Chefs kiss 10/10!!! My man grew up close to here so while traveling, we went to a few of his childhood places and this place was absolutely delicious!! The sauce and the melty cheese just combined so well!!! On half of the pizza, we got sausage and pepperoni and i have never had ground sausage on a pizza that was melted under the cheese... WOW!!! Delicious!!! That brick oven flavor with the crunchy crust... man o man!!! I hope he wants to take another drip down memory lane soon just so I can have another slice. It's 5 hours away but I'll be back!! read more

See all

Love Their PIZZA ! It's perfect. That's all they do is pizza and it's perfect. The sauce is the best.

By far the best pizza I've ever had. These guys have it figured out, and I work around the corner!

Best pizza u can get as-well the many toppings can have in one and choice also the place is quite and clam as well the pizza is cooked and done in-font of u! As well the service is good and are polite and fast and can be nice to kids to show how its made i remand it overall than dominos and its not as expensive as u think and would rate it 10/10 read more

I am kind of late writing this, but here it is. The pizza was great. An old school style, I haven't had in more than just a while. The crust was nice and crispy. The pepperoni was placed on the pizza after it was done cooking, so it steams with the heat of the pizza. We ordered the party tray pizza. I am not knocking the pineapple and sausage half that we got, but next time we will order a whole pepperoni because we really enjoyed the uniqueness and taste of the pepperoni pizza. There is not a big sitting area, but there are some tables if you want to sit down at the restaurant. Also, the staff was excellent . We will be back for sure. If there are some nice places in the city to sit down with the family and eat the pizza, please let me know. We like eating outside. read more

Big John's Pizza - Pepperoni and the other side is sausage and pineapple. - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeton, New Jersey

See all

The best pizza I think I ever had. We ordered 2 party trays, and it was delicious, we ordered 1/2 pepperoni and cheese on one, the other had sausage & peppers, everyone was saying how great it was. I'm so glad we ordered 2 , now I have some leftovers , at least a little lol read more

Big John's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza & plain cheese, tastes so good - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeton, New Jersey

LOVE THEIR PIZZA AND CRUST! wish they would add more cheese though! Always fast service too.

NY style might be the best pizza I've had in my life. Thin crust, extra sauce, layer of garlic , cheese I guess? Amazing!

Not from the area but my husband is. He grew up getting Big John's. I've always heard how great it is but walking out with a big square pizza I was skeptical. I can say that is was one of my favorite pizzas EVER. I can't wait to go back and get more than a cheese. Guys were super friendly picking up and I promise you won't regret it. Soooo good !! read more

I have lived all over nj and Ny. This has got to be the BEST pizza I have ever had. That is all they sell, pizza. Each pizza is made to order. Unlike other pizza places where pizza may be sitting around for however long. Prices are very fair. Ingredient very fresh read more

Big Johns pizza does one thing and one thing only...pizza...and they have been there since 1969 doing just that one thing. That has to say a lot! I ALWAYS get a Party Tray! It last almost an entire weekend at my house. Also, try ordering "double thick" on their regular pizza..makes it like a deep dish sorta. The sauce is like no other, sweet and tangy. I always get bacon and/or pepperoni. The bacon is under the cheese (which surprised a vegetarian friend who wanted a cheese slice). The pepperoni goes on after the pizza come out of the oven. No matter how you cut it, it's some of the best pizza I've ever had...and I did NOT grow up with this place, only had it since 2005. I go here as much as I can. Remember CASH ONLY! read more

Big John's Pizza - Party Tray Pizza 1/2 bacon - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeton, New Jersey

See all

I know it's not the popular opinion, but I find Big John's to be a greasy mess. Taste is okay, but I really just don't get the hype.

Was really good except there's a learning curve. Cheese isn't the first topping unless you're getting only cheese or pepperoni (which is added after coming) so with multiple toppings I ended up not having enough cheese. Now I know and next time I'll order extra cheese. read more

Great pizza from an unlikely place in South Jersey. Located center of town with parking first come first serve.

A Bridgeton staple. If you want pizza and only pizza this is the place to go if you are in the area.

They wouldn't let me use my yelp coupon they refused to honor it. They said they have no yelp profile. Extremely disappointed this use to be my favorite place, pizza just not the same Since the Owner died. read more

Cheeseburger with fries and cheese fries and a big fat man oh yea oh It was okay but I didn't mean to say anything to you lol lol I just got read more

Big John's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeton, New Jersey

My favorite pizza place Love people service is always fantastic!! Just great pizza place!!

All of the good reviews and word of mouth finally led to a stop at Big John's after visiting the local zoo... while dining in on a hot summer afternoon is not advised, the pizza is very much recommended! We had a large round pie with pepperoni. cheese is provisioned generously, and the crust is a thicker, chewier version than you usually find in southern New Jersey. It was really, really good. They did not cook the pepperoni on the pie, but allowed the heat of the pizza to warm it; this could be improved, but I'd order it again in a heartbeat. read more

Big John's Pizza - the outside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bridgeton, New Jersey

Best pizza in Cumberland County!! I ordered a large plain pizza and it was incredible. Perfect crust. Sauce, and cheese. Definitely my new pizza spot read more

One of the best places to eat in Bridgeton. A family tradition for me and my family and will be for a long time. Big John's pizza is that place if you're visiting Cumberland County you have to get it when you come in and you definitely have to get it when your leaving. I recommend it to anyone and everyone, read more

Best Pizza in South Jersey, I have been going here for 50 years, can't say that about any other business around, Best pizza! I buy a pizza every Friday for over 50 years, Friendly people to deal with every time, A true Gem in Bridgeton! They also take credit and Debit cards now!!!!!!!!! read more

Best Pizza in South Jersey!!! Such an amazing family owned pizza place! I seriously can't say enough about how amazing it is!

Only the best pizza in all of Bridgeton! I've had a love affair with this pizza since I was a little kid running around downtown Bridgeton. The pizza is still the same and is venture to say better! It's the same location and same great taste. Years ago when I still lived in NJ they had a another location in Vineland but I don't know if it's still there. If you are ever in Bridgeton you better get yourself a big johns square pizza. Trust me the sausage is to die for and well worth the calories! read more

See all

Cash only in the hood cheap pizza. This place could single handily save a family during this recession.

They have extremely great pizza and amazing customer service . And their prices are valuable

A childhood classic! Best pizza ever! I love that they take card now too makes the food all that more accessible!

The best is the best, hands down! Big Johns has been making pizza forever, and they do it best! They only make pizza and they are cash only, but you cannot beat their party tray. The pizza is king here, they know what they are doing with the perfect combination of sauce and cheese! read more

I'm not crazy for the sauce on the pizza. Maybe because I grew up on Pat's pizza in Salem nj

I don't I know why people go so crazy over this place. The pizza is always bland it looks like somebody threw the box against the wall before they gave it to you ,very sloppy. The employees are usually rude on the phone and in person and when you walk in the place it looks very dated and dirty. They only accept cash, no debit cards whatsoever which in this day and age not many people carry cash so if you don't know that beforehand you're beat. read more

I love this pizza. The only thing I find bizarre is that they add their pepperoni to the pizza after they cook it.

Pizza was okay, called and there was a man who picked up the phone who sounded like he hated his life.. I kind of felt bad and ordered a pizza anyway, took longer but ordered it through slice so it took about 40-60 minutes for a large pizza to come my way and I'm 2 minutes away.. I don't know any pizza shop that takes that long but like I said, might have been the app I used as a delivery method !! I used Slice read more

Big John's. Where do I start? When I was a child living in Bridgeton, this was pizza to me. I had no idea that this was as good as it gets. At 39 I have lived all over South Jersey. I've had the rest, I've had Gaetano's and Cinconte's which are probably some of the best traditional pizza around. I have had Papa Luigi's which is, again, the traditional style, that you find in South Jersey. They're all good pizzas. Just fine and dandy, you know... for a lunch slice, for a quick dinner. Maybe just for sitting down and eating. But when PIZZA is needed, you know, PIZZA for the sake of PIZZA? There is only one thing you can do. You have to drive your ass to Bridgeton. You have to hit the ATM. You have to walk up the slope into entrance this revered kitchen. And you order up. Small, Med, Large or Party Tray - the toppings are up above. Sausage is grounded up - a little off-putting for some, so be wary... But MY GOD!!! This is PIZZA. Sweet sauce, real mozzarella, pepperoni - raw on the pie, and all the best ingredients. You cannot pass this up. read more

We went on Yelp recommendations and just don't get it. Place was dirty and pizza mediocre. The owner was nice enough but we were not impressed. read more

This has to be one of the best slices of pizza I've ever had. I work all over the state and tried pizza in every county. I never thought I'd get a good slice this Far south. But sure enough it left me wanting more. read more

Simply the best in Bridgeton! Pizza usually is always on point. Can be frustrating when they don't answer the phone on purpose though. At least place the customer on hold or something. It would be appreciated if they accepted something other than cash especially in the shady area they are located. Lastly be prepared to experience the parking from hell! Hopefully they will move to a new location,otherwise great pizza & a friendly bunch of hard working peeps! read more

Owner is very nice and gives to the community. Nice atmosphere. Renovated very nicely. Food is great!

My wifes family orders from big johns all the time. Unfortunately their pizza is the worst pizza I've ever had the misfortune of eating. First off it looks like someone dumped your pizza upside down in the box, then dropped it on the floor before you got there it's so messy. Second, it's always soggy, the pizza always falls apart and slides off the crust. Third, it just tastes awful, I would rather buy a frozen pizza and have that for dinner then order from this place. When I go to a function and they order big johns I wait to get home to eat . It also gives me the shits if I do eat it. If it was possible to give a place zero stars, I most certainly would exercise my right to do so on this review. read more

Awesome group of guys, hard working, courteous, and Doug runs a tight schedule!

Best pizza in Cumberland county. I prefer the party trays. Make sure you have cash when you go.