Stepping into this Italian food store feels like lining up for a roller coaster--there's excitement…read morein the air, and you know you're in for a great ride. And just when you think it couldn't get better, there's an Oldies DJ broadcasting live right from the center of the store, setting the perfect vibe while you shop. A word of advice: do not come here on an empty stomach. That mini shopping cart will not stand a chance against everything you're about to grab. And here's tip number two--close your eyes in the checkout aisle. The items on either side are practically guaranteed to sneak into your basket and make up a third of your final bill. I absolutely love this place. It never disappoints. I walk in for one item and somehow leave with ten--like they magically jumped into my cart. The real challenge? Not digging into the bag on the way home and eating half the loaf of bread you came for in the first place. Oh well... maybe next time.

Overrated and wildly overpriced. That pretty much describes the whole store. Deli: want a…read morereasonably priced sandwich? Go to Wawa. You'll get the same mediocre quality and you'll save a bundle. And you won't have to deal with Flo. Their customer service is awful, too. If I could give them zero stars, I would.

Amazing fresh foods and delicious deli sandwiches.Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for…read moregood food and fresh sandwiches. 5

I ordered a meatball sandwich and could not believe in a full size hoagie roll you only get 3…read moremeatballs. I bit into the sandwich and I bit into saucy bread. Unbelievable!

I went here a few months ago and forgot to give a review. The ladies in the front were awesome…read more They were very happy to see us. I asked about one of the items on the menu and they took their time to explain and made recommendations. Happens to so be that their recommendations were on point. I liked very much that they sent us to the second floor. It was small but something about the place makes it feel cozy. I asked for the meatball Parmesan sub and it was packed, fresh and tasty. Someone who seemed to be the owner came around and said hi. Asked if everything was good which is a plus. I was disappointed to see the previous restaurant was gone which was the Mediterranean cuisine. But after trying them and having the service we got, I'm glad I came by. Great job!

This place is a joke. I ordered three sandwiches and was told the wait would be 45 minutes. Being…read morefrom Philly, that's a crazy wait--especially for food that ends up tasting terrible. They use an Aversa roll, which I've had at other places and it's usually great, but I don't know what they did to it here. It was so hard you could practically use it to demo a house. The chicken cutlet was rubbery, there was barely any on the sandwich, and overall the food was really disappointing. On top of that, the girls at the counter were rude. Definitely not a place I'd go back to.

I really appreciate going to get food and it being above average. There are so many places to get…read morethis type of food but this one stands out as above average.

This is a new sandwich shop in North Cape May on Townbank Rd…read more It's a must try! The young couple that own it are delightful and the food is delicious ! Had a true Philly cheesesteak and a chicken cutlet sandwich. Would order them again and again. Stop by! You will not be disappointed!

My daughter ordered Italian Hoagies on Mother's Day for lunch. They were delicious!!! Best I've…read moreever eaten!

Good food but they charge extra if you pay with a card, even a debit card. I do not understand why…read morethey cannot just adjust the prices accordingly.

Cuban sandwich is the staff is friendly and attentive. Ricky is the best. He makes you feel very…read morewelcomed. I love the fact that he greets you with such warmth

I ate here for the first time last week. I had the Funk'n Chicken, but an staying away from bread…read more Ricky (owner) suggested serving it as a bowl, and it was very good. I was even impressed with the quality of the plastic warehouse and napking. Highly recommend.

super cool place !! staff very nice !! very clean! unique delicious food !! love the theme - fun…read moreatmosphere

From the owner: Specialty sandwiches, tacos, and more …read more

Let me start by saying that my wife and I liked Pitney Italian Market very much, until today! My…read morewife called in a meat order earlier today and spoke with a young man and informed him that she was a stroke survivor. She does that so people are patient with her. He was understanding as he took the order and informed her it would be ready tomorrow afternoon. She forgot something and called back. Someone else answered the phone. This person was most indignant and nasty gentleman she had ever encountered at a business! She asked to have someone else call her back because of the rudeness she had experienced from this young man. Of course no one has called. As much as we like the products at Pitney Italian Market,we will never do business with them again,and will let our friends and family know also!

Great service put the Italian market. There's a great service and they have good products.read more

Conveniently located inside the hotel great solid sub. Huge serving and you get a long of bang for…read moreyour buck. Especially if you are in your last buck from gambling. Lol Definitely a go to when in the area.

Really good and fresh sandwich. Got the famous Italian all the way with mayo…read more Lots of meat and fresh bread. Had to have the chili relish. So good!! Service was quick and friendly. Just a little spot you pass to and from the parking garage so ambience is watching folks walk by.

I'm going to update my previous review rather quickly because of our latest visit. We went back…read morebecause we enjoyed the first visit so much. My wife ordered the Chi Chi Rodriguez salad (without the corn) and I ordered the Boss Burger. We both enjoyed our meals. So at this point it's a solid 4 and not the 4.5 I wanted to give in the previous review. My problem was with the bartender, who in my opinion hasn't been trained properly on food allergy issues. She was rather young and maybe didn't understand the problem food allergies can cause. Additional training may help. My wife has an allergy to corn and when we asked the bartender about some of the food items, she said that I don't go back in the kitchen. She just assumed the certain food items didn't have corn. I wasn't happy that she took this nonchalance approach to someone with a food allergy.

Big fan of this place. The food is consistently excellent. Burgers are amazing, chicken sandwiches…read moreare juicy and perfectly breaded, and you can't go wrong with any of the apps. Best part is it's open daily to the public, and more often than not, the bar is never crowded. The girls behind the bar are always on point.