I grew up within 10 minutes of Palermo's but, as far as I can recall, never knew it existed before…read morerecently. I'm visiting family in New Jersey for Christmas, so it seemed like a good time to place an order with them. We opted for delivery, as my mom is sick and I'm a terrible night driver, but I would not do that again. Their online ordering system was pretty confusing. At first I landed on an online ordering menu that I don't think was the correct one as it gave zero descriptions on anything. I backed out and then clicked into the correct one. Based on the layout, I assumed I was ordering delivery direct through the restaurant rather than an outside partner, which I prefer to do. Nope. It was DoorDash. Had I realized that, I could've used a DoorDash coupon or ordered elsewhere. Instead, I spent $9.99 for a delivery fee, plus $2.99 service charge, tax, plus tip, and the order was essentially double the cost of takeout. It wasn't obvious that it was an outside partner until the tracking link was emailed. Plus the delivery driver made a stop along the way, so my food was lukewarm on arrival. Ugh. It also took an hour to be delivered compared to their website estimate of 25 minutes. Delivery aside, the food was pretty good. I really enjoyed my slice of cheese pizza - the sauce was perfect! The cheesesteak was also delightfully cheesy and cooked perfectly. I probably wouldn't order the tuna club again. I think I overcharged myself, as it didn't have a description so I couldn't figure out what came on it. As such, I added bacon and assumed it'd have cheese as the site referenced "substituting" cheese, so I didn't add that. Turns out - no cheese (so sad) and now bacon on two layers, so I assume they added extra. My mom had a cup of their chicken noodle soup, which she deemed "tasty." High praise from her. Since I overall enjoyed what I ordered, I'd likely go back sometime on a future visit. Though I do feel minorly ripped off by the online ordering experience so I'm more likely to try other local spots first.

Completely EXCEEDS "New York standards". My boyfriend and I…read moreloved this place! From the large yet tasty food portions, to the Valentines Drink menu, to the live music; it was such a great experience for our first night in PA.

Service is always thorough. Food is good and fresh. Pizzas are big, especially the jumbo size…read more Lunch specials are a great deal too

I've been going to Fabio's for years. Absolutely amazing and I love the opinion of just getting a…read moreslice or two. The people there are always sweet and fast to help.

I ordered the SAUAGE and pepperoni Stromboli. It had very nice flavors . I give it an 8 out of…read more10 . All I ask that it had been cooked a little longer . I will differently be back for more items.

I am very disappointed. Not in the quality of food, the pizza was good. But in the person that…read moreprocessed my payment after hours. My bill was 18.85 for a large pizza and when I signed the receipt, I circled the price and drew a line down through to the total. So $0 tip since all they did was hand me my pizza box. I look today and they charged me $26.85. They added an $8 tip to my receipt. Completely unacceptable and downright dirty. I will NOT be back based on the fact that they cannot be trusted. 1 Star is kind since I cannot give 0 Stars. Service outshines quality of food. I would hope they see this and credit my card back.

Good authentic Italian pizzeria. The Works, Vodka and Buffalo chicken pizzas are all quite good…read more Their 12 inch pizza is too small, so definitely get the 16 inch or larger sizes! They also participate in a really cool food charity app called "Too Good To Go", where anyone can get leftover pizza at a deep discount that might otherwise get tossed when the restaurant is closed (This is how I discovered Nostra!)

Real friendly staff. And They have chicken cutlet sandwiches on GARLIC KNOT ROLLS!!!! Delicious…read moreAF!!!

I ordered a White Florentine Pizza (Eggplant, spinach, mozzarella, ricotta & diced tomatoes) for…read moredelivery 8.1.26. I no longer live in this area of Vineland but I was dog sitting nearby. Pizza was hot, delicious, with a perfect thinner, crispy crust. It arrived by delivery efficiently. I rarely eat pizza so the fact that it definitely did not disappoint was appreciated. I will be visiting again soon.

I have not been back since observing a woman old enough to be the owner's mother coughing and…read moresneezing, not even covering her mouth, while making salads. I don't want to think what spewed over the vegetables. If this is what you can observe from the customer area, I hate to think what goes on in the back of the house...

Not exaggerating when I say that this pizzeria has the best Italian hoagie in SJ…read more The bread, quality of deli meat and cheese, and freshness of the lettuce, onion, and tomato is just A++. I grew up around Turnersville and have been enjoying their hoagies for over 10 years, and during that time, the consistency of their food has been pretty astounding. When I moved away, I struggled (and still struggle) to find an Italian hoagie that is better than theirs. A few times a year, I'll make the drive so I can enjoy one again. Although this is your typical pizzaeria in terms of offerings, they do have some seating inside if you'd like to dine-in, but it's counter service and the seats aren't comfortable enough to hang for multiple hours. But the takeout service is fast, friendly, and very rarely makes any errors. (What more could you ask for?) Highly recommend

Was able to order online for a later pick-up time without issue and with the food still being hot…read more Their Sicilian pizza is amazing! Good portion of fries and mozzarella sticks, prices are comparable to other local spots.

Went there and didn't have enough money for something and they helped me out. 10/10 will go again.read more

Horrible experience and they just lost a customer. Not only was the pizza literally the worst pizza…read moreI ever ate and completely wrong from what I ordered they took no responsibility whatsoever! They blamed the Door Dash Driver for being delayed which is not even true since from order to drop off it was only 23 mins and he did not make the pizza so how is it his fault? I get things happen and mistakes are made but to not accept responsibility is completely unprofessional. The fact they offered nothing including an apology pissed me off more than wasting $34 on something that went right in the trash! Never ever again will I give them my business and the low rating they have is deserved!

In conclusion: The Shop has awesome pizza and I think you should eat it!…read more Here's a few things to keep in mind about my view of The Shop. The fact that it is 1.2 miles from my house means nothing. This location has been MANY things since I first moved to Lakeside Drive over 20 years ago - if the place was terrible, I did not patronize it, regardless of convenience. Pizza comprises 99.9% of the take-out I've gotten from The Shop. I have tried other things on the menu, but not much and not often. It's always pizza pizza pizza. Like any pizza place (or food place, for that matter), there are times when the pizza is better-than-it-was-the-last-time or slightly not-as-great-as-it-was-last-time. Note: it's never been bad or terrible. Even on their "worst day," the pizza is still fantastic. I am a huge fan of going in and trying a slice or two from whatever pies are available at the time. I know what I'm talking about - I eat A LOT of pizza! The actual storefront is no-frills. It is a market as well - there are a variety of supplies for sale. I don't peruse the shelves often, but if you're close by and ever in a bind, you should go see what they have. You can eat-in and the dining area and restrooms are clean. No problems here. There's not much of an atmosphere, if you will. But I don't really care about that. The pizza is hot and fresh and delicious. That's all I need. Oh yeah and the staff are nice and friendly and have never gotten my order wrong.

Great local pizza spot. Play to their strengths: pizza, clubs, cutlet sandwiches, fries. Avoid the…read morecheesesteaks, appetizer sampler platter, etc.