time. He WAITED!!! I could have kissed him. He was totally cool about it too. No attitude. Again I'm wondering, "am I still in Jerz?" I check out the pizzas... they look a little slippy slidey in the box, but nothing major. And the best part, which gains major points in my book- he actually checked my ID. Hallelujah! NO ONE does that anymore. Thank you sir! The best part, the party trays were DELICIOUS!!! I've never liked a party tray pizza before. This was seriously nummers. The crust wasn't all doughy and fluffy like most places. It was more like normal pizza, with a thin, flat crust- just square. The sauce wasn't overly herby, and a little on the sweet side but NOT cloying like Chef Boyardee. It was just right. The cheese was good too, although it wasn't as greasy as I prefer, but that was better, given it was a party and all. My uber picky autistic daughter even ate the pizza and commented that she enjoyed it. SCORE!!! That NEVER happens. Manny's is my new go-to place for party trays! Woo hoo! read more

Im giving Manny 3 stars because the pizza on the picture has a bite in it. Nobody wants to see someones half eaten food. I bet that pizza got teeth plaque on that ish. Yhem sayn. The pizza look tired. read more

I started a Yelp account today post this because I'm tired of places sending out garbage and charging you $40 to eat it. This place is usually on time but I almost broke a tooth on this one. How could you possibly put this in a box and deliver it? read more

Manny's Pizzeria - Manny's Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

I just spent $70 on dinner and we were missing 4 orders of fries and my onion rings are so burnt they're black. Guess I won't be ordering from Manny's again. read more

I've tried this place a few times, first time I got mozzarella sticks they were soggy and full of grease!!! The second time I tried it, I got mozzarella sticks again and they were frozen in the middle... The only good thing was the pizza when I took the mozzarella sticks back the second time they told me this was the only time they would refund the mozzarella sticks so I never ordered them again read more

I recently left a good review only to be very disappointed in a costly dinner I just purchased. Italian sub - I ordered everything but peppers what we got was one slice of three different meats, no seasoning at all no oil no mayo lettuce tomatoes looked two weeks old. Mushroom cheesesteak- three tiny mushrooms no cheese - and meat overcooked. Pizza fries one slice of cheese and about one teaspoon of sauce. We threw it out for the animals and went to the diner to eat. Will not go back there again read more

It's always a joy to go to Manny's Pizza the food is wonderful the staff is caring and kind there's no one acting like a fool unlike some other competitors around here in Millville I ordered an American sub the lunch meat is to die for it's not rubbery it's just a taste excellent there's no other way I can describe it. Other than being excellent there's no aftertaste there's no there's no secondary teams like it's being stored with a bunch of other foods are or half-open or not properly stored at all best place to go in Millville is Manny's Pizza hands down read more

Manny's Pizzeria - An excellent American sub at Manny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

Finally found a place that makes my cheese steak like I ask. And the container keeps it tasting fresh. Good job. I'll be back. From Pittsgrove read more

I called to make an order for pizza. When the woman answered there's was no customer friendly tone, I could barely hear her and she hung up right after I finished. As I walked in the restaurant, NO ONE aknowledged me. I'm just standing there and everyone is walking around in the kitchen. Not one "hello" "how are you" or even just "please leave". Some kind of notice would've been nice. Which is why I'd prefer Danny's. Better service. Everyone smiles. Pizza was great! read more

I want to give Manny's a good review as far as the pizza goes. Large pizza's are very good here. The service is not as good as the pizza. I always seem to get the same guy everytime i call, i hope he's not the boss, because he can use some customer service lessons to say the least. You're gonna need some luck if you want it delivered. i'd say they are late pretty much everytime esp on the weekends, i know they are busy but do not tell me 20 mins if takes your driver 45+ to get my order delivered. It's been awhile since my last order, i wonder if they have made any positive changes towards the service over there? read more

Manny's food is great, but I'm really quite pissed that they charged me .50 cents when I asked for two straws with my delivery order... Even the delivery driver was embarrassed. That's ridiculous, and an easy way to lose customers. read more

Manny's Pizzeria - Didn't even let me know they were going to charge me for the two straws I asked for when my delivery came. Dang yo. - Pizza Near Me - Millville, New Jersey

Here's my opinion! And It's my opinion only! Pizzas were horrible, service was terrible, and the people were not only no help at all, they were mean. What ever happened to the customer is always right? When I told them of a mistake they had made, they were rude, as if they could never make a mistake. There is so much more I can say, but I'll stop at that. Typically Manny's is a decent place, but lately, they have had a problem... read more

Food is great delivery is fast n pricess are good and your cab order online love it.. I suggest a cheesesteak

Manny's Pizzeria is one of the better pizza locations in Millville. They have a great selection of food that is tasteful and of great quality along with their pizza that has a good sauce zing, cheese, and solid crunch to it that makes it stand out. Typically, manny's is my go to location for pizza since they get it done quicker and have good prices. read more

The cheesesteak was served fast, by a friendly and courteous cook, and was everything a good Jersey cheesesteak should be, a good fresh roll and a generous filling of made to order chopped steak and provolone cheese. read more

Ate at this place today and the cheese steaks are amazing. Everybody and there mother needs to try one from here

Years ago I ate Manny's pizza when I lived alone at the apartment. Once I found New York Style, I abandoned Manny's. I had had some disappointments with Manny's so it was easy to give up on it. Gert has suggested Manny's over the years and I have always nixed the idea as I had unfavorable memories (poorly constructed 'zas, poor delivery services, etc.). Well, it was Memorial Day weekend Sunday and we were seeking something to eat late. Manny's was opened so we ordered a pizza from there. I went and picked it up a few minutes before they closed. The pizza was fine and hot. Still nothing special, but certainly adequate and I would eat this before Pizza Hut. read more

The pizza is good....SOMETIMES! 9 times out of 10 its BURNT! I am not kidding they burn it all the time. Its a gamble when ordering from them. The last time I had their pizza it was good. The cheesestakes were good back in the day but now...not so good. The meat is very dry. SMH....what happened to this place? I moved away and came back and it went down hill. Sorry mannys but you suck and your prices are WAY to high for the type of food you put out. read more

I've been to this place twice in the past 3 days. Their Jumbo slices are HUGE, about the size of two regular slices, and are only $2.25! I have a new favorite pizza joint in Southern NJ! read more

Love, love, love the food here. The pizza is not oily like other places and their meatball sub is awesome. I have never had a bad meal here.

Manny's is my go to place for a night in. Manny's has decent prices and reliable quality every time. the only reason I give them 4 stars is because they always forget extra sauce when you order it. read more

Manny's food is really delicious. I ordered Jalepeno poppers. They were great. I also ordered 3 different pizzas which were also great. The two reasons I gave them 2 stars instead of 4 or 5 is because their menu offers Small, Medium, Large Pizzas. However, when I placed my order my choice was small or large. I asked about medium pizzas but they said they didn't have any. Didn't have any? Don't they make fresh pizza for every order? I believe this is false advertising and a ploy to make money. Also, they said 15 minutes and it took 35. Yes, I could have ordered from somewhere else, but I went with a referral. Won't happen again no matter how good the food is. Just be an honest purveyor and supply what you advertise and say to paying customers. read more

The first time I ordered from Manny's, I ordered a wrap and they brought me a sandwich. Like, really? The second time, I ordered a white pizza. My boyfriend, puppy, and I all ate some of it. The oil had gone bad and it made all three of us sick. Never again. read more

First time ordering "online". Could not believe the efficiency and ease in ordering. After online order completed tracking the delivery was awesome! Food arrived well packaged and hot. Delivered exactly as order. Food was great! Delivery man Chris, was courteous and prompt! Will definitely order from Manny's again!!! read more

For the price and taste it deserves a five star. We ordered a middle size venetian for two and it was more than enough to take our full day hunger. They do not have sparkling water which I love especially during summer time. Extra cost friendly! read more

The food is good not bad for being around the corner. I've ordered from there about 3 times one time walking in, delivery, and pick up. When I walked in they made me feel awkward like give me a menu or something it was just weird and they seem rude when you order and the delivery guy was late, I got pizzas and a cheese steak ...all in all the food is okay but not worth the price read more

Such great pizza and food. The take out is quick and they have good prices for such good food. The only complaint is inside it's a little dirty but other than that they have awesome food. read more

I'm definitely not a Millbilly or Millvillian or whatever the backwards people of Millville refer to themselves, my boyfriend however is and when I stay in Jersey with him the choices for food that tastes good are few and far between. The Taste of Italy or maybe it's called The Best of Italy, it's the pizza place that you are pretty much gaurenteed to find several of the local cops eating at, they have average food but is soo soo overpriced especially for the area. Mannys is great however, first time I got a BBQ Chicken Cheesesteak and being a rather petite girl I always have to finish a sandwich in two or three separate meals, however with Mannys all I needed was a few minutes for a breather in between the two halves of the amazing sandwich. We even ended up getting pizza from here on Valentines day and it was really good as well. The only reason I gave 4 and not 5 stars is because they don't have actual menus so if I hadn't been craving a BBQ Chicken Cheesesteak that night I never would have known to order it. read more